Punch Drunk Lust: A Cursed College Halloween Romp
Chapter 1
Humor Sex Story: Chapter 1 - Clark Griffin had three simple goals for tonight: survive wearing a twelve-dollar superhero suit with migrating foam abs, guard his mother’s heirloom crystal punch bowl, and avoid making eye contact with Tina Kowalski. Tina was the untouchable queen of high school Spanish—and was currently standing in his kitchen, dressed in a nurse costume that could cause heart failure. A filthy, laugh-out-loud college erotica novelette featuring the nerd-gets-the-smokin’-hot-girl and a cursed aphrodisiac.
Caution: This Humor Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual Drunk/Drugged Demons Orgy
Clark wanted to leave.
He’d been at his own party for exactly thirty minutes, and the twelve-dollar superhero suit suctioned to his body was already unbearable. It felt like one of those plastic weight-loss wraps that made you sweat your balls off and pass out.
The costume had been advertised online as Justice Leader Supreme, a name so aggressively fake it practically came with a cease-and-desist preloaded in the shopping cart. Already, the foam abs had slid sideways beneath the blue shirt and were now parked somewhere near his left ribs, giving him the body shape of a man smuggling dinner rolls. The cape scratched the back of his neck, and the white gloves made his fingers itch.
His hallway was packed shoulder-to-shoulder with people he barely knew, all of them shouting over bass so heavy it rattled his teeth. The rental house’s walls were painted a shade of pink that made Clark think the landlord had either lost a bet or hated tenants on a spiritual level. A crooked city skyline print trembled with every beat, threatening to give up and fling itself to the floor.
Clark pressed himself harder against the doorframe.
’Maybe if I don’t move, no one will notice me.’
“Clark! My man!”
So much for that.
A heavy hand slammed between his shoulder blades, nearly launching his cape into the punch bowl. Clark jerked forward, caught himself, and turned to find Marcus grinning at him with wild-eyed triumph.
Marcus had come dressed as what he called a Bro-Barian. This apparently required a synthetic fur loincloth, a plastic horned helmet tilted over one eye, boots that looked stolen from a middle-school production of Conan, and crude black markings drawn across his biceps with permanent marker. One of the markings had already blurred from sweat, turning his right arm into an eyeliner-stained crime scene.
He looked ridiculous.
He also looked completely at home.
“You’re hiding,” Marcus shouted, leaning close enough that Clark caught the stale bite of energy drink on his breath. “Dude, this is your party. You can’t lurk at your own party like a haunted coat rack.”
“I’m not hiding,” Clark said.
Marcus looked him up and down.
“You’re pressed into a doorframe, and you’re the least convincing superhero alive.” Marcus slapped his shoulder again. “Loosen up. Tonight’s huge.”
Clark’s stomach tightened because he already knew where this was going. Marcus had that particular shine in his eyes, the shine that meant he was about to say something catastrophic with total confidence.
“No,” Clark said preemptively.
Marcus’s grin widened.
“Tina Kowalski’s coming.”
There it was. The name punched straight through the polyester and lodged somewhere beneath Clark’s ribs.
Tina Kowalski.
Queen of high school Spanish. Owner of shiny dark hair, perfect handwriting, and the kind of laugh that had once made Clark forget the word for library in front of the entire class. For three years in high school, he’d cultivated the careful, pathetic art of not being noticed by her. He sat behind taller people and pretended to be fascinated by verb charts. He once dropped a pencil on purpose just so he could duck under the desk when she glanced in his direction.
Normal behavior, obviously.
Now, they went to the same college, and Marcus had turned the faint possibility of Tina’s attendance into the emotional crowbar he’d used to pry Clark into hosting this disaster.
“She’s not coming,” Clark said, trying to shove the foam chest piece back into place. It made a faint peeling sound against his sweaty shirt. Fantastic. “She clicked maybe.”
“Exactly,” Marcus said, pointing at him as if Clark had solved a math proof. “‘Maybe’ means yes when hot people do it.”
“That’s not a thing.”
“It’s absolutely a thing. It’s party science.” Marcus gave him an aggressive wink. “And if she shows up, you’re gonna talk to her.”
Clark’s throat tried to close.
“No, I’m not.”
“Yes, you are, and you’re gonna be charming.”
“I’ve never been charming in my life.”
“Well, you’re gonna start tonight.”
“I’m dressed like a discount lawsuit.”
“You’re dressed like a man with a brand.” Marcus stepped back and gestured grandly at the room. “Now go get punch, Captain Anxiety. People like hosts who hold cups; it makes you look approachable.”
Clark glanced toward the living room. Someone dressed as a pirate had just knocked a plastic skeleton into the TV stand and apologized to it. A girl in devil horns screamed with laughter on the couch. The bass pounded through Clark’s chest in a second, uglier rhythm.
‘Approachable’ sounded terrible.
But Marcus was still staring at him, expectant and stupidly supportive, so Clark peeled himself off the doorframe and headed for the kitchen.
The fake boots resisted every step.
By the time he reached the kitchen, sweat had pooled under the cheap shirt, and the back of his neck prickled from the cape’s rough seam. As predicted, his balls were sweating. It was only a matter of time before he passed out.
In the middle of it all, sitting on the kitchen island like the only dignified adult in the room, was his mother’s crystal punch bowl.
Clark winced every time he looked at it.
The bowl was heavy, ornate, and completely out of place. It had survived two moves, one divorce, and years of his mother treating it like a sacred relic. All that, only to end up tonight filled with Everclear, generic ginger ale, red food coloring, and whatever Marcus had dumped in while yelling, “Trust me, bro, it needs bite.”
If that bowl broke, Clark would have to fake his own death and start over in Manitoba.
He reached for the plastic ladle.
A shoulder slammed into him.
“My bad, Captain,” a guy grunted.
Chad, naturally.
Chad was a local fraternity fixture who showed up at parties like raccoons at open trash cans. Tonight, he wore a plastic gladiator chest piece over a gray hoodie because commitment was apparently for nerds. He didn’t wait for Clark to answer. He reached past him, grabbed a beer from the ice chest, and swaggered back toward the living room as if he’d just conquered a province.
Clark stared down at his boot cover.
A dark scuff streaked across the toe.
Perfect. Truly, the final blow to his majestic ensemble.
He opened his mouth, considered saying something, pictured Chad turning around and asking him to repeat it louder, then closed his mouth again.
’Brave men pick their battles. Cowards also pick their battles. Same result, less punching.’
He turned back toward the punch.
That was when he noticed the person by the basement door.
At first, Clark thought it was just another guest hovering at the edge of the kitchen, waiting for a gap in the crowd. Then the flickering under-cabinet light caught the burlap mask.
A scarecrow.
Not a cute scarecrow either, and not one of those party-store costumes with stitched smiles and floppy hats. This mask looked old, the fabric rough and stained, with crooked black thread pulling the mouth into something almost like a grin. The eyeholes were dark and empty enough that Clark couldn’t tell if there were eyes behind them at all.
The rest of the costume didn’t help: a heavy coat, mud-dark pants, dirt-crusted gloves, and a shapeless hat sagging low. It all looked less like someone had dressed for Halloween and more like something had climbed out of a ditch and decided to come inside.
The figure stood beside the basement door, motionless.
Completely motionless.
Around them, the kitchen heaved with noise and color: a fairy spilled chips, a werewolf laughed into a phone, and someone shouted for limes. But the scarecrow didn’t shift, didn’t dance, didn’t look around.
Clark’s skin tightened beneath the polyester.
The basement door was supposed to be locked. It stuck in the frame and led down to a narrow, unfinished space full of exposed pipes, old paint cans, and a washing machine that banged when it hit the spin cycle. Marcus had specifically told people not to go down there.
Marcus had also invited half the campus through three different group chats, so the warning had probably carried the legal weight of a napkin.
Still.
The scarecrow lifted one dirt-caked hand and placed a small burlap drawstring bag on the counter beside the punch bowl. The bag was about fist-sized and stained dark. Then the scarecrow turned with a slow, smooth motion, opened the basement door, slipped through, and pulled it shut.
Clark stared.
’Nope.’
For one insane second, he expected someone else to react. Someone to laugh. Someone to say, “Sick costume,” or “Was that your friend?” or, ideally, “Hello, authorities, there’s a field demon in the kitchen.”
Nobody did.
The party roared on.
Clark took a step toward the basement door, but two drunk freshmen backed into his path, arguing about whether Dracula counted as a superhero. By the time Clark got around them, the door was shut tight. A crescent of muddy water marked the tile where the scarecrow had stood.
He should get Marcus, should open the door, should do literally anything except focus on the little bag sitting beside his mother’s priceless punch bowl.
So naturally, he focused on the little bag.
The rough fabric looked scratchy beneath the kitchen light. The twine around the neck had been knotted twice. Clark told himself it was probably party candy or some edgy Halloween favor. Perhaps Marcus had hired someone to wander around being creepy, though that would have required planning beyond “buy liquor” and “borrow your mom’s bowl.”
Curiosity won.
It always did in horror movies, right before someone lost a limb.
Clark tugged the twine loose with his gloved fingers and tipped the bag into his palm.
Something dropped out.
Clark stopped breathing.
A finger.
A real, shriveled finger.
For a moment, his brain refused to name it. It was too absurd, too specific, and too horrible. It lay across the white superhero glove, small and curled, dark brown like old leather, severed at the knuckle. The nail was still attached, coated in cracked crimson polish.
Clark’s stomach dropped so hard he thought he might follow it to the floor.
’I am going to throw up.’
It wasn’t plastic; it couldn’t be plastic. Cheap props had seams, had a rubbery shine, and looked like something tossed into a bin marked “gross stuff” at a Halloween store.
This had wrinkles, tiny knuckles, a chipped nail, and ridges at the fingertip so delicate they made his scalp prickle.
There were ragged tears near the end where it had separated from the rest of the hand. Clark’s mind, because it hated him personally, immediately pictured the rest of that hand, and the rest of the person.
“Whoa, what is that?”
Marcus materialized beside him like the world’s loudest curse, his plastic helmet knocking Clark’s temple as he leaned in.
Clark jerked his hand back.
“Don’t touch it.”
Marcus’s eyes widened, then lit with pure, idiotic delight.
“Dude.”
“Marcus.”
“Is that a finger?”
“I think it might be real.”
Marcus barked a laugh and snatched it off Clark’s palm.
Clark’s entire body jolted.
“Don’t touch it!”
Too late. Marcus held it up between thumb and forefinger, like he’d found the prize in a cereal box. Several people nearby turned, and a guy dressed as a zombie lifted his phone.
“Oh my God,” someone said, delighted.
“Is that edible?” another person asked.
“No,” Clark snapped, horrified by the fact that this question had apparently become relevant.
Marcus rotated it under the light.
“This is insane. Look at the nail polish. Whoever made this deserves, like, an award.”
“Give it back,” Clark said.
“Relax.”
“Do not ‘relax’ me.”
“That’s not grammar.”
“I don’t care about grammar right now.”
Marcus grinned at the kitchen.
“Yo, check this out!”
Clark grabbed his wrist, but Marcus lifted the finger higher.
“Marcus, I swear to God.”
“A little garnish for the brew!”
“No!”
Marcus flicked his wrist.
The finger arced through the light in horrible slow motion.
Clark lunged, but the boots stuck to the floor. The finger hit the punch dead center with a soft little ‘plip’ and vanished beneath the red surface.
For half a second, Clark simply stared at the bowl.
His mother’s bowl.
The party punch.
The possible dead person’s finger punch.
Then his brain caught up.
“No, no, no.” He grabbed the ladle and plunged it into the red liquid. “Are you out of your mind?”
Marcus planted his plastic sword against the ladle, blocking him with the kind of dramatic flair that belonged nowhere near potential evidence.
“Captain Justice, stand down.”
“Move.”
“It’s a joke.”
“It might be a body part.”
“No, it’s not a body part.”
“You don’t know that.”
“Because normal people don’t bring body parts to parties.”
“Normal people don’t dress like horny Vikings either, but here we are.”
Marcus looked wounded.
“Bro-Barian. Get it right.”
Clark tried to shove the sword aside.
“Move the stupid sword.”
“People are watching,” Marcus said under his breath, his smile still pasted on for the room.
Clark looked up.
People were absolutely watching.
Three girls in witch hats had paused near the fridge, whispering to each other. The zombie guy still had his phone raised. Chad leaned against the doorway with a beer and the vacant amusement of someone hoping a fight might happen. Even the fairy with the chips had stopped chewing.
Heat crawled up Clark’s neck as the kitchen seemed to tilt closer, every face pointed at him, every laugh waiting to happen. His glove tightened around the ladle until the plastic handle bowed.
’Please don’t make this a thing.’
But it was already a thing. He could feel it. One more sentence, and he’d become ‘that guy,’ the panicked host, the buzzkill in the bargain-bin cape, the weirdo who screamed about a fake finger and ruined his own party.
His pulse thudded in his ears, louder than the bass.
Marcus lowered the sword a fraction.
“Trust me, it’s a prop.”
Clark wanted to believe him. God, he wanted to believe him so badly he could feel it forming from pure survival instinct.
For the rest of this contest entry you need a
Registration + Paid Premier Membership
If you have an account, then please Log In
with a Free Account (Why register?)