Love, Lies and Punishment (Part 7 of Series)
Copyright© 2026 by BethanyBelow
Chapter 13: The Shoe
True Story Sex Story: Chapter 13: The Shoe - The 7th story in my Infidelity series about how I cheated on my BF, got involved with the guy I cheated with for 6.5 months and what started as a mistake, became an affair and then slowly turned into my loss of self and degradation. This 7th story takes place about 7 weeks after I first cheated. Be sure to read the previous stories for this to make sense.
Caution: This True Story Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Coercion Reluctant Romantic Heterosexual True Story Cheating BDSM DomSub MaleDom Humiliation Rough Spanking Anal Sex Cream Pie Enema Exhibitionism Massage Masturbation Oral Sex Sex Toys Squirting Water Sports Public Sex
The last time he had been on the phone when I arrived, I had ended up on my knees in his bedroom because he told me to wait there. I wasn’t interested in repeating the wait. I wanted to leave him as wrecked as the Uber had left me.
I stayed on the ottoman, close enough that my knees bracketed his shin, and decided the apology could wait until he did not have a witness in his ear. Just like the last time I was feeling playful and, for once, he was in a position where he was limited in what he could do in response.
I knew he had to leave for the meeting, so he couldn’t do anything about me until he got back. I wanted him to walk into that room hard and useless, thinking about the woman who had just gone to the mall for him, come to his house, and tied his shoes.
He was saying something about a revised number and that the client needed to see a face.
I rolled my hips like I was settling, which was a lie, and let the skirt ride. His eyes flicked down, froze for a moment, and then flicked back to a point past my shoulder, the way people look when they are trying to avoid something that will distract them from remaining professional. I smiled at him and made sure he saw me. It was the smile I use when I am about to be a problem.
You are going to get him fired, the mirror-voice said, delighted. Or promoted, hard to tell with men.
I spread my knees another inch. The tiny piece of fabric that was my thong was still soaked from the car. Cool air hit it, and I rubbed the leg he had parked between mine, slow, thumb tracing the muscle above the new shoe, not quite sexual and then obviously sexual, and watched his mouth fight a grin.
He mouthed crazy.
I mouthed you love it.
He almost laughed into the phone and turned it into a cough. “Sorry. Allergies. Go on.”
I cupped my breasts through the blouse and pinched, lightly, just enough to make my nipples stand harder against the cotton. His gaze dropped and stayed. I tipped my head and gave him the innocent face, the one that has never once worked on Amber and was not working on him either.
“If you keep looking at me like that,” I whispered, barely a sound, “Ray or whoever is going to think you had a stroke.”
He put a finger to his mouth. Quiet. His eyes were not quiet. They were having a wonderful time.
I undid two more buttons. The blouse fell open enough that he could see the inner curve of both breasts and the fact that I had not bothered with a bra. I stood and started to sway my hips in a little dance, badly and on purpose, a little shoulder, a little hip, straddling the leg that was still bent, his new shoe planted on the ottoman. He grinned so hard he had to look at the ceiling to keep his voice level, and mouthed sorry again, like the apology could cover the meeting and the fact that he was enjoying this.
This is still a joke, I told myself. You can stop at the joke. You are a funny woman who ties shoes and then goes home.
Then I saw his cock. It was a hard, thick line pressed sideways under the slacks, the head a clear shape against the fabric. The joke ended at that moment.
I took the skirt and the thong off together. The air on my bare pussy made me shiver. I was swollen, glossy, the kind of wet that would have embarrassed me in a doctor’s office and was currently the point. I bent at the waist, close to his face, and dropped the thong over his mouth and nose. It was soaked through, and the smell of me must have been ridiculous.
He rolled his eyes and raised a hand. He grabbed the thong, held it firmly against his nose, and inhaled. His eyes shut for half a second, and then he looked at me and mouthed Oh my God, and you have to stop. His free hand, however, did not push me away, and his cock obviously did not agree with that statement either, as I could see it almost dancing with little jerks under his slacks.
I pouted and shook my head.
Naked now, blouse hanging open off my shoulders, I stood between his knee and the ottoman and rolled my hips in a slow circle. One hand slid down my stomach.
I split myself with two fingers and let him see how open I was, how the wet strung between my fingers when I pulled them up to my mouth. I sucked those fingers clean without looking away from him. The face I made stopped being a performance somewhere in the middle.
The moan that came out of me was honest, and he gave me the quiet signal again. I bit my lip and tried. He kept talking, saying something about a deck and a timeline, his voice almost steady, but his eyes stayed locked on me.
I reached for his pant leg. I was going to grind my pussy against the wool trousers and leave a long mark he would have to explain if he stood up too fast. He shook his head and pointed at the new shoe. The one still on the ottoman. The one I had just laced.
Oh.
I understood. I hated that I understood so fast. I lowered myself until my pussy met the leather, the cool of it a shock against how hot I was, and rocked from the toe up toward the laces. My clit caught the raised seam and the little bumps and grooves. A bright, mean little spark shot through me, and I pulled myself back down to the tip, and I did it again, slower, spreading myself over the toe so he could watch my lips drag, and my wetness smear the new and polished leather.
“Fuck,” I whispered.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.