Chapter 5

That evening, as the sun set over the crystal blue ocean, I approached my Dad. He was sitting on the beach, watching the waves roll in. I could see the tension in his shoulders, his eyes distant. He looked up as I approached, a hint of surprise in his gaze.

“Mike,” he said, his voice gruff. “What’s up?”

“I ... I need to talk to you,” I said, my voice shaking slightly. “About Kiera.”

He sighed, his eyes darkening. “What about her?”

I took a deep breath, my heart racing. “I have a crush on her, Dad. I wanted to lose my virginity together with her but you ... you fuck her!”

“It’s okay to be jealous,” he said, his voice soothing. “It’s a natural emotion. Just talk to her. Tell her how you feel. It doesn’t matter if I fuck her or not.”

I stared at him, shocked by his nonchalance. “But, Dad...”

He put his hand on my shoulder, his grip firm but gentle. “Mike, this is Paradise Island. Here, love and sex are different things. You can love someone and still share them. That’s what we do here. That’s what makes this place so special.”

I nodded slowly, his words resonating through my mind. It was as if he had read my thoughts, understood my pain, and offered a path to acceptance. The tension in my shoulders began to ease, and I found myself considering his perspective.

“But I don’t know how to start.” I pressed, still grappling with the complexity of the situation. “My relationship with her is now quite mess up.”

Dad’s eyes lit up with an idea. “Why don’t I arrange a little something for you?” He suggested, a hint of a smirk playing on his lips. “A way to show her that you’re okay with it all?”

“What do you mean?” I asked, my heart racing with the implications.

Dad leaned back in his chair, his eyes twinkling with mischief. “How about this,” he began, “I’ll set up a little rendezvous for the four of us. You, me, Kiera, and her mom.”

My eyes widened in shock. “What?!” I exclaimed. “You mean a foursome?”

Dad nodded, his smirk growing wider. “Exactly,” he said. “It’s the perfect way to show that you’re okay with our lifestyle here on the island. And who knows, maybe it’ll bring you and Kiera closer together.”

The thought of sharing Kiera with my Dad was still a bit much for me to handle, but I knew that if I didn’t go through with it, I would always be the outsider in my family. So, I swallowed my pride and agreed to the plan, hoping it would bring some clarity to my conflicted emotions.

That evening, we met up at Kiera’s unit—the unit number was quite familiar in my mind. My heart was racing as I saw Kiera dressed in skimpy bikinis that barely contained their ample curves. She greeted us at the door, a wide smile on her face, but the moment she saw me, the smile faded into a look of surprise.

“Mike? What’re you doing here?” she breathed, her eyes flicking to my Dad and then back to me.

Dad stepped forward, wrapping an arm around my shoulders. “Kiera,” he said, his voice filled with pride, “this is my son, Mike. He’s a bit new to sex and the island’s way, but he’s catching on.”

Her eyes widened, and she looked at me with a mix of curiosity and excitement. “Oh, Mike,” she said, her voice a little breathless. “Did you know that your Dad and I...”

“‘Fucked silly’, is that the word you’re looking for?” I joked, trying to sound more confident than I felt. “It’s Okay, Kiera. I’m learning the island’s way, trying to lose my innocence.”

Kiera’s eyes widened even more, and she glanced at my Dad, who gave her a knowing smile. “Well,” she said, her voice low and sultry, “Your Dad’s a pro, but I’m sure you’re going to catch up fast.”

“Is that so?” I said, playing along. My mind couldn’t help but drift to the countless times Dad had probably fucked Kiera in all of her available entrances. I pictured him pounding her tight teenage ass hole until she couldn’t take it anymore, her cries of pleasure echoing off the walls. Or her mouth wrapped around his thick cock, swallowing his hot cum like it was her favorite drink. And of course, the thought of him and his friends filling her tight pussy, one after the other. It was a disturbing thought, but also oddly arousing.

Kiera brought us in to meet her mom. It was then that I realized, with a shock that was almost painful, that Kiera’s mom was Lily. The same Lily who had taken my virginity, who had comforted me and guided me through the island’s sexual norms. She looked surprised to see me but quickly regained her composure.

“Mike,” she said, her voice filled with a mix of amusement and affection. “What a pleasant surprise.”

Kiera looked at her mom with curiosity, her eyes questioning as she took in the scene. “You know him, mom?” she asked, her voice a mix of surprise and skepticism.

“Oh, yes, sweetie,” Lily said, her smile not quite reaching her eyes. “Mike and I are way more than knowing each other. He lost his virginity to me as he fucked me silly that night. Mike, you never told me that the girl you have a crush on is my daughter,” Lily said, her eyes sparkling with mischief as she took in my stunned expression.

“Yeah,” I said, trying to keep my voice steady. “It seems like we both have a bit of a ... surprise here.”

Kiera’s eyes searched mine, trying to piece together the puzzle. She had always been a smart girl, and I could see the cogs turning in her head. “So, you’re saying ... you had a crush on me. So, you’ve been fucking my mom and I’ve been fucking your Dad?” she said, her voice a mix of disbelief and arousal. “What a fucked up.”

I couldn’t help but laugh nervously. “Yeah, I guess you could say that,” I said, feeling the tension in the room thicken like the cum in my cock.

Lily stepped forward, her hand on Kiera’s shoulder. “Kiera,” she said, her voice gentle but firm, “Why don’t you go ahead and tell Mike everything?”

Kiera’s eyes narrowed, and she took a deep breath before speaking. “Okay,” she said, her voice measured. “Mike, I have something to tell you. You see, I have this ... kink.” She paused, looking at me expectantly.

“A kink?” I asked, my voice betraying my curiosity.

Kiera nodded, her cheeks flushing a dark shade of pink. “Yeah,” she said, her eyes dropping to the floor before meeting mine again. “I ... I have a thing for incest.”

The confession hit me like a ton of bricks. I stared at her, unable to process what she had just said. “What?” I managed to croak out.

“You heard me,” Kiera said, a wicked smile playing on her lips. “I love the thought of fucking family members. It’s so ... forbidden and wrong that it turns me on like nothing else.”

My cock twitched at the revelation, despite the shock. I had never considered that someone could have such a specific and taboo kink. But here we were, on Paradise Island, where the boundaries of normalcy had been erased by the endless horizon of the ocean and the lush vegetation that surrounded us.

“So,” I said slowly, trying to wrap my head around the implications of her confession, “you’ve been fucking your Dad or your brother?”

Kiera shook her head, her smile turning sad. “No, I’ve never had one,” she said. “My mom is a single mom. She told me about her past, how she came to this island and left pregnant with me.”

My mind raced, trying to piece together the puzzle. Could it be...? “Wait,” I said, my voice hoarse, “are you saying...”

Lily nodded, her eyes filled with a mix of excitement. “Yes,” she said, her voice barely a whisper. “Your Dad, Mike. He’s the one who got me pregnant.”

The room spun, and I had to sit down, my legs giving out beneath me. It was too much to take in, “Which means ... he is your Dad too.” I couldn’t believe what I was saying. The girl I had a crush on was not only my Dad’s lover but also his daughter.

“Yeah,” Kiera said, her eyes shining with excitement, “When I found your Dad, our Dad, I knew I had to have him. So, I started seducing him, using the charity card system, asking him to deflower my virgin pussy. And when he gave in, I realized that my Daddy’s cock was so big, so thick. It stretched and turned my tight young cunt into a sloppy wet mess that was hungry for his hot cum. When he was about to cum, I whispered in his ear that Lily is my mom and I’m his daughter. He was shocked but ... he didn’t stop pumping his seed into my pussy. And since then we have been fucking like rabbits.”

The revelation was like a punch to the gut, but strangely, it didn’t make me feel as sick as I thought it would. Maybe it was because I knew that on this island, sex was a currency, a way of connecting and healing. Or maybe it was because, deep down, I had always felt like an outsider, and now I had a twisted bond with Kiera that no one else could claim.

“So,” Kiera said, her voice a little shaky, “you can see why I’ve been so into your Dad. It’s not just only because he’s a big cock and provides me a good fuck, but because he’s ... my Dad.” She took a deep breath, her breasts rising and falling with the effort. “I’ve yearned for this fantasy for so long, and at the time he was the only one I thought that could give it to me. So, it’s not your fault, Mike.”

I stared at her, my mind racing. “At the time?”

Kiera’s gaze met mine, her eyes dark with desire. “Yes,” she whispered, her hand drifting to her chest. “Now ... now that I know you’re my half-brother. And that we’re going to fuck with my mom and our Dad ... it’s like all my perverted dreams are coming true. I’m so fucking wet, Mike.”

Dad leaned in, his eyes gleaming. “Her cunt’s preparing itself for our cocks, Mike.”

Lily, standing before us, her eyes shimmered with lust. “So, where shall we fuck?” she asked, her voice dripping with seductiveness. “The bedroom or the living room?”

Dad looked around the room, his eyes lingering on the floor-to-ceiling windows that offered an unobstructed view of the sea. “The living room,” he said with a smirk. “The ocean is a perfect backdrop for this ... family reunion.”

We all began to strip naked, the tension in the room palpable as we revealed ourselves to each other. Dad’s body was a bud Daddy type but muscular, with a smattering of hair across his chest, His huge cock stood proud, already hard at the thought of what was to come.

Kiera’s tan body was a perfectly curved slender figure with cute small tits and hard brown nipples. Her pussy was bare, the soft, pink flesh glistening with her arousal. Lily, on the other hand, was a voluptuous goddess. Her breasts were large, with dark areolas that begged to be sucked and bitten. Her pussy was a well-used but well-maintained playground.

Kiera and I, both equally naked, exchanged glances. Despite the absurdity of the situation, I couldn’t deny the attraction I felt for her. She was a mirror of my confusion and desire, her eyes sparkling with a mix of excitement and trepidation. We moved closer, and before I knew it, our lips were pressed together, our tongues dancing in a silent conversation that spoke of our shared secrets and dark desires.

Her skin was warm and salty from the ocean, the scent of coconut sunscreen mixing with the sweet musk of her arousal. I felt her hand grip my cock, stroking me gently as our kiss grew more intense. Meanwhile, Lily had dropped to her knees, her eyes locked on our entwined bodies as she took Dad’s cock into her mouth, her cheeks hollowing as she sucked him with the expertise of a woman who had years of practice.

Dad’s eyes rolled back in his head as he moaned, his hand tangled in Lily’s hair, guiding her movements. “Oh, fuck,” he murmured, “you’re so good, baby.”

My eyes drifted down to Kiera’s chest, her perky breasts rising and falling with each breath she took. They were small but no less appealing. Her brown nipples were hard and begging for attention, standing out against the tan skin. I reached out, my hand shaking slightly, and cupped one in my palm. She gasped into our kiss, her grip on my cock tightening.

I squeezed gently, feeling the softness of her flesh give way before my thumb found her nipple, flicking and rolling it with the same rhythm as our tongues. Breaking the kiss, I leaned down and took one of her nipples into my mouth, sucking and biting gently, feeling her breath hitch as I did so. Her hands found my head, holding me in place as I feasted on her, my tongue swirling around the tight bud, savoring the taste of her skin. The salty sweetness was intoxicating, and I knew that if I didn’t get inside her soon, I would explode right there on the spot.

Pulling away from her, I looked over at our parents, who were now fucking on the couch with an animalistic passion. Dad’s thick cock was buried deep inside Lily, her moans and whimpers of pleasure filling the room as she took every inch of him.

“I want my brother’s cock now,” Kiera whispered, her voice hoarse with excitement as she positioned herself on the couch next to her mom, her legs spread wide, revealing her glistening pussy to me.

Her cunt was a vision of perverted beauty, pink and swollen, with a slight gap between her lips begging for my cock. It was the same pussy that had been fucked by our Dad, the same pussy that had been used by many men. Yet, as I looked at it, all I could think was how much I wanted to plunge into her depths.

I positioned myself at her open, and with one easy push, my cock sank into my half-sister’s cunt. The sensation was overwhelming. She was tight and wet, her pussy clenching around me like a glove.

Kiera let out a low moan as I started to thrust into her. Her walls were tight, and the sound of our skin slapping together was hot. I couldn’t help but watch as my cock disappeared into her again and again, leaving a trail of slime as I pulled out.

“Fuck me harder, big brother,” she begged her voice a desperate whine that sent a shiver down my spine. “Make me cum like our Dad does.”

I couldn’t hold back anymore. I pumped into her with everything I had, my hips smacking against her ass with a rhythm that matched the waves crashing outside. Kiera’s small breasts bounced with each thrust, her nipples rock hard and pointing straight up at me. I couldn’t help but squeeze and pinch them as I fucked her. Her moans grew louder, and she began to buck her hips back against my cock.

Next to us, Dad pulled out of her with a wet pop, he then was on his ass and switched places with Lily. She was now riding my Dad’s cock, her voluptuous body bouncing up and down as she moaned and screamed with pleasure. Kiera watched, her eyes glazed over with lust as she sat beside him. She leaned in and kissed him deeply. He returned the kiss, his tongue sliding into her mouth.

It was a sight that should have repulsed me, but instead, it only served to make me harder. I couldn’t help but watch as Dad’s hand stroked Kiera’s breasts, her fingers playing with her nipples as I fucked her harder.

Kiera looked at Dad and Lily. She bit her bottom lip. “Let’s swap,” she said.

Lily pulled out of Dad’s cock with a wet sound. As I too pulled out of Kiera, she wasted no time switching places with her mother. She straddled Dad, her tight young cunt hovering above his big pole. I couldn’t help but stare as her pussy lips wrapped around his meat and swallowed it whole. She began fucking him by moving her hips in to receive all his length into her cunt.