Chapter 5

Eventually we got everyone back to the house and most of the girls were impressed by the size of our house and the implied economic status we had. Everyone was shown the basement, and packs and such were dropped into piles. I passed out pencils and note paper and asked everyone to write down their favorite pizza. This was much quieter than asking and I could make a better order this way. As the evening wore on I did my best to keep some distance from them all but it didn’t work for shit. When I moved to get out of the way of one I ended up bouncing off another. I was rubbed against so many times I was feeling like a scratching post in a room full of affectionate cats.

My wife actually did get in the way as the girls tried to behave when she was close by, but they did a great job of keeping her out of the room and away from me. When we were together all she could do was grin at me. She had caught more than a few of the girls in their little game and she actually loved it.

I got her aside while the girls were engrossed in the latest vampire love story and asked her how things were going. “Well Mike I am very proud of the way you have been able to hold them off as long and as well as you have.” She said with a bit of sarcasm. “Mike you have been great father tonight. To all of these girls you have been great. The thing is most of these girls don’t have dads or brothers at home so they are overloaded with horny and you are in their sights.” She smiled at me. “From what I’ve been able to overhear you could have your choice of girls to warm your bed tonight. Hell if you wanted you could go downstairs and they would stand in line buck naked to take turns.” She hugged me and smiled up at me. “The thing is I know that there is very little chance of that and I feel kind of bad for them. They are all so in need of love and there isn’t anyone to give them the kind of attention they need.”

“Well I guess maybe I can be a little less standoffish tonight. I really do feel for these girls but I already have gone as far as I think I should. Plus I don’t know if I can trust them with the kind of trust we have in Savannah and Alize.” Leah just tightened the hug and nodded. Later that night I went down to the basement and the girls went a little crazy. I grabbed Anna and Katie and sat on the couch. Eventually they all quieted down and I could see who was where. I looked around and noticed that the little shy girl was farthest away from me while Alize and Savannah were sitting with her. I whispered to Anna who she was and found out her name was Bethany.

I asked her if they would be ok if she took a seat in my lap and she smiled at me with an incredible amount of love in her eye. She hopped up and grabbed a soda, on her way back she whispered in Bethany’s ear and they both came over. Anna sat down and Bethany looked around for somewhere to sit. I smiled at her and Anna patted my leg. The young girls looked at me and then Anna. I patted my leg and she sat down on my leg with great gentleness.

Eventually I pulled her against me and she relaxed enough to just sit there and relax. We watched a movie as a group but I could feel the eyes of the others looking up at Bethany in jealousy. During the next movie Anna and Katie changed seats with two other girls and thing were better. Bethany started to get up but I held her hip and she snuggled back against me. It seemed she had lost her fear of making me mad or taking advantage of the evening. I liked the feeling of her there. I could feel the need she had of contact and as she sat on me I stroked her back now and then. Not to say the others didn’t get some kind of physical contact but they didn’t try to take advantage of the closeness either.

Then it happened. The one thing I was afraid of happened and I couldn’t stop it from happening. We were watching another girly movie and I got so bored I fell asleep. I have no idea how long I was out but when I did wake up I found my lap was empty of Bethany and I when I looked around all I saw were looks of innocence, a sure sign of guilt in young girls. I was about to get up but my erection made it difficult to do so without looking like a compass. My embarrassment helped to make it go away. When it was gone I headed upstairs and found my wife relaxed on the living room couch. I sat down with her and she smiled at me. “Let me guess you fell asleep didn’t you.” I nodded my head.

Leah just giggled. “I figured that had happened. Things got real quiet down there about half an hour ago. I was about to go down there when Anna and Savannah came up to keep me company.” “I was kind of hoping you were going to do something to keep that from happening.” She just smiled. “Sorry but I am kind of on the girls side on this. The girls came up and told me what was going to happen as I was about to head down. but they begged me to let it happen. They figured that if you woke up it would end and if you didn’t or if you played like you were sleeping then no one would be hurt.”

I was about to complain and she stopped me. “All they did was to unzip your pants and pull out your cock. When it got hard they all freaked out except for one who stroked you a few times and then they got so scared something would happen and they put everything back where it was.” She scooted over to me and gave my cock a few rubs. “Right now I have two spies down there listening to what the rest of them are saying about that little exposure.” I took my failure to stay awake as a sign to hit the sack. I kissed Leah good night and told her to behave and if she couldn’t behave don’t get caught. She laughed at me and I went to bed and crashed. I did wake up once when someone came to my bed and moved around a bit but that was it. When I woke up I was alone but the bed was a mess. Maybe Leah had a little company back here after all.

I went into the living room and found Leah still asleep on the couch. If she was out here then who the hell was in my bed last night. I looked around and found everyone was still out cold so I went back into the bedroom and look for any clues. Under the blankets I found a few blonde and brown hairs. That could have been most of the class. The same went for the pillow. I took a chance and I could actually smell pussy on the mattress. Looks like someone wiped off wet fingers here and there. Then I made the big discovery, a thong of very small size and been lost for me to find, the crotch of which was very crisp from being soaked through.

I left them there so whoever lost them could come back and get them, but I did sniff them and even sucked them a bit for a taste. Then I had to head into my bathroom for a quick jerk off to get the whole thing out of my system. Then I had an idea. I got back into bed and relaxed. Maybe just maybe someone would be in and I could find out who had such a damp little pussy. I nodded off a little but when the door opened I cracked my eyes. Creeping across the room was little Bethany. She didn’t take her eyes off of me as she crept across the room. When she found her panties she slipped them on but got a look on her face when they nestled against her little pussy. I guess she wasn’t expecting them to be damp still. She rubbed them and then sniffed but I can tell you there wasn’t anything for her to smell left.

She looked at me with a smile on her face and blew me a little kiss and left forgetting to close the door behind her. When I heard more noise coming from the rest of the house I got out of bed and head back into the living room. My wife was awake and herding the girls into eating and then going and getting ready for any parents that were doing morning pickups. Bethany was eating a waffle and was lost in thought. I looked at her and smiled and she turned three shades of red. I grabbed a plate, filled it, and then sat down next to Bethany. I pretended to not notice a thing while eating. I chatted with her about things like asking if she had fun, did she sleep well, did she enjoy all the shows last night.

Being shy she mostly made polite noises about it all but I could tell that many times she was thinking about whatever happened last night. Then I dropped a little bomb to see what happened. “I was up early but everyone was still asleep so I went back to bed. I was ok when I first got up but when I went back to bed I really wanted to nibble on something sweet.” She blushed to the roots of her brown hair and made an excuse that she had to go get ready to be picked up. One by one the girls were picked up. Everyone seemed to be happy and to have had a good time. Then things got a little strange around noon when Bethany’s parents had still not shown up. She tried to act like things were alright but I could tell it depressed her to have been forgotten like this. We did our best to make her feel at home but she was still feeling forgotten.

I called her mother’s number and it was sent to voice mail. I then called her stepdad and eventually got ahold of him. He said things got a little out of hand last night and they wouldn’t be able to pick Bethany up till maybe tomorrow. I asked what went wrong and he told me that her mom had been arrested and that he was busy getting her out. He asked if we could keep “the kid” for another day or so. I told him that it would be fine. I talked to Leah about it all and she got a little pissed at the disregard shown for Bethany but was cool with her staying. I talked to Bethany and said that her parents were held up and had asked if we could take care of you for a while. The little girl tried to hide her sadness and even thanked us for taking her in. She went on to tell me that she would do her best while she was with us.

I took her hand in mine and got her attention. “Bethany, you are not a burden to us here. I for one am glad to have you here. You are a very sweet girl and I have really enjoyed having you with us.” She blushed but she was still down. I pulled her to me and gave her a long hug. Eventually her arms shyly came around me but when I still didn’t let go she held on even harder. Before I knew it she was crying against me and I let her get it out. Leah came in to see what was going on and when she saw us she smiled and went away. A few minutes later I saw two matching pairs of eyes peeking in and then slip away. I picked the crying thing up and pulled her into my lap. I rocked her in my arms and stroked her back. I did my best to treat her just like one of the twins.

I was still rocking her when I discovered she was asleep and clutching at my shirt. I lifted her up and went to the bedroom and stretched out with her. I tried to get up but she pulled on me tightly, so I stayed with her. I looked at the bedroom door and saw Leah there. She smiled at me and pulled the door shut, but as she did she looked me in the eyes and nodded once. I pulled her to me and enjoyed the feeling of a young girl in my arms. I had dozed off a little when she woke up and looked at me. I decided to keep still and wait to see what she did. She just lay there looking at me when she stretched up and gave me a gentle little kiss on the lips. Then she put her head against my chest and nuzzled me. It broke my heart to see such a sweet girl stealing affection that she so badly needed.

I looked down and she seemed startled that I was awake. “I’m sorry I cried on you like that.” I lifted her chin and gave her a small kiss on the lips. “There is nothing wrong with crying sweetie. The only thing wrong is that something made you cry like that in the first place.” She smiled at me and I could see the tears in her eyes. “You are a sweet young woman and I want you to know I am here for you.” She sniffled a bit. “Before you say I am so sweet I need to tell you something. Last night I came in here and kind of played with your penis while I played with myself.” I could tell she was embarrassed by telling me this.

I lifted her chin so I could look her in the eye. “I knew you had been in my room last night. I saw you come in this morning to get you panties.” Her eye grew large. “And if we are admitting to doing things, I should tell you that I found your panties when I first woke up and I sucked them clean.” This made her eyes get even larger if possible. “That’s why they were wet when you put them on this morning.” She ducked her head back down but I did see her blushing at the thought. I held her tight and she squeezed me back. I decided to take a leap of faith with this girl. “Why did you want to play with my penis Bethany?” she mumbled. “I can’t tell you.” That told me much of what I was thinking. “I don’t think it was the first one you have seen is it?” She sat for a while and then shook her head.

“You were curious to see if they all looked the same didn’t you?” first a wait and then a nod. “Does he make you do things or are you doing it because you want to?” A muffled reply of “He made me do it the first few times but now I do things because it makes me feel grown up.”. I was torn at this point. “So you don’t do it because you like to, or because you love him?” She shook her head. “So you don’t love him. Does he love you?” She shook her head. She looked at me with fearful eyes. “Are you mad at me?” “Of course not little love. You are a sweet girl who has been taught things that many girls your age don’t really know about. I know a lot of them talk like they do but they don’t really.” She seemed confused. “Girls say these things to sound all grown up. They want other girls to look up to them.”

She looked at me and got a look on her face that told me she was thinking about some of the things she had heard and comparing them to things she had seen or done. As the thoughts went on the truth of what I said became more apparent. “You’re right, they do lie a lot. I wonder if he’s been telling me lies too.” Ok, thin ice time. “Bethany, I have to tell you that just talking like this with you could get me in very big trouble. Grownups aren’t supposed to talk to other people’s children like this without the parents agreeing to it. Can you keep this a secret?” Bethany gave me a look that said it all. “You really do care about me Mike. I know that now. I would never do anything that would get you in any trouble.” I nodded. “Then I need to know what’s going on between your stepfather and you, and I mean everything. I want to know the whole story.”

Bethany’s Story. “Two years ago, after I turned twelve, my mom got married. I didn’t like him but she was goofy in love. He took her out a lot, they drink a lot, and I have seen other men come out of their bedroom in the morning a few times. I didn’t understand it then but when I talked about it to a friend of mine she told me what was going on.”

“Then after about a year mom was at work and I was home sick. He came into my room and started talking to me about how he and mom needed me to be a big girl. He told me that she needed to be able to be a woman and that being a mother to a little girl made that hard to do. I asked him how to be a big girl and he showed me.”

“At first he made me rub his penis till he squirted. Then after a while he started making me suck it. He told me that if I swallowed his juice it would make me a big girl. This lasted a long time and then about six months ago she put his penis inside of me. It hurt real bad and it still doesn’t feel good.”

“Then I saw the way you treat Anna and Katie. I started to feel bad that maybe there was something wrong with me. I try to make him feel and act like that with me but he says that big girls don’t need to treated like little girls. Last night I saw that you treated all the girls like that, even the older girls.”

Tears were falling down the little girl’s cheeks. “The way you held me in your lap made me feel right. I don’t want to be a big girl anymore. I want to be a little girl and have someone hold me and cuddle me. I want it to feel good when someone touches me.”

I held her tight so she would feel the love I was feeling for her. “Tell me about your mother. Do you think she knows what is going on with him?” I realized I still didn’t know the bastards name. “Mom loves me but sometimes I don’t know. I think that’s once or twice she might have seen us. I know he doesn’t do anything when she is in the room but there have been a few times when she was in the house.”

I thought about how to say what I was going to say next. “Does she ever tell him no? I mean about things that he might get upset about?” “Oh no, she told me that if it wasn’t for him she wouldn’t be happy. I know she does things she never would have before just because he tells her to.” Great that meant he had control over her mother, she was a submissive that placed her Dom over even her own child. Part of me wanted to turn them in to the cops but her love of her mother stopped me. “Bethany, there are things that can be done about this. I can tell the police about all this if you want me to. I can say that you acted odd or something and they will get you out of this whole thing.”

The sight of her face told me that was the last thing she wanted. “Please don’t. I love my mom and they would put me in a home and she would go to jail and maybe die.” Ok that way was a no go. “Ok I need to ask if you could leave and move to a different family without your mother being arrested would that help?” She looked at me hopefully. “Is there any way to just him go away?” I shook my head. “No sweetie I don’t think so. In a strange way he kind of owns your mom. That may change someday but it might not.”

She was lost in thought. “Bethany, you don’t have to make up your mind right now. Think it over but don’t tell anyone else what we have talked about ok?” “You mean it’s a secret between you and me?” “No, I may have to talk to others like my wife about it but I promise no one will be told that will get your mom in any trouble.” She nodded. We hugged like that for a long time. Leah came and got us for dinner and the girl hardly left my side. That night after all the girls were down I talked to Leah about what I had heard. “Wow Mike that’s a lot to take in. I mean if she wasn’t so afraid for her mother I would turn them in faster than you can snap your fingers. But the little thing loves her mother and doesn’t realize the situation she’s in. What can we do?”

“Well I was thinking about calling Bill. He knows the law better than anyone I know. Maybe he can think of something we can do. One thing that may come up is a way for us to adopt her in some way. What do you think of that?” Leah thought it over for a few minutes. “Well we can always add on a room or maybe do some kind of renovation of the garage.” That told me her thoughts. The next day we all had fun. Breakfast was eating and laughing. Then all three girls went outside and played. Anna and Katie had bonded well with Bethany quite a bit in such a short time. While they were playing I got a call from her stepdad. They were home and would be over in a little while to get Bethany. I told the little girl and she got her things together. Before long he showed up and I invited him in for a talk.

We chatted and I noticed he eyed both of my girls and even ogled my wife a few times. I made our conversation general but all the years I had in education I had learned how to pump someone for information without them knowing what I wanted. Eventually I told him that if it was the girls had become very good friends and would probably want to invite Bethany over quite a bit. He seemed glad to hear that and assured me that sleepovers would leave them freer to have a more adult lifestyle. Then he chuckled at his intended meaning and winked at me. Bethany gave me a little hug as she left and shared a secret smile with me.

That afternoon I talked to the girls and without giving them too much information asked them how they would feel if Bethany came to live with us on a more permanent basis. They knew I knew things but wasn’t saying. They talked to us about it and eventually said that it would be great to have another sister. The next day was Monday and I went to see our family lawyer. I invited him out to lunch so that anything we talked about would still be confidential without being on the books. I told him that and he said it had better be a good lunch.

We met and had a conversation that covered life and such. Bill and I had known each other since college and while we weren’t buddies, we were good friends. After we ate he looked at me. “Well that was a great lunch, now I am afraid what is coming next. Normal business is done in an office, this kind of meeting is reserved for illegal or shady dealing and I normally avoid that like the plague but we have been friends for a long time. So what’s up?”

I gave him the whole package but without names. I also gave him my thoughts on the matter and the impressions I had given by her stepfather. I had never seen Bill get mad since we had gotten drunk and found out a frat boy had raped a girl he was friends with. He nearly beat the dipshit to death before the campus cops broke it up. He almost lost his chance to become a lawyer over that one. “Mike, I notice you haven’t named any names and that’s good because if it was up to me; if I didn’t have the fuckers arrested I would kill them.” He calmed down a little when he saw the look on my face. “Ok, I know that would only damage the girl as much as if we let them keep raping her. I need to look into a few things and maybe even draw up some papers for you. We will get that girl out of their hands as soon as possible.”

I was expecting that it would take him a few days at least. I mean what lawyer in the world does overtime off the books. The next morning Bill called me just after I dropped the girls off at school and told me to come over to his place. I got there and he looked like shit and I told him so. “Man I haven’t been to sleep since I talked to you, but I think I have an answer.” He took out a stack of papers. “It’s easier than I thought. First we have them sign an in loco parentis form. And then we can move onto a formal transfer of custodial rights over to you and Leah. I have it all arranged with a friend of mine who is a family court judge. I gave him a general rundown of the case and he is willing to not notice a few things. This won’t break the law it will be straining it quite a bit.”

We talked about a few ways to get them to cave in and established that it would be best when Bethany was at our house and Bill and a friend who could witness and notarize the documents could be there as well. I left him and everything else and went to get the girls from school and off to dance. I saw Bethany and told her we would love to have her over this weekend for another sleepover. She jumped at the chance and for the rest of the class she was walking on air. I got to meet her mother just before the end of class. She seemed a little haggard and quite distracted. When I was able to get her to focus on what I was saying I asked if it would be ok for her daughter to spend the night again.