Note from the author:
Hello Dear reader! You may be wondering where this falls into the SWMS timelines, and frankly, they’re mostly separate and askew at this point. It falls after the second book, during the third, but before the end of the third. This was written AGES ago, and frankly, should’ve just been thrown up here or some other site. I went back over everything, fixed the grammar and the readability, and here it is ... so enjoy SWMS 4
“How beautiful; You two stayed together all that time.” - Heather Swartz- Sex with My Sister
Joshua and Andrea set down the boxes just inside the door of their apartment. They had just moved finished moving in officially. It had only been six months since their parents had died, and now that they had executed the wills they had gotten the house on the market and sold it.
Andrea was only five foot two. She was a skinny little thing with a nice body. She wore a tank top that showed off her flat stomach and nice cleavage and short shorts that hugged her ass and pussy. Her red hair was pulled into pigtails and she had deep blue eyes. On her lower left leg, she had a tattoo of a phoenix rising from some ashes with her parents’ names written within the ashes. She kicked off her flip flops as she entered the apartment. She grabbed the front of her shirt and lifted it to her nose. She had a small figure, which resembled her mother’s, but moreover her father’s figure.
Their parents, who had died in a car crash, had been simple people. Their father had worked in a factory as a Certified Public Accountant, and their mother had worked in a local grocery store in the deli. They had both had nice life insurance policies and had set it up so their house had been paid off after Joshua and Andrea had been born.
“Oh god, I’m sweaty,” Andrea said, sniffing her shirt. “I need a shower.” She said as two younger guys carried a box spring in.
She let go of her shirt letting it drop back down.
“Where do you want this one?” One of them asked.
Joshua looked up. He stood a little taller than his sister and wore an a-shirt, more known as a wife beater in New York, where they lived. He also wore a pair of loose fitting shorts and had his sunglasses sitting on top of his head. He had been checking boxes and been moving them into various rooms of the house. He was relieved to see the box spring as it was the last item on the truck.
“Oh, that’s Andrea’s,” Joshua said, turning to see his sister had already walked off to find the bathroom so she could shower. “Um, yeah, it goes into the larger bedroom,” Joshua said pointing to the larger bedroom.
The two of them had bought new mattresses when they had sold the house, and different box springs. Joshua had gone for one that matched his mattress but Andrea had chosen something different. She had chosen a solid black box spring while their mattresses were red.
The bedrooms were down a small hallway. The apartment itself wasn’t too large, but it had two bedrooms. The master bedroom was large and had a bathroom attached; while the smaller bedroom didn’t. The walls of the apartment were some off-color of white, and the carpet was tan.
The guys walked past Joshua and carried it into the bedroom, setting the box spring flat on the floor. They put the mattress leaning against the wall on top. Joshua walked into the bedroom.
“Thanks, guys.” He said pulling out his wallet. “I can handle the rest from here.” He said as he opened it and leafed out two bills.
He handed them each a bill and they looked at it and their eyes went wide.
“Are you serious? A hundred bucks each?” They asked in unison.
“Yeah. Just let yourselves out.” Joshua said.
The two guys headed out of the room and left the apartment. Joshua headed for the front door. He closed it and locked it. He shook his head. The tip he had handed them was a mere drop into the bucket now he and his sister would live off the life insurance payouts and the inheritances they had reinvested.
He walked over to a box marked food and tore it open. He pulled out a box of spaghetti and scanned the box for any perishables but found none. He quickly went through the other boxes and put away what was left of the food. Joshua had put most of it away the previous day when his sister had moved the food to the new apartment. He set the box of spaghetti on the counter and walked over to another box marked ‘pots and pans’ and pulled out a small pot. He walked over to the sink and filled it with water from the tap. He set it on the stove and turned on the electric burner.
Joshua turned and walked out of the kitchen toward the bathroom. He checked the handle and found it unlocked. He poked his head in, only to see his sister, Andrea nude in the shower with nothing hiding her body. Joshua’s eyes went wide as he looked at the naked body of his sister. Her hair had been let down. It was to the top of her neck. His eyes went from her 28c breasts down to her trimmed pussy and back up again. She was looking away but giving him a full frontal view of her body. His cock became hard and his face went red. He tilted his head and aimed his eyes on the floor. He knocked on the door.
“Hey Andrea, can you check the water on the stove when you get out of the shower and let me know if it’s boiling?” Joshua asked.
Andrea looked over at him and blushed. She hadn’t expected him to come in while she was getting cleaned up. She couldn’t be sure if he had seen her, but the thought got her excited a little. She saw his head to the ground and assumed that he hadn’t.
“Um, Sure, Josh,” Andrea said.
“Thanks,” Joshua said, keeping his eyes to the ground.
He dragged his head out of the room making her wonder even further if he had seen anything but she whiffled it off as she heard the door click shut.
Joshua fumbled for a moment to free his seven and a half inch cock from his shorts. He stroked it a couple times, to calm himself down. He had seen women naked in R-rated flicks and in porno mags but he had never seen one in the nude before and he couldn’t get the sight out of his head.
Joshua headed for his bedroom which was the smaller of the two and opened the door. There were several boxes in it, and the mattress laid on the box spring on the floor. He shut the door behind him and walked to the far corner of the room and laid down on his bed with his cock still in his hand. He began to slowly jerk his manhood and imagined that his sister’s lips were around it. He didn’t care that he was thinking about his own twin sister, and he didn’t care if it was wrong at that point. He wanted to get off and the thought of her making love to him was getting him there.
Andrea got out of the shower, shutting the water off. She was dripping wet, and looked for a towel but couldn’t seem to find the box marked towels. She poked her head out the bathroom door and didn’t see Joshua. She guessed that he was in his bedroom and headed for the larger of the two. She had insisted on getting it as her room, and Joshua had finally caved even though he was the older of the two.
She stepped into her room and closed the door behind her, heading straight for a box with the label of ‘Andrea’s clothing’. She tore it open and found a shirt that she pulled on. It was just long enough to cover her ass and pussy. She walked back out of the room and headed for the kitchen to check the water as she promised.
The water was almost boiling at this point. She sighed and walked back to Joshua’s room. She opened his door a crack and poked her head into his room.
Her eyes went wide when she saw her brother jerking himself off. She wanted to touch it, to feel it, and to taste it. She had never seen a guy’s cock before, and it intrigued her. She felt herself getting wet at the sight. She stopped and thought for a moment. She was getting horny at the sight of her own brother’s cock. It was wrong, and she knew it, but she couldn’t help how her body was reacting to just the sight of him. She pulled her head back out the door and allowed her hand to trail down to her pussy. She slowly slipped a finger into her virgin hole and felt how hot and wet it was. She would masturbate herself if she planned on controlling her urge to run into his room and just fuck him. She reached for his door handle with her free hand and slowly and closed the door. She knocked on the door twice.
“Josh! The water is boiling!” She called before turning and walking towards her room. She wanted to keep herself in control of her body, but since they had thrown away most of their stuff for their new life, she didn’t have any lube or a dildo to get off. She walked into her room and shut her door most of the way, leaving it open a crack. She hoped her brother might walk in on her masturbation and offer to join her. She knew thoughts like that were wrong, but she couldn’t help it. She pulled off the long t-shirt and laid down on the bed and rubbed her clit.
Joshua got up from his bed and grabbed his shorts and his t-shirt and put them back on. His erection was still throbbing, and he hadn’t gotten off yet. He knew thinking about his own sister in this manner was wrong, but he couldn’t help wanting her. It was a complete turn on that this was his twin sister, and that she could walk in on him masturbating. He tried to push the thought out of his head and walked out to the kitchen.
He added the spaghetti to the water and sat down at the table in the room next to the kitchen. He waited for a moment then got up. He walked to his sister’s room and slowly opened her door, peeking inside. His eyes went wide again as he watched her playing with her clit. She moaned out what he could have sworn was his name and his cock throbbed hard. He wanted to go into her room and just take her right there but knew that it was wrong. He couldn’t help how he was attracted to her now. He had never thought of his sister like this before. His eyes stayed on her swollen pussy lips. Her head was thrown back on the pillows and wasn’t even looking towards him. Her knees were bent and she had one hand on her breast and was massaging it.
Joshua stepped back, closing her door, and letting his cock throb in anger at him as he took a logical move instead of a horny one.
“Andrea, the dinner should be ready in a little bit.” He called into her room.
Joshua turned and walked back towards the kitchen.
Andrea sat up on the bed with a disappointed look on her face. She would’ve given anything for him to come in and make love to her. She didn’t care that he was her brother, or that incest was wrong. She wanted him in every fashion now and would’ve given anything for them to be together. It was at that moment she decided, She would have her brother make love to her. She would have him as her first, and they both would be happy together.
She grabbed her t-shirt and pulled it over her head again. She grabbed two hair bands and put them around her wrist. She got up and walked out to the kitchen where Joshua was stirring the spaghetti. She put her hair back up in pigtails as she looked down at his cock. He still had a hard on that was obvious from the tent in his shorts.
“How’s it coming?” She asked as she finished putting her hair up and raised her eyes to look at him.
“Just about ready to be drained,” Joshua said.
“Here, let me get it!” Andrea said, showing her usual bubbly attitude.
She grabbed at the handle but dropped it on the ground, splashing boiling water all over the two.
“OW!” She cried out.
The pot’s metal handle had burned her hand and the water that splashed all over their clothing had done little to help. The spaghetti had stayed in the pot mostly but it now covered the two of them in hot water. She let her attention stay on her hand at first until she was sure that she hadn’t gotten burned too. Then she moved to her attention to the rest of her body. Without thinking she pulled off her t-shirt exposing her naked body to her brother.
“Andrea!” Joshua said in shock.
“What’re you doing? You don’t wanna get burned, do you?” She said. “Take off your clothing too.”
“But you’re my sister!” Joshua said, looking away.
“Oh come on! That doesn’t matter right now!” She said with more concern for his well-being and less for the actual act of them both being nude.
She grabbed at his shirt and pulled it off, then grabbed at his shorts as his eyes went back to her. She knelt down as she tugged them down, and his fully erect cock bounced back into place, almost hitting her in the face.
Her eyes went wide at the monster in front of her. It was bigger up close. She reached up, taking it into her hand. It throbbed as she touched it.
“Wow. It’s so big.” She gasped.
“I’m sorry,” Joshua said.
“Why?” Andrea asked.
“I sorta saw you in the shower and it was like this, I haven’t been able to get it to calm down yet,” Joshua said as he blushed brightly.
“Really? You got this big from looking at me that long ago?” Andrea asked looking up at him.
“And it didn’t help when I saw you masturbating,” Joshua said.
He wasn’t sure why he was telling his sister he saw her, but telling her the truth just felt right.
“I have a confession.” Andrea started. “I was only masturbating because I saw you jerking off, and it got me horny.” She confessed.
She wrapped her hand around his cock and stroked it.
“Joshua, I love you more than I’ve ever loved anyone else.” She confessed.
“I feel the same about you, Andrea,” Joshua said.
Andrea didn’t take a second to allow him to object as she plunged his cock into her mouth. Joshua moaned loudly as she sucked his cock. She forced increasingly into her mouth, and he placed his hand on the back of her head. He was in ecstasy as she sucked him off, but then came back to his senses.
“We can’t do this, Andrea,” Joshua said. “We’re brother and sister.”
She pulled his cock from her mouth.
“Josh, we’re both adults, the rest doesn’t matter.” She said as she looked up at him.
She was right, they lived in upstate New York and incest wasn’t against the law where they lived. It was only against the law if they had been married to other people and in that case, it would be adultery.
“Well let’s wait at least until after dinner. I think I can salvage the spaghetti.” Joshua said.
“All right.” She said. “But let’s stay nude.” She said as she let go of his cock and stood up.
“Fine with me.” He said smiling at her.
Joshua bent down and picked up the pot. He brought it over to the sink and salvaged the spaghetti. Not much of the spaghetti had been ruined at all, and Joshua could serve them both plenty of food at the table, covered in sauce. They ate nude, and both found it freeing as they ate. When they finished eating, Andrea cleared the table and washed the dishes. Joshua never took his eyes off of her naked body, and his cock throbbed as he watched her.
After washing the dishes, Andrea walked back over to him and sat on his lap, facing him and pressing his cock between their bodies. She put her arms around his neck.
“So you’re okay with doing this?” Andrea asked.
“Yeah. I can’t say no to you anyways. You always talk me into doing things your way.” Joshua said.
“What about Amy?” Andrea asked.
“She broke it off with me after Mom and Dad died. She didn’t want to deal with the drama, but she wanted to be around me if I was happy. I don’t think she cared for me.” Joshua said.
“She wasn’t worth your time anyway,” Andrea said. “And now you have me.”
Joshua’s cock throbbed at those words, and Andrea looked down at it.
“Don’t worry, you’ll get your fun,” Andrea told it.
“Are you having a conversation with my penis?” Joshua asked.
“Yep, is there a problem with that?” Andrea asked looking into his eyes.
“Nope, not at all,” Joshua said. “But I have to warn you, I’m still a virgin.”
“Me too, so you must be gentle,” Andrea said.
“What about Mark? I thought he and you...” Joshua asked.
“Not even close, He tried going up my shirt once or twice, but that’s as far as he ended up getting before I broke it off,” Andrea said. “No one else has even gotten close to that.” She said.
“So I’m the first to even see you naked?” Joshua asked.
Joshua’s cock throbbed again.
“You were always the first. We took baths together as kids.” Andrea said.
“You know what I mean though,” Joshua said.
“Yes. You’re the first to see me, as an adult, naked.” Andrea said.
Joshua couldn’t help but give her a passionate kiss. Their tongues entwined as they kissed, massaging each other. He raised his hands up from her hips and massaged her breasts as they kissed, gently teasing her small nipples. She reached down and fondled his cock.
“We should do this in the bedroom,” Andrea said when they broke the kiss.
“Which one?” Joshua asked.
“Does it matter?” Andrea asked.
“I guess not,” Joshua said.
“Josh, I want us to share a room after this,” Andrea said. “I don’t want this to be a fling or some one-night-stand.”
“I agree,” Joshua said. “I want to be with you, and I love you, Andrea,” Joshua said.
“Good,” Andrea said as she got off of his lap.
She kept a hold of his cock and he stood up. She led him by the cock to her bedroom.
“Lay down. I wanna be on top.” She said.
“Are you sure? I mean this is our first time.” Joshua said. “I heard it’s more comfortable on your back when you lose your virginity if you’re a girl.”
“No. I’ve decided,” Andrea said more forcefully this time.
Andrea let go of his cock and Joshua laid on his back on the bed. Andrea got down between his legs and licked his shaft. Joshua moaned at this new attention to his cock. She gently stroked and licked his cock causing it to throb again.
“Please, Andrea, don’t tease me.” Joshua moaned at her.
Andrea ignored him. She was getting more aroused by the second. The smell and the taste of his cock were perfect. She loved it. She stroked his balls right before plunging his member back into her mouth. She bobbed her head up and down as she sucked his hard member.
Joshua had masturbated plenty of times, but this was definitely a first for him. He looked down at his little sister as she sucked him off. He had expected her to just mount him and the two to fuck right there, but she was definitely intent on having foreplay. She was sucking him off with such skill; he thought for a second she had to of had experience but the thought quickly vanished as she began deep throating him. He let out a long moan, calling her name. She pulled his cock from her mouth and sucked the sides of his cock.
“Andrea.” Joshua looked down at her, with his eyes full of lust. “I need to be inside you.”
“Relax, my dear brother, you’ll get it soon enough. I want to make sure you’re nice and hard.” She said.
Joshua took her hand and pulled her to be face to face with him.
“I am ready for you, right now. But you’re teasing me, and if we were to have sex right at this second, I’d be cumming with no more stimulation.” Joshua told her.
Andrea reached back and jerked his cock again.
“Well, I can’t help wanting you to last a while with me,” Andrea said. “I heard if the guy cums first before intercourse then they last longer.”
“I understand,” Joshua said. “I had been holding back but I see you’re determined to make me cum now.”
“Good. Now, let me get back to it.” She said.
Andrea moved back down to his throbbing member and plunged it into her mouth and sucked again. She stroked his cock as she bobbed her head up and down. He moaned as she sucked and teased. Within a few minutes of this treatment, he felt himself about to cum.
“Andrea,” he panted. “I’m gonna...” He tried to warn her, but it was too late.
His cock erupted, and his hot sticky cum hit the back of her throat. It was so sudden; all she could do was swallow it down as he kept cumming. When she was sure he was done she pulled the cock out of her mouth and pumped it a few times.
“Oh my god, Andrea, that was so good,” Joshua said as she sat up next to him.
“Glad you enjoyed it, cause I want you inside me.” She said looking into his eyes.
“Hey! You’re not getting off that easily.” Joshua said.
Andrea looked down to see his hand between her legs, caressing her virgin pussy.
“I’m gonna return the favor,” Joshua said with love in his eyes.
Joshua got up and Andrea laid down. She kept her legs together for a moment but then spread them to give her big brother full access to her hot, wet pussy. He spread her outer lips and began by licking her clit in a figure eight motion. She grabbed the back of his head as he slowly slipped a single finger inside her. She bucked her hips, cumming hard. When she calmed down Joshua removed his finger.
“That was fast,” Joshua said.
“I didn’t hold back as you did,” Andrea said as Joshua moved up to her face.
“Joshua, I want you inside me,” Andrea said.
Joshua nodded and positioned the tip of his hardened cock at her entrance. He slowly slipped the head past the swollen lips of her pussy. She moaned, feeling him enter her.
“Please, be gentle when you take it.” Andrea requested.
“I will be,” Joshua said.
The two of them kissed passionately again before Joshua began slowly slipping his cock into his sister’s virgin hole, he felt her resistance stretching to compensate for him, then he felt it give way, and before he could blink he felt his manhood fully buried inside her hot, tight, and wet hole.
“Wow. I can feel you inside me.” Andrea said.
Joshua’s cock was throbbing.
“It feels so good,” Joshua said.
“Yeah,” Andrea said. “And it feels so right with you.” She said.
Joshua thrust his hips against hers. His motions were slow at first but he built speed and power with each thrust.
“Oh, Joshua.” She moaned as her pussy clenched down on his cock. “I’m gonna cum.” She moaned.
Joshua just kept thrusting in and out, until her pussy clenched down so hard he couldn’t move it. When she finished riding her orgasm, Joshua continued thrusting.
“I want you to cum deep inside me.” Andrea moaned as he kept thrusting.
“I’m getting close,” Joshua said.
“Well let me help,” Andrea said as she rolled the two over so she was on top.
She bounced on his rock hard cock. He reached up and massaged her breasts as she rode his cock. After a few minutes she bent down and kissed him passionately and he humped her. He could feel the buildup beginning again.
“I’m gonna cum.” He said.
“Do it, cum inside me. I want you to.” Andrea said. “I love you so much.” She said as he pounded her pussy as hard as he could.
“Oh yes.” He moaned as she clenched down on his cock as hard as she could.
She was cumming again and it pushed him over the edge. She could feel his seed filling her tight hole.
“Mmmm.” She moaned. “That was so good.”
“I love you.” He said.
“I love you too,” Andrea said.
The two of them stayed together for a little while before Andrea reached back and pulled his half hard cock out of her deflowered pussy. She got up and grabbed blankets and pillows and threw them to him so he could set up the bed. Joshua set the bed up and Andrea walked back over to it. She pulled the bands out of her hair letting it down again and put them on the nightstand next to their bed. They got under the covers and slipped into sleep in each other’s arms.
They were content and happy with each other.
They awoke the next morning to the doorbell ringing.
“I’ll get it,” Joshua said, rubbing his head.
He got out of bed and walked to the kitchen where his shorts were laying on the ground. He pulled them on and walked to the door. He unlocked it and opened it. In front of him, an old woman stood with a basket of muffins. Andrea walked up behind Joshua in a long t-shirt. Her hair was still down and she had a happy look on her face.
“Hello there, I’m your neighbor, Mrs. Claymore.” The old woman said. “I wanted to come by and introduce myself.”
Andrea walked up next to Joshua.
“Well Hello. I’m Andrea and this is Joshua, He’s my boyfriend.” Andrea said.
“Well aren’t you two the cutest couple I’ve seen yet. You even look somewhat alike.” She said.
“I know. We’re just gonna have the cutest kids, if we end up getting married.” Andrea said.
“Well, I wanted to drop off these muffins. I wish you two the best.” Mrs. Claymore said.
She smiled as she handed the muffin basket to Andrea and then walked off. Joshua and Andrea stepped back inside the apartment and closed the door. Andrea walked to the kitchen and put the basket on the counter.
“Well, she was nice,” Andrea said as Joshua walked up behind her and gave her a hug.
“Yeah, in a creepy old lady way,” Joshua said.
Andrea turned around.
“Now about last night.” She said.