The Greywater House
by WittyUserName
Copyright© 2026 by WittyUserName
Supernatural Sex Story: A pair of supernatural investigators try and figure out the rules to ghost hunting.
Caution: This Supernatural Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual Fiction Horror Paranormal Ghost .
~James Gray~
Tuesday 09 September, 2025
The Greywater House looked smaller than James remembered.
Two years ago he’d parked in almost the exact same spot. A house in the woods with a dark story had seemed like easy material at the time. Instead he’d spent three entire nights filming empty rooms and silent hallways, the creek behind the property, and one promising noise that turned out to be a raccoon digging its way inside.
It was a weathered two-story colonial-style home tucked among the trees, its attic windows dark beneath layers of grime. The front porch sagged slightly at the center, and moss crawled across the roof while one gutter hung partially detached near the right side of the house. Decades of rain and neglect had turned the once-white paint a sickly gray-yellow that peeled from the side in long curling strips.
Autumn Lennox unbuckled her seat belt beside him but didn’t open the door. She reached over and ran her fingers down his arm, drawing his attention.
“You’re staring,” she observed.
James smirked slightly. “I’m trying to decide if it looks better or worse.”
“Unless it collapses, I don’t think it CAN look worse,” Autumn wrinkled her nose.
That got a soft laugh from James because she was right. The property hadn’t been fully reclaimed by nature, but it was getting close. Tall grass crowded the narrow stone walkway leading to the porch, and weeds split through cracks in the driveway. Long tree branches stretched over the roof, while vines crept up the front and sides. Despite the deterioration, the structure remained stubbornly intact.
A rusted real estate sign leaned crooked near the driveway.
BANK OWNED PROPERTY
AUTHORIZED ACCESS ONLY
James pushed open the door of his SUV. Cool autumn air hit him immediately, carrying the scent of wet leaves and distant rain. Anticipation filled him as he dreamed of an investigation using his new knowledge. While there was so much he didn’t know, he felt he had discovered more secrets than anyone else in the field of supernatural study.
He eagerly rushed over to the lockbox before walking to the car while Autumn climbed out more slowly. She let out a soft sigh as she brushed her wavy blonde hair back behind her ears, quietly taking in the surroundings. The Hudson valley was quite large, and this was an out-of-the-way area most didn’t know about.
The Greywater House sat several miles outside the tiny hamlet of Bellmere, near the wooded edges of Fahnestock Memorial State Park. There were no nearby homes, no traffic, no signs of life beyond the narrow road they’d turned off nearly ten minutes earlier. Just trees and creek and birds. And The Greywater House.
“You ready?” James asked as Autumn approached him.
“I think so,” she nodded slowly. “I’m a little nervous.”
“We’ll be fine,” James insisted with a smile. “We’re here for three nights. Three nights to test our theories.”
James couldn’t help his excitement. Labor Day had been just over a week ago, and his brain had been going nonstop since. The Brinkerhoff Royal had changed everything. Many of his loyal followers had unsubscribed, saying he had given in to pressure and posted fake videos. Others joined when they saw the excitement in the events of that weekend. He understood the skepticism, but James knew the truth.
Ghosts existed.
Not strange noises or manipulated footage. Not wishful thinking from eager horror fans, or the adrenaline-fueled fears of someone alone in an old building. Real. For the first time in his life, James finally understood why every previous investigation had failed. Every investigator he had ever met focused on provoking spirits into responding. EVP sessions, Ouija boards, demands shouted into dark rooms. No one ever stopped to ask whether the dead were even capable of answering.
“James?” Autumn called out to get his attention.
“Hm?” he looked up while holding a thermal camera.
“This place didn’t give you anything before?” Autumn wondered as they headed for the porch.
“Not a thing.”
“And now?” she questioned, glancing at him with interest.
“Now?” James looked at the dark windows as excitement flowed through him. “Now we have a better plan than yelling at dead people.”
The front steps groaned beneath their weight as they climbed onto the porch. The house looked even worse up close. Cracks split through sections of the railing, and the door hung slightly crooked within its frame. Autumn paused beside James as he pulled a small ring of keys from his jacket pocket.
“Did you get those from the real estate agent?” she asked.
“No,” he shook his head. “They were in the lockbox. I got them while you were getting out of the car.”
“Somehow that makes this place feel less spooky,” Autumn commented.
“Haven’t had your fill of spooky, Lennox?” James smiled as he slid the key into the lock and struggled to force it to turn.
“If I had, we wouldn’t be here,” she pointed out as James shoved his shoulder against the door until it finally opened for him.
Autumn immediately wrinkled her nose. “That’s disgusting.”
“Wasn’t me,” James shrugged, gesturing for her to step inside.
“You’re gross, too,” she grumbled as she waved her hand in front of her nose in an attempt to disperse the scent of stale air.
James was still grinning as he stepped into the entry hall, causing the floor to creak loudly beneath him. A small amount of light filtered through the dirty windows, illuminating floating dust particles and strips of peeling wallpaper. Someone had draped old sheets over the furniture; the fabric was yellow and sagging in the dimness.
Nothing. James slowly turned in a circle without seeing anything strange. No movement, no voices, no impossible cold. Just an old house. That excited him more. It was a chance to experiment. To see if they could truly replicate the results of that luxury hotel. Autumn entered behind him, her boots thumping softly against the hardwood floor as she closed the door.
“What did the previous owners report?” Autumn inquired.
“Strange noises, shadows, hearing a woman crying,” James counted on his fingers. “A few other things over the years. Someone claimed to see a woman appear and disappear.”
“Any chance that woman paid the power bill?” Autumn asked.
“No, but the lights work. We have to flip the breaker in the basement,” James answered. “The bank keeps up with basic maintenance for showings and so the place doesn’t actually collapse. The water’s shut off, though.”
“I’m surprised a house built in 1884 has pipes,” she commented, crossing her arms. “And electricity.”
“Renovations,” he answered quickly. “I think they added electricity in the forties. Same time they added a small bathroom. But don’t worry, there’s an outhouse out back if you need to do the thing ladies claim they don’t do.”
“We’ve known each other a week,” Autumn reminded him. “You got familiar fast.”
“Because we got familiar fast,” James waggled his eyebrows while scanning the room for entry points and electrical outlets.
“I’ll use the trailer bathroom,” she rolled her eyes.
“And I will run downstairs and turn the power on,” James said. “Remember to wash your hands.”
“I didn’t mean now!” she called after him.
Using the light from his phone, he ran down to the basement before returning to the parlor. James crossed toward the wall switch and flicked it upward. For a few moments, nothing happened. Then the overhead light sputtered weakly to life, turning on and off again a few times before finally maintaining a semi-constant illumination. The yellow glow barely reached the corners of the room.
“Comforting,” Autumn sighed.
“It’s atmospheric!” James reasoned.
“It’s tetanus with electricity,” she grumbled.
“We aren’t all rich enough to buy hotels, Lennox,” he laughed lightly.
“Hey, you have a home now that isn’t your brother’s place. You’re welcome, sugar baby,” she grinned proudly. “By the way, the bank doesn’t expect us to buy this place, do they?”
“They’re probably hoping,” James winced. “At this point, I could probably pick it up for forty bucks.”
“You’d be getting ripped off,” Autumn muttered under her breath.
They moved deeper into the house, James already mentally mapping equipment placement. One camera in the parlor, another in the basement. He wanted thermal upstairs and an audio recorder in the attic. Definitely a camera in the master bedroom upstairs.
“So what exactly are we trying first?” Autumn asked from across the room.
“Observation tonight,” he answered while checking one of his cameras. “No forcing anything yet.”
“Yet?”
“At Brinkerhoff, they weren’t just popping up randomly,” James said while adjusting a tripod. “They were pulling from you.”
“Right,” Autumn nodded in understanding. “And we think spirits need to pull from someone to manifest.”
“We do,” he agreed. “And sometimes that manifestation drains them? Knocks them out? Uh, can ghosts pass out?”
“I don’t know, I’ve never been dead,” she rolled her eyes.
“Anyway, a haunting happens and people get scared,” James stated. “Then someone like me comes along and finds nothing because the ghosts hadn’t regained their strength? Or hadn’t woken up?”
“Or you went somewhere there haven’t been any people in decades,” Autumn added.
“Just like this place,” he confirmed, pulling out his phone. “Let’s head back outside. We need an introductory stream before we set things up.”
“Okay,” she agreed, following him outside.
James shut the door and started the livestream while aiming the phone at himself and getting the door in the background.
“Hello, hello! And welcome to another episode of Gray’s Hauntings and Mysteries!” James declared, smiling at the phone’s camera. “Oh wow, a lot of you in here already. Are you excited?”
James glanced at the comments before continuing. “I’m your host, James Gray. Tonight should be a weird one. I hope. For the first time ever, I will be tackling a site for the second time!
“That’s right, a repeat visit. Where, you ask? Why the very famous Greywater House located just outside of Bellmere, New York!” James exclaimed. “Barely a stone’s throw away from the legendary Cold Spring where we captured footage some of you are still arguing about online.”
He sighed when looking at the comments. “Yeah, yeah, I know some of you are already spamming ‘fake’ in the chat. Feel free to watch reality TV then.”
Autumn laughed softly at the last comment.
James turned the phone’s camera to show the tall blonde. “And you all remember my lovely assistant-”
“Partner,” Autumn interjected immediately.
“Right, partner. My lovely partner, Autumn,” James said before putting the camera back on himself. “We’re going to spend a few days testing our new theories on the paranormal.
“Now, first we’re going to take you on a little tour of the house. Then we’ll log off and set up our usual cameras. This is a more remote area of the Hudson Valley than Cold Spring, so you all know how this works,” James said to the viewers. “That’s right! The cameras will be continuously streaming, but the signal won’t always be great. Thank the streaming overlords for portable hotspots and signal boosting antennas.
“Anyway, without further ado, let’s get this tour started!”
James went inside, the light from his phone showing the way. They started in the entry room, where he went over the year the house was built and a bit about the renovations. Then they continued on to the parlor before covering the dining room and kitchen. Autumn opened the back door so James could give everyone a quick look at the small creek at the edge of the property.
After showing the small bathroom, James and Autumn returned to the parlor for a more in-depth talk with the viewers.
“Very funny guys, very funny,” James gave a fake laugh while shaking his head. “For the last time, no, Autumn is not here to babysit me.”
“You should have heard the jokes he was telling before we were recording,” Autumn smirked. “They were too immature for a ten-year-old boy.”
“That’s ... okay, that’s partially true,” he admitted. “But!” James held a finger up. “We’re not here to talk about my sense of humor or my rugged good looks. Tell us, Autumn; just what’s up with The Greywater House?”
“Well, during our research we found out that the Greywater family used to own all the land in the area,” Autumn began. “This house was built in 1884 by the Greywaters for their daughter, Eliza Greywater. She had fallen in love with a local man who took her last name, which was much more prominent. The guy taking the woman’s name? Now THAT’S progressive for the nineteenth century!”
James looked at the comments and winced. “Some of the comments in here aren’t very progressive. Yes folks, Autumn is very pretty, but there’s other sites for the kind of content you’re angling for.”
“Ew,” Autumn made a face as she removed the sheet covering a faded loveseat. “For you normal people watching; what we just told you is most of the verifiable information. What we could find was sparse and often littered with speculation.”
Continuing with facts,” James interjected, “there have been a few owners throughout the years, including the family who added the electricity and bathroom. They always moved out. Others would stay in the house as a dare and leave in terror.”
“Which raises the question: what happened to Eliza Greywater?” Autumn asked.
“Depends on which version of the story you find!” James exclaimed passionately before sighing. “Yes, I’m James Gray investigating The Greywater House. Ha. Ha. Ha. Moving on.”
“Greywater Creek is out back,” Autumn gestured with her thumb. “And we are here to see if we can make contact with the spirit of Eliza Greywater, for it is supposedly her who haunts this house.”
“Some stories say she hanged herself from the rafters in the attic,” James shook his head sadly. “Others suggest she drowned herself in the creek. I even found one story saying she went on a murder spree before being killed in a struggle with law enforcement.”
“Yeah, that one’s made up, I’m sure,” Autumn took over. “What’s true is that Eliza is often called The Greywater Widow. She lived here for decades after her husband died. Alone. Her entire family gone. They do say she disappeared from public view.”
“Possibly as a serial killer. This guy’s got a point,” James pointed at his phone. “Quiet. Lived alone. No family. Throw in wets the bed and you’ve got a serial killer.”
“I don’t think that’s how it works,” she scoffed.
“Nah, that’s definitely how it works,” he grinned and gave the camera a thumbs-up.
Autumn and James took a quick walk down to the damp basement, which was mostly-empty. Then they went up to the second floor. The small study still had a desk, which was also covered with a sheet. Eliza’s bed was still in the master bedroom, and there was furniture in the guest bedroom. If it weren’t for the dust and disrepair, it would almost seem like the house was still occupied.
“The attic!” Autumn exclaimed, looking extra excited for the camera. “This is where Eliza supposedly spent most of her time after her husband’s death.”
“This young lady in the chat has a point!” James suddenly spoke up. “How do we know where she spent her time if she was a loner with no family or friends?”
“Good question!” she grinned, pointing toward the window. “That window. Kids would come down to the creek and see The Greywater Widow looking out of the attic window.”
“See? We do our research!” James stuck out his tongue at the camera, but froze as the lights flickered. “Oh! You might have just upset Eliza by implying her story isn’t true.”
“Or it’s an old house with barely-working electricity,” Autumn smirked.
James shot her an exaggerated glare for the benefit of the camera. “Anyway, that’s all for now folks. We’re gonna set up the cameras and start them streaming as soon as possible, so please keep a look out for that. Thanks for watching Gray’s Hauntings and Mysteries!”
The livestream ended and James slipped his phone back into his pocket. Autumn remained standing near the attic window, gazing out over the grounds and the flowing creek. Fading evening light filtered through the dirty glass, casting shadows across the dusty floorboards.
“Well,” Autumn smiled softly, “that went well.”
“Yeah, only about fifty people called me a fraud,” he sighed.
“They’re wrong, James,” she said seriously. “And with how far technology is from, some people won’t ever stop. Even if we find proof of a thousand hauntings.”
“Great pep talk, Lennox,” James chuckled.
“I’m just saying; don’t let the skeptics get you down,” Autumn explained. “After all, you were a skeptic until about a week ago.”
With a nod of agreement, James accompanied Autumn downstairs. The noises the old house constantly made were much more audible once they’d stopped talking. Pipes knocked faintly in the walls, the house creaked and groaned, and wind brushed tree branches against the siding with uneven scratching sounds.
James loved every second of it. Autumn seemed nervous but excited.
They worked for the next couple hours setting up equipment throughout the house. James mounted static cameras in the parlor, master bedroom, upstairs hallway, attic, and basement. Autumn helped run extension cords and backup batteries through the old rooms. Keeping the cameras powered shouldn’t be an issue; keeping them connected to the internet was another matter entirely.
By the time darkness fully settled outside, The Greywater House no longer seemed abandoned. Tiny red recording lights shone from corners and tripods throughout the room while cables stretched along the baseboards. Portable battery packs rested near the walls beside backup audio recorders.
James checked the tablet in his hands to make sure everything was working. Night vision, full audio, motion sensors. He had also used the old strategy of placing baby powder down the hallway to pick up footprints. All the windows were confirmed closed, and the five camera feeds were all functioning.
Mostly.
“The basement feed froze again,” he noted while Autumn walked by with another equipment case.
“Think it’s Eliza?” she asked eagerly.
“Unless she’s somehow your long-lost great aunt, no,” James chuckled. “I think it’s the stone foundation, thick walls, trees everywhere, and the fact that we’re in the middle of nowhere.”
“Convenient excuse if something weird happens,” Autumn commented.
“That hurts coming from you.”
Autumn smirked faintly before setting the case down near the love seat. They’d stopped in Bellmere before arriving and grabbed sandwiches and sodas for dinner. The other supplies they’d bought at the grocery store were in a cooler and a couple of bags that had been placed in the back of the SUV.
“It was easy for you to be believable as honest when you caught nothing extraordinary,” she reasoned. “You caught something extraordinary.”
“Why are you so smart?” he asked with feigned annoyance.
“I am?” she arched an eyebrow as she sat on the love seat. “I got my MBA at nineteen and am one of the biggest names in consulting. Last week I bought a haunted hotel and I’m currently in the middle of nowhere with a guy I really don’t know.”
“Hey, those are all sound business decisions,” James chuckled, sitting down beside her. “Well, other than being alone with a strange guy.”
“It’s okay, he’s a sweetheart,” Autumn sighed happily, resting her hand on his thigh. “He helped me when I was scared. He took me seriously when I thought I was going crazy.”
“I’m not completely convinced we aren’t having some sort of shared delusion,” he admitted as he wrapped an arm around her shoulders. “What we saw ... uh, hopefully the inspectors don’t see something similar.”
“I think we’ll be okay,” she laughed. “It’s only three days. Three days for the full inspection. Then the hotel is ours.”
“Ours? No,” James shook his head. “It’s yours. It’s your money and your ancestor.”
“And you’re my roommate? Or my sugar baby?” Autumn giggled.
“Well, I’m happy to earn my keep,” he husked, squeezing her upper arm.
“Down boy,” she shook her head before glancing upward.
“Why do you keep looking up?” James wondered.
“The attic is ... I don’t know? Strange?” Autumn offered.
“Because of the hanging story?”
“No,” Autumn sighed. “It feels ... occupied.”
“I’ve had feelings like that before,” James replied slowly. “It was always nothing.”
“Or maybe it was something,” she reasoned. “You just didn’t know how to take the next step.”
“Possibly,” he mused, glancing around. “I think we’re set up. Ready to head back to the trailer?”
“Well, I’m not sleeping in here,” Autumn crossed her arms and smirked. “With the mold we saw, we should probably be wearing masks.”
James chuckled. “Let’s go, princess.”
The Greywater House loomed beyond the trailer windows, the moonlight slipping through the tree branches to illuminate a few sections. Most of the structure was in shadows, but James and Autumn both noticed they had a clear view of the attic window. Silver light reflected faintly off the dirty, cracked glass.
With the trailer door shut, warm air had replaced the chill of the September night. Compared to the house, the interior was almost luxurious. The compact camper had been lived in for long stretches at a time. Camera cases were stacked beneath the small table near the kitchenette while charging cables snaked across nearly every surface. Portable battery packs, thermal cameras, audio equipment; everything a traveling ghost hunter needed.
A narrow bed occupied the rear of the trailer beside overhead storage cabinets. James noticed Autumn looking at the travel stickers from locations where James had done investigations over the years. Salem. Jerome. Savannah. New Orleans. All places that had produced nothing.
“You really live like this?” Autumn asked quietly while setting her overnight bag on the table.
“Pretty much,” James answered with a nod.
“That’s both cool and concerning,” she continued looking around.
“I prefer to be thought of as mysterious,” he said proudly.
“That work to convince the ladies to come back here?” Autumn smirked.
“Not usually,” James admitted. “Then if it does work, they’ll see the recording equipment and get the wrong idea.”
Autumn laughed lightly as she removed her jacket and sat down “I’m glad you don’t make that kind of content.”
James grabbed two bottles of water from the tiny refrigerator and handed one to her. “I hope my humble home meets your standards.”
“I’m not nearly as high maintenance as you seem to think I am,” she giggled, accepting the water. “This place is clean and safe. It’s perfect. I don’t think it makes me spoiled for not wanting tetanus or whatever else is lurking in that house.”
“I just like teasing you,” he smiled, sitting down across from her. “You did buy a haunted hotel with cash.”
“Perks of family money,” Autumn shrugged, her blue eyes sparkling.
James grinned faintly while opening the tablet connected to the camera feeds inside the house. The five screens appeared almost instantly. Upstairs hallway. Master bedroom. Parlor. Attic. Basement. The attic feed flickered once before immediately stabilizing. With a small smile, James went to check comments on the videos, confirming they were streaming properly.
Sounds of the wilderness could be heard inside, reminding them both where they were. Wind rustled softly through the trees surrounding the trailer while the bubbling creek behind the property was just barely audible. James leaned back while staring at the feeds. Nothing moved inside the house. No footsteps or shadows, no windows opening or things falling down. Not even a raccoon digging its way inside.
“You really think we can figure this out?” Autumn asked quietly.
“What do you mean?” he looked up from the tablet.
“The rules,” she clarified. “How any of this works.”
James considered the question. A week ago he was confident that any haunting was a complete hoax. He had been trying to find a way out of this line of work. Then he met Autumn and they both saw things he never thought possible. Life got weird fast.
“Something happened at Brinkerhoff,” he said firmly. “Something real. And if it happened once, it can happen again.”
“I’m not related to The Greywater Widow,” Autumn reminded him.
“True, but that can’t be the only way they become strong enough to manifest,” James reasoned. “We think they gather energy from all the living, just faster when there’s a connection. There has to be a method to form one. There just has to be.”
“It feels different than the hotel,” she admitted.
“How?”
“The hotel felt crowded,” Autumn said slowly. “Emotions everywhere, growing for decades. This place feels ... lonely.”
“I guess we’ll just have to keep experimenting until we find the answers,” James reasoned.
“We’ll see,” Autumn said, standing up.
The tall blonde briefly disappeared into the tiny bathroom to change. She returned in a large t-shirt and a pair of cotton pajama pants. James had converted the table into a second sleeping area so Autumn could use his bed. He had already changed into lounge pants and climbed onto the table.
“You didn’t have to do that,” she whispered.
“I’m a gentleman.”
“I stopped counting after six inappropriate jokes, including one about my boobs,” Autumn pointed out, hands on her hips. “You then giggled at the word ‘boobs.’”
“In my defense, they take up a lot of space,” he grinned.
“They did get squished in that tiny bathroom while I was trying to change,” she admitted with a small smile.
“Seriously, though,” James chuckled. “We haven’t been together long. We sleep in separate rooms at the hotel. This is new, it’s reasonable to not share a bed all the time.”
Autumn rolled her eyes, smiling in spite of herself. She then got into the bed and pulled the blanket over her. James shut off the lights to conserve power, leaving only the faint glow of the tablet to illuminate the interior.
Inside The Greywater House, all five camera feeds showed absolutely nothing as midnight passed.
At 2:13AM, the attic camera briefly flickered to static.
Then it returned.
~Autumn Lennox~
Wednesday 10 September, 2025
Autumn woke to the sound of a strong wind gusting through tree branches. She was disoriented for several seconds as she stared at the low ceiling of the trailer. Morning light slipped through the blinds, illuminating the cramped interior. She remembered. The Greywater House. The investigation. Ghosts.
The last thought sounded ridiculous even in the privacy of her own mind. Autumn believed in numbers, contracts, and things that could be proven. Ghosts did not belong anywhere in the carefully organized version of reality she had built for herself since childhood. Not even her parents’ deaths had changed anything. Then Brinkerhoff happened.
Slowly pushing herself upright, Autumn was careful not to bump her head. The scent of fresh coffee filled her nose as she ran a hand through her blonde hair. James was sitting at the table wearing a dark sweatshirt and lounge pants while staring intently at his tablet. Two cups of coffee sat beside him along with a notebook.
“Did you sleep?” she asked groggily.
“Yeah, I’ve only been up for a few minutes,” he answered, not looking up from the tablet. “The attic feed cut out again overnight.”
“Oh?” Autumn questioned. “Anything else happen?”
“No,” James glanced toward her. “A few seconds of static and nothing else.”
Stifling a yawn, Autumn carefully got out of bed and sat down across from James. She accepted the mug he slid toward her before looking out the trailer windows. Morning fog drifted between the trees, while The Greywater House stood silent beyond them. To Autumn, it looked more sad and lonely than frightening.
James handed the tablet to Autumn so she could watch the footage. Empty hallways. Silent rooms. Nothing moving. At 2:13AM, the attic feed dissolved briefly into static before returning. There was no strange figure, no sound, no visible disturbance.
“That could be anything,” she said, handing the tablet back. “Didn’t that happen last time you were here?”
“Yeah,” he nodded slowly. “It mainly happened in the basement, though. The stone foundation. This time? Everything is perfect except for those brief moments of static.”
“You’ve investigated hundreds of supposed hauntings,” Autumn mused. “You never found anything, not until Brinkerhoff. We haven’t done any experiments yet, so I’m not surprised there’s nothing.”
“You’re right,” he agreed. “The static’s probably nothing. So how do we start?”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.