Chapter 4: Like Mother like Daughter

Sunday, July 16th, 2006, Boston Massachusetts

“Hey, Jake!” Abby greeted me warmly as she climbed up into my truck, which caused her breasts to jiggle enticingly.

I couldn’t help but stare; her tits were just bursting from the tiny tight white Hooters shirt that she was wearing. The cleavage that she was sporting was huge; she had to be wearing some sort of push-up bra to get a look like that. I think that I must have zoned out just staring with my mouth open.

Damn, she’s smoking hot! Much better in person than by looking in your spank bank! I can’t believe that you were actually trying to fight this!? I’d bang her no matter how we were related. Are you sure that you’re not some wimpy ass faggot?

<What the hell, Dude? Don’t be an asshole if you’re going to be living in my head!>

Sorry! I must warn you now, I have Tourettes! Shit just comes right out, like verbal diarrhea! I don’t mean anything by it. Just ignore me when I get like that. I really do apologize, but there is absolutely nothing that I can do about it.

<Great, so now I’ll be fucking my three closest relatives, mind-controlling anyone and everyone, all while looking for more magical rings, and to top all that off, I have a mentally ill ghost living in my head. Maybe I’m just insane, and all of this is only part of my overactive imagination, and in reality, I’m just banging my head on a padded wall somewhere while drooling.>

“Uh, Jake? Umm, are we going to start driving any time soon? Or do you just wanna stare at my tits for a while? I cooooould take my shirt off if yaaaa waaant? Is that the problem, Jake? Would it help you to start the truck if I took off my shirt?” she asked as she giggled and used her hands to push her tits together even more obscenely.

“Uh, shit, Abs! I, uh, I’ve never seen you dress quite like that! Damn, you look hot, though,” I exclaimed as my gaze finally ran down to her tiny orange booty shorts that looked like they had been painted on.

“Thanks, Bro! But I mean, you’ve seen me in my bikini’s and my spandex and tube tops. That’s way less than this,” she pointed out with a curious smile.

“Yeah, but this is just, I dunno, it’s eye-popping, I guess. It’s damn sexy, that’s for sure. You must make a killing in tips, holy shit,” I muttered as I finally managed to drag my eyes away from her to start driving the truck.

“Thanks for the lift, Bro, but I’m curious, what’s up? I was kinda surprised that you wanted to come and get me at two in the morning when I already had a ride.”

<Uh, you mean that some poor sap had to do it with his own fucking brothers?! Ewww, damn, that’s gross! If your point was that I get to at least be incestuous with three gorgeous women, then yeah, I guess I’m lucky. That poor bastard!>

“I just wanted to spend some time alone with you. I missed you while I was gone for the past six weeks,” I said with a shrug.

“Aww, that’s sweet, Jake! I missed you too, and I mean that I really do. I didn’t really think about it until you were gone, but then after the first week, I found myself thinking about you a lot. I’m glad that you came home. We need you here. You’re the glue of the family since Dad died, you know.

Ram it up her poop chute!

“And holy shit, but did you set Heather straight or what! I was so pissed off at first thinking that you were perving on her because you spanked her bare ass, but it sure as hell has fucking worked so far! I sure hope that she stays this way, I really missed the little shit, and she was breaking Mom’s heart. We had such a great supper last night; we laughed and talked like we haven’t in forever. Thanks, Jake, I love you so much, Bro,” Abby said as she reached over and squeezed my forearm and smiled at me.

<So tell me, how did that poor sap die anyway?>

“I missed you, Abs, a lot. I thought of you, Heather, and Mom almost every night, and then I just couldn’t take it anymore, and I had to come home. Abby, the real reason that I came to get you tonight is that I wanted to have a real heart to heart talk with you. I want you to be honest with me, Abs,” I said as I reached a hand over and grabbed hers.

Tingle.

“Okay, sure thing. What’s so important? Is it something bad?”

“No, nothing bad, well, not really, I guess. I just wanted to know the truth about what you thought about what we did yesterday,” I asked as I glanced over to see her reaction.

She looked puzzled, “What do you mean? What did we do?”

<How would things spiral out of control? If people obey me, isn’t that what I want?>

<I can choose the strength?>

“Abby, I told you to pretend that nothing happened between us, but you don’t need to pretend with me. In fact, from this moment onward, you don’t need to pretend anymore at all. It’s okay. I want to know how you honestly feel about what we did together,” I told her sincerely as I squeezed her hand.

Tingle.

“Cool! I really wanted to talk to you about it, and then when you asked me not to, I just wanted to keep you happy, Bro. I love what we did; it just seemed so natural. When we came together, Jake, and you shot your stuff all over me, well, I’ve never been that turned on before. It was so naughty, and that made it so hot,” she said with a crooked sexy grin as she returned my hand squeeze.

My cock hardened in my pants, just listening to her. Fuck, there was no denying it anymore; I wanted my sister. I needed her; in more ways than one. She wouldn’t need to keep looking for the right man anymore because I was it, and she was mine.

You should try practicing

Practice fucking with her by making her get gangbanged by a roomful of midgets!

“God, Abby! I gotta confess something to you. I want you, I want you so badly, and my cock is a steel bar in my pants right now, just thinking about you. When I came on you and watched you cum for me, it was one of the horniest moments I’d ever had. Do you have a boyfriend right now?”

“Not really. I was seeing this guy that I met a couple of weeks ago. Why?” she asked, puzzled because I didn’t usually ask about her boyfriends.

“What happened to Tom?” I asked, mildly curious.

“Oh, him? I dropped him like a hot potato a few days after you left for New Orleans. Now I’m pretty much single,” she replied with a shrug as we pulled up in front of our house, and I parked the car. “Do you really want me, Jake?”

<I’ll figure something else to practice with besides my truck windows. I’m too caught up in making her mine.>

You’re beating around the bush for nothing. Just tell her that she’s yours, and then she will be, plain and simple. She wants it anyway, so it’s like you’re trying to throw a match on an already burning bonfire to make sure that it’s lit.

<Yeah, I’m still nervous. It’s not exactly like I’m used to all this. I still have that gut feeling that I’m going to command something and get slapped in the face. Oh, well, here goes nothing.>

“Yes, I do, Abby. I know that you’ve been looking for the perfect guy, and I know that you’ve been with quite a few men because you can never find the right one ... Abby, I am the right one. From this moment on, I am your man; you will stop seeing anyone else but me. I know that you love me, Abs, and I love you. You know how perfect we are for each other, we’ve always been close, and now we are going to be lovers, Sis,” I said matter-of-factly as I looked into her blue-grey eyes.

Tingle.

<I tried to amplify the command and make it stronger, but I was also trying to think that I didn’t want to hurt her mind in any way. Do you believe that I made it a suitable strength? I saw the rubies glow faintly this time instead of the emeralds.>

I watched as tears suddenly started streaming down her face as she stared at me with liquid shimmering eyes. For a second, I thought that I’d fucked up somehow, and my heart started hammering as I waited for her outburst of disgusted shock.

“Oh! Jake! You have just made me the happiest, luckiest girl in the whole world! I love you so much, and I’m going to be the best girlfriend that you’ve ever had! I always wondered what it’d be like to be with you and if you’d ever be able to do that with me. When Dad died, and I used to slip into bed with you when I was fifteen ... I wanted you so badly that my tummy ached, but I was so nervous.

“Too nervous to try anything, but I sure loved my big brother that cared enough to comfort me with no questions asked. You held me and cuddled me all night, it meant so much to me, and I was so sad back then. Being held in your arms was the only thing that helped. I’ve often dreamed of being able to sleep with you again, and now I can!” Abby said to me as she let her feelings pour out of her.

I turned off the truck, stepped out, and I walked over to her side, and helped her down. We stood under the street lamp, in front of our house, staring at each other. I reached out a hand and stroked her cheek, wiping away an errant tear as she placed her hands upon my chest and looked up at me.

“How much do you love me, Abby? Do you love me enough to give up all other men? To only be mine?” I asked quietly as she stepped closer and pressed her scantily dressed body against me.

“I love you more than life itself, and from the moment that you told me that you wanted me, the thought of any other man touching me became too abhorrent to even think about, and I exist only to be yours,” she said solemnly almost like she was making a vow. “Please, take me to your bed again like when I was fifteen, only this time make love to me, Jake,” she pleaded quietly, her voice quivering with her need.

“Okay, Abs, I want to do nothing more than to make love to you right now. I need you to know that as part of our new family dynamic, Heather is also my lover. I want you to not only understand and accept that but to be happy for us both. Rejoice in the fact that I can find love with both of my sisters. I want the thought of me making love to our baby sister to turn you on, Abs. She deserves happiness just like you do,” I told her seriously as I looked upon her with pure love shining from my eyes.

Tingle.

“Oh, God,” she groaned as she swooned a bit in my arms. “Jesus, Jake! That’s so fucking hot! Did you jizz in her yet? Oh, fuck, you gotta let me watch sometime, please! Oh, I am so happy for you both. We’re the luckiest sisters to have you, Jake. Please, take me inside; I need you. I’m so wet for you ... I’ve never been this horny before,” Abby said to me as she slipped her arms around my neck and pulled my lips down to meet hers in a scorchingly hot kiss that made my knees weak.

I gently broke the kiss as she whimpered and tried to keep her lips locked with mine.

“Come, Abs, let’s go inside,” I breathed as my cock throbbed in my shorts; I could feel the sticky wet spot from my pre-cum. It seemed like I’d been leaking like a sieve the past few days.

Tingle.

“Okay,” she breathed huskily.

I stuck the key in the door, yanked on it, and pulled at the same time. I really wanted to fix that goddamn door soon. As soon as we were inside the house and the door had closed, Abby launched herself at me again. She started trying to take her clothes off as she practically rammed her tongue down my throat.

“Whoa, slow down, Abs, we have all the time in the world. Let’s grab a few beers and take them to my room,” I suggested while I squeezed her ass and kissed her quick.

“We do? I thought we had to rush before Mom got home. That’s cool if we don’t have to rush. I want to fuck you all night, brother,” she purred in a sultry voice.

“It’s okay, Abby. Mom will be completely understanding about me being with you and Heather,” I said as I grabbed her hand and started leading her towards the bathroom.

<Yeah, I’m concentrating hard. I might slip up if I’m distracted though.>

“She will? Are you sure? I thought you wanted to grab some beers and go to your room, Jake?” she asked, mildly confused.

“Yeah, Mom’s going to be just fine, and she will be my lover also. Mom’s lonely, and she needs a man too, but not just any man can come and try to be a part of our family. Mom needs me to be her man, just like you and Heather do. We are all going to be one big happy family again, my love,” I told her warmly as I squeezed her hand. “We’re going to take a shower together, and then we’ll grab some beers.”

Tingle.

“Oh, wow, Mom too! Have you done her too then?” she asked salaciously.

“Not yet, but I’m planning on seducing her tomorrow after supper. I love all three of you more than I can even imagine, and it’s my job to take care of you,” I said as I led her into the bathroom and closed the door.

<Curse?>

I’ll tell you about it later. You need to learn a few other things first.

“Mom is going to be so lucky! I can take Heather out to a movie or something if you want some privacy, Jake. Mom deserves it, and I hope that you make her feel like a real woman!” she gushed, sounding both supportive and excited at the prospect. “Did you know that she hasn’t had sex since Dad was alive? She’ll be able to save a fortune on batteries now,” she said with a giggle as she peeled off her Hooters shirt and her white lacy push up bra.

“Yeah, I figured that she hadn’t. I didn’t know for sure about the sex part, but she’s never even been on a date that I saw. She loved Dad so much, and all that love just transferred to us after,” I said while my heart sped up from watching Abby’s tits flop free.

I froze in the middle of taking off my shorts as I was mesmerized by her mouth-watering twin globes of perfection. Her reddish-pink nipples were rock hard, and I was looking forward to sucking on them. Realizing that from this night onward, she was mine and that I could take her any time that I wanted her, along with our baby sister, was mind-boggling.

“You really like my tits, don’t you, Bro?” she asked rhetorically as she titled her head and smirked at me knowingly.

“Goddamn, they are magnificent, Abs,” I exclaimed as I continued to admire how they just seemed to defy gravity floating right there in front of me. “Girls must have hated you in high school, Sis.”

Whatever floats your boat. Abby could float a whole lot of motorboats with the personal flotation devices she’s sporting. She could probably float an entire football team worth of boats too.

“Some, but I didn’t care. The girls who liked me also liked sucking on them, and the jealous bitches just lost their boyfriends to me anyway,” she replied with a shrug as she stepped close to me and started to undress me.

“Shit, Abs! That’s so fucking hot!” I moaned as I peeled my shirt off while she pulled my shorts and boxers down.

“What is? My tits?” she asked as she made me lift each foot in turn so that I was standing there as naked as a jaybird.

“Well, yeah, that just goes without saying! But I meant the thought of some chick sucking on them, man, that’s hot!” I said as I pulled her up to kiss me.

<Hey, Malachar, Dude. Does seeing all this sex I’m having get you off too? Does it do anything for you? Can you feel what I feel and stuff? I mean, obviously, you can hear and see what I do. So I was wondering, how far does that go?>

“Mmm, I’ve always been bi, Jake. I thought that you knew that? Would you like me to bring another woman to join us some time?” Abby asked as she broke our kiss to start licking and nipping her way down my chest.

<Uh, what!? Uh, Dude, I, uh ... I don’t swing that way, man! Like, are you serious? Uh, oh, man! Fuck! I dunno even what to say, Bro... >

“You all right? Is something wrong?” Abby asked me with concern as she stopped kissing my chest to look up into my face.

“Yeah, everything is awesome, Abs. I mean, how can’t it be! I got you in my arms, and I’m going to be making love to you for the first time very soon. I love you, Sis. Come, let’s get in the shower,” I said reassuringly while concentrating on not using my ability.

<You fucker! Your laughter echoing through my head is pretty fucking creepy just so you know!> I told Malachar with an internal smile.

I watched as she leaned over into the shower stall and turned on the water. Luckily for us, we had a separate stand-alone one, and it was big enough to fit two easily. It was one of those all-glass units, no curtains. I remembered being fascinated with it when our Dad had first installed it. It was one of the last things that he had built before he was diagnosed with lung cancer. He’d put in one of those fancy chrome shower heads that you can pick up and move around, and the pressure was intense. The shower that we used to have in the bathtub had almost zero pressure, and it had been like showering in a drizzle. I reminisced about back when I had first seen the new one and about how I’d thought that it’d be so cool if I could see my sister taking one through the glass. Now here I was about to take one with her.

I reached out and grabbed the waistband of her skin tight Hooters booty shorts and peeled them down.

“Mmm, oh my God, Jake. I want you so fucking bad! I’ve had lots of sex, Bro, and I’ve never for the life of me been this excited before!” she moaned to me.

Underneath her shorts, she had on the skimpiest white lacy thongs, and I peeled them down as well, planting a big wet kiss on her ass cheek as I did so. I could smell her arousal, which in turn increased mine. What a fantastic thing sex was.

“Shit, let’s make this a quick shower; I dunno if I can wait much longer. You’re so goddamn hot, Abs!” I told her seriously as my cock was straining to reach out and touch her.

We both got in and kissed for a few minutes while letting the hot water run over our torso’s. I let my hands roam all over her tight sexy body; man was she was stacked! The hazy feeling of lust was back inside of my brain again, although it felt comfortable this time around. I didn’t feel like I was being dragged anywhere that I didn’t want to go; I was just so damn turned on. Kissing Abby and feeling her hands running all over me while I did the same to her was surreal, and damn could she kiss!

Heather had been a whole different type of experience, I realized, and they really couldn’t be compared. Other than the fact that they were both my sisters, I got super turned on by each of them for entirely separate reasons. Heather was innocent, and making love with her had been a heady experience knowing that I was taking her down a path that she had never been on before.

Abby had me ready to climb out of my skin; she knew exactly what she was doing. Her every touch was designed to spike my arousal, and she knew how to mold herself to me in such a way that had me panting for more. She was electric, and she had me zapped with her current of love.

“Shit, wash me Abs, and then I’ll do you. Quick, I really don’t want to fuck you in here for our first time, but I am not going to be able to hold out for much longer,” I said in between the sexy wet kisses that she was giving me.

She playfully bit my lower lip and pulled it out from my face as her gorgeous blue-grey eyes sparkled at me with lusty amusement. She knew that she drove guys crazy, and now the most important man in her life was under her spell, and she reveled in it.

“Mmm, okay, Jake! You know you have a very sexy bod, Bro,” she complimented as she grabbed the soap and started to wash me sensuously. I turned around so that she could do my back, “Oh, Jake! Did Heather tear up your back, Bro? Is she a little hellcat or what? Fuck, I really want to watch you two, especially if she claws the fuck out of you like that! You must have fucked her really good!”

“Actually, no, the claw marks aren’t from her, although she was amazing to make love to. The best I’ve had so far, to be honest...”

“Really? Hmmm, we’ll just have to see about that!” Abby challenged with a fierceness in her eye as she nipped at my shoulder and growled like the little minx that she was. “So who made the wounds of love all across your upper back then, loverboy?”

“My new girlfriend, Sheila...”

“You have a girlfriend?! When do we get to meet her? Do I need to be worried?” she asked with a tinge of jealousy showing through.

“You will love her, Abs. She’s smart, funny, gorgeous, and a wildcat in bed, and she makes me happy. She’s no threat to you, Mom, or Heather at all. In fact, I bet that you guys will love her just as much as I do when you get to meet her. So don’t be jealous, I will always put family first, and I will never abandon you or leave you, Abs, I mean that. I promise you, I will always love you as a man loves a woman and as my sister,” I said to her with a loving smile on my face as I cupped her cheeks and kissed her deeply with meaning.

Tingle.

She melted under me, and I felt the tension leave as she moaned into my mouth and her hands clutched at me around my waist.

“Okay, thank you, Jake. I couldn’t bear it if you ever left me or neglected me for another. I trust you, and I’m glad that you said what you did. I believe every word, but I truly needed to hear that. Now I’m looking forward to meeting her. Will she be okay with you being with us three too? Incest won’t bother her?” she asked as she continued to wash me.

“No, she loves me deeply, and she just wants me to be happy, and my family makes me happier than anything else in the world,” I said with a pleasant sigh; her fingers were magic.

It’s smart to have them all meet, so they can get to know each other, especially if you intend to make Sheila one of your five.

I closed my eyes and tilted my head back as I concentrated on the feeling of her touch, rubbing all over every inch of my skin. She left my ass and cock for last, and when she finally washed me there, I hissed with a sharp uncontrollable intake of breath.

“Oh! Fuck, your touch feels so good! I never thought that it’d be my sisters touching me and loving me one day ... this is so crazy and so fucking hot...”

“I know, right?! I wanted you for so long! I just thought it’d always stay a fantasy, and now you made me yours forever! You’ve made me so happy! Okay, you’re all done, my turn!” she quipped as she handed me the soap and turned her back to me.

I enjoyed washing her and sliding my hands all over her slippery skin, but I went fast; I really needed to make love now. When I got to her slick pussy and her asshole, I almost shot off just by touching her there. Seeing the reaction that she had to my hands upon her didn’t help either.

“Oh, Jake, fuck, let’s get out of here! I can’t wait any longer, or I’ll rape you right here for fuck sakes!”

I made a grunt of agreement and turned off the water as soon as she was all rinsed.

“Hey, just out of curiosity, have you ever done anal?” I asked as I dried her ass and back.

“Yeah, a couple of times. Why? Does big brother want to stick his big weenie in his wittle sister’s butthole?” she asked as she acted like a little girl twisting side to side and biting her finger while looking up at me with doe-eyes.

“Well, if I didn’t before, I sure as fuck do now!” I laughed as I smacked her ass.

Without warning, I picked her up and threw her naked body over my shoulder, and burst from the bathroom, running off with her to my room on the other side of the house. Her giggles were priceless. I loved making her laugh and smile.

I burst through the door into my bedroom, startling Heather awake, who had been sleeping naked in my bed. I felt abashed at first. I genuinely felt bad that I’d forgotten that I’d left her there asleep to go and get Abby. For some reason, I’d had the thought that she would have gone to her own bed, but now that I was confronted with the reality of the situation, that wouldn’t have been right. She had just lost her virginity to me; I needed to make sure that she felt loved.

Why not just send her to her room? She won’t mind if you command it.

<Maybe not, but I would. Even though I have this power, I want them to feel truly loved and special to me because they really are.>

“J-Jake?” Heather asked as she blinked her bleary eyes. “Abby?”