Kelly's Eyes
by Souvie
Copyright© 2026 by Souvie
Drama Story: On a Caribbean cruise, carefree college student Kelly meets a married couple whose relationship is quietly falling apart. Attracted to both yet unwilling to destroy their marriage, she sets out to bring them together. But helping two strangers rediscover love may become the turning point in Kelly's own life.
Caution: This Drama Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual Romantic Fiction Humor Exhibitionism Slow .
A “Foursome Moresome” story
Oh yes, another sun-kissed day of fun in the sun. The third day of a seven-day cruise to the Caribbean, and I was bored out of my mind. Hard for even me to believe, but there are only so many times you can work out in the ship’s gym, play shuffleboard, or flash the upper deck bartender to get free drinks.
I rummaged in my suitcase for my blue bikini. I wanted to read, and sitting out by the pool beat staying in my cabin; at least there I’d be able to people-watch when I got bored with Faulkner. I tied the strings on either side of the thong panty and then reached behind me to do up the one around my neck. The dolphin on my hip winked back in the mirror at me. Michael had said that tat suited me to a “T” - cold as a fish and as likely to stay in one place. The same Michael who had dumped me a couple of weeks before the cruise, yelling at me about maturity, commitment, and responsibility. Oh yeah, I can learn a lot about maturity from a dope-head who lived in his mother’s basement and worked nights at Safeway. I was better off without him.
I gathered my hair up in a ponytail and slipped on some shades, protecting my baby blues. With a beach towel and book in hand, I was ready to hit the pool.
I noticed them almost as soon as I sat down on the lounger. Man and woman, mid-thirties probably. The man had a wedding band, so I assumed they were married; whether or not to each other was hard to say. They were staring at me, but acting like they weren’t. You know, quick furtive glances, and doing such a bad job of it, I hid a smile behind a fake yawn.
I checked the ties on the sides of my bikini bottoms, for show, stretching out my long legs and giving them a nice expanse of skin to look at. I rolled over onto my stomach and reached back to untie the top from around my neck. I wasn’t fond of tan lines, but going totally nude was against ship’s policy. I wiggled around a little, getting comfortable and pushing my breasts up nice and tight against the hard plastic lounger. I reached for my book and pretended an interest in the words on the page. In reality, I was watching the couple out of the corner of my eye, and wondering just how hot I could make them.
The thong wasn’t bothering me, but I reached back with my left arm to straighten it anyway. I ran a finger underneath the material, sliding it from the top to the bottom, caressing the crack of my ass with my knuckle. In the process, I’d raised up off the lounger high enough to let a dusky, puckered nipple show. I sighed deeply and wiggled back into position. The husband got up and padded over to the high dive. I almost laughed out loud when I saw the start of his erection poking against his swimming trunks. I lowered the glasses and stared right at the woman. I don’t think her eyes had ever left me since I first sat down. I smiled widely and flicked the gold stud in my tongue against my upper teeth. She flushed and turned her head away, watching her husband do laps in the pool.
Finished with my fun for the time being, I opened my book back up and immersed myself in “Absalom, Absalom!”
Two hours later, I’d forgotten about the pool couple when the woman took a seat at the bar next to me. I was in the Seafarer’s Lounge, my drink courtesy of Johnny the bartender. Johnny wiped the bar in front of her. “I’ll have what she’s having,” she said, pointing at my shot glass.
“One screaming orgasm, coming right up.” He winked at me and turned to mix the drink.
“A what?”
The look on her face was priceless. I couldn’t resist. “Don’t tell me you’ve never had a screaming orgasm before? You look like a screamer to me.” I licked my lips.
She blushed and ran a hand through her wind-tossed auburn hair. She took the drink and swirled it around in the glass, avoiding my eyes.
“Drink up. All it is is vodka, Kahlua, Irish cream, and amaretto. It won’t bite.” I tipped my glass up to my lips and downed it in one gulp.
She slammed back the shot and then choked. Laughing, I slapped her on the back. “You’re not a hard drinker, are you?”
“No,” she wheezed out. “I stick to mainly wine.” She wiped a tear out of her eye and then stuck out her hand. “I’m Stacey, Stacey Robinson.”
Geezus, people still shook hands when they met? I took her hand; nice smooth skin and manicured nails. Not working hands at all. “Kelly Thomas. So what brings you to the Caribbean, Stacey?”
“My husband and I are on vacation.” Her voice was strangely flat when she said it.
“Well then, why aren’t you off bouncing the bedsprings instead of talking to a strange woman you just met?” I motioned for Johnny and ordered a club soda while I waited for her answer.
“Do you always say what you’re thinking?”
She said it in such a way that I was reminded of my mother. In a split second I was ten years old again and had just been caught playing “doctor” with little Alex Myers from next door. “I’m sorry, I sometimes speak before thinking,” I said, contritely. I slid off the barstool. “Nice meeting you, Stacey Robinson.”
Her hand touched my arm lightly as I went to walk past. “How about we have a couple more drinks and I bore you with the story of how I came to be on this floating city?”
She looked like she needed someone to talk to, and if truth be known, I couldn’t remember the last time I’d had an honest-to-God female gab session. I sat back down. “Only if you let me bore you first.” She laughed and I ordered another round from Johnny.
I never got around to hearing her story that afternoon. We sat around, drinking whatever Johnny brought us, and commenting on the ship’s accommodations, the upcoming ports that we were scheduled to pull into, and other non-consequential things. She didn’t seem all too eager to hear my boring life’s story, and I didn’t press her for hers. About an hour before dinnertime, she put money on the table for her drinks and asked me if I’d like to get together and do some shopping at one of the ports. I could never have too many clothes, plus I enjoyed her company, so I accepted. She promised to call me, and then walked away. I motioned Johnny over for another drink.
I awoke the next morning with the worst hangover of my life, and I’d had some hellacious hangovers before. I moaned as I rolled over, and barely made it to the trashcan by the nightstand before I threw up.
I sat on the nubby carpet beside the trash can, wiping beads of sweat from my upper lip and trying to calm my lurching stomach. At least we were in port and not sailing at the moment.
After tossing my cookies into the wastebasket, I called room service for some toast and juice, and then made a call to housekeeping to change out my trashcan.
I spent the whole day in my cabin, alternately sleeping off my drinking binge and hugging the porcelain goddess.
Stacey called later in the morning to see if I wanted to head into St. Kitts, our port for the next day, and I told her that I hoped I’d be feeling better by then. She sympathized with my plight, asking if there was anything she could do for me. The gesture was nice, but all I could do was sleep off the drink. We arranged to meet on the upper deck the next morning, and I went back to my fitful sleep.
Day five of our cruise dawned bright and beautiful, same as the first four days. St. Kitts seemed to be calling my name, carrying on the soft sea breeze the promise of adventures to come, and I dressed with a sense of anticipation. Slinging my huge mesh purse over my shoulder, I headed out to meet Stacey.
I happened to pass by the gym on my way to my rendezvous and noticed the man who’d been sitting with Stacey the other day. I assumed it was her husband. He was bench pressing an amount of weights that I couldn’t quite make out from my distance. I looked at my watch; I was running early, so I decided to go in.
He looked even better up close — sweat-soaked skin and tangy-tart body odour could be powerful aphrodisiacs.
“Hi,” I said, looking down at him. “Remember me from the pool the other day?”
He grunted and set the weights down in the grooves. Sitting up, he reached for a white towel to wipe the sweat running in rivulets down his face. “Yeah, vaguely. Blue bikini, right?”
He more than vaguely remembered me, I’d bet on it. “You got it.” I looked around. “Having fun?”
His laugh was as masculine as you could get. “Hardly. One doesn’t work out to have fun; it’s done to keep in shape. Either out of sheer vanity or for solely health reasons.”
“Which one are you?”
“I haven’t decided yet,” he answered honestly. “Sorry about my lack of manners; my name’s Jake Robinson.”
“Kelly Thomas,” I answered.
“Well, Kelly, it looks like you’re dressed for something other than working out,” he said, looking at my clothes and garish pink purse.
“I’m fixing to hit the shops in port.”
“Ah, my wife is going shopping, too.”
“You’re not going with her?”
“I wasn’t invited,” he said, a touch of something in his voice that I couldn’t quite make out. “Besides, all that touristy stuff isn’t for me. Give me a book and a nice quiet place to read any day.”
“I like to read, myself,” I said, an idea forming in the back of my brain. “Would you care to meet me after dinner tonight for a drink or two?”
His look indicated that he was on the verge of declining, so I quickly added, “I promise, it’ll just be one drink, and all I want is to talk about authors and books. You can even bring your wife along if you want.”
He thought for a moment longer, and I was on the verge of withdrawing the offer when he answered, “Make it 10 p.m. on the Luau Deck, and it’s a deal.”
I gave him a flirty smile and headed off. The day was shaping up to be pretty great indeed.
My day in port with Stacey was wonderful. I’d found out that she and I were almost the complete opposites in what we liked to wear and the colours we chose, but that only made our shopping more fun. I convinced her to buy a spaghetti-strapped evening gown in fire engine red, and she’d wheedled me into purchasing a tailored skirt with a matching A-line jacket in multi-toned browns.
We’d also had a chance to share more of ourselves. I told Stacey about my go-nowhere relationship with Michael, and how I still hadn’t decided on a major yet. Stacey started telling me about how she and Jake had come to be on vacation, and before long, she was spilling out the whole story of their romance, from the beginning. They’d met while in college and married shortly after graduation. She worked at a bank during the early years, helping to put him through law school, and then when he landed a lucrative position with an up-and-coming law firm, she quit to be the trophy wife she thought he wanted.
I sat and listened, fascinated at the wealth of emotions playing across her face and in her voice. She’d laughed afterward, an embarrassed little chuckle, and apologized for “boring me.” She said I was easy to talk to, and it just felt nice to confide in someone.
“Think nothing of it,” I replied. “I had a great time today.”
“Me, too.”
At that point, we were both foot-sore from all the walking we’d done, so we headed back to the ship.
I took a short nap, ate an early dinner in one of the quiet, rarely used restaurants, and then walked along the upper deck of the ship until the time to meet Jake.
He was handsomely decked out in a charcoal grey suit and a snow-white shirt, and our one drink quickly turned into two and three, and after that, I lost count. I didn’t think to ask where his wife was, and he didn’t volunteer. I also didn’t mention that she was the one I’d been shopping with earlier. If she’d not said anything to him, and I felt certain he would have told me if she had, then I wasn’t going to clue him in either.
We started out by talking about some authors we both liked and found some common ground. We both liked Faulkner and Shakespeare, but we did have some differences among all the likes. He liked erotica, while I preferred historical romances.
“That’s not very surprising; a man who likes to read smut,” I said with a laugh.
“No,” he answered with a shake of his head, “not smut or porn, but erotica — stories with more than just straight sex to them. I’m talking about stories where if you took the sex out, they could stand all on their own.”
“Then why put the sex in them in the first place?”
“A lot of times, the sex helps move the plot along, adds spice to a long narrative or series of adventures, and oftentimes helps illustrate the growing relationships of the characters.”
“Wow, you must have given this a lot of thought.” I was certainly impressed.
His grin was a tad bit self-conscious. “I, uh, used to write erotica for Stacey when we were dating,” he confessed.
I blinked. “You did?”
He nodded. “Yes. She used to get so turned on by it. I’d write it out on paper, then leave it in an envelope for her, either on her pillow, stuck in her backpack, or sometimes I’d send it through the post office. I could always tell when she’d found it, because there would be this impish little sparkle in her eyes and an extra, subtle vibrancy in our lovemaking that night.” He was lost in his memories for a moment, then came back to the present. “I’m sorry, this is probably all boring you.”
“No, it isn’t,” I answered, putting my hand over his and squeezing. “I think it’s sweet.” He removed his hand from underneath mine, but I didn’t say anything or try to take it again. “Do you still write stories for her?”
“No, I haven’t done that in a long time.”
“Why not? She doesn’t like them anymore?”
“I don’t know why. I guess I’ve just been busy with my job, and then I thought that she’d outgrown them.”
He shook off the momentary pallor that had gripped him and steered the conversation back to novels.
It was 3 a.m. before we knew it, and he gave a gasp of surprise when he looked at his watch. He mumbled something about Stacey waiting up for him, thanked me for a good evening, and walked quickly away.
I watched until he turned the corner and disappeared from view. Slowly, I made my way to my cabin.
I spent part of day six in town, exploring St. Maarten, and the other part of it thinking about Stacey and Jake. I knew why I was so preoccupied with Jake - I was attracted to him. Very attracted. I could also tell, just from our talk last night, how much he was still in love with his wife. Maybe if I hadn’t gotten to know Stacey, I wouldn’t have any qualms about seducing Jake, but the fact of the matter was I considered her a friend. I could tell she was hurting, and I didn’t want to add to that hurt.
I wondered what I could do to help them salvage their marriage. Then I wondered why it mattered so much to me. I’d never been one to analyze a situation; I usually just jumped in feet first and to hell with the consequences. I could see what their problem was, so why couldn’t they?
That train of thought somehow led to an examination of my own life. I was a 21-year-old college student with a string of dead-end relationships behind me. I’d changed my major three times and still didn’t know what I wanted to do with my life. I viewed the world as one huge playground, which was fine if you were four years old, but didn’t bode well for my future if I kept on that way. I knew all this before, on some level, but it’d never bothered me before.
I decided to sleep on it, and maybe an answer would come to me overnight. It was a long shot, but it couldn’t hurt.
I awoke to a knocking on my door. I padded to the door, not bothering to throw something on over my tank top and panties, and opened the door. Stacey stood there, cheeks stained with tears and a handful of tissues clutched tight.
“Oh, Kelly, I’m so sorry, but I didn’t know where else to go.”
“Come in, come in,” I said, slipping into a “mother-hen” mode I hadn’t even known I possessed. I put one arm around her shoulders and led her into the room, shutting the door behind us. I steered her toward a chair. “What happened?” I asked.
“Jake ... Jake and I had a fight. I don’t even remember what it was about now. He stormed into the bathroom and slammed the door. I can’t stay there tonight, I just can’t. Please can I spend the night here?”
“Stacey, Jake’s going to wonder where you’ve gone and be worried. I know I would be.” I held her hands in mine.
Stacey looked into my eyes and leaned forward and pressed her lips against mine, light as gossamer. I was so surprised I didn’t move at first. I got my wits about me and pulled back, a frown creasing my brow. “What was that?”
“Didn’t you like it?” Stacey asked, hesitation and a trace of worry in her voice.
“Stacey, this isn’t right,” I tried to explain.
“I’m a little bit experienced. There was this girl in college and --”
I put my fingers against her lips to silence her. “That was then, you’re married now. Do you really care so little about Jake, about the vows you made, to go through with this? Because I sure don’t.”
To my dismay, she started crying. Loud, wracking sobs and shook her whole body. I leaned forward and put my arms around her, rocking her like my mother had done to me when I was a small girl. “Shhhh, it’s okay.” I could have laughed at the irony - irresponsible, carefree Kelly Thomas being the mature one for a change.
I stayed like that until her sobs had subsided, and her breathing had become more even. She pulled back and wiped her face. “I’m sorry. I seem to have just made a mess of things.”
To read this story you need a
Registration + Premier Membership
If you have an account, then please Log In
or Register (Why register?)