Chapter 5

“You know, for a ‘good Italian Catholic girl,’ Melanie, you’re rather open-minded. I don’t object to that, far from it. I certainly approve. It’s just a cognitive dissonance that I can’t overlook. Though, of course, you don’t always have to be a ‘good’ Catholic girl. You could be a bad one now and then,” I teased Melanie a little, causing her to snicker before feeding me my snowball.

“See now, I can be a ‘bad Catholic girl’ from time to time, can’t I? And the inner bad girl wants so badly for her fiance to fuck around on her. She even wants to make it happen, while the inner good girl will obey her husband and never even think of divorce or anything of the sort. I told you that you have a hall pass with each of these girls, you know. I mean it, trust me. Of course, even if you had no hall pass with a girl, what am I gonna do about it? I already told you that I’ll never leave you. I have no leverage here ... and that’s exactly how I like it!” Melanie confessed to me.

“And if I told you to do a girl, which part of you would want to do it? The good Catholic girl or the bad one?” I asked out of curiosity now.

“Both, if I’m being honest. The good girl wants to obey her hubby, while the bad girl wants to experience Sapphic pleasures at last,” Melanie admitted to me now.

“So, you’re at least bi-curious, if not bi outright?” I inquired of my fiancee.

“Oh, I’m definitely bi. It’s all that I can do not to grab Heather and kiss her on the lips,” Melanie told me as the episode ran its credits.

“Okay, then. I dare you to do it. Make out with Heather. That’s a dare from me, your own fiance,” I told Melanie, while Becca, Janine, and Paige listened in fascination.

“Come here, you!” Heather told Melanie as their tongues danced together at last, making it a very sensual Sapphic kiss.

“Wow, that’s incredibly hot ... but if we’re doing dares, what about bets? I bet you guys that Melanie won’t suck Simon’s cock out of someone’s ass. Now, who wants to volunteer their ass?” Becca interjected now.

“Stakes?” I asked, “and who is taking your bet?”

“Okay, I bet Heather that Melanie won’t suck your cock out of someone’s ass. Better? Stakes are that I get to suck her tits if I win. I’ve wanted to suck her tits for a while now. They’re such wonderful tits! I know that Melanie loves Simon and would do anything for him, but there must be limits to her devotion, right? After all, they don’t know each other that well. It’s almost love at first sight, okay, it basically is, but she doesn’t trust him that much, does she?” Becca asserted, making what I was sure was a sucker bet for Heather.

“Whose ass and what if you lose?” Heather demanded now, seemingly eager to get on with it now that Melane and she came up for air.

“If I lose, I have to eat your pussy instead. And as for whose ass, that narrows it down to Paige and Janine,” Becca asserted.

“What happened to not cheating on Eddie?” Paige laughed.

“Good question and I wish to make an amendment. If you lose, Becca, you have to eat Paige’s pussy, not mine. Still up for it?” Heather smirked.

“Sure, but that leaves Janine as the anal fuckee. If she’s up for it, that is. If she dares,” Becca insisted, “as for not cheating on Eddie, you know the guy would never object to me eating pussy or sucking tits, so it’s not cheating in this case. It’s only cheating if it’s something that your partner would protest or dislike. Eddie would so watch me suck tits or eat pussy, I can promise you that much.”

“I see your point in Eddie’s case. He’d think that he’d died and gone to voyeur Heaven,” I laughed now.

“Well, Janine? What’s it to be?” Becca asked her.

“Don’t you think that it’s taking a huge risk basing this on predictions of Melanie’s behavior? I think that your tongue is about to get very up close and personal with my ginger bush, girl,” Paige taunted my sister a bit now.

“So that we’re all on the same page here, if Melanie sucks Simon’s cock straight from my ass for at least a minute, it counts. If she backs off at less than a minute, Becca wins and sucks on Heather’s tits for ... how long?” Janine stipulated.

“Since Heather’s not lactating, let’s make it half an hour, unless she’s comfortable with longer,” I proposed now.

“Works for me. I’ll stick to the half hour ... this time. If she does well enough, I may seek an encore. I have to warn you ... my tits are a big zone for me. When people suck on my tits, it really turns me on. Just ask Paige. Simon, you should try it someday. I think that you’d love it!” Heather winked at me now.

“You mean that you could come just from having people suck your tits?” I asked my loving neighbor.

“Hell, yeah, and I have! Again, just ask Paige!” Heather licked her lips now.

“So, are we doing this bareback, then?” I wondered aloud now.

“Sure, that’s why it’s a bet. It’s also a test of how far I’d go, right?” Melanie licked her lips and I got a strong instinct about the outcome now ... but was my gut to be trusted here?

I shivered a bit as I considered the ramifications. It might not be cheating given Eddie’s likely tolerance and a possible lockdown hall pass, but Becca certainly pushed the envelope a bit with everyone here. She showed that she wanted to watch me sodomize someone and see if my own fiancee would do ass-to-mouth for me afterward. That was some pretty intense escalation of events now.

“Plenty of lube, please. I’m about to get my virgin ass wrecked by that thick prick of Simon’s. I’m gonna need it, trust me!” Janine declared as she led us to Becca’s bedroom and bent over.

“Spread ‘em, Janine. Let’s get you all lubed-up for my brother’s cock!” Becca surprised me now by even kissing and briefly licking Janine’s backdoor, “I had to get it a little wetter, you know. Eddie won’t mind this, I think.”

Then my sister started slipping fingers inside Jane’s asshole, applying the lube that Melanie eagerly brought us for this act of buggery. To our complete amazement, Becca really got into it for a minute, seemingly forgetting that her role was to prepare Janine’s tush for my prick. She must have enjoyed the taste of Janine’s bottom, which would make her more like me than she could ever really know. It was all that I could do not to rim and spank Janine before or after butt-fucking her, her ass looked that damn yummy!

Finally, though, Janine’s butthole was ready and I eased my first inch or two inside her. I gave her a moment to catch her breath, but then she bucked her hips on her own and I slid more of my dick into her derriere. I stopped again and she audibly moaned in response before bucking her hips yet again.

“Thanks for giving me a moment to cope, but you can stop the slow-poking. I’m horny as fuck now! Ram me deep! It will hurt, but I like it rough!” Janine pleaded with me.

I picked up the pace and sure enough, Janine moaned again ... and again ... and again. She moved that butt and her hips back at me repeatedly, trying to draw me deeper into her cornhole. On an instinct, I started slapping those olive-skinned buttocks of hers and she moaned even louder. There was a very strong feeling that she wouldn’t want to give this up. I had created an anal monster and she’d crave sodomy for the rest of her life now that she gave up virgin ass to me.

“You know that this is ... yours now, right? Forever yours! This ass belongs to you! No matter who I date or marry or whatever, you ... can ... have ... this ... on ... tap!” Janine announced now in front of everyone present.

“Repeat that, please, for posterity, Janine! I want to hear this for the record and I want future generations to know that MY BROTHER owns your sweet Iraqi ass! Are we clear?” Becca asked Janine as she hit record.

“SIMON HAVEN OWNS MY ASS!” Janine screamed in a way that there would be no mistaking her words on audio.

“Attagirl! I’m extremely pleased at this, since it means that I can asked to borrow it from Simon, not from you, and you’ll have to give it up to me ... if he tells you. Hell, if I have to, I can borrow your sweet ass for Eddie’s use as a peace offering after all of the cheating that I’ve done today,” Becca licked her lips while Janine bit her bottom lip from my strokes inside her butt.

“You’ve surrendered the booty to me, to me, a guy with such a fat cock that you might well leak blood from your asshole when I’ve finished, even with lube? Hot damn, that’s sexy as fuck! You really must dig pain!” I admired and fondled Janine’s buns while I plowed her backfield now.