Homeschool Annie's Divided Heart - Cover

Homeschool Annie's Divided Heart

Copyright© 2026 by Mathias Carter

Episode 4: The (Un) Accidental Meet Up

Erotica Sex Story: Episode 4: The (Un) Accidental Meet Up - Annie has built a full life on a rural Ohio homestead—married for 22 years, raising her 10 children, and settled into the rhythms of family and farm. A message arrives from her former boyfriend she hasn’t heard from in over 20 years. She tells herself it’s harmless. Just catching up. But will the door she just opened be the catalyst to something she can no longer control?

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Teenagers   Consensual   Reluctant   Romantic   Heterosexual   Fiction   Farming   Restart   Cheating   Cuckold   Slut Wife   RAAC   Interracial   White Female   Hispanic Male   White Couple   Exhibitionism   Facial   Masturbation   Oral Sex   Voyeurism   Public Sex   Slow   Illustrated  

It was the Saturday after the accidental photo send. James waited in his black pickup truck, a 2022 Ford F-150, in the parking lot of the corner store, next to the local hardware store. His eyes fixed on the road where he anticipated Annie’s black minivan to pull in.

Ever since James was fortunate enough to obtain Annie’s phone number, the temptation floated around in his mind; should he push for an in person meet up with Annie? He had to be wise about it and not appear desperate or creepy. And Annie’s suspicion of him would be high, especially since they definitely did not end on good terms. Nobody would think Annie would give him the time of day given the evil James had engulfed upon Annie after the break up.

But Annie was a Christian woman, and although James didn’t realize it, her care for those who were without Christ and the hope she now held out for others would be the open door that he needed to get back into her life. Carefully.

As the days of conversation went by with Annie, James began to collect information about Annie in his curiosity. First he had looked up her address through basic searches online. Putting things together through who her husband was, and then property records searches. Easy stuff for someone like him.

James would later decide to park his truck on the road Annie lived and take a walk down the road at certain times of the day where there was less activity. A lot of people on the road took walks. He knew how to dress to look like he was someone just walking or jogging the area. Sunglasses, a hat. Nobody would know better.

He learned some of Annie’s routine through observation and what Annie had shared through their daily texting. Enough to know that Annie would very likely be at the Hardware Store sometime between 10-11a.m. Today she was going to pick up some wood chips and grab a few other things. The Carter’s always tried to support their local businesses nearby instead of going to the big corporate stores.

Finally, after what seemed like a very long wait, Annie’s black minivan pulled into the parking lot of the Hardware Store around 10:44 a.m. Pete’s was family owned and had grown in size and capacity from the early years, back in the 1980s. Annie parked the van, looking distracted. She took off her seatbelt and pulled out her notebook.

“Perfect,” James thought to himself. “She isn’t alert enough to notice me.”

Annie got out of the van, holding her large denim purse on her shoulder. She wore a light cotton sundress, yellow with flowers, with thin straps. The dress went down to her ankles, and though not the tightest dress, she still couldn’t hide her shape. James noticed she was wearing her typical black rectangular glasses and her hair in pigtails. Very cute, and intentional, but modest and not provocative. As Annie approached the entrance, an older gentleman held the door open for her.

Once James knew she was inside, he pulled his vehicle into the hardware store parking lot.

“I’ll give it a few minutes, but not too long,” he thought to himself. He didn’t want it to look like he had followed her but didn’t want to wait so long as to miss his opportunity.

James knew he shouldn’t be doing this. Several days before he got to see the new and improved version of Annie’s wonderful body in that hot set of lingerie, James had asked Annie:

“Annie, would you ever be open to meeting in person? Just once. Before I go back to Texas. We can do it in public so you know I wouldn’t try anything funny. Hell, you can even bring your husband or someone from your family if you think it’s safer that way. I just want the proper chance to apologize in person for how I treated you in the past.”

Annie contemplated strongly, but ultimately decided against it. She debated in her mind between showing forgiveness in person– giving him a chance to show his repentance, and the danger James presented. Not a physical danger. No. She believed that James had changed somewhat for the better. It was the danger of her own emotions she was afraid of.

She finally got up the courage to tell her husband the truth. Well ... most of the truth anyway. She mentioned how that James had contacted her on Facebook and wanted to meet to apologize. She explained the full details of their past, as far as how it ended is concerned. The violent nature of his past and the fact that Annie had such a close relationship with him, made him give a firm “No” to Annie. Annie knew her duty was to obey her husband and so she decided to tell him, “I’m sorry, James. I just can’t. I hope you understand. I am praying for your safe trip back to Texas and that you’ll find a good life back in your home state.”

Annie didn’t give Mathias the whole truth, however. How she had maintained a texting conversation with him for days. No. She wanted to, but was afraid that he would be very angry with her. So she decided to try to gradually wean off the conversation until James finally returned to Texas.

James stepped out of his truck. He paused for a moment, then shut the door. He put on his sunglasses to slightly conceal his identity. Once he got into the store, he walked towards the area where the furnace filters would be. Chris never told him he needed one, but “he needs one now” James said to himself. He needed a decent excuse to be at the same store as Annie.

James didn’t completely know why he was pressing the situation with Annie, but deep down he had to admit to himself that he wanted another opportunity at a relationship with her. At the very least, a sexual connection. What he had with her back then he was never able to duplicate.

He looked down at his phone. The picture of Annie in her red lingerie. He thought of Annie, on her knees for him at his family’s home; when he took Annie to Mexico with him. Annie looking up at him with those same innocent blue eyes; so willing. So submissive. Willing to serve. It’s what she lived for. What she still lives for; but now for Mathias and not him. He longed for that again.

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In