Chapter 5: Visitors and Surprising Results

Anna’s and my twin sisters, Cindy and Sandy, arrived on schedule two weeks after we and our close friends made the discovery and revelation to each other that we were all in love with our sibling. Our mutual affection for each other was also flourishing in that we often had sex with each other.

We needed to hide our incestuous love from our visiting siblings. Thus, for this visit, Penny was going to be my erstwhile girlfriend, and Anna would have Dave as her boyfriend. That arrangement, also allowed Marie and Ryan to get together for some loving.

Cindy and Sandy flew in on Wednesday afternoon from up north where our parents lived. They planned to visit the two nearby colleges on Thursday and Friday, and then stay over with us until Sunday afternoon.

I drove to the airport and picked the two of them up at curbside as we’d arranged. We drove back to the apartment and I helped by carrying their two small bags upstairs as they carried their backpacks. They were now both seniors in high school and worried about getting their college applications submitted before the holidays. We’d pledged to help them however we could.

At the apartment, Penny greeted us as we came inside. I got a kiss and made introductions of my younger siblings. They were about eight years younger than me; a second family my parents had decided on as Anna and I achieved some independence earlier in our lives. I could still tell them apart despite their classification as identical twins.

Penny announced dinner plans, specifically that Dave and Anna were also joining us after Anna closed up her shop. We were certainly playing the ‘girlfriend’ and ‘boyfriend’ chips in our game of subterfuge.

The girls were going to use our convertible sofa since it was queen size and could easily sleep the two of them. We hadn’t planned much else, other than to be near constant companions with our BF and GF when we weren’t working.

The six of us went out to dinner: Dave, Penny, Anna, me, and our twin sisters – Cindy and Sandy. We had fun, and talked about what we knew about the two schools they were looking at.

Fortunately, or unfortunately, depending on how we looked at it, Cindy and Sandy were looking favorably on the two schools because we lived nearby to either campus. They also felt their grades and activities would position them well to be accepted and maybe to even get financial aid.

If they were in town, Anna and I would have to be on near constant alert to hide our emotional and physical relationship. We would have to always appear to be aloof and brotherly or sisterly to the other, and not romantic lovebirds that we usually were.

Dave and Anna put on a good show, often displaying the legitimate new relationship energy they felt for each other. Of course, Penny and I were likewise involved. The small touches, kisses, hugs, and gestures or words of affection were not lost on the twins.

By agreement, Penny went home that night and Dave stayed over with Anna, sleeping in her bed with her. The twins seemed mildly shocked that their older sister was so casual about sleeping with a guy, but Penny and I made no big deal about it as bedtime neared. Dave brought in his overnight kit, but noted that he’d already left a bunch of stuff in Anna’s bathroom, such as his toothbrush and shaving kit.

I expected that would be the first night I slept alone in ages. A couple of times, I’d had Marie and Penny overnight with me while Anna romanced Ryan or Dave in her bed.

After the apartment got quiet with everyone in bed, I shot awake as my door opened and one of the twins came into my room. It was hard to tell in the dark which one it was.

My sheet was lifted and my younger sibling slipped under and then came right into my arms. This might have been all right, except I was naked. Anna and I both slept au naturel because we didn’t want any impediments to our lovemaking when the mood struck.

It turned out that my visitor was also deliciously naked.

“Cindy? Sandy? What are you doing?”

“I’m planning on loving my older brother. I don’t want you to think of me as your sister. I want you to think of me as a young woman that just adores you and always has. Please let me love you, and please make love to me.”

Young lips locked onto mine and then I had a teenage tongue deep in my mouth as we French kissed. It was Cindy, I learned. Sandy drew a short straw, but I’d have her the next night, because she felt the same way about me.

Before I could blink, Cindy had my cock in her mouth as I felt her breasts along my legs. My teenage sister actually had significant skill in giving blowjobs. I’d have to learn more about that later. In the meanwhile, I was going through all the pros and cons of whether to do what I seemed to want to do with Cindy. It was obviously what she wanted me to do, too.

I was already involved in a deep incestuous relationship with one sister. I thought, what was one more or two more. I was already doomed and going to hell. I didn’t resist very much. In fact, I started to respond and reciprocate with more enthusiasm. I even turned on my bedside light so we could see each other and I could marvel at her sexy body.

Cindy maneuvered us into a sixty-nine position at my request, and I started to eat her pussy and finger her holes. She purred like a kitten as I worked on her. I was sure I was making noises of satisfaction, as well. I wondered whether Anna and Dave could hear us.

Cindy spun around on my body and fed me one of her young breasts. I devoured the boob, sucking on the nipple until I had it highly aroused. This girl was in heat and needed cock. My cock.

I was hard. Cindy had gotten me that way and kept me that way while we did oral and fondled each other.

“Are you sure you want to do this?” I asked. “This would be incest – a very taboo thing to do.”

“I’m legally an adult. Yes, I’m sure. Please forget I’m your sister and just make love with me. Have sex with me. Fuck me. I need you – every inch of you. I promise we won’t say anything to mom or dad, Anna, or to your girlfriend. Sandy will make the same promise, too.”

I was clearly thinking with my little head. Cindy pushed me onto my back, and then mounted me and slithered her tight teenage cunt down my cock until I was fully embedded inside her. I was surprised she took all of me without a single complaint, only a sigh of satisfaction and a moan of supreme pleasure. We then started to move together as our fucking started. We kept kissing and using our tongues, too.

Cindy gasped, “Oh, fuck. You feel so fuckin’ good inside me. I’m on the pill, so you can blast away when you’re ready, but not just yet. I want to try to have an orgasm on you. This is so much better than I ever dreamed.”

I knew how to solve the orgasm problem. Sixty seconds later, Cindy squeaked and moaned loudly as her first orgasm rolled through her body. I continued to use my fingers on her clit after she rode that one through; she had another and then another. I kept plunging my cock into her, too. We changed positions so I could take a more assertive role in our lovemaking.

My other sister snuck into my room and shut the door. She quickly doffed her PJs so she was as nude and desirable as her sister. I got more kisses but continued to focus on Cindy. Sandy sat with her legs spread in my line of sight and stroked her pussy. Occasionally, she’d put two or three fingers into her vagina and pump them around with attendant wet sounds.

The presence and horniness of my two younger siblings pushed me over the top. I warned Cindy that I was near, and brought her to the edge again. As she started to topple into an orgasm, I came, too. I probably disgorged about a gallon of potent cum into the small warm and snug pussy surrounding my shaft.

Cindy’s orgasm seemed transcendental and transformative. She almost levitated into some other ethereal realm of joy, bliss, and happiness, as we came to a stop and my spasms into her body stopped. We kissed for a long time.

We separated and I could see the presence of my semen leaking from Cindy’s pussy almost immediately. I suddenly had a devilish idea.

I turned to Sandy and said, “Well, don’t just sit there. Clean up your sister with your mouth. Get busy.” I pointed at Cindy’s leaky quim and physically nudged Sandy in that direction.

Sandy protested, “But ... but...”

“No, you have to do it. I do it with my girlfriend all the time. It’s a normal part of sex. You both want this, I assure you.”

Sandy said, “How do I ... I’ve never done anything like this.”

I leaned down and licked my tongue up one side of Cindy’s labia. I then turned to Sandy, “Does that give you a hint? It’s not rocket science. Just get in there with your tongue and lick and suck up the juices. If you want to do something really sexy, collect a bunch of the cum and fluids and then bring it up to Cindy so you can snowball what you find.”

“Sno ... sno ... snowball?” Sandy said in obvious innocence. Cindy was suddenly looking worried. This was a learning experience that big brother was providing.

“I’ll show you.” I bent my body forward to Cindy’s slit again, and lapped up some of the evident fluids. I then came up and initiated a French kiss with Cindy. At first, she was standoffish, but I think as she actually got a taste of the fluids, she got into it, until we were very open-mouthed in our kissing and trading fluids back and forth as we turned our heads back and forth. I broke away and looked at Sandy.

Sandy slowly leaned into her sister’s twat with her tongue extended. She made some tentative swipes and then increasingly got into the lewd act. I secretly congratulated myself for further corrupting my twin sisters.

Sandy made several up and down trips to collect and snowball with Cindy. They got into it. I explained about extracting my cum from inside her with two fingers, and Sandy tried that. She got more into the act with each second.