My First Anal Experience - Cover

My First Anal Experience

by Kim Florentina Fox

Copyright© 2026 by Kim Florentina Fox

Erotica Sex Story: At eighteen, one daring decision turned fear and curiosity into an unforgettable first anal experience.

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa   Consensual   Heterosexual   True Story   Anal Sex   Analingus   First   .

This is a blog post written in the style of a short story. A true story—about me!

I’m not writing here about my very first time—about the first time I ever had sex. Some stories are better left where they belong: in memory, not in the middle of an erotic blog. #TooYoungAtTheTime

But my first time having anal sex? That’s a different story.

I was an adult by then. Curious. Pretty nervous. And open-minded enough to push open a door behind which I would later learn a hell of a lot about pleasure, trust, and my own body.

This story can be told. So I’m telling it.

My First Time Anal: Eighteen, Inexperienced, and Pretty Uptight

I was eighteen. Sexually inexperienced. A little uptight too. Unlike my boyfriend at the time, I was anything but adventurous. I was happy if I could somehow manage to focus on the sex at all. Because back then, that was many times harder for me than it is today. I’m not entirely sure, but I think I had experienced barely a handful of orgasms by that point.

I don’t think my boyfriend was unhappy with me. After all, we had sex often. Despite my nervousness, I was frequently aroused. That must have been down to the urges of a young woman—urges strong enough to outshine her fears and worries. But he was the one who had to put in the effort to get what he needed.

So I was the stereotypical starfish: I lay there. Ready for anything, but relatively motionless. I opened myself to his manhood but contributed little more to the whole affair than providing my tightness.

His foreplay was always fantastic. Thorough and wet. His tongue work was pure poetry, and my clitoris was grateful for it. Sometimes, I managed to work myself up to giving him a blowjob, usually terrified that he would come too soon and shoot his load into my mouth. But he was sensible enough not to do that. So I did it as often as I could bring myself to.

From Starfish to Wildcat

At some point, my caution began to shift. My shyness gradually turned into genuine interest. Slowly—veeeery slowly—I became more confident. I understood that despite the flaws I saw in my appearance, I was desirable. That I didn’t need to hide. That my small breasts and generally very slender frame were nothing to be ashamed of. And the more I allowed myself to embrace those new thoughts, the better I became.

Eventually, I transformed from a starfish into a wildcat. Instead of lying there and breathing quietly, I purred and hissed whenever the moment called for it. I moved with him and learned that other positions had their own hot appeal. I learned how to ride. How to kneel. I switched between submissive and dominant depending on my mood. Sometimes, I took control. Other times, I let myself be guided.

But enough about that.

Let’s get to the back door.

An Evening on the (german) Reeperbahn

My boyfriend and I went to the Reeperbahn. Unlike on other weekends, we weren’t there to party in the clubs. Nope. After visiting Hamburg, we simply wanted to take a relaxed stroll along the noisy strip. Grab a bite to eat and then head home. Watch something on TV and go to bed.

Plans are one thing. Reality is something completely different.

Thanks to one particularly likable promoter, we stepped inside a sex shop. It was huge and spread across two spacious floors. And wow, the things we saw in there...

Porn, lingerie, toys, fetishes, cages, gallows, crosses, masks—and yes, things people stuck up their asses. It was a world I had never encountered before. My boyfriend was absolutely thrilled. With a wink, he held anal plugs in front of my face. Showed me beads, gels, dildos with progressively larger diameters, and enemas. The gleam in his eyes told me that he would have loved to try some of those things with—and especially on—me.

But since I had absolutely no experience in that department, I immediately made it clear that none of it was going to happen.

Never ever!

The very idea of inserting something into my ass was completely incompatible with my worldview.

“Nothing goes in there. At most, things come out.”

But the most important thing was this: I didn’t want to be in pain.

He was disappointed, but he didn’t let me feel it. That was something I liked about him: no pressure, no coercion, just complete understanding.

No Means No. And Sometimes the Idea Still Lingers in Your Head.

My firm “no” had swept the thought of anal sex from his mind. We continued browsing. I even managed to convince myself to buy some new underwear that was so skimpy, the fabric was barely worth mentioning. Before long, we were sitting on the train heading toward Elbgaustraße. And while my boyfriend dozed beside me, my thoughts were racing.

For some reason I still don’t understand, I couldn’t let go of the subject of anal sex. Something tingled inside me, and I began to realize that a strange curiosity had taken root. I had no idea where it had suddenly come from. But part of me wondered what it would feel like to be pleasured through that forbidden opening. I thought and thought as the darkened houses passed outside the window.

It hurts! It isn’t normal! A penis has no business being there. And once again: IT HURTS!

And despite all those warning thoughts, I couldn’t banish the idea of ass play from my mind.

By the time we got home, I was suddenly so horny that I grabbed my boyfriend. The sex was great. Intense. But not enough. He worked hard to give me an orgasm. Fingered me, licked me fantastically, and fucked me well. But the carousel inside my head kept circling around something else.

When I felt his climax approaching, I did something that shocked him pretty badly: while riding him, I rolled off and told him to stop.

The look on his face? Pure shock.

Sweet as he was, he thought he had accidentally hurt me.

The Moment I Changed My Mind

I took a deep breath. Gathered my courage and asked whether he might ... want to play around back there after all...

He looked at me questioningly. His expression shifted between excitement and suspicion. He probably thought I was playing some nasty trick on him. Only after I assured him that I wasn’t up to anything cruel did his face brighten, and he began to glow. Something I still love about men to this day: their endless gratitude when a woman opens up her back door.

Before he could begin, however, he had to promise that he would be careful. I knew he had never had anal sex with a woman before. His experience—just like mine—was basically nonexistent.

He agreed.

What else was he going to do?

Very Slowly. Very Carefully. Completely New.

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In