Amari's Dilemma - Cover

Amari's Dilemma

by Subconscious_P

Copyright© 2026 by Subconscious_P

Erotica Sex Story: Amari Battle is an aerospace engineer from Atlanta — observant, methodical, better at reading other people than himself. He flies to Los Angeles for his best friend's birthday party expecting nothing more than good drinks and a flight home Monday. One night introduces him to Marnie, who is warm, funny, and there with her boyfriend. What follows is a weekend he didn't plan and can't walk away from. Amari's brother Adrian appears in the companion one-shot: Lauren's Unexpected Encounter

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Consensual   Heterosexual   Fiction   Cheating   Interracial   Black Male   White Female   .

I’d been in Los Angeles less than a day and I still wasn’t sure what to make of the place.

That wasn’t a complaint. Los Angeles was just different. Coming from Atlanta, I was used to a city that felt familiar even when I didn’t know the neighborhood. I understood the rhythm of it. The traffic, the sprawl, the way you could drive twenty minutes and somehow still be in the same damn city. I could tell what side of town I was on from the buildings and the roads.

L.A. didn’t give me that. Everything felt bigger and more compressed at the same time. The mountains were right there, but so was the ocean. Palm trees on streets that had no business having palm trees. Expensive cars every couple of minutes. Everybody moved like they had somewhere important to be, including the ones standing still.

Then there was the industry thing. I’d known Roland was doing well out here. I hadn’t understood what doing well meant until I started meeting the people he’d met. Actors, producers, a director whose name I recognized from a movie I’d half-watched on a plane, and a whole tier of people I’d never heard of who could apparently get a film made if they woke up feeling like it.

Roland had been one of my closest friends since high school. Basketball first, which was probably the foundation of the whole thing, and then years of doing dumb shit together. Construction sites at night. Getting chased out of places we had no business being. Skinny-dipping with girls who were willing to make decisions of the same general quality we were. Staying out until hours that guaranteed somebody’s mother would be sitting up in the dark when we got back.

Nothing with drugs or guns or anything that could have permanently wrecked our lives.

Roland moved out here to write full-time. I stayed in Atlanta. Somehow both of us ended up all right. He’d landed deals on a few productions, and those had introduced him to a ridiculous number of people, and I was proud of him in a way I’d never actually said out loud.

Tonight’s party was for one of those people.

Amy Sutherland was twenty-five, an aspiring actress who had just booked her first real role, and Roland had met her earlier in the year working a project. Tonight was her birthday. She was celebrating at her condo, which was big, bright, and decorated with the kind of restraint that costs money. Enough luxury to make you wonder whether she owned all of it or had just gotten very good at seeming like she did.

The place was loud in the specific way a party gets when there are more people than the furniture planned for. Music underneath everything, turned up just past conversation level, so everybody was talking a half-step louder than they needed to. The kitchen had become the center of gravity the way kitchens always do. Somebody kept the balcony door cracked, and every so often a thread of cool air cut through the warmth and the perfume and the smell of somebody’s cigarette out there. Ice in a metal bucket by the drink table. Two women on the couch with their heels off and their feet tucked under them, already at the stage of the night where they’d stopped pretending they were going to circulate.

I’d been there about thirty minutes when I decided I liked it. Mostly because I could stand in one place with a drink and watch.

People watching was one of my favorite things. I’d always been like that, and I’d never fully been able to explain why it was interesting. The way somebody held a glass. Whether they looked you in the eye while they talked or checked over your shoulder for something better. Who interrupted, who got interrupted, who laughed a beat too late because they’d stopped listening a while ago. Who gravitated toward whoever mattered most in the room. Who was comfortable, and who was working very hard at looking comfortable. You could learn a surprising amount about a person without asking them a single question.

Roland, for example, was impossible to miss. He’d always been outgoing, but Los Angeles had turned that up another notch. Maroon button-down tucked into jeans, blazer, loafers, short dreads neatly done, and that grin that made strangers feel like they’d known him a year. He was working the room, but not in the fake way. Roland genuinely liked people. Within half an hour he had an entire group of strangers laughing, two women clearly interested, and one of them not bothering to hide it.

Neither was Amy, which was the funny part.

She’d been talking to four or five people at once all night, but her attention kept drifting back toward Roland every time he opened his mouth. And Roland, to his credit, wasn’t flirting. Not directly. He was praising her. How hard she’d worked. How long she’d stayed in it. How many times she’d been told no before somebody finally said yes.

“You deserve this,” he told her.

Amy lit up like somebody had handed her a set of keys.

I took a sip of my Jack and Coke and shook my head. Yeah. I could see where that was headed.

Earlier that evening, while we were getting ready at his apartment, Roland had leaned into the bathroom doorway and announced it.

“Bro, I’m telling you. Tonight is your night.”

I’d looked at him in the mirror. “My night for what?”

“You know what.”

“I genuinely don’t.”

“Bullshit.”

I’d laughed, because he knew exactly how little effort I put into meeting women. It wasn’t that I was opposed to a good time with somebody who happened to be interested. I just wasn’t going to spend an evening hunting for one. I’d rather have a couple of drinks, eat something good, talk shit with my friend, and enjoy being somewhere that wasn’t home.

Roland had no intention of letting that happen. Every fifteen minutes or so, he found a way to work me into whatever conversation he was running.

“This is my boy Amari.”

Then, before I could get a word in: “Dude’s an aerospace engineer.”

A woman with a clipboard’s posture and no clipboard raised her eyebrows at me. “Like NASA?”

“Like airplanes.”

“He builds the flight systems,” Roland said. “Custom stuff. The part that keeps the whole thing from becoming an expensive metal coffin.”

“I do all right.”

That was my standard answer. Sometimes I upgraded to I try. Then I’d take another sip and let somebody else talk.

Three conversations later he did it again, and this time he added the degrees, which was worse. UVA for the bachelor’s. Georgia State for the master’s, because apparently I’d gotten bored and gone back. Somebody said wow in the tone people use when they’ve decided you’re a category instead of a person.

I didn’t need a room full of strangers knowing my résumé. Whatever made you interesting at a Hollywood party, I was reasonably sure it wasn’t a mechanical engineering degree. I was there to hang out with my friend. Roland kept doing it anyway.

Then the front door opened.

A guy walked in, and the first thing I noticed was that he was already drunk, or close enough that the distinction didn’t matter. Dark hair, a lot of it. Mixed or Latino, maybe, though I couldn’t tell for sure and it didn’t seem like the kind of thing worth deciding from across a room. Jacket over a T-shirt, jeans, Converse.

He came through the door like he expected somebody to announce him.

Nobody did.

He handled it himself.

“What’s up, everybody!”

A few heads turned. Somebody laughed. He went straight for the drink table without stopping to greet a single person he’d just interrupted, and poured himself something with a ratio that made me wince from fifteen feet away.

This guy is going to be hammered in twenty minutes.

Then I noticed the woman who’d come in behind him. And forgot about him.

She stopped just inside the door and let the room happen for a second before she moved into it, which is a thing people do when they aren’t sure they want to be there yet. When she finally walked in, she didn’t follow him. She drifted a few degrees off his line, close enough to be with him and far enough that a stranger might not assume it.

I was fairly certain they’d arrived together. I was also fairly certain she was putting effort into not looking like it.

That made me curious before anything else did. She was tall. The heels were doing some of that work, but not all of it. When she passed a guy I’d been talking to earlier, I had a reference point, and she was somewhere around my height in her high heels.

Light brown hair down past her shoulders. Fair skin. A green dress, dark green, the kind of fabric that caught the light every time she turned, and short enough that she’d made a decision about it in front of a mirror at some point tonight. I couldn’t have told you what the dress was called or who made it. I could tell it was expensive the same way I could tell a plane was well built from the outside without opening a panel. Nothing about it was working hard.

Her eyes were light. That’s as far as I got from where I was standing. Blue or gray or something between the two, and at that distance the room’s lighting wasn’t going to give me more than that. She was holding a drink she hadn’t touched.

I looked away and took a sip of mine. Then I looked back, which answered a question about myself I hadn’t asked.

The guy’s name arrived a few seconds later.

“Keenan!”

Somebody called it from over by the kitchen. Keenan raised his glass over his head.

“That’s me!”

He said it loud enough that half the condo heard him. I watched him take a long pull, then another.

Yep. He was going to be a problem.

Not because he was drunk. People drank at parties. Hell, I was drinking. It was the way he needed the room to confirm he was in it. He started telling jokes to a circle of guys who clearly knew him, and a couple of them landed. A couple didn’t. One or two were just far enough out of pocket that I caught two people trading a look over his shoulder.

He didn’t notice. Or he did and it didn’t register as information.

He was trying to become the center of the room, which was the part that wasn’t going to work, because Roland already was one and hadn’t done anything to get there. Roland never had to reach for it. People just handed it to him. Keenan was trying to take something that only gets given.

I glanced back at the woman.

She’d moved to the edge of the group. Still smiling. Still doing the job. But the smile had gone shallow somewhere in the last ten minutes, and when Keenan got louder, she found a reason to be six inches farther away than she’d been. When he laughed at his own joke, she looked down into the drink she still wasn’t drinking.

Then she checked the door. Not obviously. A glance, the kind you’d miss if you weren’t already looking.

Then the room. Then back at him.

Her shoulders came down about half an inch. That was the moment I understood.

She regretted coming. Maybe not the party. Maybe just the arriving-with-him part of it.

I didn’t know her. I didn’t know Keenan. I had no idea what they were to each other. Dating, friends, coworkers, two people who’d met an hour before they got in the car. Not my business, and I’d spent enough of my life reading rooms to know that being good at it doesn’t grant you standing in them.

But I knew that look. She’d already started working the math on how to get out of the situation. And somewhere in there, my attention had stopped being on Roland, or Amy, or the party, or Los Angeles.

I had a flight home Monday morning. I knew exactly one person in this city. The woman in the green dress had walked in on somebody else’s arm, and whatever that somebody was to her, he was hers to deal with and not mine to have an opinion about.

All of that was true.

I set my empty glass down and started toward the drink table anyway.


I made it as far as the drink table and no further, because Keenan had started making rounds.

Apparently being in the room had stopped being enough. Now everybody had to be told. I watched him work his way along the wall, shaking hands, saying his own name before anybody asked for it, and I had about ninety seconds to decide whether I wanted to be somewhere else when he got to me.

I didn’t move fast enough.

“Hey, man. I’m Keenan.”

He stuck his hand out at Roland first. Roland, being Roland, shook it and smiled like he’d been waiting all night.

“Roland.”

“Good to meet you, bro.” He turned. “And you?”

“Amari.”

“This is my boy Amari,” Roland said, because he couldn’t help himself.

Keenan nodded at the condo in general, at the ceiling, at the catering trays somebody had set out on the island. “Y’all ever been to one of these where everybody’s a writer?” He lowered his voice. “I got cornered by a dude for twenty minutes about his pilot. Twenty minutes. I don’t even know what a pilot is. I was nodding like I had notes.”

I laughed before I decided to.

Behind him, the woman in green laughed too. Quick and real, a little surprised, and then she caught it and pulled it back in.

That was the first useful thing I’d learned all night.

Keenan grinned at his own line and settled into it. “Where you from, Amari?”

“Atlanta.”

His face lit up. “Hotlanta!”

I nearly inhaled my drink. Got it down without embarrassing myself, but not by much.

Hotlanta. Nobody in Atlanta calls it Hotlanta. Nobody. Walk into a bar on Edgewood and say it out loud and somebody will quietly begin the process of revoking your residency.

I gave him the polite smile.

“Man, I love Atlanta.”

“It’s a good city.”

He looked at me a second longer than the conversation needed, and something behind his eyes changed gear.

“You don’t sound like you’re from Atlanta.”

There it was.

I knew exactly what he meant, because I’d been handed some version of it since I was about fifteen. He wasn’t hearing what he’d budgeted for. He had a sound in his head that he’d gotten from somewhere he’d never examined, and I wasn’t it, and the gap between the two had come out of his mouth before anything in him thought to stop it.

I could have asked him what somebody from Atlanta was supposed to sound like. I’ve asked before. It never goes anywhere good and it always costs me the rest of my night.

I took a sip instead.

“I just talk,” I said. “But I’m definitely from Atlanta.”

There was about a second and a half of nothing.

Roland’s eyes came over to me and went away again. He didn’t say anything. He didn’t need to. We’d been having that conversation without words since sophomore year.

Keenan missed all of it. “Yeah, yeah,” he said, already looking somewhere else.

I was prepared to let it die. Then the woman in green came up on his other side.

She’d heard it. That was obvious from ten feet away. Her face had gone through something on the way over and hadn’t fully finished, and what was left wasn’t horror exactly. It was closer to the look you get when somebody you’re responsible for knocks a glass off a table in a restaurant.

Roland, unlike the man she’d walked in with, possessed the basic social hardware required to notice a woman standing there.

“Hey. I’m Roland.”

“Hi.” Somehow her voice matched her appearance perfectly. “Marnie.”

“Marnie. Nice to meet you.”

“You too.”

“Amari,” I said.

She turned, and I finally got a look at her from inside three feet instead of across a room.

Blue-gray. I’d been guessing from the lighting earlier and I’d guessed low. They were the kind of eyes you have to consciously decide to stop looking at.

“Nice to meet you, Amari.”

We shook hands. Two seconds, maybe. Nothing in it. Except she held on for the back half of it the way you do when you’re trying to say something a handshake isn’t built to carry.

Keenan reinserted himself. “This is my girlfriend.”

Her smile went out for half a second and came back on.

He put an arm across her shoulders. “She’s hot as hell, too.”

She looked at him. Then at us. Then back at him, and gave him the small flat smile people use when they’ve decided the scene isn’t worth what it would cost.

“Thank you, Keenan.”

He grinned like he’d said something generous. I took another drink.

It limped on for a few more minutes. Keenan talked, mostly about Keenan. Marnie said almost nothing. Roland steered twice, which is a thing he does so smoothly that people never notice they’ve been steered. Eventually Keenan drifted off toward a louder corner.

Marnie watched him go. Then she looked back at me, and there was an apology sitting in her face that she hadn’t said out loud yet.

I gave her a small smile. She gave me one back. Then she followed him.

Roland leaned in. “Fuck that guy.”

“Yep.”

That covered it. Ten minutes later I was building another Jack and Coke when I heard her behind me.

“I’m really sorry about that.”

She had an empty glass and the expression of somebody who’d been rehearsing on the walk over.

“It’s fine.”

“It’s not.”

“It’s really not a big deal.”

“He was being an asshole.” She said it flatly, like a fact she’d checked.

I shrugged. “I’ve met the type.”

“Still.” She looked down. “I’m sorry.”

“You don’t have to apologize for somebody else.”

“He shouldn’t have said the thing about how you talk.”

“People say dumb shit.” I moved over to make room for her at the table. “You want the tequila or the good tequila?”

“There’s good tequila?”

“Behind the vodka. Somebody hid it, which means somebody knew what they were doing.”

She found it, looked at the label, and poured herself something that was probably ninety percent tequila and ten percent an idea about juice.

I raised an eyebrow.

“Tonight requires a serious drink,” she said.

“Fair,” I replied.

She took a sip and winced at it in a way I liked. “I’ve tried to tell him. About the— “ she circled a hand. “About all of it.”

“That’s not your job.”

“I know.” She leaned back against the counter, shoulder to the cabinets, angled toward me. “I still feel bad.”

“How long have y’all been together?”

“Six months.” She said the number like it had gotten heavier recently.

“And?”

“We’ve had fun.” That wasn’t an answer, and she heard herself not answer, and she kept going anyway. “It used to be lighthearted. He’s actually funny. You saw. The pilot thing, that’s him.” She turned the glass a quarter turn on the counter. “That’s who I met.”

“What changed?”

“He started drinking like this.” She said it to the counter. “Not always. Two, three months ago. And now it’s every time, and every time it’s a little worse, and I keep waiting for the week where it isn’t.” She looked up. “I don’t know what happened.”

I didn’t hand her anything. Sometimes people change. Sometimes the thing was under the floor the whole time and it just finally came up through the boards. Neither of those helps anybody at a party.

“That sucks,” I said.

“Thank you for not giving me advice.”

“I’ve known you nine minutes.”

“Most people don’t let that stop them.” She studied me for a second. “You’ve been watching this whole room all night.”

I smiled. “That obvious?”

“Very.” She sipped. “So, what do you do?”

“Aerospace engineering.”

She stopped with the glass halfway down. “Seriously?”

“Seriously.”

“That’s—okay, that’s actually really cool.”

“I do all right.”

“You say that like it’s nothing.”

“I work on airplanes.” I set my drink down. “Flight systems, specifically. Somebody hands me an aircraft and a list of things they want it to be able to do, and my job is figuring out how forty systems that were never designed to talk to each other are going to talk to each other without anybody dying over the Atlantic.”

She was nodding before I finished.

“What?”

“Nothing. Just.” She laughed. “That’s my job.”

“You build airplanes?”

“I’m a technical designer.” She set her own glass down, which I would learn later meant she was about to use her hands. “A designer gives me a sketch. A picture. Sometimes literally a drawing on a napkin, I’m not exaggerating. And it’s beautiful and it’s completely impossible, and my job is to turn it into a document a factory in Vietnam can actually build. Every seam. Every tolerance. How it grades from a two to a sixteen without falling apart at the shoulder.”

“So, you’re the one who tells them it won’t work.”

“I’m the one who tells them it won’t work and here’s what will.” She picked the glass back up. “Nobody knows we exist. You see the runway. You don’t see the ninety pages behind it.”

“Yeah,” I said. “Nobody’s ever taken a picture of a wiring diagram either.”

She laughed at that, and it wasn’t loud and it wasn’t performed, and I noticed I’d been waiting to hear it again since the thing about the pilot.

“How do you know Amy?” I asked.

“College, kind of. We were servers at the same restaurant.” She tipped her head toward the living room, where Amy was holding court by the balcony door. “She was trying to make it as an actress and I was trying to figure out what the hell I wanted, and we closed together four nights a week for two years. You can’t not know somebody after that.”

“You still close?”

“She’s the first person I call.” She glanced at me. “Both ways. That’s the part that’s rare.”

“Roland’s mine.” I nodded across the room. “Since high school. Basketball.”

“That explains why he’s so comfortable here.”

“Roland’s comfortable everywhere. I’ve watched that man make friends in a dentist’s office.”

She smiled into her drink. “Okay, so if you’re the flight systems guy and I’m the ninety-pages person — do you ever want to do something else?”

“Not really.”

“That’s annoying.”

“Why is that annoying?”

“Because I do.” She said it fast, then slower: “I want to do build. Costume. Film, television, whatever will take me. Not the designing, but the making. Running a workroom. Somebody says we need forty of these and they have to survive a fight scene and they have to look like 1912, and I’m the person who figures out how.”

Her whole face was doing something different now.

“So do it,” I said.

“I’m twenty-eight. I’d start over. Hourly, on set, fetching things, bottom of a list.” She shook her head. “I’ve got a salary and health insurance and I work from my couch in pajamas. And I’ve watched Amy get told no for six years straight.”

“But she got the yes.”

“She got one.” Marnie looked at me. “That’s not a system. That’s a coin.”

“Doesn’t mean you don’t flip it.”

“Says the man with the salary and the master’s degree.”

“Two master’s-adjacent degrees and a mortgage,” I said. “I’m not pretending I’m brave. I’m saying I’ve read your face for about fifteen minutes and you only lit up once, and it wasn’t when you told me what you do for a living.”

She held that one for a second. Then she looked away and drank.

“My sister says the same thing. Constantly.”

“Older?”

“Younger, which makes it worse. She’s in New York, she works for a news station, she’s twenty-five and completely fearless and we talk almost every day.” She smiled. “She’d have told Keenan where to go about four hours ago.”

“You could still do that.”

“I’m going to,” she said, and I believed her, and I think it was the first time that night she’d said it out loud to anybody.

We kept going. One thing turned into another and neither of us had to work for it, which I don’t have a lot of experience with. She got Atlanta out of me. My mother, who has opinions about how often I call. My father’s obsession with a lawn that does not need that much attention. My brother Adrian, who is two years older and has spent his entire life being the calmer one.

“He’s having a baby,” I said.

“Your brother?”

“Yep.”

“That’s wonderful.”

“It is. The circumstances are interesting.”

“How interesting?”

“He met the woman having his baby at a housewarming party.”

“Okay.”

“And it happened that night.”

“Okay...”

“In the guest bathroom.”

Her eyes went wide. “No way.”

“Yes.”

“You’re kidding.” She got a hand over her mouth.

“Nope. She came to that party with a boyfriend, and by the end of the night she was in Adrian’s car at a Waffle House.”

She laughed so hard she had to put the glass down on the counter.

“That’s insane.”

“I know.”

“And they’re together now?”

“Somehow. Six months and it’s the most stable thing in my family.”

She wiped under her eye with a knuckle, still laughing. “What’s her name?”

“Lauren.”

She shook her head slowly, and when she spoke again the laugh had drained out of it and something more careful had taken its place.

“Honestly? I love that.”

“Which part?”

“That something that started in a completely indefensible way can turn into something real.”

She said it to her drink. Not to me. And she said it the way you say a thing you want in the room without having to own it.

I read it exactly. I want to be clear about that, because I’ve thought about this moment a lot since. I knew what she’d just put on the counter between us, and I knew she’d built it so that either of us could pick it up or pretend it was a story about my brother.

“Yeah,” I said. “Me too.”

She glanced over. Whatever was on my face, she didn’t push it.

“When do you go back to Atlanta?”

“Monday morning.”

“Oh.” She turned her glass another quarter turn. “That’s too bad.”

I looked at her. She looked back, and neither of us filled it. There wasn’t much under those words. There was just enough.

“Birthday girl!”

The whole room turned. One of Amy’s friends came through from the kitchen carrying a cake that could have fed twice the guest list, candles going, and everybody folded in around her and started singing. I sang. Marnie sang, off-key and unbothered.

Amy blew them out. The room came apart in applause.

“Oh—shit.”

Marnie looked at me. “What?”

“I forgot something.”

I dug the card out of my jacket. I’d been carrying it around since eight o’clock.

Amy took it and her face looked genuinely surprised. “Amari! Thank you.” She hugged me, hard, the way people do when they didn’t expect to be thought about.

When I came back, Marnie was watching me with her arms folded.

“You brought her a card.”

“It’s her birthday.”

“You met her tonight.”

“Seemed like the thing to do.”

She shook her head slowly. “You would be amazed how many people can’t clear that bar.”

“Maybe.”

She looked at me a second longer.

“So does your girlfriend miss you back home?”

I almost laughed. Clean work. No wasted motion.

I leaned back against the counter. “Been single for a little over a year.”

Her eyebrows went up about a millimeter.

“Work, school, getting my own house in order. Wasn’t looking.”

“That’s good,” she said.

Not that’s too bad. Not why. Just that’s good, in the tone of somebody quietly ticking a box on a form I hadn’t been shown.

And that should have been the high point of my night.

Instead, I looked past her, and there was Roland by the balcony doors with Amy, standing closer than the conversation required, saying something that made her tip her head back.

And I did the math I’d been carefully not doing.

Amy was the first person Marnie called. Roland was the first person I called. Whatever was happening across that room was going to be a real thing by Sunday, and Roland had spent two years building a life out here on relationships exactly like it. If I put a hand on any part of this and it went wrong, it wouldn’t land on me. I’d be on a plane. It would land on him, in his city, in his industry, with the woman whose oldest friend I’d made a mess of.

That was the first moment all night I understood I was actually deciding something.

I was still holding it when the sound cut across the room.

Crash.

Everybody turned. Keenan had brought his glass down on the side table hard enough to take the bottom out of it.

“ANOTHER!”

The room went quiet in stages.

Amy crossed to him. “Keenan.”

He looked up, loose and pleased with himself.

“You’ve had enough.”

“I’m fine.”

“You just broke a glass on my table.”

“So?”

“So if you break another one, you’re leaving.”

The grin came off. “Come on, Amy.”

“No.” She folded her arms. “It’s my birthday. I’m not spending it picking glass out of a rug.”

“You’re killing the vibe.”

I looked at Roland. His face had gone somewhere I’ve only seen it go a few times.

Amy didn’t move. “I’m not killing the vibe. You are.”

“You always do this shit.”

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In