I love this story.
It's extremely well-written for a start. This is some of the best writing that's available on SOL.
It's UK based, so that's a little different but not distracting. There's plenty of sex, some of it 'pretty' and some of it not so... Lots of codes on this one.
It's also provocative in that it touches social issues - important ones. The emotions and reactions of the characters are 'spot on' and, agree/disagree with them, you can't say they're not real.
Marcus and Shawna and Hope and... all their mates are university students with lots of baggage who can and will do stupid things. But they're believably stupid and I like being able to pull for and be cross with the heroes and heroines.
Summary: Judgements gets those high marks for the right reasons.
NOTE: It's ongoing but, with 90+ chapters, there's plenty of catching up for new readers.