Like a Good Neighbor
Copyright© 2026 by Rhiannon57
Chapter 9
Drama Sex Story: Chapter 9 - After losing his entire family in a devastating accident, a young man with money, strength, and no direction starts over in a new neighborhood. When he discovers the woman next door is trapped in an abusive marriage, he steps in to protect her and her daughter. What follows is a hard-won story of rescue, healing, chosen family, and building a future from ruin.
Caution: This Drama Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual
The rest of the evening went well, and we left close to twelve o’clock that night. We were home a little before one o’clock. I paid the babysitter and walked her home and then back. By the time I returned, both Shelby and Samantha were already in bed. I took a shower and dressed, then went to the living room to watch television for a bit. I was not tired. I fell asleep on the sofa and woke up when Samantha was shaking me.
“Jace, go to bed. It’s six in the morning.” she urged.
“Oh, shit, I fell asleep. That’s okay ... Let me make some coffee.” I replied, jumping up.
I went to the kitchen and started a pot of coffee. I asked Samantha if she wanted some breakfast, but she said maybe later. I could tell she was feeling a little down, probably due to seeing her husband the night before, especially with another woman. She was on the other side of the island, so I didn’t realize until she came around to grab a mug that she only had a t-shirt and a pair of pink panties on. I must have had a funny look on my face.
“What’s the matter ... Don’t like your sister-in-law’s ass?” she asked, smiling.
“No, no. From right here, my sister-in-law’s ass looks just fine.” I replied.
“I’m glad to hear that.” she giggled.
A short while later, Shelby woke up and was dressed much the same. Here I was in the kitchen with two sisters who were in their underwear. Thank God around that time Jennifer came in the kitchen rubbing her eyes.
“Jace, can you make me some cereal, please?” she asked, yawning.
“Yes, ma’am. Jump right up on your stool.” I suggested.
We stayed around the house most of the day on Saturday until Beth stopped over and asked Jennifer if she wanted to help her make pizzas and sleep over at her house. Jennifer jumped at the chance to go. She always loved to sleep at her grandparents’. Shelby packed Jennifer a bag, and she kissed us all goodbye and left with her grandmother.
Shelby and Sam ran to the store to pick up a few things, and I ran the heaters on the pool because they wanted to go swimming later. They came back with four large bottles of 1800 Margaritas in lime. I figured that they planned on doing some serious drinking. The only time I had seen Shelby drink was the first night we went to bed together.
They went out to the pool around seven that evening, but I was still halfway through a movie. Sometime after eight o’clock, I joined them, and they were on bottle number two. The two of them were giggling and joking around when I pulled my t-shirt off and walked to the stairs of the pool.
“God damn sis, that’s one fine man you have there.” Sam laughed.
“Why thank you...” Shelby giggled.
“Maybe you two should think about keeping the cap on that bottle there.” I laughed.
Shelby swam up to and wrapped her arms around me, pressing her firm body into mine. She put her lips on mine and softly pushed her tongue into my mouth. I kissed her for a second, then pulled away.
“Hey, what was that?” Shelby complained.
“We have company.” I reminded her.
“Uh, Sam does know we fuck.” Shelby giggled.
“Yeah, Jace, I know you fuck.” Sam laughed.
“This is going to be very bad.” I answered.
“Aw, come on, baby... you’ll be fine.” Shelby laughed, grabbing my dick.
The rest of the next hour or so was almost the same. Both girls had drank enough to have little to no inhibitions. Sometime around ten o’clock, we all got out and went inside, locking up. I took a shower first, then got into bed, turning the television on. Shelby took quite a while before coming in from the back to the bedroom. When she did, she was wrapped in a white towel.
“You took a shower in the hall?” I asked.
“Uh-huh.” she giggled.
“Are you drunk?” I laughed.
“No, not really. But I am horny.” she stated, her eyes locked on mine.
“I can fix that.” I replied, grabbing her hand.
“No, wait, I want to talk to you first.” she said, pulling away.
“Okayyyyy ... what do you want to talk about?” I asked.
“Okay, first of all, do you really trust me?” Shelby asked.
“Absolutely, not a doubt in my mind.” I replied.
“No, I mean really trust me.” she asked again.
“Of course, I do, baby. You know that.” I answered.
“Good, because I need to tell you something that I hope you don’t take the wrong way.” she started.
“Okay.” I replied.
“Remember when you asked me if I shared just about everything with Sam? You know that conversation about me cumming six times?” she asked.
“Yes, I remember.” I answered, curious as to where this was going.
“Well, I have shared everything, and I mean everything with Sam since we have been teenagers. When I was fifteen and Sam was seventeen, we started ... um, you know ... masturbating together. We would watch each other and get off. Then we kind of started touching each other, and one thing led to another. My mother knew about it and just told us to make sure my dad never caught us. It was not hard because we shared a room for a long time.” she started.
“Then once we started dating boys, we would tell each other about getting felt up and/or who we just made out with. I knew the first time she got fingered, the first time she got fucked, or the first blowjob she gave. She was older, so she had more experience than I did. Anyway, I wanted you to know that. I felt that I was not being truthful with you. I think the reason I am so comfortable with sex is because she and I started so young. And I think that is why I can cum so easily.” she finished.
The whole time Shelby was telling me this story, I could not help but think back to when I had the same experience with my sisters. My head was spinning round and round, wondering if I should confess to her as well. I mean, it was not that different other than I was a man. I guess I must have had a weird look on my face because Shelby started smiling.
“What are you thinking about?” she asked.
“I don’t know, maybe I shouldn’t ... I started.
“Jace, don’t lie to me.” Shelby said, grabbing my hand.
“OK, but I honestly never thought I would tell you this. Maybe three months before the accident that killed my family, I woke up in the middle of the night. When I was coming back from the bathroom, I noticed my sister Jessica’s door was opened a bit. So, I looked in for a minute, and she was playing with herself. So, I stood there and watched my older sister get off.” I started.
“I then went back to my room and immediately jerked off thinking about what I just saw. About a week later, Jessie confronted me and told me she knew I watched her. So, after some conversation, she talked me into masturbating with her one night. Then Jessie told Julia what we did, so one day when my parents were out of town, the three of us got together. A few weeks after that, the accident occurred.” I finished.
“Did you like doing it with your sisters?” Shelby asked, a wicked grin on her face.
“I really felt it was wrong, but it felt so good.” I admitted.
“So basically, your sisters taught you how to finger a pussy and give head?” Shelby giggled.
“Yes, guilty as charged.” I replied.
“Okay then, this is about to get so much better. Well, maybe...” Shelby promised.
“What do you mean?” I asked.
“What if I asked you to do something for me?” Shelby asked.
“What do you want me to do?” I asked.
“I want you to fuck Sam.” she answered, running her tongue across her top lip.
“Fuck Sam ... Come on, don’t be silly.” I replied.
“I’m not being silly. I want you to fuck Sam, then fuck me. Then fuck both of us.” she quickly shot back.
“You’re serious?” I answered.
“Dead serious... Sam needs to be fucked. She has not had a good cum in months.” Shelby advised.
“You don’t think this will cause a problem?” I inquired.
“Certainly not for you... You got two women to fuck.” Shelby giggled.
“Samantha is okay with this? I mean you have already talked about this with her?” I inquired.
“She’s probably in her bed right now fingering herself waiting.” Shelby laughed.
“Is this really what you want?” I asked.
“What the two people in the world that I love the most and my two best friends all in the same bed. Hell yes, this is what I want.” Shelby answered.
“Go get her then.” I instructed.
Shelby got up off the bed and walked to the door and opened it. I heard her walk down the hall and open the door to Samantha’s bedroom. I could not hear exactly what Shelby said but soon there were two sets of feet walking down the hall. Shelby came in first pulling Samantha by the hand. Shelby still had her white towel on, but Sam has a sheer tank top and white lace panties on.
Shelby brought Sam over to the bed and sat her down next to me. I could see Sam was probably as nervous as I was. She kept looking down at her lap.
“Sam is this what you really want?”, I asked.
“More than anything right now... if what my sister says is true you are about to rock my world.” she whispered, looking at me.
“Geez, no pressure there huh?” I laughed, causing both to giggle.
“How many times can you cum?” I asked, taking Sam’s hand in mine.
“I really don’t know. Brian would usually make me cum once then I would get myself off one more time a few minutes after because he could not get hard again. I once came three times watching porn on television while he was out of town.” she admitted.
“Jace, I want you to make love to my beautiful sister first. I want to watch the two of you.” Shelby whispered.
I reached out and took Sam in my arms and pulled her down on the bed next to me. Shelby walked around the bed and climbed in on the other side. I leaned over and kissed my sister-in-law for the first time. Sam was a very good kisser and soon her tongue was in my mouth. I reached down her body and slipped my hand inside her panties. I moved down until I felt a small patch of silky hair, then two smooth, very wet lips. I slowly ran one finger up and down her wet crease as she moaned in pleasure.
“Oh fuck, it’s been so long.” she whispered.
There was little doubt that Sam was probably not going to last long, but I had to try my best to make sure she did. I gently eased my finger inside of her as she kissed me passionately. I pulled out and began to gently rub her clit using her fluids as a lubricant. Samantha was extremely wet and very aroused. I pulled away from her mouth and looked into her eyes.
“Shelby was right ... you are good.” she whispered.
I looked over at the other side of the bed, and Shelby had removed her towel, and she was softly fingering herself as she watched us. I can’t even explain how exciting it was to see her do that while watching us.
I reached down and pulled Sam’s panties down and off her legs, tossing them on the end of the bed. I moved down her body and got between her legs, lowering my head until I was inches from her wet pussy. I reached up and gently rubbed her clit in small circles as she opened her legs even wider. I leaned in and tasted her pussy for the first time as she cried out in pleasure.
“Oh, fuck yeah...” she wailed.