Chapter 3: The Dads Do Their Own Daughter First

It was well past noon by now and we were all starving so my dad headed back to the marina to refuel the boat and grab some lunch. As we headed in, I noticed my dad and uncle talking to each other but with the loud din of the motor I couldn’t hear a thing they were saying. From the grins on their faces and the occasional leering look back at Tammy and me, I had a pretty good idea what they were discussing - and it wasn’t anything my aunt would want to know about.

Back on shore, my mom and aunt went off to find a picnic table to set up. My uncle pointed at Rick and ordered him to carry the picnic baskets. With the wives setting up and Rick with them, that left the fathers and daughters on the boat, a not so subtle point that even Rick didn’t miss and I could tell that he was pretty upset with his dad. Although I couldn’t hear what they were saying at the end of the pier, it was obvious from the heated gestures and stiff body language that Rick was royally pissed off at his dad. I remembered his “promise” back at the rest area to fuck the two of us and so I assumed he thought he might be missing out on some ‘action”. I couldn’t blame him because if my expectations came true, he was right!

While Rick was arguing with his dad, I saw my dad talking to my mom who wasn’t looking all too pleased herself. She kept glancing towards Tammy and me, shaking her head at my dad. From the way her shoulders eventually slumped, I think my mom finally resigned herself to the inevitable. After all, it wasn’t like this would be our first time. My dad and uncle returned as a clearly miffed Rick ran to catch up with his mother.

“Well, it’s a go!” My dad said to his younger brother, flashing a double thumbs up sign.

“Fantastic! Guess I owe Mary one later, eh?” my uncle replied, the grin on his face even larger than ever. Something told me that was one debt he was looking forward to paying off.

There was no mention of Rick as Tammy and I took our seats in the stern. It was funny how both of us just seemed to understand what we needed to do without anyone actually coming right out and telling us. Well, it’s not like it wasn’t obvious after all. It was just over a year ago that a similar scenario had played out and I was positive that Tammy remembered the circumstances just as vividly as I did. The key differences were back then Tammy was still dealing with the recent loss of her virginity and had no idea at the time what her own dad had planned for her. Well, it was a distinctly different Tammy with me today, THAT was for sure. It still astounded me how quickly and seemingly effortlessly she’d transformed from being just another little tease at school to achieving “class slut” status. Of course, she DID have a couple of cousins to mentor her.

Given the time constraints we faced, I knew that this year there weren’t going to be any games, no pretending that we were heading out to ski or anything like that. We all knew that there was only ONE reason why my uncle and dad would head out to an open lake with the two of us while leaving the rest on the shore. I looked at Tammy and smiled as I saw her anticipation clearly being expressed in the way she was squirming and licking her lips without even realizing it. God she was quite the little sex pot these days, even more so than I was when I was fifteen and that’s saying quite a bit if I do say so myself.

Tammy looked over at me and our eyes met and it was like we were somehow linked telepathically. We both knew what we were expected to do next. After all, it didn’t take a doctorate in rocket science to know what our father’s both wanted - and it wasn’t to watch us water ski.

“Ready?” I said with a grin as she leaned closer so she could hear me over the noise of the engine below us.

Tammy nodded and as if following the instructions of an unseen director, we both slipped off our bikini bottoms and dropped them to the deck at our feet, leaving us bare-bottomed on the sun-warm bench seat. There was enough of a seat back that anyone going by wouldn’t have been able to see that we were both lacking our bikini bottoms as we kept our tops on, but the naughty thrill remained anyway. Up front, my uncle looked back and seeing what we’d done, gave us a thumbs up while tapping on my dad’s shoulder to get his attention.

Looking back at us, my dad also grinned broadly and then turned his attention back to the busy lake, trying to find somewhere we could anchor where we wouldn’t be interrupted. Fortunately, the lake was surrounded by numerous tree-lined coves and inlets and eventually he picked one that looked promising. Pulling in slowly until we were out of direct sight of the lake, he killed the engine and dropped the anchor.

“Well, well, looks like we have two horny little sluts with us, eh Jim?” my dad gloated with a grin.

“Yeah, looks that way John,” my Uncle Jim replied, “What do you think we should do with them?”

“Well ... I say we fuck ‘em,” my dad continued on with the little play-acting episode.

“Sounds like a plan if I ever heard one,” Uncle Jim agreed.

In the meantime, Tammy and I were smiling and grinning. I don’t know about hers, but my pussy was tingling and getting wetter by the second. I’d been waiting all day for this and just wished they could get on with it and fuck us without all this fooling around. My dad and uncle quickly dropped their swim trunks and stood naked before us, both their dicks literally growing as we watched them.

“What do you say Jim, daughters first or nieces?” my dad asked his brother.

From the way my father was staring at Tammy’s cute little bare pussy, there was no doubt what HE was hoping that the answer would be. It didn’t help that the little tart was toying with herself already, teasing them mercilessly as she slipped a single finger in herself quickly and then sucking on it like a pacifier...

“Hmmmmmm...,” my uncle mused, pretending to be undecided but I knew there was no question in his mind who he wanted. “What do you say we start out with our own daughters first?”

As much as my dad tried to smile, there was no mistaking the disappointment he was trying desperately to hide. He loved fucking Tammy, I knew that, but I have to admit that I was just a tiny bit jealous of my cousin at that moment. To be honest, I couldn’t blame both our fathers for wanting her first. C’mon, what guy wouldn’t choose a fifteen year-old innocent-looking high school freshman like Tammy over a 22 year-old who wasn’t even a college student anymore? Still, it wasn’t like I was just some old used up whore either so he didn’t have to look THAT disappointed!

Unlike my dad I was thrilled by my uncle’s choice. Personally, the longer I went without having to deal with my smelly rude uncle, the better. In fact, if my uncle never even fucked me today I would’ve been ecstatic. Unfortunately, the odds of THAT happening were slim to none so sooner or later I knew I would have to face the consequences. Oh well, why not put it off as long as possible if you could?

Tammy didn’t seem to be terribly concerned at all about her dad fucking her. Being he WAS her father, she certainly must have had a different perspective of him. I also knew that even if she had been disappointed, she wouldn’t have dared let her father know it. Tammy knew her place and what her father’s expectations of her were, just as she knew the consequences of not honoring her obligations to him.

Once again I witnessed the contrast between brothers. Although as his daughter I certainly feel an obligation to let my dad fuck me, he has never held that duty over my head. Uncle Jim, on the other hand, had made it known to Tammy early on that it was her duty to satisfy him, even more so since her sister didn’t do her part so Tammy had to fill in for Kate as well.

It wasn’t like we had all afternoon and I was getting a bit anxious at the delay. My mom would only be able to stall my aunt for so long so if we were going do anything, there was no point in playing these games or pretending we all didn’t want the same thing. A sense of relief filled me when both men stepped forward and we each grabbed our assigned cock, stroking them a little and then leaning forward, as if synchronized together, to take their stiffening dicks in our hungry mouths. God it felt wonderful to suck my dad’s dick again!