Peggy Sue Hunts Down a Prom Date!
by Urtles53
Copyright© 2026 by Urtles53
Erotica Sex Story: Peggy Sue proves a cock slut beats a cheerleader every time!
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Teenagers Consensual Heterosexual Fiction Oral Sex .
Several guys had asked Peggy Sue to her high school senior prom, but she had her eyes on bigger game. Craig McAdams was the football quarterback, the cutest guy in the class, and all-around BMOC. The only roadblock was Janie Stevens. She was beautiful, the head cheerleader, and had been wearing Craig’s letterman jacket all senior year. But Peggy Sue had a few weapons in this battle that Janie didn’t. This was the class of 1957, and Janie was a good, chaste, wholesome fifties’ girl. Peggy Sue wasn’t.
Peggy Sue was also 19, as she had flunked a grade in elementary school, so she was a year older than the majority of her peers in her senior class. It wasn’t because she was stupid either. She just didn’t care about school and was bored. She had been ‘boy crazy’, as they used to say back in the day, ever since jr. high. It was her incestuous and horny Uncle Gil who took her virginity shortly after her eighteenth birthday and taught Peggy Sue what the birds and bees were all about. Peggy Sue found out that she loved sex and pleasing men and went on in that next year, having many sexual adventures with husbands in her neighborhood, a few high school boys in her class, an art teacher at her school, getting gang banged at a church retreat, and even had a lesbian encounter with a fellow student! Peggy Sue was the bad girl all mamas warned their sons about. She considered Craig McAdams easy pickings with her skill set. Peggy Sue only had one month before the prom, and she needed to set the snare quickly!
Peggy Sue knew there were two constants to this equation. One, nothing is hornier than an eighteen-year-old high school boy, and two, nothing can be more jealous than an eighteen-year-old high school girl. Luckily, Peggy Sue had a couple of variables on her side, also. She had both Craig and Janie in her American Government class, and her locker was next to Craig’s. Peggy Sue’s reputation had spread throughout the school that she was a ‘loose girl,’ and she dressed the part, at least by 1950s standards. This was before the days of every high school girl looking like a Sunset Strip hooker. Now to divide and conquer.
Peggy Sue began the campaign in her class with Craig and Janie. Dropping pencils to give Craig a peek of cleavage, timed leg crosses for a panty shot, sultry and sexy glances, and smiles. It continued after class by the lockers they shared with laughing, talking, and provocative poses and innuendos. Craig was getting smitten for sure, and Janie was getting pissed. Peggy Sue put it into high gear when she asked Craig if he could give her a ride home after school. The rumors had already spread about Peggy Sue and Craig. Janie was furious now. Then Janie showed up at school without Craig’s letterman’s jacket. The first battle in the war had been won. Now to claim victory.
“Do you have a date for the prom?” Craig asked a little nervously when he bumped into Peggy Sue at their lockers a couple of days later. “Looks like mine fell through.”
Peggy Sue thought this was almost too easy! The war had already been won! Now to go in for the final kill.
“I sure do. You!” Peggy Sue said with a wink. “I can assure you I will be way more fun than Janie on prom night! And please don’t rent a limo, take me in your car. That might work out better after the prom. Get prepared to have the time of your life!” Peggy Sue could almost hear the blood rushing to Craig’s cock.
The night had come, and Peggy Sue did one last mirror check as she heard the doorbell ring. She looked beautiful and hotter than Hell. Janie didn’t stand a chance. Her dad answered the door as a traditional nod to her being a good, moral, respectful suburban daughter. In his heart, he knew his daughter was a natural-born slut. After all, her mother was too. He had even gotten a few boners fantasizing about banging his very own daughter. Craig’s eyes lit up, and a smile crossed his lips when he first beheld Peggy Sue in all her sexy glory. The sexual tension in the air was electric.
Off they went in Craig’s dad’s brand new, white ‘57 Caddy! He was a rich kid from the other side of the tracks for sure. Peggy Sue checked out the spacious back seat for future reference. It was the bridal suite of back seats and way above the ones she was used to having sex on with her history of low-life boyfriends in old hot rod beaters. Peggy Sue was moving on up!
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.