Chapter 4

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:

I’d like to thank my editor, markf52.

STORY:

When Dani reached home after meeting Matt in the ice cream store, she was confused and sad. She had broken up with Chase for Matt. More importantly, she really liked Matt and she thought they would be good together.

And then he rejected her. Not only did he reject her, he fed her a story about how he was a werewolf and it was his pheromones that seduced her. The whole charade was an insult to her intelligence.

But she still couldn’t get rid of the voice in the back of her head that kept telling her that maybe Matt wasn’t lying. Dani had known Matt for some time and he wasn’t someone who lied to people and went around sleeping with girls, then breaking up with them. And the way he told her the story, it felt as if she truly believed in what he was telling her.

Dani decided to check out whether he was telling the truth. He told her that her strength would have increased. She did drag Chase around like a ragdoll, but that could’ve been adrenaline. She went near her bed and grabbed one of its legs. She lifted the bed and it weighed like a feather! It was true! She had gotten stronger!

Matt had also told her that she now had the ability to make herself seem older or younger. She went into the bathroom and stood in front of the mirror. Matt had told her that to make herself older, she had to concentrate and conjure up an image in her head of herself as an old person. Dani imagined herself as older and concentrated. She could see before her eyes, in the mirror, her body was changing. Her hair was turning grey and she had wrinkles around her eyes. Dani stopped the transformation and concentrated on changing her body back to its younger self.

Once she changed herself back to her old self, she made her way to her bed, laid down in it and closed her eyes. Matt was telling the truth! He was a werewolf and he had turned her into a freak. Dani decided that she needed to have a talk with Matt.

Matt had just come back from having a shower and he was over the moon. He had just had sex with his mother and she had promised him that they would have sex every day. He heard his phone ring, so he picked up the phone and saw that it was Dani.

“Hello. Dani?

“Yeah. Is this Matt?”

“Yeah.”

“I tried what you said.”

“What?”

“When you told me to try changing my age.”

“Oh, yeah.”

“It happened. It actually happened. I got old and then became normal again.”

“I told you. I wasn’t lying.”

“Matt, what have you done to me? You’ve turned me into a freak.”

“Dani, I didn’t know back then that this would happen. And please don’t call yourself a freak.”

“Matt, I need you to come over to my place tomorrow after school. We need to talk about this.”

“Ok, Dani, I’ll be there.”

The next day at school, Matt and Dani barely looked at each other. They were both busy with their classes, but both of them were anticipating meeting the other person that evening.

After school, Matt went home, took a shower, changed and started towards Dani’s. Diana saw him as he was about to leave the house.

“Matt, are you going over to Gary’s?”

“No, Mom. I’m going over to Dani’s place. She believes me now and she wants to talk about it.”

“Oh, Ok.”

Matt made his way to Dani’s place and knocked on the door. Dani’s mother opened the door, “Hi, Matt.”

“Hi, Mrs. Eriksen. Is Dani home?”

“Yes. She told me that you’re helping with her studies. Thank you so much.”

“Oh, please don’t mention it, Mrs. Eriksen.”

“Dani’s upstairs in her room.”

“Thanks, Mrs. Eriksen.”

Matt went upstairs and knocked on Dani’s door. Dani opened the door and let him in. Matt looked around and saw that there were two beds in the room. The sisters must share a room.

“Where’s Joanna?”

“I told her I needed some privacy to talk to you, so she went over to her friend’s place.”

“Oh, cool.”

“No, it’s not cool, Matt. Look at what you’ve done to me!”

“Dani, I’m really sorry. When we had sex, I didn’t know that having sex with me would change you.”

“Speaking of changes, is it safe for me to be around you, you being a werewolf and everything?”

“Yeah, absolutely. I only change into a wolf during a full moon and even then, I’ll retain my consciousness. It’s just that when I transform, I’ll go into a sort of sexual frenzy and I will mate with any woman in my vicinity.”

“So, I’m your mate?”

“No. You’re a “mate”! You don’t have to be with me. You can still date whoever you want.”

“But because I had sex with a werewolf, I’ve now become something other than human?”

“Yeah. You’re basically immortal now, eternally young and also, you’ll have super strength.”

“You know, when I hear it like that, it doesn’t really sound that bad.”

“Right? You can live with this.”

“Thank you so much, Matt. For coming over and explaining all this to me.”

She leaned over and hugged Matt.

“No problem, Dani. Hey, can I ask you something?”

“Yeah.”

“Yesterday, in the ice cream shop, did you ask me out?”

Dani blushed.

“Yeah.”

“Dani, I’ve always had a crush on you. If it’s ok with you, will you go out with me?”

“Yes. Yes. Absolutely yes.”

She threw her arms around his neck and gave him an intense kiss. He reciprocated her kiss and slowly started to massage her breasts. She pulled away from him and pushed his hands away.

“Not now, Matt. My parents are downstairs. If we do something, they’ll hear us. They’re going out tomorrow evening, I’ll send Joanna away and if you come over after school tomorrow, we can do whatever we want.”

“Ok, that sounds like a date.”

Matt and Dani spent some time together kissing. They made sure that they didn’t make any noise. Then Matt bid Dani goodbye and returned home.

Joanna Eriksen retrieved her phone from under her pillow as soon as she came home. She looked around to see if her sister was watching and as soon as she confirmed that Dani wasn’t watching, she plugged her earphones in.

Joanna had developed suspicions about Dani and Matt as soon as Dani asked her for some privacy to talk to Matt. She knew that her sister had broken up with Chase the previous day and she wanted to know if Dani and Matt were hooking up and if Matt was the reason her sister broke it off with Chase.

Before she left the room, Joanna had turned the sound recorder on her phone on and hidden it under her pillow. As soon as she came back, she listened to what her phone had recorded.

She was shocked by what she heard. Were her sister and Matt pranking her? No, there was no way they could have known about the hidden phone. They must be serious.

But it’s not possible. Werewolves were not real and the stuff they were talking about, being immortal and eternally young, it was too much for Joanna to believe. So, having sex with Matt, who was a werewolf, turned her sister into an immortal super human?

Even though Joanna knew that it wasn’t possible, there was something in the conviction in their voices that made her want to believe. The only way she could find out if it’s true or not is if she had sex with Matt and she turned into a super human. She thought it would be pretty sweet if she became immortal and eternally young. But Matt was now her sister’s boyfriend, so it wouldn’t be easy to seduce him. She started crafting her plan about how to seduce Matt.

The next day, the Eriksen sisters came home after school. Their parents had gone to one of their friend’s anniversary party and would be home only after nine p.m. Dani had already asked Joanna to spend the evening at one of her friend’s place.

“Dani, I know this is none of my business and you can tell me to shut my mouth, but are you and Matt dating?”

Dani smiled.

“Yeah.”

“Are you gonna do it with him today?”

“Jo, that’s none of your business.

“Dani, come on. We’re twins, no secrets.”

“Ok, fine. Yeah, we were planning on doing it today.”

“Hey, as long as you don’t do it on my bed, I’m cool with it. So, is this your first time doing it with Matt?”

“No, we’ve done it once before. But this is the first time we’re doing it after we started officially dating.”

“Wow, cool. So, is there something special you’re doing for him tonight?

“What do you mean, something special?”

“Oh, it’s just that this is your first time you’re doing it as an official couple. Have you bought some sort of sexy lingerie for him or anything like that?”

Shadows of doubt crept over Dani’s face.

“No, I’m not doing anything like that.”

“Oh, really. That’s ok, maybe Matt’s not the kind of guy who’s interested in all that superficial stuff.”

“He isn’t that kind of guy.”

But Dani couldn’t shake off the feeling of self-doubt. She decided to go and buy a set of lingerie for their first time as an official couple.

“Joanna, if Matt comes, just tell him that I’ve gone out for a small errand and tell him to wait. I’ll be back soon.”

Joanna smiled. The first part of her plan was a success.

Matt knocked on the Eriksen’s door. Dani opened the door, she smiled at him and kissed him.

“Come on, let’s go upstairs.”

Matt followed Dani to her room. As soon as they entered the room Dani grabbed his head and kissed him intensely. Matt responded to her kiss and he grabbed one of her breasts. Dani slapped his hand away, as if by reflex, causing Matt to look at her questioningly.

“No. It’s just ... let’s ease into it. Slowly.”

Matt kissed her again. Then they hugged and continued kissing each other for some time. Matt grabbed her breast again and this time Dani didn’t do anything. Matt slowly took off his shirt, pants and underpants and Dani took off her shirt, pants, bra and panties.

Matt bent down and sucked her nipples. He sucked her nipples for some time before kneeling before her and licking her cunt. Dani stopped him, “No, not today. Just fuck me.”

Matt smiled at her as Dani laid down on the bed on her back. She smiled at Matt and gestured to him to come to her. Matt approached her and spread her legs, as he placed his cock near her cunt’s entrance and then he slowly thrust his cock into her cunt.

“Aaah!”

He stopped and looked at her.

“Am I hurting you?”

“No. It’s just ... I’ve never had something as big as yours in there before.”

“What are you talking about? We just had sex a few days ago.”

“I meant before you. I’ve never had someone as big as you before I started dating you and it’s just taking me some time to adjust to your size,”

“Oh, ok. I’ll be gentle.”

He slowly inserted his cock into her, inch by inch, until it was in her completely. He was concerned that he was going to hurt her, so he was very gentle and careful. He started thrusting his cock slowly in and out of her and he watched her breasts jiggle as he pumped his cock in and out of her.

“Aaahh! Aahhh! Oh, my God. It feels sooo good! I’ve never felt anything like this before.”

Matt continued to fuck her slowly and gently.

“Matt, faster. Fuck me faster. I want you to cum in me.”

Matt started plowing her cunt with cock. Her breasts were jumping up and down as he fucked her without holding back. He felt a familiar tingling sensation in his balls and he knew he was about to deposit his cum in her cunt.

He increased his pace and came inside her. She screamed and shuddered as she experienced the best orgasm of her life. It felt like he deposited a gallon of cum in her pussy. Cum overflowed out of her pussy as he took his cock out of her cunt and laid beside her, taking deep breaths. He turned to her and looked at her, she was smiling.

Suddenly, the door flew open and Joanna came in.

“Joanna, what happened? I heard you screaming,” Joanna said.

Matt didn’t understand why Joanna was calling Dani “Joanna”. Then it hit him like a thunderbolt. He had slept with Joanna and the sister who was standing at the door was Dani. Dani’s mouth was open as she was trying to take in what had happened. Her boyfriend and her sister were lying naked in the same bed, NAKED, and his cum was leaking out of her cunt.

Tears started flowing out of Dani’s eyes.

“Matt, you asshole, how could you do this to my sister? How could you do this to me?”

“Dani, this isn’t what it looks like.”

“Now, my sister will become one of the “mates”, like me. How did this happen, Matt? Couldn’t you have controlled yourself a little?”

“Dani, I thought she was you.”

“Come on, you expect me to believe that? She would have told you that she wasn’t me.”

“Dani, believe me. She didn’t tell me that she wasn’t you.”

Dani’s eyes narrowed as she turned around to face her sister, who had now gotten up and was sitting in the bed, she had a smirk on her face.

“This is why you manipulated me into going out of the house to buy lingerie, so you could fuck my boyfriend. Why would you do this to me, Joanna?”

“Because, I know, Dani. I know that Matt is a werewolf. I know that ever since you had sex with him, you became immortal. We’ve been together since birth, Dani. I just couldn’t stand the thought of growing old and dying while you enjoy eternal life with your boyfriend, so that’s why I fucked him.”

“How did you know about Matt and me?”

“Yesterday, when you and your little boyfriend were having your little chat, I was listening.”

“But you left the house.”

“I turned on the sound recorder on my phone and kept it under my pillow. It recorded everything you guys said and then I listened to it once I came home.”

“Dani, we need to confirm if she has undergone the transformation to really become a “mate”.”

Dani grabbed Joanna’s hand and dragged her into the bathroom. She made Joanna stand in front of the mirror. “Joanna, I need you to imagine yourself as older and close your eyes and visualize it in your brain.”

“What? Why?”

“Just do what I say.”

Joanna closed her eyes and visualized how she would look as an older woman. She concentrated on the image and then she opened her eyes and found the image of her as an older woman staring at her in the mirror. She let out a scream, but Dani shut her mouth with her hand. Dani gestured to Joanna to keep quiet and Dani took her hand away from Joanna’s mouth. There were tears in Joanna’s eyes as she was scared shitless.