Chapter 3: David Fucks Me

Later that night we launched our plan. Brenda and I went to the family room where David was watching TV in an overstuffed chair. David was wearing just his shorts having taken off his tank top which was all sweaty after working hard outside. I caught myself wondering if he had anything else on underneath those shorts and subconsciously licked my lips at the thought of what I might see if he took them off.

As usual, Brenda’s parents had said goodnight and were in bed early. The boys had also long gone to bed, as had David’s wife had complained earlier of a bad headache (probably due to her two spoiled kids). Brenda told me that she had taken some extra-strength headache medicine and now was snoring in bed, passed out for the rest of the night. That left just the three of us remaining in the land of the living so we sat around talking about school and town gossip as we watched some silly reality show on TV.

Brenda and I were sitting close together on the couch. She sat up while I lay on my side with my head in her lap and my legs curled under me. Brenda played with my hair - something that makes me feel so relaxed and if done right, incredibly horny. The only thing I was wearing was a tight T-shirt that barely covered my ass. I had to keep tugging at it so as not to be too obvious I had nothing on underneath. Brenda had just a nightshirt on with a pair of white lace panties as she was never comfortable being bottomless. With my head in her lap the growing scent of her pussy told me that Brenda was getting wet with anticipation.

David was trying to make it appear that he wasn’t watching us but it was so obvious that he was it was almost funny. It was like some little boy staring at an older girl in the mall, thinking he wasn’t being watched but obvious to everyone around him. I had one hand on Brenda’s bare leg and was running my fingertips up and down her smooth thigh. Brenda played with my hair with one hand while her other hand was running all over my body, tracing little circles and tickling me at times. My nipples were so hard that they stuck out through my T-shirt like bullets. David HAD to realize from the way we were touching each other that Brenda and I were more than just friends and I knew that he had to be getting turned on seeing us playing with each other like this.

When the TV show was over Brenda yawned and said it was time for her to go to bed. She got up, gave me a kiss on the lips and winked at me as she left the room. I sat up in the couch with my legs under me. In doing so my T-shirt rode up for a second to reveal my shaved pussy until I quickly pulled it back down again. I giggled and looked at him, acting as if I was embarrassed. With Brenda gone, David and I continued to chat for a while when suddenly he turned towards me. He looked uncomfortable, as if he wanted to ask something but wasn’t sure if he should. I waited silently and finally he took a deep breath and let it out slowly.

“Kelly, do you mind if I ask you a very personal question? If you don’t want to answer after you hear it just say so but I have to ask you something.”

I just smiled and sat up straighter in the couch to pay closer attention. “Sure David, just don’t ask me how much I weigh!”

David laughed and the anxiety level seemed to drop just a bit for him. In a low voice he asked, “Do you and Brenda have something going on between you? I mean, the way you two act around each other, always hugging, kissing, dressing sexy, touching. It seems pretty obvious you’re not the typical dorm roomies.”

I flashed David a crafty smile and replied, “Well ... what would you say if we did have something going on? Would it turn you on”

David blushed just a bit. “Of course it would. Come on Kelly, I’m sure I don’t have to tell you that every guy dreams of watching two girls get it on. Add to the dream that one of them is my sister and the other is her roomie ... well you end up with one really hot fantasy.”

I raised my eyebrows at this. “Wow David, I didn’t know you had a thing for Brenda! So tell me, does big brother wanna be naughty with his little sister?”

David looked a bit embarrassed and started to protest so I tried to soften it a bit by telling him more about us.

“Don’t get all flustered. What if I told you that Brenda and I have been together sexually since last fall? Don’t go overboard - we’re NOT lesbians lovers or anything kinky like that but we DO enjoy each other if you know what I mean. Please, don’t go telling her I told you but just today we were talking about you and she confessed she’s had her own naughty thoughts about you as well.”

David looked a bit surprised at the last part but it seemed to encourage him to open up and tell me more. “Well Kelly, can you keep a secret from Brenda? I know the two of you are really close but this is something I don’t want her to know about.”

“Sure David, I don’t tell her EVERYTHING after all,” I said with a laugh.

Actually, this was true. For instance, I had never told Brenda about me being with my parents. Brenda was sexy and all but in many ways she was a bit on the conservative side and I was always afraid she would freak out on me if she knew. Of course, that was before I knew she was hot for her brother!

David continued, “When I was nineteen, Brenda was twelve and looking so cute. Her tits were starting to grow and she was starting to pay a lot more interest in the boys. I was dating girls my age and no virgin by a long shot, but until then I never even considered anything with a younger girl, let alone one that was twelve years old. In this case I found myself looking at her and started thinking about her as someone other than my pain-in-the-neck little sister.

When I masturbated I found myself thinking about her more and more. You know what great tits she has now. Well, she already had a nice rack by the time she was thirteen and her figure was looking pretty good. She was barely sixteen when I got married but by then she was a real babe and I was peeking in on her every chance I could get, trying to get a glimpse of those big tits. When she wasn’t home I would look through her dresser and check out her underwear and bikinis to see how they felt and smelled. A few times I jerked off by rubbing myself with her panties or bra. I would cum on them and then put them back in her drawer. Then later when I would see her. I would think about her wearing them and how she had my dried cum up against her pussy or tits. God, I get a massive hard-on just thinking about it!”

Actually, looking at his crotch I could see that David was indeed getting an erection just from thinking about it again! I listened intently as he kept talking. It was like a floodgate had opened and all of his pent-up emotions and fantasies were coming out. Actually, I couldn’t believe he was telling me all of this but I guess there comes a time you need to confide in somebody.

My hand moved between my legs and I started to rub myself slowly as I listened to David tell me about his fantasies about his sister. Not only did I enjoy the feeling it gave me, I wanted him to know how turned-on he was making me so he would be encouraged to tell me more. I could see from his gaze that he knew exactly what I was doing. Of course, any excuse to play with myself was good too and to do it in front of a guy was always an erotic experience for me.

David continued, “Brenda likes to suntan out in the back yard so I would peek at her through the upstairs bathroom window shades. As you know, it’s pretty private back there so when she thinks nobody is watching, she’ll spread her legs wide apart to get an even tan. Well, that lets me see up into her crotch and even though her pussy is still covered, it makes me really horny, especially when it pulls up into her slit. Around here she has always worn tiny bikinis, much sexier than anything she wears in public. With her figure today, she looks really hot in it but even when she was younger she still looked great - especially those incredible tits. Once when she was just twelve the whole family was in the pool and I took a lot of pictures, pretending to take them of everyone but actually just taking a bunch of her.

Later I got so horny looking at the pictures of her little girl body that was just beginning to develop and fill out her bikini in all the right places. Sometimes I would masturbate on my bed with her pictures in front of me imagining her coming into my room while I was jerking off. In my dreams she would ask me if I wouldn’t rather have the real thing and then let me do anything I wanted to her. Would you believe that I actually left my bedroom door cracked open a few times hoping she would watch me? Well, if she did she never told me so I have always assumed she didn’t want to do anything like that with her brother. Oh well, so much for horny teenage boy fantasies.”

David took a breath and then a look of concern came over his face. “Damn, I can’t believe I’m telling you all of this. I hope you don’t think I’m some sort of pervert!”

I smiled and replied, “Of course not David! Actually, as you may have noticed I think it’s really hot what you are sharing with me. You know, it’s too bad you never told her what you really wanted.”

David frowned. “Yeah right. How could I ever tell her Kelly? She would’ve gone running to mom and told her everything. So as much as I’ve dreamed about it, I’ve never really seriously thought that she would really want to do anything with me.”

“Oh David,” I said in a low voice, “You have NO any idea how much Brenda wants you. She just told me today that she watched you masturbate to those pictures you took of her. She also told me that she still gets herself off thinking of being with you.”

“What? You’re kidding,” he said with his eyes wide open. “If that’s the case, how come she’s never said anything to me?”

“Well David, I guess maybe for the same reason you’ve never told her!?” I shifted my position again to give him a better view of my bare ass. “You know, this is really crazy. For all these years the two of you have fantasized about being together but neither of you idiots would make the first move! So tell me, are you REALLY still interested in her?”

David lowered his head, “Since I married Stacy I’ve never seriously considered being with anyone else, probably more out of fear of her than anything else. Even so, sometimes when I come here and Brenda’s running around all but naked around the house, I still get turned on something terrible. Believe it or not, I still jerk off in her underwear! Then, seeing the two of you together on the couch tonight playing with each other - it was driving me crazy!”