Giving Myself Away, One Piece at a Time (Part 3 of Series) - Cover

Giving Myself Away, One Piece at a Time (Part 3 of Series)

Copyright© 2026 by BethanyBelow

Chapter 4: Projecting Desires

True Story Sex Story: Chapter 4: Projecting Desires - The third in my infidelity series, dealing with the continued fallout of my cheating and my continued descent.

Caution: This True Story Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Consensual   Reluctant   Heterosexual   True Story   Cheating   MaleDom   Humiliation   Rough   Spanking   Analingus   Masturbation   Oral Sex   Spitting   Squirting  

I stood in front of the mirror in my bedroom one last time before leaving for Mike’s. The left earlobe looked unfinished, a small, accusing blank. I opened the small jewelry box on my dresser and stared at the remaining options. Most of them felt wrong, too formal, too casual, too gaudy, and obviously not the pair I had worn almost every day for the past year. My fingers closed around a pair of simple blue stone studs I had bought on a whim two years earlier and rarely worn. The stones were small, a clear, cool sapphire blue that caught the light without shouting. I told myself Mike would never notice. He was not the kind of man who tracked jewelry. He would see that I was wearing earrings and that would be enough. I fastened them carefully, the metal cool against skin that still remembered the heat of the night before, and forced myself not to look at the empty place where the diamond should have sat.

The drive to Mike’s was short. The girls were already waiting in the front window of the living room when I pulled up, Sophie bouncing on the balls of her feet, Lily holding a small backpack with the quiet seriousness she always carried. Mike kissed me at the door the same way he always did when the girls were watching, soft, unhurried, the corner of my mouth. His hand settled at the small of my back, and the bruise between my shoulder blades answered with a low, private throb. I smiled, accepted Sophie’s fierce hug, and let Lily lean in for a quieter one. The blue stones felt heavier than they should have.

Then both girls started talking at the same time in a rush of “Beth!” and “Daddy said we can feed the giraffes!” and “Can I sit next to you in the truck?” I hugged them both, felt the clean, ordinary weight of their excitement, and for a second the marks under my clothes felt almost manageable.

Mike let the girls chatter for another minute, then raised his voice just enough to cut through.

“Okay, you two, tablet, living room. Fifteen minutes of videos while I talk to Beth. No arguing.”

They groaned in unison but obeyed, already scrambling for the couch and the shared tablet. Mike’s hand settled at the small of my back and guided me gently toward the kitchen. The touch was light, almost casual, but it pressed directly against the long bruise between my shoulder blades and sent a sharp, private pulse through me. I turned once we were past the doorway, mouth already opening to ask what was going on, and never got the chance.

His lips smashed into mine.

No soft lead-in, no careful question. Just the sudden, hungry pressure of his mouth and the way his body crowded mine against the edge of the counter. For half a second I froze- shock, guilt, the reflex to protect the marks- then the heat of him broke through, and I kissed him back. Hard. My hands came up to his chest, fingers curling into the soft fabric of his shirt. His tongue slid against mine, and the familiar taste of him- coffee, toothpaste, the faint mint of the gum he always carried- filled my mouth. One of his hands slid up my side, over the curve of my waist, and settled possessively on my breast. The pressure landed square on the dark bruise Tyler had left near my left nipple. Instead of flinching, I moaned into Mike’s mouth, the sound low and involuntary. The slight pain bloomed into something hotter, dirtier. Only a few hours earlier, another man’s mouth had been there, twisting, claiming, praising. The knowledge that Mike’s hand was now resting on the same place made my knees weaken.

His other hand dropped to my ass and squeezed, fingers digging into the soft flesh through my jeans. Another bruise answered, the deep one on my right hip where Tyler’s fingers had held me while he fucked me against the wall. The dual sensation of Mike’s touch and the memory of Tyler’s sent a fresh rush of wetness between my legs. I kissed him deeper, almost desperately, trying to drown the comparison in the present.

When we finally broke for air, I was breathing hard. A smile tugged at my mouth even as the guilt sat thick under it.

“What has got into you?” I asked, voice a little rough. The twinkle in my eye was real; the heat between us always had been. Without thinking, I added, “Don’t we have to get on the road right away to get there on time for our tour?”

Mike’s hands stayed on my ass, holding me against him so I could feel the hard line of his cock already pressing against my stomach.

“Nothing,” he said, mouth brushing the corner of mine. “Can’t I just want to kiss my girl when I haven’t seen her in forever?”

“Forever, huh? It’s been two days, you horny little devil.”

He squeezed again, harder this time, and the bruise under his fingers flared bright enough to make my breath catch. The pain was sharp and clean, and it only made me wetter. I hated how easily my body translated it.

“Traffic doesn’t look bad on the app,” he murmured against my neck, “and the girls should be all right for fifteen minutes. Why don’t you come help me with a problem I have in the bedroom that needs urgent inspection and attention?”

I let both hands settle on his chest, palms sliding slowly over the solid muscle, feeling the steady thump of his heart.

“An urgent problem? Sounds serious. What type of problem could you ever need Nurse Beth to help with this early in the day?”

Mike leaned in and kissed the nape of my neck, open-mouthed and slow. One hand slipped around to the front of my jeans and brushed directly over the sensitive bruise Tyler had left high on my inner thigh, right at the edge of where my pussy began. I flinched hard before I could stop myself. The word “inspection” from his earlier joke and the sudden contact with that particular mark sent a cold spike of panic through me. If he got me naked, if he saw the full map of what Tyler had done, everything would collapse.

I recovered as fast as I could, forcing my voice into the same playful, seductive register we had always used.

“I’m sorry, baby. My period came a few days early. But maybe there’s something else I can give you.”

I gave him the mischievous smile that usually worked and prayed it looked genuine.

Mike sighed, the sound half-frustrated and half-amused. “Well, I suppose I can submit to a different type of inspection.”

I took both of his hands and began walking backward, grinning at him, leading him out of the kitchen toward the hallway. The girls’ voices floated from the living room—some cartoon, laughter, the ordinary soundtrack of a Saturday morning. I raised my voice just enough to carry.

“Girls, I forgot my coat, and I’m worried it might get cold later. Your dad’s going to show me what jackets he has in his closet to see if anything fits and looks good on me. We’ll be back in ten minutes. Just keep watching your videos.”

“Okay, Beth,” they answered almost in unison.

I had already moved one hand to the hard shape of Mike’s cock through his jeans and was using it to pull him down the hall. His weight and size in my palm felt familiar and good. The guilt felt worse.

Mike laughed under his breath as we reached the bedroom doorway. “I feel like a bull being led to the slaughter. And when did you get so fast and good at making up a story and lying?”

The question was playful, almost admiring, but it didn’t feel that way to me. I somehow managed to keep the mischievous smile on my face, but inside the words cut deep. Three years of a relationship built on the kind of honesty I had always been proud of, and now I could invent a cover story and lead him by the cock without hesitation. The cheating slut who could lie without blinking. The thought sat cold and heavy even as my body stayed hot.

I pulled him into the bedroom. Mike turned just long enough to call back toward the living room.

“We’ll be back in a few minutes. Go pee now if you have to, and no fighting.”

He closed the door and locked it without looking, his hand still on the handle behind him. That was all the time I needed. I dropped to my knees so fast the carpet burned, yanked his jeans and boxers down together in one rough motion.

Mike’s cock sprang free, already thick and hard, the head flushed and leaking. I leaned forward and took as much of him as I could in the first pass, the hard size of him heavy on my tongue, the salt of his precum sharp and familiar. My lips stretched around the shaft. I looked up at him through my lashes and found him staring down at me with an expression that was pure heat and surprise and something softer underneath.

“Jesus, Beth,” he breathed. “You look so fucking beautiful like that.”

I hummed around him and took him deeper, tongue working along the underside, spit already slicked the shaft. I kept my eyes on his face while I worked, watching the way his jaw tightened, the way his eyes went half-lidded. His hand settled lightly in my hair, not pushing, just resting there as if he needed the contact or I needed the support.

“That feels incredible,” he said, voice already rough. “God, the way you use your mouth. You’re amazing.”

I pulled back just enough to speak, still stroking him with one hand, saliva connecting my lips to the head of his cock in a thin, shiny string while I looked up at him demurely.

“Do you like your slutty little girlfriend sucking you like this?”

Mike’s laugh was breathless. “Oh, I like you, every single version, but especially this one.”

Not the word I had offered. I took him back into my mouth and tried again a minute later, bobbing faster, letting the wet sounds fill the quiet room.

“Am I a good little cocksucker for you?”

His fingers tightened slightly in my hair. “You’re perfect, you’re everything. Fuck, Beth, the way you’re looking up at me right now...”

He never used the names; he never would. The contrast landed hard. Only a few hours earlier, I had been on my knees for Tyler, and the words that came out of his mouth had been completely different. “That’s it, you little cocksucker. Take it, you dirty girl.” He had told me exactly what to do. He had directed. When he told me to suck his balls while I stroked him, I had done it without question. The memory rose so clearly that I found myself doing the same thing now for Mike ... cupping his balls, rolling them gently in my palm, then leaning down to take one into my mouth while my hand kept a steady rhythm on his shaft. Mike groaned, low and deep, the sound pure pleasure.

“Fuck, Beth, yes, just like that. You’re so good at this.”

I switched to the other side, tongue working, still looking up at him. The praise was warm and real, and it made my chest ache in a way that had nothing to do with bruises. I remembered Tyler telling me to eat his ass. I remembered the internal battle, the reluctance, the way I had given in because he had done it for me first and because the part of me that wanted to please him had already started to outweigh the part that found it dirty. For a brief, dangerous second I considered asking Mike to turn around, to bend over just a little. The thought of offering him the same thing made my pussy clench. But there was no time, and I was not sure he would want it, and the morning already felt too close to collapsing under the weight of everything I was carrying. I let the idea go and returned to his cock instead.

I picked up the pace, taking him deeper with every pass, until the head nudged the back of my throat and I had to fight the gag. Mike was a solid seven inches, thick enough to stretch my lips, long enough that the last inch always required focus. I compared it automatically to Tyler. With Tyler, the struggle had been different. Longer. Thicker. He had to force the final inch into my throat, and I had choked and watered and still taken it because the way he looked at me while I did it made the struggle feel necessary. The memory made me wetter. I could feel myself leaking into my panties, the fabric already damp against the swollen bruise high on my thigh. The disgust at my own body’s reaction sat right next to the arousal and refused to separate.

I tried to emulate what Tyler had done. I reached around, grabbed Mike’s ass with both hands, and pulled him forward at the same time I pushed my mouth down, impaling myself on his cock until my nose smashed against his stomach and my throat convulsed around him. The gag was loud and wet. Spit ran down my chin. I held myself there, throat working, trying to give him the tight, rhythmic squeeze of a full gag the way Tyler had forced me to take. My lungs burned. Darkness flickered at the edges of my vision. I wanted Mike to grab my head and hold me there, to take the control the way Tyler would have, to fuck my face until I had no choice but to take it. Mike’s hands stayed gentle. They rested on the sides of my head, thumbs stroking my temples, giving me every opportunity to pull away.

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In