It’s Not My Fault
Copyright© 2026 by SexyPreeti
Chapter 41
True Story Sex Story: Chapter 41 - My name is Preeti and I am writing this story on behalf of Nandini. Please note, this is a slow burn story so don’t expect full sex very soon. Be patient with me because I will take you thru a detail of her real life and the way it evolved. I hope you all enjoy it and show me your love with your likes and comments.
Caution: This True Story Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Mult Consensual Reluctant True Story Cheating Polygamy/Polyamory Indian Male Indian Female Anal Sex Analingus Cream Pie Double Penetration Exhibitionism Lactation Masturbation Oral Sex Safe Sex Tit-Fucking Big Breasts Foot Fetish Hairy Public Sex Indian Erotica Slow
It took me more than a few minutes to get accustomed to his big fat cock and for my pain to reduce. I knew with more than half his cock already inside me, this had to be it. So I signalled him with my eyes to push again. This time I was mentally prepared in case Suresh pushed his full length inside my ass.
So I too fully relaxed my butt muscles and pushed them outwards matching the exact moment when he pushed. This time I felt a different kind of pain because his big long meaty cock had reached depths inside me which I had never felt before.
I could feel his ball sack hit my buttocks meaning he was fully home and deep inside me. I wrapped my legs around his torso locking him and also preventing him from moving. Suresh immediately resumed sucking my nipples alternating between massaging my boobs and sucking them.
This greatly helped because the pain receded very quickly getting me accustomed to his huge cock. But this time, Suresh still noticed the painful look on my face. He held my face with both hands and gave me a quick lip kiss. He whispered “aunty darling looks like you are really hurting. Should I pull out now”?
I tightened my legs around his torso and nodded no. I whispered “Suresh darling please understand. This is because you are so big down there so I am taking time to adjust”. He asked but aunty darling doesn’t uncle do it there to you”?
I nodded no and said “darling you are the first one to enter my ass because uncle never does it there. Even if he did, then too, you are more than double his size so this was naturally bound to hurt”. His face immediately changed to being very guilty and apologetic.
He whispered “aunty darling why did you have to do this if it was going to cause you so much pain? We could have tried something else”. I whispered “Suresh darling this was the only way ... The pain is temporary and happens when you do it the first few times but we have crossed that stage now”.
The expression on his face eased a little. He was about to scream out of excitement when I shushed him to keep quiet. Suresh was still semi kneeling between my legs till now with his big meaty cock deep inside my butt. I pulled him making him lie fully on top.
He whispered “aunty darling, I am feeling on top of the world having lost my virginity to you”. I replied “same here Suresh darling, I too am feeling the same having lost my anal virginity to you ... My young BF and lover...”. I relaxed my grip around him and Suresh felt it too.
I whispered “darling now start moving slowly”. He began moving to and fro giving short and slow strokes. Fuckkkk ... The pain I was experiencing was nothing compared to the pleasures of getting fucked by a nice big meaty strong young cock.
In just a few minutes, it happened. My body tensed ... My lungs swelled ... My breath got stuck in my throat. I experienced another thrilling orgasm. Suresh was looking in my eyes smiling without moving. He whispered “aunty darling, you climaxed again ... Didn’t you”?
I nodded yes but before I could say anything, he was down between my legs slurping on my pussy juices. Between slurping he whispered “mmmmm ... Aunty darling ... Milking your boobs and drinking your holy juices are the two things I can never have enough of...”.
I patted his head and whispered “darling let’s finish this before you get late for college...”. He quickly replied “aunty darling I don’t care about college as long as I get to be with you to enjoy like this...”. I sat up and pushed him away.
I sternly whispered “Suresh don’t forget our deal. If you are going to take your studies lightly just to be with me then our deal is off right now”. I was about to get off the sofa when he stopped me. Suresh got on his knees and begged “sorry aunty darling, I didn’t mean it that way. I swear I will not let this affect my studies...”.
He sounded honest so I relented and lay back again on the sofa. Then I saw him stroking his big cock because it had become soft. My own arousal was gone. I felt sorry for him so I sat up again and started stroking his big cock back to hardness.
I whispered “darling take your mind off what happened and focus on the present. It will help...”. I too focused on his big fat cock throbbing in my hand to arouse myself again. I started licking and sucking his cock while slipping one hand below to finger myself to accelerate my own arousal.
Suresh was letting out soft moans meaning he was back to enjoying this. In no time, I was back to being dripping wet and Suresh’s cock was dripping with my saliva. I laid back on the sofa signalling him with my finger to come on top. I positioned his big hard cock at my butt hole.
This time Suresh maintained eye contact with me while pushing his cock inside very very slowly. The pain was negligible now so I told him to start moving. The pleasures were back. I was again on cloud nine. Suresh was also back to giving feeble moans while squeezing my boobs and sucking my nipples.
We were both back to like when we started having a great time. I whispered “darling go faster now like you did between my legs...”. He looked at me like asking with his eyes if I was sure about this. I nodded yes. Suresh went berserk pounding me fast and furious style like he had only been waiting for my go ahead till now.
The next ten-fifteen minutes were pure sexual bliss for me with one more powerful orgasm but Suresh didn’t stop. Suresh continued pounding my ass like a sex machine on full speed. He was too lost in his own world to realise my condition. Then it happened ... My body tensed ... My back arched ... My lungs swelled...
I experienced another mother of all orgasms. The rapid convulsions of my butt muscles around his cock pushed him to his climax. I felt his warm thick fluids flood inside my butt as he slowly came to a stop. He collapsed on me panting heavily and took a good few minutes before he was able to talk.
Suresh whispered “fuckkkk ... Aunty darling ... This was the best time I have ever had...”. I kissed his forehead and whispered “thanks darling. I too experienced the best time of my life”. Suresh got off and as soon as his cock slipped out of my butt hole, I placed my palm there to collect his cum.
It surely was quite a lot. I looked at him seductively while licking my hand because I understood the look on his face. I whispered “darling just like you relish the taste of my juices, I too enjoy swallowing yours...”. Then I signalled him to come closer. I licked his softening cock clean.
Even in the soft state, Suresh’s cock was still very big and fat. After I licked his cock clean, Suresh grinned and quickly wore his clothes. I too wore my nighty and went to the kitchen to get the bowl to collect milk from him. I assumed Suresh would also be wearing his clothes and would wait near my main door to give me milk.
Totally unaware to me, Suresh stealthily followed after me and hugged me from behind with his hands around my waist. I could feel his hard cock digging into my butt cheeks. I was like, how does this young kiddo get hard again so quickly because it had been just over five minutes since we had sex.
Suresh was already kissing the length of my neck with burning passion getting me aroused again. He whispered “ohhh ... Aunty darling ... I am not yet done with you ... Can we please do it once more? Pleaseee auntyyy...”? Suresh’s hands now cupped my boobs from over my nighty gently fondling them.
I was thoroughly enjoying now because sex is all that I want and can never have enough of it. My arousal was back at its peak and my pussy juices flowing. I whispered “darling aren’t you getting late for college now”?
After giving me a few more wild kisses, he said “aunty darling you forgot I came much earlier today. So I still have another thirty minutes and fifteen minutes of buffer time after that”. I really felt happy hearing this. By now Suresh had raised my nighty to my waist and his hands were cupping and squeezing my naked boobs.
At the same time, he was already trying to push his cock inside me by pushing with his hips. Due to his size, his cock head was pushing against my pussy instead of my butt hole. Due to my wetness his cock kept slipping and didn’t enter. I decided to try again and make him fuck my pussy this time.
I reached down below and held his bulbous cock head against my dripping wet mound and whispered “darling now push a little and go slow like we did the first time”. Suresh cupped my big tits more firmly as if for having a better grip on me and pushed.
This time his fat swollen cock head entered stretching my pussy beyond limits I thought I was capable of. It was painful but bearable with difficulty. Also my back was facing him so he couldn’t have seen the pain evident on my face. Suresh let out a soft moan “Aaahhhh ... Fuckkk ... Aunty darling ... You are really tight...”.
I whispered “darling is it hurting this time”? Between kissing my neck and cheek and fondling my boobs he said “no aunty darling, no pain this time. This is feeling like nirvana...”. All his actions on my body helped quickly reduce my pain. This time I pushed myself backwards against his super big hard cock trying to get a little more inside.