Poly... What? Book 1
Copyright© 2026 by Wolf
Chapter 15: In for a Penny
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 15: In for a Penny - Luke’s marriage and life ignites when wife Ellie proposes open marriage and polyamory. He suspects her interest in coworker Darren, meets his wife Megan, and their adventures in poly soon begin with many surprises as others join in. The growing group likes teasing and making love together in one space. Luke and Ellie navigate awkward situations, emotions, love, and exceptional pleasure. Book 2 already posted at Zbookstore.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual BiSexual Heterosexual Fiction Humor Sharing Wife Watching Group Sex Polygamy/Polyamory Swinging Anal Sex Cream Pie Double Penetration Exhibitionism Masturbation Oral Sex Sex Toys Voyeurism
Monday morning after Ellie’s evening with Ally, Martyn, and Brad, I thought to ask, “So, what happens next with your dates?”
Ellie responded, “Nothing until Wednesday or Thursday evening, if at all. To discourage dependency or immediacy, Ally and I told them we couldn’t accept evening calls until then. We told them that calls at work were also not in the picture.”
I just nodded and thought that was wise of her.
Wednesday evening, however, her cellphone rang at seven-thirty. I could tell from the way she responded to the call that it was either Brad or Martyn. After their greeting, I sensed that the question was why Ally and she had kept changing partners when they were making out at the marina.
I heard Ellie chuckle and she came into the room so I could hear the conversation. She shushed me and put the call on speaker. “Brad, Ally and I are sisters, and we are libertine thinkers when it comes to the awesome subject of sex. We thought it would be fun and a novelty for the two of you to have blowjobs from two different women, plus all the lovely feels of our body parts that you seemed to enjoy from two women – well, we did, too. We like sharing and would do it again, given the opportunity.”
Brad’s voice said, “I told Martyn that it was something like that, but he is totally flummoxed by it, to quote the exact word he used – very British. I think that means caught by surprise, not sure whether he liked it initially, but he sure likes it in retrospect. I hope it was alright, but we compared notes and were very happy about our date.”
Ellie laughed, “Well, Ally and I liked it, too.”
“We wanted to ask you out again, either on a couple date or on a double date. You choose. We’d love to see both of you again.”
She instantly responded as I already knew, “Friday and a foursome. How about pizza at the Mellow Mushroom.”
“That’d be great, but ... I have another question that I probably should have asked first. Are you sure your husband is okay with us going on a date ... and making out and all. Neither Martyn nor I want to create an awkward or disruptive situation...”
Ellie winked at me as I nodded. She interrupted, “Yes, I’m sure. If you pick me up on Friday, I’ll even introduce you to him.”
“Errr ... that won’t be awkward?” Brad asked.
“Nope. He’ll find a female friend to spend the evening with while we’re out. Also, find a better place to make out than the marina. I’m not a contortionist like my sister. I think we’d both feel more comfortable being somewhere not in a car after dinner.”
“I will, I promise,” he pledged. “Text me the address. I’ll be there at six-thirty. One more question, will you have a curfew?”
“No curfew, but I need my beauty sleep.” She winked at me again, and I flashed her a thumbs up to indicate my approval at what she said.
The call ended.
Ellie then exploded my brain. “So, I’ll be on a date in two nights. I don’t want you sitting home alone thinking about what we’re doing. I want you to make a date with one of the honeys from your gym – an ‘outsider’ like we’re doing. Wine her, dine her, and show her what championship sex is like.”
I posed, “You plan on having full blown sex?”
Ellie slowly grinned and made a playful punch lightly on my shoulder. “Didn’t you ever get lucky on the second date?”
I teased, “Only with you, dear.”
I was ambivalent about asking anybody out for Friday. Thursday I was at my State Street Prime Fitness Center. I did some paperwork in the small office, watched several of our trainers with their charges, and checked out the women on the various machines.
Penny was one of the women who always flirted with me. She was a bottle blonde, somewhat older, obviously had some kind of professional job, and had been a steady customer for at least the past two years, since before I took over that gym. I hovered near her to see what would happen.
Penny came up behind me and put a hand on my shoulder. “Hey, there, handsome. Got time for an old lady?”
I laughed, “Old? My eye. You’re in better shape and physically younger than anybody else that ever uses this place except me ... and yes, I always have time for you. What did you have in mind?”
My acceptance of her flirt threw her off pace for a moment. “I’d like to see you,” she blurted out.
I replied, “The feeling is mutual. What are you doing tomorrow night?” I must have been putting out vibes about being available.
“Uhmmmm, maybe going out with you ... but, just to be sure, aren’t you married?”
“I am, but wife has her own date tomorrow. We have an open marriage. She even suggested that I find a companion for the evening. Seeing others isn’t a big deal for us and shouldn’t be for you.”
“Do you know the Oakridge apartments on Lemon Drive?”
I nodded. “Which one and what time?”
“Seven. Apartment 12. That’s in the middle unit on the ground floor. I have to buzz you in. Just so you know, I have a nine-year-old daughter, who you might meet. She’s cool with mom going out, so it’ll be fine. She stays with her grandmother a lot.”
“I was thinking dinner at Gecko’s or that Greek place on the main drag. You’re welcome to bring your kid.”
“Gecko’s is good. No to the kid, at least on this date. See you tomorrow. Casual, right?”
I nodded and we bumped fists to confirm the arrangements.
Brad was my height, dark hair, a clear voice, and a strong handshake. He was as nervous as a long-tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs. “Sir, errr, sir, it’s a pleasure to meet you, sir. Thank you for allowing your wife to join me for dinner, sir.”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.