It’s Not My Fault
Copyright© 2026 by SexyPreeti
Chapter 34
True Story Sex Story: Chapter 34 - My name is Preeti and I am writing this story on behalf of Nandini. Please note, this is a slow burn story so don’t expect full sex very soon. Be patient with me because I will take you thru a detail of her real life and the way it evolved. I hope you all enjoy it and show me your love with your likes and comments.
Caution: This True Story Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Mult Consensual Reluctant True Story Cheating Polygamy/Polyamory Indian Male Indian Female Anal Sex Analingus Cream Pie Double Penetration Exhibitionism Lactation Masturbation Oral Sex Safe Sex Tit-Fucking Big Breasts Foot Fetish Hairy Public Sex Indian Erotica Slow
I whispered “Shyam I was desperate to feel your big cock inside me”. He didn’t reply and continued eating and tongue fucking my pussy. This time the pain reduced very quickly so I whispered “let’s try it again Shyam. I am ready”.
He looked at me and understood I was serious. He quickly got into position without wasting time. He gave a slow long push and stayed still while looking at me. The pain was there but negligible so I nodded him to continue. He pulled out a little and gave a harder push.
Again it hurt but not like the first time. They say third time is a charm and I was determined to make this third time successful. I nodded again indicating him to continue. Shyam again leaned over me fully cupping my tits and sealed my lips in a kiss. He pulled out till only his cock head remained inside me.
He held my face with both hands kissing me more fiercely. At the same time, he gave one hard thrust pushing the full length of his big hard cock inside me and stayed still. I couldn’t scream due to the pain because he had my lips squarely sealed with his.
I knew if I could endure these moments of pain then it was only unlimited pleasures after this. I knew Shyam was fully inside me now because I could feel his cock in my womb. I was sure about this because his crotch was sticking to mine and his big balls were pressed against my butt hole.
I had tears rolling down my eyes but not for too long. I knew this had to be done so I was determined to get over it. Just that I underestimated his size and all this happened. Shyam kissed my tears wiping them with his lips. Then he held my face and whispered “Nandini the painful part is over now ... So it’s okay”.
He remained still and moved to fondling my breasts and sucking my nipples again. This greatly helped and the pain came down to bearable levels very soon. I could have waited for a few more minutes but I didn’t because I was desperate to get fucked by Shyam and his super big strong cock.
I quickly patted his shoulder to continue. He looked at me questioningly and I nodded yes. Shyam pulled out very slowly completely and gave my pussy a few more licks. Then he lined up his big hard cock and slowly pushed it inside.
Ohhh ... fuckkkk ... This felt so good now because the pleasures were far greater than the pain ... I whispered “Shyam now fuck me without mercy like you have been fucking Nirmala lately”. I don’t know why this triggered him.
He said “fuckkkk yesss Nandini ... I have been waiting for this moment. Now I am going to show you what real fucking feels like. What your husband with a two finger sized cock can never give you. What only a man like me can give you making you beg me for more”.
I think I had found his weakness and what triggered him. I was definitely going to use this for my own benefits. I quickly replied “yess Shyam, I have been dying to experience what a real man like you feels like. So give it to me nice and hard with your big strong cock ... Without showing any mercy...”.
This worked, the look on his face changed. He stood up grabbing my thighs and pulled me more to the edge of the sofa. Shyam held my legs straight up resting them against his chest. My feet were at his face level. He held both my feet kissing them feverently and rubbing his cheeks on my soles.
Down below he started ramming his big hard cock into my pussy bull style. Yes, the pain was still there but the pleasures of having such a fucking experience were far greater. The way Shyam was licking my soles and sucking on my toes was driving me mad with pleasures multiplying my arousal.
In just a few minutes the pain was totally gone. I was swimming in sexual heavens enjoying the best fucking of my lifetime. Shyam let go of my legs and leaned in cupping my big boobs. He again started sucking my nipples while squeezing my tits at the same time.
Down below he continued ramming his big hard cock into my pussy with the same speed and force. Fuckkkk ... This dual stimulation felt so good pushing me quickly towards my orgasm. I could feel his big hard cock reach depths inside me which I never thought were possible.
Then it happened ... My back arched ... My body tensed ... My breath got stuck in my throat ... I experienced a super mind boggling orgasm ... My best ever orgasm till now. All the pain I had to endure to get till here seemed worth it now.
I never felt like this when my body naturally orgasmed when Ramesh fucked me on my first night and many other times since. I was without doubt that the way a man uses his cock makes all the difference ... I looked below and Shyam was busy slurping on my juices.
I whispered “Shyam we don’t have time for this. So let’s finish this before Nirmala comes looking for either of us”. Between licking my pussy, he replied “no Nandini, this is something I have to do because compared to my aunt and Nirmala, your juice is by far the tastiest”.
I was surprised because Ramu said the exact same thing earlier today. I also felt very elated because all other men other than my husband found me tasty while my husband didn’t care. Shyam stood up and grabbed my hands pulling me to my feet. He said “Nandini I want to continue in another position now”.
I was blank because I didn’t know what he meant. Shyam turned me around and bent me on my chest on the sofa. I did it fully willingly because I also wanted to enhance my own knowledge of sex. Shyam lined up his big black cock at my pussy from behind.
He whispered “Nandini this might hurt a little ... So just bear with me”. I didn’t know why he said it would hurt now after he had fucked me nice and hard for so long. So I nodded okay mentally prepared to experience the unknown.
Shyam gave a slow push entering his cock inside maybe a few inches and then grabbed my hips firmly. He gave a very hard push burying his full length inside me. I almost screamed in pain at this. Thankfully my face was buried in the sofa, that helped to muffle it.
He exclaimed “Aaahhhhhhhh ... Fuckkkk ... Nandini your tight virgin pussy clamped around my cock feels so good...”. Fuckkkk ... This time, I could feel his cock much deeper than previously. This time Shyam went ballistic right from the start pounding me.
Loud clapping sounds like phat ... phat ... phat ... of our bodies were ringing in the room. Fuckkkk ... I was finally experiencing my first real bull style fucking just like I had read in Sabitri’s stories. I was feeling on top of the world now enjoying the best fucking time of my life.