Poly... What? Book 1
Copyright© 2026 by Wolf
Chapter 25: More of the Toga Party
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 25: More of the Toga Party - Luke’s marriage and life ignites when wife Ellie proposes open marriage and polyamory. He suspects her interest in coworker Darren, meets his wife Megan, and their adventures in poly soon begin with many surprises as others join in. The growing group likes teasing and making love together in one space. Luke and Ellie navigate awkward situations, emotions, love, and exceptional pleasure. Book 2 already posted at Zbookstore.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual BiSexual Heterosexual Fiction Humor Sharing Wife Watching Group Sex Polygamy/Polyamory Swinging Anal Sex Cream Pie Double Penetration Exhibitionism Masturbation Oral Sex Sex Toys Voyeurism
Still holding onto Amber, I dug into my toga and took a business card out of my wallet that also had my home address and contact number on the back. I presented it to the luscious co-ed that I’d just spent a romantic hour with making love and eliciting orgasms from her. “Here’s my contact information. Please come and hang out. Daytimes during the week, we work, but otherwise, come. We’re very welcoming.”
Amber pulled away slightly to look up at me as her sadness waned, checking on my sincerity. As though my invitation and the card were a hot iron, she gingerly took the card and looked at both sides. “Really?”
“Yep, really. I need to warn you that we live a crazy lifestyle, particularly on the weekends and on most nights – very sexual. I occasionally work some evenings, or I might have a date, but there’s always good company around.”
We dressed in our togas, and I steered Amber to the door and out into the hallway. “Come on. I want to walk around the house. I’m supposed to be a chaperone.” We went up one level and walked down the dimly lit hallway flanked by the doors to various study rooms. I was making sure things were hunky-dory. I tuned into the sounds coming from each room when I couldn’t look in. I noted that most doors were ajar, and when I could see inside there were one or two couples making out or fucking like civilization depended on it. Nudity seemed to prevail.
About the sixth room down the hall, I heard my wife’s voice urging someone to ‘Go, go, go faster, harder, deeper’. She was emphatic in her usual manner. I chuckled and muttered to Amber, “There’s my wife.” I peeked in the doorway, holding the door further open so Amber could investigate the dimly lit room and see Ellie in action.
Ellie was riding one young man’s body with his cock deep in her cunt and her full breasts flying around. When she could, she sucked on another ‘brother’ who was standing on the bed so that his cock was available to her mouth at the right level. All of them were naked, and Ellie looked happy and busy. I wondered what else she’d been up to before setting up the M-M-F session.
Amber frantically poked at my side and pulled me away from the door and back along the hall. When we got to the top of the stairs, she said in a near hysterical tone, “You have a WIFE? You’re married? How...”
I interrupted, “Oh, yeah. We’re in an open marriage. Her idea, really. You shouldn’t worry. It’s cool.” I gestured back at the room where Ellie was fucking up a storm.
Just then, Erin appeared partly clad in her toga costumer from inside one of the other rooms nearby. I hadn’t seen her before. She saw me, planted a long, hot kiss, and sashayed down the stairs towards the loud music and keg party going on. A young man who looked sated and worn out joined her without saying anything.
I told Amber, “That’s Erin – she lives with Ellie and me – intimately; like a second wife. She’ll graduate in May. She’s one of the eight women that I have that kind of relationship with.”
“She looks so young. What’s her major?”
“Not from here; she’s about to graduate from her high school in town. She wants to start here in the fall, though; probably as a computer science major.”
“Holy shit, you mean you live with two women – and one is a wild, hot high school babe, and the other is gorgeous and down the hall fucking two guys?”
I nodded.
Amber did a huge eye roll and added, “You may be the most interesting person that I’ve ever met. I want to meet Ellie and Erin when they’re not in party mode; especially if they’re part of your open marriage and whatever else you were referring to. I’m serious when I say that I want to get on your wagon. You have other friends besides your wife and Erin though.”
“Oh, yes, our loving group of friends – around twenty of us. If you like to be romantic and intimate, you’d love our Saturday parties. Half our group is here tonight, so the friends that didn’t come are having a smaller sex party on their own.”
Amber again rolled her eyes, “I think there are about a thousand things that you haven’t told me about you and your friends, and I want to know every detail.” She shook her head in disbelief at the relationships with Ellie, Erin, and the others that I’d just told her about in a superficial way. The emphasis in my comments had obviously been on the sexual side. I was still teasing.
I’d become enthusiastic about the pretty co-ed and could see her as a great addition to my life and to our regular group. She was very pretty – beautiful, had sparkling eyes and perky breasts, an outgoing and winning personality, and was a unicorn – a young woman that loved sex.
Amber jumped up and down, “Yes, yes. I want to come to your Saturday parties. Next Saturday even and maybe all the Saturdays after that. If there’s sex involved, I’m your girl. Remember, I’m the slut – and that didn’t seem to bother you.” She then stopped suddenly to see how I’d reacted to her remark.
I chuckled as we stood there watching other party goers flow in and out of various bedrooms in the hallway. Occasionally, one or two would appear naked, especially if they were headed to the communal bathroom on that floor.
I had a lewd thought. “Amber, I have a request and a challenge for you. I’m still worked up and would like to engage with another co-ed or two at this party. I’m super horny – a perpetual state you’ll find as you get to know me better. I want you to match me up with someone that you choose – a cool friend even. I’m not forgetting you, I just want some variety tonight.
“My challenge for you includes finding a guy that you like so that you can join us – fucking alongside and even trading partners. Can you do those things? Is that too much of a request? Too bold?”
Amber nodded enthusiastically. She said, “Wait here and promise that you won’t go off with anybody else.” I agreed.
Amber raced down the stairs towards the loud music making the entire house throb. Hell, the entire neighborhood. I patrolled the hall again and took a seat. I noted for the first time that the TV had some porn playing on it in an endless loop. After a few minutes, Ellie emerged from the room she’d been in and strolled down the hall with a towel over her bare shoulder. Her male friends were close behind. The three were naked. Ellie had a zip in her step, so I knew she was up for more of the same.
Amber ran up the stairs followed by an equally gorgeous co-ed and a handsome young man that was about two-inches taller than me but nowhere near as muscular. They were in togas and had grins on their face as though they were the Cheshire cat in Alice in Wonderland.
“Luke, this is Molly and Mark. Molly is my roommate at the sorority house. Mark is a PTR brother and an occasional fuck buddy for both of us.”
I shook Mark’s hand and surprised him. “I recognize you. You were at the beach with Brad and Martyn a few months back when they met Ellie and Ally – the sisters. You should have come over to meet the rest of the group we had there that day.”
He looked at me more closely and grinned. “I hear they did well with the friendships that developed. They’re kind of cagey about talking about it, but we can tell that they still see those girls. I saw Brad with Ellie here earlier but didn’t get a chance to talk to her.”
“Ally is around here somewhere, too, only not as Martyn’s date. He brought anoher friend of mine – Erin.”
Amber jumped up and down a little. “I told them about how fabulous you were when we had sex. You’ve got to do some of the same things to Molly, and show Mark so that if you’re not around, he can replicate some of your trademark moves. You should teach a course in your brand of sex.”
I laughed, “Now, there’s an introduction that makes expectations so high that they’ll never be met.” I shook Molly’s hands as Amber babbled on about my challenge to her. I made polite small talk with Mark and Molly about majors and their course work. He was an ME. Amber and Molly were sophomores and hospitality and communications majors, respectively.
Amber herded us back to the room that the two of us had used. I asked whether anybody had ‘paper’. I could have asked Amber earlier but hadn’t. Each of them produced their cellphone from inside their togas, and as we paused in the hallway, we showed that we were all clean coming into the party. Good, we could go bareback.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.