Chapter 37

“GYUAAAAAAAH!” Tabitha cried out as her eyes snapped wide open from the sudden single-thrust invasion of her ass. The very same thrust that Tabitha felt not only deep within her bowels, but also within her cock. The stimulation was so sudden and overwhelming that for a moment Tabitha could not even tell if she’d been fucked into her ass or straight into her clit-dick.

Before Tabitha could even properly process what happened, she already shot a fresh load into Olivia’s pussy, before her cock could even properly harden again. A single, powerful thrust into Tabitha was all it took to milk her.

“Ah? W-what the hell are you doing?” Olivia exclaimed when she felt another hot load unleash within her pussy. And as Tabitha’s cock hardened, Olivia blushed, realizing that her pussy craved to be filled again, and saw her own cock rise along with Tabitha’s.

Tabitha’s eyes rolled back mid-scream as the familiar, euphoric tingling that rushed through her dick combined with the overwhelming shockwave that blasted through her body from her stuffed ass. What might have been immeasurably agonizing, mind-numbing pain to others, was heavenly bliss for Tabitha. The masochist only uttered a single word, “More!”

“That’s the spirit!” Beatrice encouraged Tabitha. “Pass on your feelings to Olivia, too!”

“W-what?-AHH!” Olivia was not mentally prepared, but she could not even finish her feigned protest before Tabitha already moved her hips and thrust her rapidly swelling cock deeper into Olivia.

Tabitha’s actions were rewarded in the best way she could ever imagine—the goddesses’s tail moved ever deeper into her. For every seven inches of her tail that Beatrice pulled slowly out of Tabitha—rubbing the long length of her tail against the inner walls of Tabitha’s intestines—she roughly and powerfully thrust eight inches right back in.

Only yesterday, this would have resulted in Beatrice cumming swiftly and prematurely, but Beatrice’s absurdly frequent sexual encounters had taught her the levels of endurance she could not have even imagined, which the succubus could now use to prolong her lewd encounters and play with several girls at once as she pleased.

“Amazing! Incredible!!” Tabitha screamed, losing her mind. No one had ever fucked her ass as Beatrice did. Nobody was ever as deep, nobody’s thrust was ever as powerful. And never before did Tabitha have a cock to cum through while her ass was ravaged. With each deliberate thrust of Beatrice’s tail, another shot of cum ejected out of Tabitha’s milked cock.

“Hahhn~! H-how?” Olivia moaned as she got creampied again and again. The futanari ninja couldn’t even tell whether Tabitha was fucking her or if she herself slammed against Tabitha’s cock as she masturbated herself to orgasm.

“Does it feel that good, Olivia?” Beatrice asked while playing with Ember’s pussy and moving the vibrator closer and further from the redhead’s clit.

“It does! It does!” Olivia moaned as she bounced on Tabitha’s cock while jerking herself off, completely lost to the animalistic pleasure.

“And you would selfishly take all that pleasure for yourself?” Beatrice asked. “Did you not plan to make Ember feel just as good as you do now? What about justice? Have you resigned yourself to simply bouncing on cock while masturbating? Did you not aspire for more? Does your justice amount to so little?”

“H-huh? B-but-Ahn!” Olivia whimpered as tears built up in her eyes. She wanted to stop. She had to stop. But each time Tabitha thrust up into her pussy, each time Tabitha shot another load inside her, Olivia’s resolve shattered. That sweet, forbidden pleasure that built up rapidly as she masturbated while a futanari nympho creampied her again and again! She was so close! So close to cumming again! Through cock and pussy! “Cumming through cock and pussyyyy!”

Olivia arched her back and moaned in ecstasy as she shot another load all over Tabitha while slamming her hips against the futanari to milk herself dry. I’m so pathetic! Olivia thought even as her tongue hung while her body spasmed from the pleasure.

“Yes, it does feel good,” Beatrice agreed. Her cock was rock hard from seeing the two sexy futanari’s screw each other. “The pleasure is too great for mere mortals to resist! Get it out of your system! Cum! Cum again! Let go! Cum as much as you need to! Then you’ll be able to focus on the task at hand!”

“Ahh, yesss~~!” Tabitha and Olivia cried out in unison. Somehow, Beatrice’s approval broke open something inside them and got rid of whatever remnants of guilt they had.

Without even going limp, Olivia let all of her inhibitions go and rode Tabitha like there was no tomorrow while continuously jerking herself off, playing and pinching her small breasts, moaning like a cock slut that she was.

“Do me more lady, Beatrice!” Tabitha moaned. “Please! Fuck me as I fuck her! Make us both cum!”

“I soon won’t be able to reach any deeper from where I stand,” Beatrice laughed, reminding Tabitha that there were limits to the length of her tail. And as soon as Beatrice thought that, she made a mental note to check for ways to fix that later.

“Please! Please, lady Beatrice, I want more!” Tabitha begged as she thrust her hips upward, clenching Beatrice’s tail with her butt and then slammed herself down, trying to impale herself on Beatrice’s tail and get as much of it inside as possible.

Realizing that there was no going back, Olivia did whatever she pleased to get herself off again and again. She rubbed her pussy that Tabitha screwed, stuck two fingers inside herself to fill her pussy even more, and fuck herself together with Tabitha’s cock.

Olivia even started wondering how Tabitha felt like with her ass getting screwed by Beatrice’s long, cock-like tail. She pressed her well-lubricated index finger against her ass and surprised herself with how effortlessly it slid into her lewd body, causing another, smaller orgasm, and shot more cum on Tabitha’s cum-covered body.

“Mmnf,” Ember moaned as her legs trembled from the increasing stimulation around her clit and pussy.

Beatrice kept playing with Ember. Moving it closer and farther, pressing it hard against Ember’s clit and moving away completely for long enough that Ember desired to feel the vibrator again. Her pussy was wet for a decent cock, and it took all of Ember’s willpower not to push herself onto Beatrice’s hard cock that pressed against her pussy lips just enough to massage them without penetration, just enough to make Ember wish to be penetrated.

Beatrice already increased the intensity of the vibrator to the second level out of four while also making time to torment and play with the cum-addled temporary futanaris.

“See how good it feels when you stop worrying about silly things?” Beatrice said to Olivia, who fingered her ass into another orgasm as she masturbated her aching dick while Tabitha pounded and creampied her over and over again.

“Yeahn!” Olivia moaned her answer as she let the pleasure ruin her mind.

How many times had she cum through her cock in the last few minutes? She could not care less! How many times did she let herself get creampied by a traitorous nympho that betrayed her just yesterday? It did not matter! How many mind-numbing orgasms did she have while masturbating her thick futa cock as she impaled herself on a crazy nympho’s fat futa cock? Not nearly enough!

“Good girl! Make the most of it!” Beatrice encouraged Olivia while pressing the vibrator against Ember’s clit again, and turned up the vibration intensity to the third level. “If life deals you shitty cards, takes everything from you, it is only just that you find ways to take back! Find what little happiness and pleasure in this world you can! And if such an opportunity presents itself, grab it without hesitation! Grab your justice!”

“Ahn! Yeesssss! Justice!” Olivia moaned with a lewd voice and a depraved expression that she despised so much in others.

Olivia realized that Beatrice was right. She realized that if she gave up all her shame, dignity, and common sense already anyway, she might as well make the most of it! A finger felt so good already! What about two? What about three? Olivia fingered her ass, escalating by the second. The next thing she knew, she was already fucking her ass with four fingers. And after coming this far, Olivia saw no reason to hold back. After cumming so much, she needed to escalate even more.

Olivia mustered enough willpower to part from Tabitha’s drenched cock for a second. Excessive amounts of semen poured out of Olivia, covering Tabitha’s cock like a waterfall. The masochist kept thrusting into the air, fucking the cum waterfall, oozing more cum as she moaned and cried in pain and ecstasy from Beatrice’s tail fucking her harder and deeper than any before.

Olivia moved her hips and aligned her other hole with Tabitha’s cock. Despite the warm-up with the girth of four fingers, the lewd ninja had intended to take her first cock in her ass slowly. But “slowly” was not something that Tabitha was even capable of understanding by that point. The moment that the perpetually orgasming nympho felt a hole at the tip of her cock, she pushed that hole down by the hips of the owner and thrust up to fuck and inseminate it while feeding more sweet pleasure to her pleasure-addicted brain.

“HAAaaaaaaaah!!!” Olivia cried out as her ass was suddenly, rudely, roughly, and thoroughly invaded by Tabitha’s cum-drenched cock.

But what Olivia felt was no pain. Or, rather, it was a strange, “filling” feeling. The way Olivia’s pussy craved to be thrust into and filled, the way she thrust and stretch her ass with her fingers, it felt right to have a hot cock in her ass. With hot, horny blood circulating in its veins. And in that single, life-altering thrust into her ass, Olivia felt cum rushing through her cock.

Tabitha thrust, again and again, plunging her cock to the base into Olivia’s ass. And as Tabitha fucked her, Olivia stroked her twitching cock, shaking and trembling from a powerful orgasm that started deep within her and swept through her body.

And as Olivia climaxed hard from getting her very first anal fuck, she knew her life would never be the same. There was no going back to normal for a girl that let another girl fuck her in the ass with a magical cock and orgasmed by jerking off her own magical cock. Cumming with both cock and ass, letting herself be milked and getting off on it, shaking like a drugged whore with a perverted, shameful grin on her face, and loving it!

“You’re both ready,” Beatrice said to her moaning bodyguard, turned her around, and pushed her down on her knees. The succubus parted the vibrator from Ember’s clit for just a moment, just long enough for Ember to long for it. The second Beatrice placed it back between Ember’s pussy lips, the redhead moved on her own to meet it.

“Ahn! Beatrice!” Ember moaned, leaning against her elbows, grinding her hips against the small vibrator that stimulated her clit in ways she had never felt before.

Beatrice had all but reached the limit of holding back her urges. She massaged Ember’s pussy with her cock, doing her best not to touch the vibrator directly with the head of her cock. The vibrations that Beatrice felt spreading through Ember’s pussy were already barely tolerable in her aroused state. But she also held back for far too long.

“Isn’t it about time you let Ember feel your justice?” Beatrice asked Olivia.

“Yes! Justice! Ah! Justice” Olivia moaned as she thrashed in her orgasm and aimed her last shots of cum at Ember’s face.

“Your true justice! Not that half-assed attempt from earlier!” Beatrice told Olivia. “You had the spirit, but neither your mind nor your body was prepared. This time, you shall not fail!”

“No ... Haaaahh ... no, I won’t,” Olivia said as she came down from her high and looked at Ember that was on all fours with her ass toward Beatrice’s cock. The Ember that escaped her cock and tricked her into getting fucked by Tabitha. The Ember that laughed while she tricked Tabitha into fucking her and watched the ninja cum involuntarily. The Ember that always made fun of her. The Ember whose fault it was that she was now in this humiliating position. Cumming endlessly and loving it.