Josh's Tale  - Cover

Josh's Tale

Copyright© 2025 by EVHayes720

Chapter 13: Knocking on Heaven’s Door

Fiction Sex Story: Chapter 13: Knocking on Heaven’s Door - A drunken encounter leads Josh to failing upwards in increasingly unlikely and serendipitous events. This story is a humorous take on non-con stories where the MC is well-meaning, but truly oblivious (and will remain so) to his impact on those around him.

Caution: This Fiction Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Teenagers   Blackmail   Coercion   Consensual   Drunk/Drugged   NonConsensual   Rape   Reluctant   Lesbian   BiSexual   Heterosexual   Fiction   Humor   Rags To Riches   Cheating   Incest   Mother   Father   Daughter   BDSM   DomSub   MaleDom   FemaleDom   Humiliation   Light Bond   Spanking   Group Sex   Harem   Anal Sex   Analingus   Cream Pie   Exhibitionism   Oral Sex   Sex Toys  

Part XIII Character Refresher:

Josh’s Girls
Allison: Head of the household.
Emilia: Holy sister.
Jeniffer: Josh’s daughter.
Alice: Mayor of SF.
Mikaela: Alice’s daughter and chief brat.
----

Father Paul pinched the bridge of his nose, rubbing it and sighing at how this church had gone downhill ever since the new Mother Superior had taken over. Where once they had had thousands of parishioners and hundreds of kids for Sunday school, now they barely had enough families to fill the front pews. And the ones that did come ... oh boy. They’d somehow ended up with the dregs of society. Not the poor, just the scummiest souls around that only came to church in the vain hope that they might find some semblance of forgiveness for their horrendous sins ... not that it ever stopped them from doing it all over again the next week.

This had to be some devious plan by the Mother Superior to syphon all the high-end socialites from here to the mega-church next door. She was far too chummy with the Sisters there, going so far as to host joint events and introducing all their wealthiest congregants to them.

They should never have allowed them to break ground in the first place. Whatever students they had once had were now either in that place’s boarding school or had left for more progressive churches, ever since the hard conservative path she had put them on. Again, likely some plot to drive this church out while setting herself up nicely to move next door.

“Bless me Father, for I have sinned,” came the voice from the other confessional booth. “It has been one month since I have last confessed.”

Sitting back against the padded seat, Paul slid open the panel, giving him a muted view through the woven mesh of a young man in the booth.

“What has been bothering you?” he asked, suppressing his weary sigh.

He really needed to get a new gig. This ‘Father’ business stopped being fun years ago. Now it was all politics and money. No one even cared anymore. Why even should he?

“I’ve, uh, I’ve been doing some stuff that I shouldn’t be.”

“Like?”

“Well, uh.”

There was a light knock at the lower panel.

Paul stifled a groan. Ever since they’d moved to confiscate contraband from the confessioners, they’d been getting inundated with nothing but trash. When it wasn’t treated as a handy way of getting rid of illegal goods quietly and not getting the cops called on them, because of ‘rules’, then they were just giving him all the nastiest shit they could think of, presumably to ease their guilty consciences.

What would it be this time? Dildo? Pot? Casino chips?

God, please let it be pot. He could really use some right about now. Just enough to take the edge off.

Sadly, God was not so obliging.

Sliding open the panel, a crumpled box of condoms was handed over.

Lovely.

Paul deposited the contraband in the drawer, right between the shining butt-plug with a mocking sign of the holy cross encrusted in blue rhinestones on it, a cat o’ nine tails that someone had lovingly crafted from soft leather, and the ball-gag with more than a few teeth impressions bitten into it and, somehow, still glistening as if wet.

God, why did all the freaks come to this church?

“Anything else?”

After some hesitation an unmarked plastic bottle was handed over. Something small enough to house a few mints and be easily palmed.

It rattled as he shook it.

... Were these drugs?

“I, uh, I’ve been kinda, uh, living it up this last week.”

Popping open the cap, Paul inspected the tiny pills, a delicate ‘J’ carved into the surface.

Holy shit, this was the good stuff. The last time he had taken one he’d been spaced out for hours laughing at a lava lamp. With this much, he and the guys could get blazed down at the fishing hole and be tripping balls all weekend long.

“Father?”

“Hmm? Oh, uh, right, you’ve done well bringing me this, my son. Uh, five Hail Mary’s.”

Paul capped the container, slipping it into his robe for later.

“Um, that’s it?”

“Hmm? Then do ten. Get on out of here, I need to take a break in a bit,” Paul said, pressing the button to turn off the confessional light. The last thing he needed was more people showing up and crowding into his down time.

When the kid had left, Paul pulled out his phone and texted the Mother Superior that he was taking off for the weekend. He didn’t bother to wait for a reply, already texting his buddies to bring along some ‘entertainment’ for the trip.


The old bell tolled far above, the clear ringing carried across the warm courtyard and echoed off the stone halls of the boarding school. Laughter soon filled the once silent hallways as doors opened, young women adorned in crisp uniforms moving ponderously toward their next classes. The sea of giggling highschoolers moved as one, the watchful gazes of their school guardians panning across them, ever vigilant for improper words, attire, or worse ... boys.

The boarding school’s strict anti-boys policy was in place to keep them all safe. At least, that’s what the Sisters had all told them. They never specified how it was keeping them safe, though. Any further inquiries were usually met with severe scoldings and a ruler slapped against the backs of hands or calves.

Danielle had once heard tell of someone sneaking a boy into the school grounds. From years past, a friend of a friend’s sister’s roommate had apparently opened the gate in the back for him. Following the incident, The Sisters had bricked up the other exits, leaving only the heavy metal gates in the front, the cafeteria loading dock, and oddly, that same gate in the back, as ways in or out of the compound.

Regardless, after many hours, the boy had eventually been caught and expelled through the front gates, but not before he’d apparently kissed the girl. The girl had then been taken away, her belly already swelling due to her pregnancy.

No one knew what had happened to that girl, but some said she was still locked away in the highest steeple, her moans the only sign of her continued imprisonment.

Of course, the Sisters never entertained such gossip, severely punishing anyone who even whispered the tale, leading even more credence to the story.

“I think it’s true,” the girl beside Danielle whispered from her desk to the girl behind her, the Sister with her back turned to the class as she wrote on the whiteboard. “I swear I heard moaning last night.”

“From where?” the other girl asked, leaning forward in her chair.

“From upstairs,” the first replied. “It was late at night, but a voice was crying and moaning in the distance. I think she’s haunting our dorm, looking for her baby.”

The girls quieted down as the Sister turned back to the class, continuing their preparations for going out on a mission once they’d graduated. Danielle was barely listening though as that story gnawed at her.

When the Sister turned away again, the second girl leaned forward and whispered again, several other girls now leaning in to hear more.

“What about the boy?”

“He never found her either. He died and now haunts this place, looking for her while she’s searching for her baby. If you say his name in the mirror three times, he’ll appear and try to kiss you so that he can give your baby to her.”

“Oh no!” one of the girls gasped, recoiling as the Sister fixed her glare at her.

“Was there something you needed to say to the class, Margeret?”

“No ma’am.”

“Then sit quietly. One more disturbance from you and you’ll be sent to detention.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

A shiver ran down Danielle’s spine, thinking about how her belly could swell at any moment if a boy kissed her.

What would happen if a boy got loose in the school? Would he go on a kissing spree, impregnating all the girls unlucky enough to mash their lips to his? Would the Sisters lock her up, letting her rot away until she too became a ghost, haunting these halls in search of her lost baby?

Surely, there had to be a way to prevent this.

But ... who would know how to defend oneself from them? The Sisters would never teach anything like that. All they ever said was to have faith in the Lord and he would protect them. But, he hadn’t protected that girl, and now she haunted this place.

The story continued to gnaw at Danielle throughout class. While she would typically have sat in rapt attention to her lessons, learning all the things she would need to do to spread the word of the Lord, now she could only dwell on the hidden darkness lurking outside these walls.

Eventually, the bell chimed, releasing the class from their studies.

Danielle followed closely behind the girls that had been gossiping, hoping to hear more. Danielle melded into the growing group of girls that surrounded the original storyteller as they made their way down the hall.

“Did you hear about the 1C incident?” one of the newcomers asked, her bible held over her mouth so as to muffle the sound of her voice and keep the Sisters from overhearing. Receiving only wide eyes and head shakes, she continued. “I heard that there was a group of boys that had snuck in and hidden themselves in the back of the room. When the Sister left, they popped out and kissed all the girls in the class.”

“But ... we don’t have a 1C class,” one of the girls offered after a brief moment of shock.

“Not anymore,” the girl said grimly. “The Sisters had to take them all away. Some of the girls were already giving birth before they could even chase away the boys.”

Danielle blanched at the image of dozens of girls falling over, pregnancy inflating them as they helplessly lay there as the boys kissed the others.

Breaking off from the group, Danielle walked shakily down a silent corridor to center herself. The outer hallways, with barred windows to keep the girls safe from intruders, were rarely used by students as they were utilized primarily by the Sisters for their self-studies. While they weren’t prohibited from wandering these halls, the girls generally avoided them as a lonely spookiness often inhabited them. A draft always seemed to blow, even with the windows shut, somehow several degrees cooler than the outside. At night, ethereal shapes were said to move between empty rooms, as though searching for something.

Danielle didn’t believe in such nonsense though. As everyone knew, ghosts and spirits only haunted places with unfinished business, like that pregnant girl. They didn’t haunt empty classrooms and hallways. There wouldn’t be a point. But not all the girls here were as levelheaded as her.

These hallways were also a fascinating view into the outside world, something she hadn’t experienced in years. Once she’d hit puberty, it had been safer to sequester her here with other young ladies, lest they fall prey to the voracious appetites of boys. The bars here would keep them at bay, but still, she stooped a bit lower, only letting her head peak over the waist-high ledge to hide her shameful body from those lusty wolves.

Outside, a group of girls, likely no older than her, congregated around a bus stop, talking and laughing without a care in the world.

While everyone here wore the traditional white blouse buttoned to the collar, neatly tucked into their flowing black skirt that reached their shins, those girls wore significantly less. Truly, it would be scandalous if anyone were to step foot in the church so attired. One wore elastic pants so tight the outline of her underwear showed. Another wore a skirt so short it barely seemed to cover her behind properly. And the shirts! Only one wore a buttoned shirt, but even that had nearly half the buttons open, displaying an inappropriate amount of skin. Another showed her bellybutton, the flash of jewelry somehow fastened there. The third had on a top with spaghetti straps that barely restrained her heaving bosom.

These would definitely not be the kind of girls she should be talking to ... but they would be the kind that would know about how to fend off boys.

Casting a quick glance behind her, Danielle stepped further into the hallway, ducking into one of the unattended rooms. The space was small, barely enough for a chair and desk for self-study, but she only needed standing room anyway. Closing the door softly behind herself, she quickly stepped toward the window, twisting the old handle and prying the rusty hinges to tilt the lower pane down.

“Psst!”

As one, the group of girls who had been standing at the nearby bus stop turned to her.

Danielle checked behind herself, ensuring the door was still shut.

“Can I ask you something?” Danielle whispered through the narrow slit, beckoning them closer.

Perhaps the girls were hesitant to step onto the church’s lawn as they looked at one another awkwardly.

“Please?”

Stepping gingerly closer, the girls cocked their heads, as though trying to puzzle out what she had in mind.

“I promise, it’ll be quick. Do you go to public school?”

As though it were a trick question, the girls exchanged glances.

“Um, yeah? Like, doesn’t everybody?” the girl with the belly jewelry said.

“And, um, are there boys?”

The girls exchanged another glance.

“Um, obviously.”

“And? Do they, you know ... try to kiss you?”

Danielle must have asked something strange as the girls behind this one tittered nervously.

Rather than answer, the girl just looked her up and down, like she was evaluating if she should reveal a terrible secret.

“I promise, I won’t tell anyone,” Danielle said, signing the cross.

“What’s your name?” she finally asked, waving at the other girls to quiet down.

“Danielle. Danielle Ashton.”

“I’m Ashley,” she said, a warm smile finally replacing her puzzled look. “Have you never been kissed before?”

“Goodness, no,” Danielle said, aghast at even the thought. “I don’t want to get pregnant! I should wait until I’m married before doing that.”

The girls behind Ashley turned away, perhaps in embarrassment or shame, choking back sobs.

Those poor girls. Maybe they’d been kissed. It must be hard going to school with boys.

“Right, yeah, totally,” Ashley said, covering her mouth, obviously aghast at the idea.

“So, um, how do you avoid kissing?” Danielle asked.

“Oh, yeah, it can be a real problem,” she admitted. “You know, sometimes they’ll just try to kiss you while walking by. I had a friend who, like, went to a party, and got kissed three times.”

“Oh no,” Danielle cried, covering her mouth in horror. “Did she get pregnant?”

“Totally,” one of the girls said. “She had twins.”

“No, triplets,” the other corrected her. She was obviously troubled by the story, as tears were forming at the corners of her eyes and she kept covering her mouth. “Like, she got pregnant from each kiss.”

“Yeah,” Ashley jumped in when the girls started crying again. “From three different boys. They all looked like her though, so they couldn’t tell which one was who’s kid. They decided the best way to figure it out was to kiss her again, individually. After every baby, she’d kiss the next one.”

Danielle’s eyes grew wide in shock.

“And, and,” the other girl continued between gasps of horror, “they had their friends come and kiss her afterwards, so they could check if the babies would also look like her.”

Clearly distraught, the other girl fell to her knees in prayer, her head hanging low as she sobbed.

Filled with images of puckered lips, each set seeking her out like a homing missile, Danielle fled the room, her face burning hot as she vowed never to let a boy kiss her.


Ashley’s stomach cramped at how hard she was laughing, Rachel and Gina rolling on the grass in tears at that girl’s reaction.

“I can’t- I can’t breathe,” Rachel gasped between hysterical laughter.

“Oh my god,” Gina laughed, “did you see her face? She really thought she’d get pregnant from kissing.”

“Oh god, I haven’t laughed this hard since I gave Tim that fake pregnancy test,” Ashley said, wiping a tear from her eye. “I thought he was going to shit himself. And that’s still not as funny as this.”

Bouts of laughter continued until the bus came, taking them away from this horrendous pillar of puritanical oppression.

What kind of moron would willingly go to a place so sexually uneducated and repressed?


Sister Emilia struggled with the dusty boxes in her arms, stacked so high she couldn’t even see where she was going. Her long skirt flapped in the strong gusts, tangling her legs as she stumbled across the poorly leveled and cracked stones of the homeless shelter. Cans clinked against one another, threatening to spill out as she regained her footing.

“Lord have mercy,” she mumbled as a faint burning tingled in her ankle.

While she loved helping the unfortunate, the physical toll of carrying hundreds of pounds of dried and canned goods to and from the van wasn’t something to be underestimated. Just loading the van had been hard enough, but at least some of the girls had been able to help then. But she could hardly ask them to help deliver all this, not when they still had their studies to attend to. The girls next door couldn’t help either. While they were happy enough to help with painting the van, they couldn’t leave the boarding school grounds.

Well, it wasn’t her place to question the Lord’s plan. The Sister Superior over there, having received her revelation, led her group as she’d been told. Everyone had a different purpose. And it brought a smile to her heart that they would be guided to fulfill it. Just as the good book said.

That, however, didn’t change her current predicament.

She really should have thought this through better. Sweat dotted her forehead, plastering some errant locks of hair there as the mid-morning sun beat down on her. Her body already ached, and this was only the first of the boxes.

“Woah, need a hand with that?” someone asked, his body blocked by the towering stack in her arms.

Emilia craned her neck to peer around the boxes, a friendly smile greeting her. A freshly shaven and amicable appearance, his chestnut hair parted to one side as it waved lightly in the breeze, he radiated calmness. That gentle countenance of his stilled her worries, his smile lightening her spirit, and his soft eyes making her heart beat faster.

“Oh, um, yes, please,” Emilia said with relief. “I may have underestimated just how heavy these were.”

“No worries, let me grab that.”

The man slipped his hands around the boxes, easily lifting them from her grasp. Instant relief flooded her exhausted arms, even as a small shiver ran up them when he’d lightly brushed them.

“Donating these?” he asked, turning toward the shelter. “I’m sure they’ll be grateful for this. It’s always hard to keep stocked up on supplies.”

Emilia couldn’t place him, but he seemed so familiar. It was like a memory was tickling the front of her brain, but she just couldn’t recall where she’d seen him. Tall and broad-shouldered, with the calm and assuredness of a man of the cloth. Surely a godly man.

“Oh yes, we recently had a charity drive, so I wanted to drop these off before Sunday school.” Emilia fell in step with the man, marveling at how easily he held those boxes.

He could probably hold her up without a problem, his muscles closing around her in a tight embrace as he lifted her higher.

Emilia shook the errant thought out of her mind.

“That’s really nice of you,” he said, flashing that sweet smile of his again. “You know, I wish I’d known about places like this back when I’d, uh, been having problems.”

“Oh? I’m so sorry to hear that. Were you homeless?”

“For a while,” he admitted with a bit of a sigh. “It wasn’t a good time in my life. Everything just seemed to go wrong at once.”

“Why didn’t you look for help? The churches would have happily helped.” Emilia held open the door for him, not sure how he was navigating without being able to see. “I’m sorry, that sounded accusatory. I just meant that there are always people willing to help.”

“No, I understand. It wasn’t that I didn’t need the help, but I couldn’t bring myself to get it. It certainly wasn’t a pride thing, considering how I was living. It was more like a mental block. Like I couldn’t imagine others caring, so I never tried. It’s kind of silly, looking back at it.”

“No, not at all,” Emilia hurriedly responded, following him through the narrow corridor. “I completely understand. When we’re at our lowest, it can be hard to imagine that others would help. Or want to help. I wish I could do more and be more engaged with outreach. I think a lot of people suffer like that and just need a hand.”

The corridor widened into a large hall, volunteers moving and shelving items in a controlled chaos. The man helping her nodded to a woman with a clipboard who pointed him toward one of the shelves to the side.

“Yeah. It wasn’t until someone made the effort to reach out that my life finally turned around. It’s why I try to help out here now. A lot of people just need that chance.”

Emilia smiled as she helped unload the top box, organizing the cans with similar donations that filled the old metal shelves of the shelter.

“That’s so beautiful,” she said, bending down to hand him some additional cans while he stocked the lower shelves. “I’m glad that you could make something of that experience and not lose your faith.”

“Well, something like that,” he laughed. “Do you have more boxes? I’m happy to grab more.”

His smile was so bright and disarming that Emilia’s heart fluttered for a moment. His eyes were so achingly familiar, but she just couldn’t place them.

“Oh, I couldn’t ask you to do that,” she said, heat slowly spreading across her face. A little shiver ran up her spine as he squeezed her shoulder comfortingly.

“Please, I insist.”

Her giggle sounded foreign to her ears. An unfamiliar coy smile spread across her lips. Her face burned like she had a raging fever. She squirmed under his burning gaze like a guilty schoolgirl.

What was going on with her?

“Um, well ... if you insist,” she replied softly, brushing the hair from her face. “Um, what’s, um, what’s your name? I’m Emilia. Emilia Anastos.”

“Joshua Nelson,” he said, offering his hand as he rose ponderously over her.

His hands were rough, yet gentle, his grip firm, yet soft. Emilia’s insides squirmed as he pulled her to her feet.

“Please, call me Josh.”


It had taken him a bit, but Josh was now able to place this girl. She’d seemed so familiar, but it wasn’t until she started blushing furiously every time he looked into her eyes that he knew.

This was Allison’s friend from that day he’d roleplayed as the psycho killer who’d trapped them in the house. It had taken a while for his eyes to adjust to the dark at that time, with more than a few bruises from stumbling through the window and cluttered hallways, but it had still been a fun experience. And the girls had gone absolutely nuts over it. He’d needed to ice himself down afterwards, they’d been so insatiable.

She obviously recognized him, given how close she walked, even brushing her chest coyly against his arm on occasion. He’d never taken off the mask at the house, as that would have ruined the immersion, but Allison had probably shown her a photo beforehand. It would have been weird if she’d gone into that scenario blind. Well, based on how eager she’d been, maybe she just liked that kind of vibe. Still, odd to have run into her here of all places.

“Did you have to drive far?” Josh asked as he picked up another set of boxes from her utility van.

“No, ah, not far at all,” she stuttered out before blushing again. “I, uh, I’m based out of the Pacifica. It’s only thirty minutes or so away. It’s a really beautiful area. Have you ever been?”

“Oh, that’s a nice area. Have you ever been to Mable’s Ristorante out there? I think it’s off the highway near Rockaway Beach.”

“Oh, I love that place,” she said, excitement in her voice. “I haven’t been in so long. I used to love their sliders.”

“I could pack away more of those than I care to admit,” Josh laughed as he carried another set of boxes, Emilia giggling beside him.


This fuzzy feeling in the pit of her stomach was spreading rapidly, making her fingers tingle. Every time she brushed against Josh her face grew hotter.

The metallic taste on her tongue let her know that she was sucking on her cross again. When had that behavior started? But anytime she wasn’t focused on her actions around him, she’d find it in her mouth, sucking on it like a pacifier.

She’d gotten so absorbed in keeping her cross from her mouth that she once again tripped over the cracked pavement on one of their return trips, sending her right into Josh’s arms as he caught her.

Worry shown in his eyes. His lips were moving in slow motion. The sun shone behind him. This feeling deep inside her ... it was so familiar. It wanted to burst forth. It wanted to shine as bright as him. To bring the light of the Lord’s love ... just like that day...

Emilia whimpered, gazing into his chestnut eyes.

Yes ... it had been him. Those eyes. She could never forget them. She saw them when she prayed. She felt them late at night, as she lay awake on her bed, unable to still her racing heart at the memory. The memory of that day. The day when he had taught her what true faith and devotion was. How to feel the Lord burning inside her.


“Are you okay?”

“Hm?” Emilia was still limp in his arms, gazing up lovingly at him.

“Are you hurt?”

She shook her head, nibbling her lower lip.

It was kind of warm out. Maybe she was having heatstroke? She felt like she was on fire, and her cheeks were flushed.

“We’re almost done. Would you like me to drive you back? You seem a bit unsteady.”

She maintained eye contact, slowly raising her cross to her mouth and sucking on it suggestively.

He’d seen that look before. Not heatstroke then. Just really, really horny.


The van was an odd design, now that Josh could finally see it without all the boxes in the way. It had a single bench up front rather than two separate chairs, and the entire back of the van was covered in something like a shag carpet from the 60’s. It seemed like something a bunch of hippies would drive on their way to some music festival. Even the paint on the outside screamed ‘free love’ with its clouds and vibrant colors. Might as well have been a unicorn on a starry night. At least the ride was smooth. Good shock absorbers.

Emilia hadn’t said anything after Josh had started driving, only inching closer every few minutes until she was fully pressed up against him. She was still flushed and sucking on her cross even as she wiggled next to him.

She was obviously angling for some car fun. Well, it was an easy drive and not many cars on the road, so ... sure. Why not?


Emilia’s gaze was unfocused, lost in her own mind. This feeling, this aching need, she longed to feel him once more ... to feel the Lord’s blessing coursing through her. She was so close. It was just out of reach, yet it blazed with the promise of untold rapture.

Her breath grew ragged, the sweet tang of the cross playing over her tongue.

She shuddered and gasped as something warmed her thigh, the heat bleeding through her skirt.

Her eyes focused on Josh, his sidelong glance and gentle smile making her heart beat faster. His hand slowly caressed her thigh, a comforting pressure as he squeezed her.

When had she gotten so close to him? It was like she was being pulled to him. Like the Lord was guiding her once more.

His hand made its way higher up her thigh, pulling at the soft material of her skirt as he slowly rubbed her. Her body reacted automatically, her legs spreading as he made his way ever higher. Emilia whimpered around her cross, sucking the metal more insistently.


Yup, that’s what the girl had been after. He shouldn’t have been surprised, all of Allison’s friends were just horned up all the time. Josh would like to think that he had something to do with that, but it was probably best not to let his ego get too out of control. If he could play some small part in making them happy and help further their OF careers, then he was happy to do it.

Josh glanced briefly at the dashboard, not noting any cameras or recording devices.

 
There is more of this chapter...

When this story gets more text, you will need to Log In to read it

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In