The Peanut Butter Babysitter
Copyright© 2004 by MarkStory
Chapter 6
Romantic Sex Story: Chapter 6 - Jim and Aimee have a chance meeting over a jar of peanut butter. In the beginning, he's a married father, she's a college student. That chance meeting in a grocery store, and the coincidence that follows, will change their lives (and others' lives)! I brought this story back to life in late 2025, more than 20 years after I first started writing it.
Caution: This Romantic Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Fa/Fa Consensual Romantic Lesbian Heterosexual Fiction Cheating Polygamy/Polyamory Masturbation Oral Sex Babysitter Slow
The following Tuesday, I was supposed to be on a job site until four. That was the plan. Dry forecast until evening, temperatures steady, good enough to pour concrete and get the last footing set.
But by 10:15 a wet snow rolled in off the river -- too warm to stick, too cold to ignore. The foreman swore, the site shut down early, and I found myself sitting in my truck idling outside the chain-link gate, wondering if I should go to the office or just call it a working lunch and head home first.
Home won, so I could at least swap out my muddy boots. Maybe eat something that wasn’t from a gas station.
When I turned onto our street, I saw Aimee’s car already in the driveway, dusted with slushy flakes.
Huh. She was supposed to be in class until two.
Inside, the house hummed with a familiar quiet -- the kind that belonged to nap times and empty rooms. No voices. No TV. Just the low steady churn of the dryer.
I paused in the hallway as I kicked off my boots, listening.
Laundry day, then.
Something about that made my pulse stumble. Too many memories tied to the scent of detergent and warm cotton.
I set my keys down and walked toward the laundry room, stepping quietly in sock feet.
The door was half open, warm light spilling into the hall. I saw movement first -- her arm lifting, shaking out a piece of clothing before tossing it into a basket.
Aimee stood barefoot on the cool tile, wearing an old gray T-shirt and -- God help me -- nothing but thin cotton panties underneath, pale and clinging. Not lace, not planned for seduction, which somehow made it ten times worse. Her shirt’s hem skimmed the midline of her buttocks, leaving just enough visible that my imagination didn’t have to work hard at all. Her bare legs were smooth and soft looking, and my eyes roamed over them hungrily.
Her hair was messy, a few damp strands stuck to the back of her neck from the steam. The warm rush of the dryer had flushed her skin; she looked like she had just stepped out of a shower, like she belonged to this room, to this house.
She hadn’t heard me. The machine masked everything -- my footsteps, my breath, the low groan I made without meaning to.
I should have backed away. Cleared my throat. Given her warning.
Instead I stood there and let the sight of her hit me like a door slammed against my chest.
She bent to grab another armful of laundry, and the shirt lifted -- higher this time, enough to reveal the curve of her hip, the soft stretch of cotton across her backside, the place my hands had memorized in Portsmouth. The T-shirt slipped off one shoulder, exposing a long line of skin I had once kissed like I was starving.
Something in me lurched forward, unsteady and inevitable.
“Aimee,” I said.
Not loud, but enough.
She startled, spun, eyes wide, one hand flying to the hem of the shirt, aware of her ... exposure.
“Jim! What -- I thought you were on-site all day.” She swallowed. “Class got canceled. I didn’t think anyone would be home.”
I was already shaking my head. “Storm shut the site down. I came home for lunch.”
Her gaze flicked over me, jacket half unzipped, cold still in my hair. Then something changed behind her eyes -- something she recognized in mine, and didn’t look away from.
“Oh,” she said, voice softer. “Lunch.”
The dryer ticked as it cooled, a slow settling of metal. Aimee stood barefoot on the tile, one hand still clutching a shirt she wasn’t folding anymore. The air felt warmer than it should. Closer. Thicker.
I should have looked away. I didn’t, my gaze still roaming over her half-naked body, head to pink-painted toes.
“If you tell me to leave,” I murmured, “I will.”
Her breath caught -- just a small sound, but enough.
She shook her head once. Not a command, not a plea. Just truth.
“I won’t,” she said.
I took a step inside the room. Close enough to see the drop of moisture clinging to the hollow of her throat.
“We don’t have to do this,” I managed.
Her eyes flicked over my face, searching, and when she spoke, it was barely sound at all:
“You’re lying,” she said, tossing the shirt in her hand aside.
My hand found the warm cotton at her waist, and the shirt lifted under my fingers. Her skin was soft from the steam, and when she leaned in, her forehead met mine like a promise neither of us had earned.
“I’ve thought about you every night,” she whispered.
I didn’t answer. My hands did, sliding up under that thin shirt, cupping her breasts, my palms covering them entirely. Her nipples hardened under my touch, and she stood on her tiptoes to kiss me. Our kiss was hard and frantic and fast, tongues tangling, teeth clacking together.
As I kept fondling her breasts, her hands reached for my ass, pulling me against her. I shrugged out of my jacket, letting it fall to the floor.
We broke the kiss, gasping for air, and my hands went to the hem of her shirt, pulling it up and over her head. She stood there, naked except for a thin pair of panties, and my eyes roamed over her, hungrily. She watched me watch her, and asked a simple question.
“What do you want, Jim?”
“I want you, Aimee. Right now.”
“I’m yours,” she responded, hands frantically unbuttoning my dress shirt, pulling it off me, fingertips scrabbling at my belt. Our limbs tangled as we tried to touch each other, everywhere, at once. I moaned when her hand slid inside my khakis and touched my cock through my boxer briefs. She echoed that sound when my hand slid down her smooth stomach, under the waistband of those panties, fingers pushing through her sparse pubic hair. Her lips were already warm and wet, and she moaned my name in one long, impossibly sexy syllable as I touched her.
“Jimmmmmmmmmm,” she groaned, and my cock felt like it was harder than it had ever been in my life.
I finished unbuckling my pants and pushed them down along with my boxers, letting them pool at my ankles, not even bothering to step out of them. I peeled Aimee’s panties off, crouching to drag them down her long legs, my eyes feasting on her pussy as I stood back up.
I grasped her waist, kissing her again, hard and fast. My fingers sliding to her hips, I turned her around, a little roughly, positioning her belly against the edge of the washing machine. She squealed from the cold.
“Jim -- what are you -- ohmygod,” she moaned with realization as I stepped between her thighs, my cock in my hand, sliding it up against her from behind. She spread her legs wider, lifting her butt a little higher in the air. “Yes, yes, like this, so fucking hot oh god!”
I slid my cock head between her labia, gathering the wetness there, sliding it up and down, making her cry out as I bumped it against her hooded clit on the downstroke, then moving back up. My cock was wet with my own pre-come and her lubrication as I moved the head back to her entrance, and I crouched a little to get the angle right, pushing into her slowly, her torso now fully bent over the washing machine.
“Oh fuck,” Aimee cried out. “That feels so good, Jim,” she said, as my cock pushed more than halfway into her. “You’re so big in me like this, ohmygod ohmygod...”
I gripped her ass cheeks with my fingers, hard enough to leave marks, as I drove my cock into her. Not rough, but not gentle like Portsmouth, either. I wanted -- needed -- my cock to be buried in her as far as it could go, completely enveloped by her warmth, and she was pushing back at me like she desperately needed the exact same thing.
Finally, I felt my pelvis bump up against her ass cheeks, and she moaned in delight, realizing I was all the way inside her. I pulled out halfway, then pushed back in. Out, and in, out and in. The laundry room was hot and humid, and my sweaty skin moved slickly against her own. I felt like I couldn’t tell where hers ended and mine began.
We moaned in pleasure as the washing machine continued to spiral underneath her, as my cock continued to slip in and out of her tight passage. The situation was so illicit, so unexpected, so amazingly hot that I knew this wouldn’t be a long encounter. I was struggling to maintain control from the first stroke, my balls already throbbing. Fortunately, that didn’t matter. Aimee was as turned on as I was, reaching down between her thighs to play with her clit as I fucked her, her fingertips brushing the edge of my shaft as it slid in and out of her.
“This is so fucking hot Jim ohmygod I have wanted this so bad, ohgod it feels so good, you’re so deep in me,” she moaned as I pistoned in and out of her, balls slapping against her thighs. I slid one hand around the front of her torso, clutching at her breasts.
“I can’t ... I mean ... I need to ... it’s going to be soon, Aimee,” I said through clenched teeth, the fire building low in my gut.
“Oh god me too,” she cried out, her fingers moving even faster over her clit. “Give it to me, come in me, let’s do it at the same time, ohmygod ohmygod this feels so fucking good oh god...”
Her essentially begging me to come flipped the switch, and I felt my cock swell inside her, felt my balls tighten. As the pleasure overtook me, I thrust into her one last time, hard, bringing her to her tiptoes against the washing machine, burying myself inside her as far as I could go, wishing it were deeper.
“Ohgod Aimee ohgod,” I cried out, as my orgasm slammed over me, my cock pulsing inside her, expanding even further against her tight inner walls, the pleasure almost too much. My cock throbbed as I came hard, once, twice, three spurts, pushing deep into her. Her cries of pleasure echoed my own, “Yes yes yes oh fuck YES” as her pussy clenched and throbbed around me, a sudden burst of lubrication letting my last few thrusts slide even easier within her.
I slowed my thrusting, both of us sensitive in the afterglow. She relaxed from her tiptoes, and I leaned over against her, arms bracing myself on the washing machine. I let my abs rest against her cheeks and pressed my face to hers, my lips just behind her ear, kissing it gently. “Holy fuck, Aimee. Holy fuck.”
She giggled, the movement of her body interesting under and around mine. “Yeah, that about covers it.”
We stayed pressed up against the washing machine longer than made sense, the tile cooling beneath our feet while our breath still hadn’t figured out how to slow down. I slid in and out of her a few more times, both of us shuddering in the sensitive afterglow. My cock eventually softened and slipped out of her, Aimee moaning lightly as she felt it go.
I leaned up off her, stretching. She stood up and turned around, arms sliding around my waist, flattening her breasts against my chest, my cock soft but still slick and hot against her thigh. She let out a stunned little laugh. “Okay. So ... that’s not how I thought I was spending my surprise laundry day.”
I huffed a breath that might’ve been a laugh if my body remembered how. “Your class got canceled, my site got weathered out, and somehow this is where the universe put us.”
She pushed her hair back, eyes still a little dazed. “Last week, Colin could’ve been the nicest guy in the world, and it still wouldn’t have led to anything close to ... that.” Her cheeks warmed, but she didn’t take it back. “I mean it. I kept wondering why it felt so flat with him. Now I know exactly why.”
My pulse kicked again -- not from ego, but from the terrifying simplicity of it. We both knew she was right.
We eased back from each other, sweaty skin reluctant to separate. I pulled up my boxers. She reached for her panties. We didn’t look away when fabric met skin this time.
Aimee glanced toward the stairs. “I should probably take a shower.”
That was all it took -- one image, and the heat flared back so fast it almost hurt.
“Oh,” I said, a flurry of thoughts running through my head. “We could ... no, nevermind.”
She froze, shirt clutched to her chest. The thought had crossed her mind too -- I saw it. The small, wicked smile proved it.
“Jim,” she murmured, stepping close enough that I felt the warmth of her skin. “There is absolutely no version of reality where you and I take a shower together and it ends with you going back to work for the afternoon.”
That broke something in both of us. I leaned my forehead to hers, still breathing her in.
“No,” I whispered. “There isn’t. And you’re right, I need to.”
Silence swelled again -- thick, knowing. Then she sighed, softer this time, practical in the way you get when the ache doesn’t disappear but you stand up anyway.
“We should -- separately,” she said, nodding toward the stairs.
“Yeah,” I answered, because the alternative was setting the house on fire.
She backed up a step, then another, slinging the t-shirt over her shoulder, her breasts unashamedly on display. At the doorway she paused, one hand on the frame.
“I don’t think I can pretend that Portsmouth was an accident anymore,” she said. “Or this.” Her eyes held mine. “There’s no universe where that was a one-time thing. Or now, a two-time thing. And we both know it.”
There was no point lying -- not to her, not to myself.
“You’re right,” I said. The truth, bare and reckless.
We didn’t touch again. We didn’t need to. Something had already been decided, even if neither of us had said the words.
She disappeared down the hall, and I stood alone in the laundry room, every machine still, every surface ordinary.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.