The following is a side-story within my Ordinary Sex Life series, and takes place during my longer story "An Ordinary College Sex Life". Familiarity with the OSL series is not actually a requirement for this one, but it is encouraged. If you haven't read the series and you enjoy this one, I strongly recommend you go back to the beginning and read "An Ordinary Teenage Sex Life".
This story also makes reference to several locations and an organization that exists in real life. They are not necessarily represented accurately in this story, and any similarities to real people or real situations are unintentional. My apologies if anyone feels offended, but this is fiction.
-- DECEMBER 2003, SOPHOMORE YEAR --
I was told to be ready at 8:30pm sharp, dressed informally despite the supposed formality of the event. I was told to expect the unexpected. And I was told to have eaten and hydrated beforehand.
It was all very mysterious and cloak and dagger. But even so warned, I was still surprised to find three people standing outside my door at the appointed time. I was even more surprised to find that they were all cloaked in black robes with ominous hoods, Venetian masks covering their faces.
"Uh, hello?" I greeted them awkwardly.
The lead figure stood up straight, as tall as me, and took a deep breath. "It is time," spoke the feminine voice, tinged with a semi-familiar tenor. "Come with us."
For a brief second, I thought these might not be the people I was expecting. For that brief second, my overactive imagination posited that they might be total strangers ready to beat me over the head with a baseball bat, stuff me in their trunk, and race off to bury my body in the desert.
But that second passed and mustering all of my self-confidence, I nodded and replied, "Right." I stepped out the door, crooking my elbow to the lead girl.
She didn't take my arm. Instead, rather formally, she produced a fourth black cloak and a male Venetian mask, holding them up to me. With an amused grin, I donned the costume articles, tying the mask behind my head with the black laces and then raising the hood over my head. The two of us then headed off the porch and down the steps, flanked by the other two girls.
The whole thing felt formally ritualized as we approached a black Lexus ES. My "date" stopped a few feet away from the car while one of our "attendants" went to the back door and opened it for her. Rather than stand back and observe, I took my own cue to lead my date to the door and help her in to take her seat. Only when she gave me her hand did I notice the caramel skin tone, and putting that together with her voice, I offered, "After you, Tonya."
The young pledge to the Delta Delta Delta Sorority giggled behind her mask before sliding into the seat, and then I circled around to where the other attendant held the opposite door open for me. I had to admit, all the ceremony was puffing up my ego nicely.
Of course, ceremony slipped a bit when our attendants got back in the car. The driver had to drop her mask, and Andie Holland flashed me a pixie wink before starting the ignition. A moment later, Jocelyn Canilao raised her mask and winked at me as well from the front passenger seat.
I grinned, recognizing them. After my thorough sexual destruction of a couple of Tri-Delt pledges at their Halloween party, I'd earned something of a reputation with the sorority. The pledge mistress had subsequently put a bounty of 100 pledge points on my head to the first pledge who could successfully seduce me, not an easy thing once I became aware that I'd been targeted. And after I'd gone out of my way to seduce the pledge mistress herself, that bounty had been raised even higher.
I'd spent the better part of the last few months toying with the Tri-Delt pledges, unable to decide exactly which one of them I wanted to earn the points. Ultimately, I didn't choose only one. I nailed Andie, Jocelyn, AND Tonya just last week. And now that all three of them had come to pick me up, I didn't think their selection was by accident.
"So I'm guessing Leighton gave you three the points?"
Behind her mask, Tonya nodded. "250 points for each of us. Enough to make us the Top 3."
I grinned. "In what order?"
Tonya shook her head, and even with the full-length mask in the way, I could still see her eyes sparkle. "That's none of your concern."
Jocelyn giggled anyway.
Our arrival was a reverse of the departure. Andie and Jocelyn escorted us into the Sorority House and into the Chapter Room. That's when I met the other three guys and their sorority dates. I say "met" loosely, as they were also wearing cloaks and masks and everyone was dead silent. Tonya held my hand and I wracked my brain to figure out what the hell was going on. I knew Adrienne was pledging in this class, and she wasn't the type to hide anything from me. Surely she would have told me about these weird rituals, just to share, right?
But then I realized that Adrienne NEVER told me about her sorority rituals. If I had to bet, at some point during the night everyone would be sworn to secrecy, even from our loved ones. And I started to relax. Sure, something kinky would probably happen tonight, but nothing too drastic. Sorority oath or not, Adrienne would have confided in me anything TOO outside her comfort zone.
The ten of us in masks and cloaks stood around the perimeter of the room, unmoving, like an ominous honor guard. Some guys started to get restless, but were quickly silenced by the girls. And then as the grandfather clock in the corner chimed out 9:00pm, the double doors opened and about 20 additional figures were herded in, funneled through the doors by the foreboding sight of seventy sorority girls in two lines of cloaks and masks just outside.
Once all of the pledges were inside, the doors were closed, leaving the majority of the sisters still in the outer room. Not everyone could fit into the Chapter Room anyway. One of the sisters, I didn't know who, directed me and the other three guys to line up against the west wall. And the 25 total pledges, each wearing a white cord around their necks that was long enough to droop halfway down the front of their robes, formed three uneven rows in the middle of the room right in front of the stage. 25 other figures in robes, who I suspected were the pledges' "big sisters", stepped up immediately behind the pledges and laid their right hands on the pledges' left shoulders.
I tried to pick out Adrienne by her height and the particular way she carried herself. Plus, even a heavy robe couldn't contain those massive hooters of hers. But from my particular vantage point and the masks in the way, I couldn't decide which pledge I thought she was.
Leighton Barrister, Tri-Delt Pledge Mistress this year, took the stage and immediately launched into some boring speech about honor and loyalty, character and friendship. She wore the same cloak and held a mask in her hand, surveying the room with a cold demeanor. The imposing, serious Senior had quite the erudite tone tonight, but I wasn't paying attention. I was too busy scoping out the scene.
There were nearly sixty people crammed into the room, their bodies entirely obscured by the heavy black cloaks and their faces half-covered by the Venetian masks. I instantly thought about Eyes Wide Shut, a movie my friends and I had seen when we were fifteen, mostly so we could see Nicole Kidman and other chicks completely naked. So of course I started to fantasize about re-enacting the orgy scenes that had taken place while the participants were clad in these same costumes, not that there was any room for us to actually have sex with so many people in here.
My attention was drawn back to the speech when, as one, all 25 pledges solemnly intoned, "We so pledge."
Nodding in approval, Leighton took a deep breath and then asked her second question. "Do you pledge to obey all laws and codes of The Sorority?"
"We so pledge," they all replied together.
"Do you pledge to represent The Sorority with grace and beauty?"
"We so pledge."
"Do you pledge friendship and support for your sisters?"
"We so pledge."
"Do you pledge your unswerving loyalty to The Sorority?"
"We so pledge."
"Do you pledge, no matter where your futures may take you, to always remember that you are Delta Delta Delta, and to always represent The Sorority as such."
"We so pledge."
The ritual came to an end a minute later, and Leighton at last stepped off the raised platform and walked through the middle of the crowd. The pledges stepped to the sides to let her pass as she went straight for the closed double-doors. As she reached the doors themselves, she paused to look back. With a final flourish, she yelled encouragingly, "Welcome to Delta Delta Delta!" And as she flung the doors open, every single big sister inside the room ripped away her mask and screamed, "WOOO!!!"
Fifty girls outside, similarly clad in cloaks and masks, pulled away their masks and screamed as well. "WOOO!!!"
Twenty-five pledges inside the room took up the cry, throwing their arms in the air and ripping off the white cords, screaming, "WOOO!!!"
And we four guys, just for the hell of it, joined in screaming "WOOO!!!"
The party was underway.
I started by finding Adrienne and then staggering beneath her as she jumped into my arms, wrapping her long legs around my waist. She had a hard time getting a good grip since I didn't have any hips and the robe was proving to be quite slick. And after fifteen seconds of my forearms burning from holding her up, I finally set the bombshell blonde back on her feet and let her give me a more chaste hug. We chatted for a bit, and then she spun around to charm a few big sisters and let the gaggle of cute girls descend on me.
As the party went on, I started to wonder exactly why I was there. It's not that I minded the lopsided ratio – like I said, the now "ex-pledges" all seemed to want to flirt with me. But it's just that it wasn't a typical dancing and drinking party for the sake of partying. Masks were off and everyone was free to mingle with each other, but there was no dance floor. The ambient music was just that ... ambient. And everywhere I looked were packs of girls deep in discussion. This was a party to welcome their new sisters in, and to answer all of their questions about what sorority life with the Tri-Delts would be like. It wasn't a party for inviting fifty guys to flirt with and have a good time.
So why even have four of us? Looking around after we got our masks off, I recognized the other four dudes. Two of them were well-known long-term boyfriends of sisters. The other was at least an acquaintance. A couple of us shared our thoughts of wondering why we were around, the boyfriends claiming that their girlfriends hadn't told them anything.
Of course, that's when Leighton arrived back on the scene. Nearly an hour had passed, during which each and every single new sister had been hugged and congratulated and welcomed to the sorority. Food had been consumed. Drinks had been drunk. And there had been so much chattering that I felt like I'd taken a trip to the lake during the migrating ducks mating season.
But now many of the sisters had already left, some of them even removing their cloaks before departing. Leighton wielded a microphone, getting atop a stage in the near corner. And after thanking everyone for coming and welcoming in the pledge class of Fall 2003, she said it was time to move on to the next step of their initiation.
Her words were foreboding, but to a girl, every single remaining upperclasswoman cheered, "Wooo!!!"
The guys gawked at each other, wondering what the heck was going on. To my consternation, even the ex-pledges were staring at each other in confusion. To their mind, they were already initiated, weren't they? Wasn't that the whole point of the formal ceremony with the masks in the Chapter Room?
Jocelyn elbowed me in the ribs. "Do you know what's going on?"
I frowned, staring at one of the girls who had escorted me here without explaining a damn thing. "Don't you?"
Leighton just grinned almost evilly and gestured back to the double doors. "Will all new sisters please move back into the Chapter Room? Gentlemen in attendance, you too. And designates, please also enter at this time."
Shrugging, I followed the crowd as we turned and filed back into the Chapter Room. Two sisters, both wearing their masks and hoods once again, touched each person on the shoulder and directed them where to go. I thought I caught the sparkle of green eyes as one such sister took my shoulder and firmly pointed me to the front of the room.
"Go get 'em, Tiger," she said with a purr.
I glanced back at her, wondering who had just singled me out. Even though she'd called me 'Tiger', it wasn't Adrienne. And I rather nervously let one of the other mask-clad girls lead me up and onto the stage.
The twenty-five ex-pledges all assembled in front of me. The stage wasn't that elevated, only about three feet up. But it was enough that I felt terribly exposed despite being completely covered by my clothes as well as the bulky robe. The ex-pledges all were maskless, their faces the definition of innocent curiosity as they gawked at me. The three guys below looked on somewhat nervously, relieved not to be in my position while simultaneously worried that they'd be next. And four mask-covered big sisters guarded the corners of the room.
What the hell is going on? I wondered to myself.
I got my answer when the lights suddenly went out. Everyone squealed at the sudden pitch blackness, but a second later, an overhead spotlight came on, directly over a couch that had at some point been placed on the stage directly behind me. The next thing I knew, a mask-clad girl on either side of me took hold of my arms, firmly tugging me back to that couch where I was rather formally seated in the very center.
The music turned somewhat ... theatrical. The cloaks and masks had already reminded me of Eyes Wide Shut. But now, the music and ritualistic movements REALLY reminded me of the movie, and I started to get an idea of just what the three remaining guys and I were here for.
Sure enough, a procession of four sorority girls, in full cloaks and donning their masks, ascended the stairs and began a march directly for me. They were in a diamond formation, their bodies, faces, and identities hidden. And I let out a long exhalation. Just when I thought my life was simplifying, as I got used to my newly single life after breaking up with DJ and just enjoying my day-to-day existence without the hassles of maintaining the complexities of a romantic relationship, my life had to go and get a little ... over-the-top ... again.
All my attention was on the four girls in front of me, the lead girl stopping right before me while the next two moved to sit with me on the couch, and the fourth circling behind it. Automatically, I started trying to identify them by their physical build and skin tone. But the robes obscured most of their bodies, the masks and hoods even hiding their heads. Plus, the harsh illumination of the lone overhead spotlight in the pitch black room drowned out all sense of color, so that I couldn't tell the skin tone of a white girl from an Asian from a Latina. And none of my current four were black.
I chuckled to myself at how often I seemed to be in this position of fucking someone whose identity I didn't even know. No one was blindfolded, but the costumes still made the girls anonymous to me, as well as to our attentive audience. I wasn't being approached by Jocelyn or Kelly or Andie or whoever; I was being seduced by four unnamed sisters, period.
I did notice that all four were wearing half-masks that left their lower faces bare, the curves of their lips familiar to me, although I still couldn't identify them. But the absence of covering wasn't to give me clues to the girls' identities. Indeed, it was a fashion choice born of necessity, as the lead girl knelt before me, licking her lips in obvious anticipation of a blowjob.
Leighton's voice echoed in the silent room. "We work as a team."
On cue, the girl to my right reached down to open up my slacks while the girl to my left pulled my face to hers for a searing kiss. The girl behind me started massaging my neck and shoulders. And the one kneeling in front of me pulled down my zipper. Distracted by the girl kissing me, I don't know whose hand wrapped around my already half-hard cock. The whole situation was arousing, if not entirely comfortable.
Leighton again spoke. "We share without jealousy."
The girl on my right pulled me to her for a kiss of her own, while the girl between my knees sucked me into her mouth and then went to town using her lips, tongue, and hands to bring me to full mast. Her touch was familiar. I'd been with whoever was giving me the blowjob before, but not enough that I'd easily recognize her.
My current kisser, the one on my right, was also familiar. My brain automatically rifled through my catalog of "user manuals" trying to identify the specific flavor of lipstick and perfume and kissing technique assaulting my senses. Little by little, it started to come to me. I began forming a picture of her in my head, with enough detail to eliminate a lot of the Tri-Delts I'd been with but not enough to fully confirm who it was.
But just before I put a finger on it, Leighton spoke again. "And we make sacrifices for the greater good, both for ourselves and for The Sorority."
A little too abruptly, Right Kisser stopped kissing me and Blowjob pulled off my cock. Left Kisser got off the couch. And the fourth and final one, Massager, stopped her neck massage and came back around to the front of the couch.
Blowjob stopped and whispered something into Massager's ear, the two of them pausing and then briefly squeezing hands. And then with ritualistic formality, Massager knelt on the couch beside me, putting herself in a doggy-position while bracing herself against the backrest.
My cock twitched as Massager's robe rode up her thighs, revealing that her legs were bare. But then Right Kisser moved in and lifted the hem even higher, raising it over Massager's ass and lower back, showing me that the girl was completely naked beneath the cloak, with a perfect backside neatly bisected by a wonderful asscrack, complete with crinkled rosebud and bare-shaven pussy. She was also physically petite, with narrow hips and a near-flat ass. It was more the body of a younger teenager than a fully-grown college-aged young woman.
Idly, I wondered if all four of the girls were similarly naked, or just this one "sacrifice" as Leighton had put it. It certainly took some guts to be completely nude in front of a whole crowd of people. Then again, I currently had my cock and balls hanging out for anyone to see.
Leighton intoned, "We provide whatever help and support the others need."
Blowjob reached a hand down, gliding around Massager's tiny waist and into the bent-over girl's crotch. Left Kisser cupped one of Massager's shapely breasts in her hand. And Right Kisser started to undress me.
Then Leighton finally finished. "And when we take action, we always do it together."
Right Kisser fisted my cock and turned me around to stand behind Massager. Left Kisser kept fondling Massager's tits. And Blowjob reached down to pull apart Massager's asscheeks. So with a firm grip on the petite girl's narrow hips, I pushed my way forward.
"Nnnnghh!" Massager yelped in a high pitch. I'd thought she had the body of a young girl before, and she also seemed to have a youthfully girlish voice to match. But despite the whole "virgin sacrifice" vibe I was getting overall, from her eager sexuality and ability to open herself up to allow my entry I knew she wasn't actually some inexperienced 15-year-old girl. And with that last roadblock removed from my mind, I simply let the sexual creature take over.
They wanted a show? They were gonna get a show.
It didn't take long for me to figure out the four Tri-Delt identities. I'd been intimate with all four of them within the past month, and even though it had only been a single encounter for each one, I'd learned enough about their unique scents and distinct moans to determine who each of them was.
"Massager" was Kelly Park, a Korean Junior a year older than me despite her petite body and snug pussy. She had ultra-sensitive nipples that I tweaked with my left hand, and though she'd never had anal sex, she'd confessed curiosity the one time we'd been together. She wouldn't let me take her anal cherry that night – though I promised her I would do so eventually – but she'd proven that when I buzzed my thumb over her sphincter, her entire body would lock up and became that much more susceptible to the pleasures of my tweaking fingers and deep-burrowing dick. So of course I buzzed her crinkled anus right now, grinning as she tensed and then squealed as my left fingers strummed her clit like a guitar string.
"Blowjob" was Carli Singer, a fiery Junior with an impish, dive-in-and-fuck-the-consequences kind of personality. The pretty redhead with great tits shrieked as I grabbed her by the hips, suddenly jerking her into the air and literally throwing her atop Kelly's prone body on the couch so that the two sisters were double-stacked doggy-style before me. Lifting up the hem of Carli's cloak, I found that she too was completely naked beneath it. And swiftly jerking my cock out of Kelly's tight snatch, I aimed a few inches higher and stood up, sliding my dick into Carli's wet cunt instead.
"Left Kisser", conveniently, was still on my left as I reached out for her. Bottle-blonde and busty Senior Bridget Marks at first panicked that I was going to hoist her up and plant her on top of Carli and Kelly, creating a triple-stack. Instead, I simply wrapped my left arm around her waist, pulling her to me before knocking her mask and hood off her head with my right hand. Her deep brown eyes gawked at me in mixed alarm and lust right before I gripped her jaw and pulled her to my mouth for a searing kiss. And I continued pumping Carli from behind with just my hips while dropping my left hand down to fondle Bridget's lush ass before sliding a finger down through her crack and then into her slit from behind.
"Right Kisser" tried to make a run for it, or at least I imagined she did. Perhaps she was supposed to fuck me all along, perhaps not. The point is that I saw her out of the corner of my eye starting to back away, and I abruptly left Bridget lest I lose my fourth conquest. Leah Hirsch was the most recent Tri-Delt to have the Big Ben and Adrienne experience, and also the most hesitant once we'd gotten started, so I wasn't surprised she'd started to panic at the last second. But sometimes the quietest and most reserved girls are the most wanton between the sheets once you get them going, and Leah had certainly been one of those. The sweet-looking brunette Junior shrieked as I caught her from behind, squealing as I lifted her into the air with her feet kicking out erratically. In the audience, I saw Adrienne cover her mouth while giggling as she got an eyeful of Leah's bare bottom from kicking up the hem of her robe. Tossing Adrienne a wink, I carried Leah back to the couch, dropped her into a seated position on the couch, then spread her knees to the side and swiftly lunged forward to skewer her tight pussy on my prick.
"Aiiieee!" Leah shrieked as she felt my dick stretch her wide in a single thrust. She threw her head back and tried to melt into the couch beneath the force of my body. And whimpering, she let her head loll to the side as I began to pump her with rough, heavy strokes.
"Ahem," Leighton's voice carried over us. "Even in the face of the most imposing adversary, we work as a team."
Suddenly Carli and Bridget were beside me, grabbing my arms and yanking me out of Leah. I fought them instinctively, trying to break free without hurting them or anything. But the girls spun me around and flung me back onto the couch, Bridget jumping into my lap to take the dominant position and shoving her big bare D-cup tits into my face to get me to quiet down. Like a starving baby, I found myself pacified, and Kelly reached between Bridget's legs to grab my dick, elevate it into a fully upright and locked position, and aimed it so that the busty blonde Senior could sink down.
I now had gotten my dick wet inside all four of the girls, but with not enough time to stimulate anyone to orgasm. That was all due to change now. Carli was working something on the side of the couch, and after we all heard a loud clicking sound, the support against my shoulders suddenly gave way and I went falling backward.
Turned out, the couch was a convertible futon. Bridget continued to hump herself up and down my cock, shrugging her robe off her shoulders and tossing the garment aside to leave her fully illuminated in all her naked glory by the overhead spotlight that cast delectable shadows beneath her pendulous breasts and haloed her hair as I stared up at her. "From the minute I kissed you at that Halloween party," she hummed. "I always knew I wanted to do this."
"Lots of time between now and your graduation for even more," I replied with a smile.
She just grinned happily before closing her eyes and letting her head fall back, moaning rapturously.
From behind the futon, Kelly similarly shucked her robe and then squatted over my face while facing Bridget. Brushing some of her dyed-blue bangs away from her face, the hot Asian babe leaned forward to suckle one of Bridget's pale nipples into her mouth. Her bare-shaven pussy covered my vision, and then wet smacking sounds began to emanate not only from where my tongue joined Kelly's snatch, but also where Kelly's and Bridget's mouths now began to meet.
Actually, I heard a lot of moaning around me, including a couple of male grunts. This futon on the stage wasn't the only piece of furniture in the room, and I wasn't the only guy in the room, either. Although the four girls and I on stage were by far the most publicly exposed sex act taking place, by now we weren't the only one.
After eating Kelly to a squealing orgasm and letting Bridget ride me to a keening climax of her own, I pushed the girls off me and sat up to take a look around. There were now other lamps on in the room, giving enough illumination so that everyone could see what they were doing, although the atmosphere was still what one would call "moody". Some of the newly-minted sorority sisters had taken Leighton's intonations about teamwork to heart, and I saw them working in harmony to strip the other three males of their clothing and begin to work on them.
Not every ex-pledge participated, of course. As sexual as this sorority was, it wasn't the only thing the girls did together. Besides, 25 girls was still WAY too many for just three guys to handle, and only the daring and most uninhibited 8 or so had moved in on the other males. So I noticed Cadence Carmichael standing off to one side, watching me intently while a hand subtly wriggled underneath her robe. Andie Holland was intently watching her big sister and me. And Adrienne had decided to just skip the males entirely, pulling two of her fellow pledgemates into a corner where the three of them were making out and pawing at each other's body hot and heavy.
Worked for me. Carli Singer and Leah Hirsch were sixty-nining beside us, and taking charge once again, I rolled Carli over and then physically manhandled Leah until the two Juniors were kneeling side-by-side on the futon. And after a couple of healthy spanks to both of their bare butts, I took turns fucking them each from behind while at the same time, pointing to Kelly and Bridget and ordering them beneath Carli and Leah into new sixty-nine positions.
"Suck my balls," I commanded Kelly while slow-dicking Leah.
"Reach up and stick a finger in her ass," I ordered Bridget while she lapped at Carli's cunt.
"I'm not letting you cum until you make her cum," I told Leah.
"And the same goes for you," I laughed while reaching over to spank Carli.
Obediently, Leah and Carli focused on the girls beneath them. I wasn't sure it was in the spirit of tonight's events for me to be giving the sorority girls orders as if I were one of them, but it was hard for me to resist the power trip as I played four beautiful older women like my own personal string quartet on top of this stage in full view of their sorority sisters. As I surveyed the room, I noticed that more than just a handful were just sitting back to watch the show. And I grinned as I pulled out of Leah and then rammed myself into Carli so hard that she picked her head up and squealed at my penetration, her cries echoing around the room.
"Fuck me," Carli whimpered while I pounded her from behind.
"Fuck ME," Leah pleaded from my left.
"No, fuck me," Kelly whined while reaching up to Leah's head and shoving it back down into her crotch.
"Please, fuck ME!" Bridget complained from just beneath my balls.
"You had your turn!" Carli whined, ceasing to lick the bottle-blonde.
I rolled my eyes and spanked Carli three times in quick succession, causing her to shriek and buck herself back against my invading prod. "Focus on fucking ME and tongue-fucking HER or I'm gonna get off this stage and go grab a few pledges to get myself off!"
"WOOO!!!" some of the girls in the audience called.
Carli, Leah, Kelly, and Bridget all shut up and focused. I grinned, pumping Carli a few times while Bridget furiously licked her out, getting the redhead remarkably close to climax before I suddenly pulled out and switched back over to Leah. With Kelly working her over and the resumption of my dick stretching out her vaginal walls, Leah got pretty damn close as well. But despite my earlier commands about making their sisters cum first, I decided that I wanted to knock down all the dominoes myself.
Picking Leah up, I manhandled her around for the third time tonight, spinning her around and planting her facedown on top of Kelly so that they were tit to tit and cunt to cunt. I did the same to Carli, smashing her on top of Bridget. And while all four girls wondered what the hell I was doing, I circled around and swiftly entered Leah again from the other side of the futon, grabbing her hips, reaching around to her breasts, and powerfucking her from behind.
"What the-? Oh, holy ... Jesus-fucking-Christ!" the Jewish girl screamed as she was suddenly overcome with orgasm, throwing her head back and cursing a name that I'm sure her parents would not want to hear pass her lips.
Kelly started giggling beneath her, but as Leah collapsed her dead weight onto Kelly's body, I aimed my prick into the Korean babe's tight snatch. Seizing her hips, I jerked her against me with each thrust while grabbing the back of Leah's head and pushing it down to Kelly's so that the two girls could swap spit and moan as I continued fondling Leah's tits through her orgasm while pumping my cock in and out of Kelly. My right hand slid down Kelly's hip to palm her firm asscheek, raising it off the mattress. And when my middle finger shot out and buzzed over the Asian beauty's anus, she tightened up and screamed in orgasm, "MotherfuckingSHIT!"
Immediately I was on to Bridget, skewering the busty-bottle blonde while she wetly kissed and ground her pelvic bone against Carli's cunt. Unlike with Leah and Kelly, I didn't set them off one-by-one. I switched back and forth, aiming my cock up and down to give each girl a dozen or so strokes before pumping into the other one. My hands roved around both of their bodies, squeezing a nipple here and gently strangling a neck there. I tickled ribs and other sensitive nerve clusters. In the end, I was rewarded when both girls began the tell-tale quivers of orgasm. And just as Bridget began her earthquake of pleasurable tremors, Carli threw her head back to scream, "I'm cumming! I'm cumming! I'm cumming!"
"Nnngaahh!" Bridget gasped beneath her, arching her back and thrusting her tits against Carli's chest right around the same time I popped a finger up her butt. I felt the blonde's pussy contracting around my prod, milking me like a third hand and causing my pleasure load to top off and tell my balls to stop production so they could fire both barrels.
"Fuuuu-EEEK!" Carli shrieked when I pulled out of Bridget and suddenly invaded her pussy instead. She too arched her back, pushing herself upright so that I could easily reach around and grab onto both of her big titties, squeezing the fleshy firm funbags in my palms and pinching her nipples to amplify her sensations. Like Bridget beneath her, Carli's inner muscles were spasming in orgasmic overload. And when my balls finally got the message to fire away, it was while I was nearly eight inches inside the hot redhead that I did so.
"FILLLL MEEE!" Carli moaned as she felt her vaginal canal flush with sudden warmth. "OHHHHH!" she moaned, jerking spasmodically in my arms while I continued splashing sperm into her womb.
"Nghh. Fuck. Yeah," I grunted, pleasurable relief filling my brain as I spooged the hot redhead.
But then I was done, and she was done. Simply opening my hands and pulling my arms away, I let Carli's near-lifeless body drop forward, which also pulled her off my cock. And Bridget had to reach up and grab the redhead's tits to arrest the girl's fall.
Bracing a knee on the futon for support, I leaned back and put my hands on my hips while calming down from the effort of fucking four girls to orgasm at the same time. I felt steam rising up from my sweaty body into the cool December air. And as I surveyed the four naked beauties on the bed, I smirked with pride.
Just then, three more girls approached me, all of them still wearing their robes, albeit with hoods thrown back and the masks nowhere to be seen. Tonya Brackett, Andie Holland, and Jocelyn Canilao grinned at me. "Hey, this pledge ceremony is supposed to be for us pledges," Jocelyn announced. "And I think it's time we started putting this teamwork thing to further practice."
In quick succession, Tonya, Andie, and Jocelyn dropped their robes and began to strip off their clothing underneath. And while they did so, a fourth newly-minted Tri-Delt sister also joined us on the stage.
"If you girls want to experience teamwork," Adrienne stated with a distinctly predatory grin, similarly opening up her robe and then working the buttons on her blouse. "Then you won't mind Ben and me showing you exactly what the Big Ben AND Adrienne Experience is all about."
"That's it, spread your cheeks for me baby. Let me watch my thick cock pounding in and out of your tight little cunny."
Whimpering slightly, Andie Holland did as ordered. The slender bottle-blonde cutie reached back with pale white hands, spreading her paler white buttcheeks to the side so I could see the dusky rose of her anus and her pinker puffed out pussy being penetrated by my pistoning prick. Having her arms extending back also meant her upper body was unsupported, her tits crushed flat against the futon mattress and her cheek being driven down with every thrust of my dick from behind.
Beside us, Tonya and Adrienne were sixty-nining, a perfect vision of caramel and cream. Tonya was on top, nuzzling her nose into Adrienne's pretty pussy and arching her back so she could get her head lower and nuzzle her cheeks amongst the bodacious blonde's lush titflesh.
Adrienne, on the other hand, was giddily slurping my jizz out of Tonya's snatch. I'd deposited my second load of the evening into the Tri-Delt's caramel cunt just a few minutes ago, although we hadn't knocked her out yet. Adrienne had given me enough eye signals to let me know she still wanted more playtime with the buxom black babe.
And Jocelyn ... well, Jocelyn was already unconscious. I hadn't meant to knock her out that early, really. It just sort of happened. One minute, the petite Filipina cutie was riding me in a reverse cowgirl while Adrienne knelt next to the bed and ate her out from the other side. The next minute, Adrienne had wrapped her tongue around Jocelyn's clit and sucked the poor girl to a climax so powerful her eyes had rolled up in her head and she'd toppled forward right onto Adrienne herself. We gently lay the girl down on the floor beside us and covered her with a robe. And then we went back to playing with the two girls who were still conscious ... well, conscious for now.
Speaking of which, I started up my little knockout routine with Andie. I'd developed a "user manual" for every girl I'd ever been with. Sexually, I knew their likes and dislikes. I knew the things that turned them on and turned them off. And more specifically, I knew the things that GOT them off. The pretty bottle-blonde liked things a little rough, and after buzzing her butthole with my thumb I started spanking her, switching hands to impact both cheeks while also increasing the force each time. Her whole body quivered with each impact, shaking more from her own internal pleasure than from the physical spanks. I also reached around to hold both of her tits as handholds, using them to really pound the slender girl's body from behind while pinching her pale pink nipples roughly between my fingernails. And just as she approached her orgasm, I reached forward with both hands, covering her mouth and nose with my left hand while using my right to gently grasp her neck.
"HRRK!" Andie jerked in panic as her air supply was cut off and she felt me strangling her. Her upper body came off the bed and she reached up with both hands to instinctively try and free herself. But I held fast with my grips and rotated my hips to carve my shaft around the inner walls of her vaginal cavity.
"Hmph-HMMPH!" she screamed into my hand, the sound muffled almost completely. The quivering began in her hips, a gentle side-to-side motion that quickly grew into the spine-bending wriggling of a snake as Andie jerked left and right, desperately trying to escape. At last, I removed the hand from her mouth, letting her take just one big gulp of air. But I used my left hand to swiftly reach back and land a wicked spank across her left buttcheek, and that burst of air immediately flew back out as Andie screamed in an unholy mixture of pleasure and pain. "AAAAAAAAAAGGGGHHHH!"