Chapter 4

“Wait, what about Sarah?” I suddenly remembered, “I know that she can’t do certain dares or have them done to her, we’ve all agreed, but she still gets to play the game. We can’t exclude her. How about this? Sarah gets to ask the questions from now on. That resolves the other issue, too. It also means that she can make the dares rather than have to do them.”

“Awww, thank you, Daddy!” Sarah went from a little put out from feeling forgotten to over the moon from being made the center of attention, and it showed on her beaming face, even as she dodged Kay’s kisses to plant a few on my face.

“See, this is why Abe is such a good father. He thinks of everyone. He looks out for all of his kids. Jerry, by contrast, had the nerve to imply recently, the last time that I contacted him to remind him of his parental obligations and ask him about possibly making it a wash by letting Abe adopt, that Sarah wasn’t his, because he thought that perhaps I had gotten her from another man.

“So what if she has somewhat darker hair and skin, she’s still Jerry’s unless I have reason to think otherwise, and Jerry mounted me far more often than any other man did, well, up until I met Abe, which sadly wasn’t until after Sarah was born.

“To be honest, I wish that Abe had put Sarah in my womb. I wish that he had put all of them in my womb, in fact, but the facts are the facts. And another fact is that, whatever paternity says, Jerry may or may not be the biological father, but he is the legal father. Still, he’s not Daddy and never will be. Abe is Daddy to Sarah and all of my girls, just ask them! That’s what Jerry lost by not being there for his girls. They’re not his anymore,” Tricia observed, praising me and openly castigating her ex.

“Yeah, he’s my Daddy and that’s just how it always will be! And I do hope that Jerry lets Daddy adopt us! You notice that I never call Daddy by his given name, but I always do with Jerry. That alone should tell you something,” Sarah remarked, “I never even met the guy, not since I was taken to Nana’s house and Daddy came along. Daddy is the only father that I’ve really known at all. I was just a baby when he took you back to Ohio with him. Daddy is the only father that I know and America is the only country that I know. Odd that I’m not a citizen yet, but I’m so American it’s not funny.”

“Yeah, we’ll have to work on getting you naturalised. It would be a grave injustice not to see you become officially American. You don’t even speak with an Australian accent and you only use Anglophile words now and then, mostly around us. I’ve heard how you talk around others. Very American. You’re my daughter, but you’re Abe’s daughter, too. He’s a Yank, why shouldn’t you be? For me, I’m content to be an Aussie, but I do love America, too. It’s become my home, at least with Abe, our daughters, and good friends like Stavros and Vicki here. Anyway, Sarah, my dear, sweet baby girl, be a darling and ask the next round of questions, will you?” Tricia piped in, kissing our daughter on the lips, but more in a familial than a romantic or sexual way.

Sarah replied to that by inserting a bit of tongue in her mother’s mouth, leaving no question that she found Tricia physically attractive as well as a wonderful mother, and answering, “For you, Mom, or Mum, if you will, absolutely! Oh, and Mama?”

“Yes, dear?” Tricia asked her.

“When I turn fifteen, I’m going to find you, and I’m going to make love to you!” she said as she gave her another steamy French kiss.

“Well, darling, you shan’t have to look very hard, shall you?” Tricia teased her, making her laugh.

Sarah then replied, “No, thankfully, I won’t. Anyway, first question should be for you, I think. Truth or dare?”

“Dare!” Tricia’s eyes blazed now with growing lust.

“I dare you to let me sit on your lap. Don’t worry. I won’t do anything sexual with you. I know the rules. I’m only fourteen. I can’t actually do anything of that nature. But I want to sit on your lap and I want you to feel the wetness of me. Again, we haven’t done anything wrong or inappropriate and we won’t, but I would like to sit on your lap and rest my head on your lap for a while, and let you feel just how wet I really am right now. I am very attracted to you, to Daddy, to Stavros, to Vicki, to the Cohens, and yes, to my own sisters, and also to Demetrios. That’s just how it is,” Sarah asked her, approaching her mother, who simply cooperated with her daughter’s stated intentions.

“Done! You’re on my lap. Happier, sweetie?” Tricia said as she hugged our baby girl.

“Yes, very happy, Mommy!” Sarah answered, hugging her tightly and kissing her face.

Tricia was admittedly a bit uncomfortable, but Sarah was as good as her word, not grinding against her mother’s crotch or squirming enough to actually make it feel inappropriate. She contented herself with hugging and kissing her mother, resting her head on her shoulders and her bosom, and things of that nature. Aside from the fact that she was naked and so was Tricia, no one would have thought anything odd about it.

Sarah was just being a sweet and loving daughter as always. She was admittedly nicer to her mother than most girls her own age might have been. It was not typically “cool” or whatever to be so affectionate toward one’s parents.

“Okay, now, Daddy, truth or dare?” Sarah turned to me next.

“Dare!” I spoke for my part.

“Okay, I dare you to fuck Stavros in the ass!” Sarah became very bold, even as she innocently sat on her mother’s lap.

“Well, Stavros, a dare’s a dare. Care to get out the lube? I think that the girls want to watch us do this, anyway,” I coughed a bit.

“Yes, they do! And this is frankly a fantasy come true for me. I won’t lie about that. I’ve wanted this for a good while now,” Stavros got out some lube and carefully applied it to my dick before putting it in my hands, “Will you do the honors and lube up my asshole with your fingers?”

“Sure, buddy,” I acted as if it were perfectly normal for a happily married man who always considered myself straight to lube up his neighbor manually so that he could sodomize him.

Stavros reacted to my fingers with obvious excitement, his dick stiffening in a hurry, and I hadn’t even entered him yet. When I began to inch my cock, a little at a time, into his butt, my friend reacted by moving his hips, too, while the girls became noticeably wet, especially Tricia and Vicki.

Something about watching their husbands have gay sex really turned them on. Once I was inside Stavros, I couldn’t help but notice how tight he was, but to be fair, he usually Topped rather than bottomed.

It wasn’t too much longer before I had bottomed out inside Stavros, my thick cock stretching him a bit further, even as my hands wandered on their own toward his prick to pleasure him manually. He responded by pushing back aggressively with his hips, as well as grunting and sighing in reaction to my efforts to jerk him off. We kept up the rough, lusty buggery for several more minutes, my hands inexperienced with giving a man a reach around, but I figured it out, just as I got used to pounding his asshole at just the right pace. When Vicki joined us to help me masturbate Stavros, I didn’t exactly object, as we both knew that he needed hands more expert in handling his cock and balls.

We continued the sodomy for probably fifteen to twenty minutes, but by the end, Vicki already made Stavros cum in her palm. She began licking his jizz up as if it were a very nice cream and I became even more excited, making it tougher not to cum just yet. When Vicki started rimming me and fingering my own asshole, even slipping what was left of Stavros’s spunk inside my sphincter, I lost it, shooting my load deep inside her husband. I had done it. I had just sodomized my best friend and he had loved every minute of it!

“Wow, that was amazing! Thank you, Abe. Thank you, honey. Thank you, Sarah! I enjoyed that a lot. In fact, I think that I needed it. It helps to experience life as a bottom now and then, at least when your buddy is the Top. Don’t worry, I won’t ask you to bend over for me. This was a special treat and I meant what I said before. You should Top. I should bottom. And we both Top with Demetrios. He should always bottom. Here, let me wipe off your dick,” Stavros lovingly applied sanitizing wet wipes and a washcloth in a hurry, making my prick jump a little with excitement at his surprisingly gentle touch.

“Ooh, somebody enjoyed his first gay sex, didn’t he?” Vicki teased me a little before giving me a serious lip lock and one to her hubby as well, “You guys, that was awesome! I loved helping you out with that. Now, if you’ll pardon me, I shall wipe my face and wash my fingers clean.”

“Alright, next one, as it will take some time for Daddy to recover. And we haven’t even eaten lunch yet. Stavros, your turn. Truth or dare?” Sarah challenged him now, still sitting on her mother’s lap like an angel while giving out devilish dares.

“Dare, since I enjoyed your last one so much!” Stavros chuckled, although he was a bit sore as he sat down.

“I dare you to eat Fanny out for the next ten minutes. Just kneel and worship her pussy with your mouth, and bear in mind that she might still have your taint on her tongue, so this is a reasonable act of gratitude, don’t you agree, Uncle Stavy?” Sarah encouraged him, not that he needed much to do that to a girl who had actually licked his taint that same morning.

Stavros shrugged and went to town on Fanny, making her moan, hiss, whimper, groan, and sigh as he spent the next ten minutes devouring Fanny’s snatch. My eldest couldn’t help herself. Stavros knew how to eat a girl out for sure, no question of that. We all watched in fascination, especially as Stavros stuck his tongue as deeply inside Fanny’s twat as he could get it, which really excited her and brought her to yet another climax from his oral favors. When ten minutes were up, both of them were actually loathe to stop, but they finally tore themselves away and resumed the game.

“Alright, so it’s Vicki’s turn, and she just returned, too!” Stavros noted as his wife reacted by giving him a French kiss that allowed her to taste Fanny on his lips and tongue.

“Mmmmm, Fanny’s really yummy, isn’t she?” Vicki winked at my firstborn and her own husband as she said that.

“That she is,” Stavros agreed, making Fanny blush in spite of herself.

“Alright, now, Aunt Vicki, here it comes. Truth or dare?” Sarah now addressed my neighbor’s wife, who gave a gleam of absolute mischief as she licked her lips in response.

“Dare, of course! Seems to be fun at this stage of things, and everyone else is taking dares. I don’t want to be left out,” Vicki shrugged and winked at me now.

“I dare you to suck Daddy’s cock,” Sarah now directed her, and boy did Vicki answer! The next thing that I knew, my dick was buried in a hot, wet mouth that felt like a pussy at times, as Vicki licked, sucked, and orally pleasured me with a vengeance! She licked me from the head to the base more than once, and then she went back to practically inhaling my prick, more than once stopping to mouth, “Thank you,” to both Sarah and me before she went back to work on my dick. If Vicki worried about the fact that this dick had just been in her husband’s ass, she didn’t show any signs of it, as she proved by blowing me with enthusiasm.

“This mouth is yours whenever you want it, you know. Yours. Stavros’s. Tricia’s. Everyone’s. Just a reminder. You want me to give you head, just grab my ears and push me down to your crotch. I’ll get the message. Face fuck me, please!” Vicki urged me now, as I began to actually do just that, fucking her throat like it was a twat.

“So, if I want to shut you up when you’re talking too much, this is the way to do it,” I teased her, though not too much, as she had me in a rather vulnerable place right then ... one sharp bite and I’d be a eunuch.

“Hell, yeah! Shut me up with your dick and I’ll be happy as a clam!” Vicki winked at me as she eagerly resumed the deep-throat part of the blowjob and gladly chose my cock over air.

“I might have to take you a place or two and have you give me head under a desk or table or something. It might be fun to know that you’re giving me a blowjob while no one but us has a fucking clue. Same with Tricia, actually. I bet that either of you ladies would enjoy it. Hell, maybe my daughters and the Cohens, perhaps even Stavros and Demetrios, would like that, too,” I actually stroked Vicki’s hair, short in a dirty blonde pixie cut, as she went down on me with a gusto that few could match. That girl knew her fellatio for sure!

“Honey, take me anywhere that you want and do that to me! I’ll gladly tag along and suck your cock under the table! I’d do it for Stavros and Demetrios, too! And all of our ladies as well. If they want me to eat them out under a desk, I’ll do it without hesitation!” Vicki swore to us all.

“Time’s up!” Sarah announced, “Sorry, guys. I hate to interrupt your fun, but you don’t want Daddy to cum in your mouth yet, do you? That would ruin the fun of seeing Daddy knock Aunt Vicki up, for instance! I just want to see you have fun without going too far yet. Have to build up that load again, right?”

“Fair enough. I would be far too sore to impregnate Vicki for a few hours if I went too long this time around. So soon after butt-fucking Stavros, that is,” I admitted, as Vicki shrugged and kissed me eagerly on the mouth.

“That’s for fucking my face and that’s for fucking my husband’s ass!” Vicki gave me yet another steamy tongue kiss, “That was so much fun! We should do it again some time, and finish the job. The blow job, that is.”

“Yes, we should. Now, who’s next, Sarah?” I reminded my youngest, who had become the impartial (or not so impartial) mistress of ceremonies by now.

“Fanny’s turn. Fanny, dear Sis, truth or dare?” Sarah challenged her elder sister, sticking her tongue out at her in a gesture meant to suggest cunnilingus, too ... there was no missing the lesbian subtext there.

“Dare!” Fanny continued her brazen tomboy ways.

“I dare you to eat Mommy out, then!” Sarah demonstrated her boldness yet again, and there was no doubt that her earlier gesture had been a foretaste of her intentions.

“You’ll need to slip off her lap if I’m to eat her cunny, Sis,” Fanny reminded her, which Sarah willingly did with a parting kiss to her mother.

“Enjoy Fanny’s mouth, Mommy,” Sarah teased Tricia a bit, making my wife and Fanny both blush.

Sure enough, we were then treated to the sight of my eldest daughter enthusiastically performing oral sex on her own mother, my own wife, who couldn’t help but moan and writhe as she experienced the sheer bliss of her daughter’s tongue. Tricia began cussing, screaming, whimpering, squirming, and shivering as she felt Fanny’s mouth on her twat. The way that Fanny cupped her buns while she licked her pussy didn’t hurt, either, as she was very gentle and loving in her approach to her mother’s cheeks.

For the next twenty minutes or so, we watched in fascination as Fanny truly dined at the Y, licking her mother’s snatch like it was going out of style, while Tricia endured one orgasm after another until she was exhausted and Fanny finally stopped. My eldest daughter’s face was shiny with her mother’s juices, but that didn’t stop Tricia from pulling her up and giving her a French kiss that set new levels of eroticism. To say that my wife appreciated her daughter’s oral services was to understate the matter, as she made out with Fanny for a good minute longer before coming up for air.

“Darling, that was fantastic! I don’t know where you learned to be that good at eating quim, but you’re a natural! Thank you so much, dear daughter! Your Mum is so happy with you right now! I owe you, big time, love!” my wife assured our daughter, even as I noticed how hungry we all were.

“Speaking of things eaten, let’s take a lunch break, shall we? It’s almost noon. Time to eat something that will actually reach the stomach, though I must admit that Tricia has a truly delicious cunt. I should know,” I winked at my wife, who then gave me a kiss that let me taste both Fanny’s mouth and her own slit, while everyone applauded.

“I should add, though, that the yummiest part of Tricia is her ass! Trust me on that! Rimming her is a definite treat! You think that her pussy tastes great, try her bottom some time!” I recommended my wife’s booty to my friends and family as if there were nothing unorthodox about that.

“Oh, stop! Just for that, you get a blowjob under the table while we eat, and I don’t want to hear any arguments about that, darling! The kitchen’s my domain, remember? You’re the boss elsewhere, but my kitchen, my rules!” Tricia announced as she made out with me and fondled my cock and balls, both of them still semi-hard from Vicki’s blowjob earlier, “Since we don’t want to edge you, or waste your spunk right now, that means that you should go ahead and fuck Vicki while I cook. Are you up for that?”

“Am I ever!” I grabbed Vicki and to no one’s surprise, she bent over the smaller table in the kitchen quite eagerly, offering me her twat like it was standard operating procedure for her.

“So, are you really going to give up your receptionist job to become a porn star?” I teased Vicki as I fucked her in front of our entire family.

“Well, that or a stripper. Maybe a cam girl. Something sexual in nature, that allows me to perform, though porn star sounds best in my present, raunchy mood. I’ve always been a slut at heart, but now I’m really getting in touch with my inner whore. And guess what? I love her! Like right now, I adore you and I want you to really slam me hard! Take me! Ravage me! Make me your bitch!” Vicki egged me on as I fucked her good and rough while my wife cooked grilled cheese and ham sandwiches for lunch, one of my personal favorites now that I’m no longer kosher.

“Yes, take her, Abe! Fuck my wife good! Pound her nice and hard! Screw her over the kitchen table!” Stavros encouraged me, while Fanny cupped my ass and whispered sexy words to me, mostly to motivate me to really ravish my neighbor’s fertile wife.

“She’s fertile, Daddy! I want a baby brother or sister, Daddy! Knock my auntie up! Put a baby in her womb! Put your seed in her belly!” Emma now spoke up, adding her words to the mix.

“Yes, love, go balls deep! Fill my sweet sister slut Vicki up good with your spawn! Seed her! Breed her! Long dick her! Hit it hard from the back! Bottom out inside our Vicki slut, and you know that’s what she really is now! OUR Vicki! She’s ours. Yours. Mine. Stavros’s. The girls’ Vicki, too. Vicki belongs to all of us, don’t you, Vick? You want my husband to breed you, don’t you?