Chapter 17: Surprise!

Jake and Anna hosted the Saturday evening get-together next door to Ellie and me. Steve and Sophia were not in attendance because her parents were visiting and they had to be attentive to them. Sophia made me laugh when she teased me on the phone, “I just can’t bring myself to tell them that I’m going to be missing a fuck party.”

As we suggested, Penny showed up a few minutes early at our house. She was properly and sparsely dressed in a tight blouse, a micro skirt, and CFM heels, as Ellie and Ally had suggested. Ellie was her mentor for the evening, at least to get her started and answer any ongoing questions of a female nature. I did the same for Martin and Brad.

Several guests stripped and went in Jake’s pool au naturel. I saw a short conversation between Penny and Ellie, and then Penny doffed her clothes and plunged into the pool with a graceful dive at the deep end. She had her eye on Greg who was in the pool as an available male. She’d met everyone and established a rapport with the group.

Brad and Anna had formed as a couple over dinner at my instigation. Brad was smart and would catch on quickly, but Anna’s IQ probably doubled his. He was temporarily speechless about the match-up because of Anna’s beauty, flirty nature and hyper-horniness. She made it clear upon meeting him that she ‘wanted to be with him’ that evening. She liked new meat and Jake had already blessed the event.

Martyn formed a friendship with the older Stacy. I’d coached Brad and him about how to form couples over dinner, so they’d have a friend to start the erotic part of the evening. Megan claimed me. She’d been naked in the pool.

Everyone stayed outside that evening, taking advantage of the warm evening temperatures and the comfortable chaises. I detected an aura of awe from both Brad and Martyn as the making out and sex started. They slid into the romantic sex with their partners without effort. I had prompted them to be exceptionally oral, and each put their cunnilingus skills to the test as they started off.

Greg put Penny on display by using Jake and Anna’s massage table – a surprise given that she was a newbie. The table was under a low wattage spotlight, so while not glaringly obvious they were highlighted as sexual entertainment for the others scattered about on chaises on the patio that were not highlighted by specific lights. Penny was more of an exhibitionist than I realized.

Since there was one additional man, some interesting doubles formed of the M-M-F variety. Cole joined Ellie and Darren, and the two men and my wife put on their own interesting show, with Ellie rapidly becoming a pile of orgasming, female mush on the outdoor mattress they’d used as their love nest.

Given the cars parked on the street and the aroma of barbecue that permeated the block, I’m sure the neighbors knew that a party and cookout was underway at Jake’s. After nine p.m. the laughter and conversational overtones they might have heard gave way to loud moaning, the slapping together of bodies making love, and occasional groans or shouts of glee and orgasms by both men and women. Those same sounds came from my backyard when Ellie and I hosted the parties.

I discounted any concern about the volume of our sex party sounds, and continued with Megan, took a rest and swim, and then Anna asked me to make love to her on the massage table. Anna was noisy when she was with the right man. I was an exhibitionist at heart, so the two of us put on a little show that started with me going down on her for a long period and then the two of us in a ‘69’. Every orgasm, and there were many, resulted in a shriek of glory that couldn’t be mistaken for anything but what it was.

Anna and I eventually came up for air after my orgasm, that I’d synched to the last one she had with me that evening. We cuddled on the table for a bit and then I suggested some wine. She liked that idea, so we dismounted from the table.

I helped Anna off the table, and we hugged to confirm the joy we’d just shared. We started to thread our path through the other chaises to the new bar that Jake had installed a few weeks earlier. As we walked amid the fucking and cuddling couples, I checked on Penny, Martyn, and Brad. Penny was riding my brother Jake; Martyn moved slowly in the missionary position with Megan; and Brad appeared to be finishing with ... someone I didn’t recognize!

I gasped, grabbed Anna’s elbow, whispered frantically, “Hey, who’s that?”

Anna froze mid-step looking at the girl – a teen and not a woman. Small – pixie like. Blonde. She then pushed me forward towards the bar, clearly upset. She whispered to me, “Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! That’s Erin, the teenage daughter of our next-door neighbors. I don’t know what to do. How’d she get here and start participating? I have no idea. Help. What should I do?”