More Than Time Can Heal a Broken Heart (a Memory)
Copyright© 2026 by BethanyBelow
Chapter 51: Oh Shit
True Story Sex Story: Chapter 51: Oh Shit - This is a SLOW BURN story with the real sex only in the last 1/3 though some masturbation in earlier parts. While graphic the sex is very vanilla. This story focuses on when I was newly 18, inexperienced & insecure and my boyfriend of 4 years dumped me. The main purpose is to give those of you reading my Infidelity/Cheating series some background on me. This can be read as a stand alone. It is also not necessary to read this in order to enjoy my Infidelity/Cheating series.
Caution: This True Story Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual Heterosexual True Story Oral Sex
We pulled into the driveway, and both cars were there. Kevin’s. More importantly, Carrie’s. The search-party joke from ten minutes ago stopped being a joke and became a driveway.
“Oh shit,” I said.
“Oh shit,” Andrew said, almost on top of me.
Then we both laughed, the short, helpless kind you laugh when the universe has decided to be funny at your expense and you cannot even be mad at it yet.
It was just after eight thirty. Carrie was supposed to work until ten. She had gotten off early. Of course she had gotten off early and the afternoon had been too lucky to hold its shape all the way to the porch.
Andrew took my bag. I took my purse and the other bag, the one with makeup and toiletries and the curling iron I had grabbed like a person who still thought hair was the problem we were walking into. We went up the walk wearing the same stupid grin. I could feel mine on my face, and I could see his on his, and I knew, with a clarity that would have been useful an hour earlier, that anyone with half a brain was going to read that look the second they saw it. It was the grin of people who had done something they probably should not have done and had so much fun doing it that their mouths had not gotten the memo to lie.
The front door opened on voices. Carrie’s first, loud, already in the living room, already mid-argument with the two people who had raised her.
“Well, doesn’t it concern you that they have been gone for over four and a half hours and you have not heard from them? It should have taken no more than an hour. Forty-five minutes with the way Beth dresses.”
Sue, milder, the way Sue always was when Carrie was trying to turn a kitchen into a courtroom.
“I am sure they are fine, sweetie. Maybe they stopped for ice cream or something.”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.