Like a Good Neighbor
Copyright© 2026 by Rhiannon57
Chapter 18
Drama Sex Story: Chapter 18 - After losing his entire family in a devastating accident, a young man with money, strength, and no direction starts over in a new neighborhood. When he discovers the woman next door is trapped in an abusive marriage, he steps in to protect her and her daughter. What follows is a hard-won story of rescue, healing, chosen family, and building a future from ruin.
Caution: This Drama Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Consensual
Jennifer’s regular season was finishing up, and she was being heavily recruited by five large schools: Oklahoma, Clemson, Virginia Tech, Duke, and Arizona State. They were all trying to get her to sign. She also had conversations with Tennessee, Northwestern, Texas, and UCLA. Several schools had offered her a full-ride scholarship, and others were partials. I did tell her not to let money influence her decision, and I could cover the tuition with no problem.
She was still seeing Lance every now and then, but knowing she would be away for the next four years seemed to cool things off between them. I can’t say I was disappointed because I did not want Jennifer to make any bad decisions this young in life.
That Friday night, the three of us sat down and talked about what schools Jennifer wanted to visit. She was allowed three official visits before having to make a decision. Jennifer seemed to be leaning toward Virginia Tech, Clemson, and Arizona State. She had accepted a visit from Clemson and would leave the following Friday. And for the time being, she had put the idea of a medical degree on the back burner to pursue softball. Once again, I noticed that Kate seemed a bit distracted, and I’m sure that Jennifer noticed it too.
I dropped Jennifer off at the airport the following Friday at noon for her trip to Clemson. It would also give Kate and me some time to be alone, which I felt we desperately needed. Everything had become a little stale for us. I sent Kate a text telling her that I wanted to take her out later to have dinner at whatever restaurant she wanted. She told me where she wanted to go, so I called and made a reservation for seven o’clock that evening. We arrived on time, and the hostess took us to our table and seated us. We ordered our drinks, and the waitress promised to return.
The waitress brought our drinks back and took our order. She told us it would be about twenty minutes before our food was ready.
“How was your day, baby?” I asked.
“OK, still trying to catch up.” she sighed.
“You ever think about going back to the hospital? You seemed happy when you were in the ER.” I asked.
“I have thought about it... I didn’t have to worry about all the bills and salaries. But the hours were super crazy. I’m not sure right now which was better.” she answered.
“Only you can answer that, Kate.” I replied.
“Hey, have you ever given Sarah any more thought?” Kate asked.
“No, not really. Why would you ask that?” I inquired.
“I was just wondering.” she said, glancing away.
“Kate, is that what this is all about... You want me to accept Sarah?” I asked.
“Not really... I mean maybe a little. I don’t know really...” she answered, her voice trailing off.
“Kate, I will do whatever you want me to do. All you must do is ask.” I responded.
“I’m not sure really...” she mumbled.
“Kate, have you slept with Sarah?” I asked, staring directly into her eyes.
From the look on her face, I did not need a response. I knew that she had and it also hit me that Sarah was the reason that Kate had been so distant lately.
“I uh... yes, I have. You told me that you were okay with it.” she said, hardly able to look at me.
“Yes, I did tell you that. Only you should have told me. How long have the two of you been sleeping together?” I asked.
“Right after that time we all went out to dinner together.” Kate answered.
“So, what exactly does your relationship with Sarah mean? Is it just fucking or is it more than that?” I asked.
“At first it was just fucking... I’m not sure now.” Kate said, softly.
“You’re not sure about what. Sarah or me?” I inquired.
“She wants me to move in with her. Be in a real relationship...” Kate offered.
“Oh... I had no idea you felt that strong about her.” I answered.
“I’m sorry Jace... I knew that you were not crazy about her, so I didn’t ask you to join in. Then one thing led to another and now I’m really confused. She is open to a relationship with both of us if you’re okay with that.” Kate suggested.
“Honestly, I can’t ever see me being in a relationship with Sarah nor do I want to share you.” I replied.
“I’m sorry, Jace... It just happened.” she said, getting emotional.
“Kate, do you love her?” I asked, my stomach in a knot.
“Yes...” Kate answered, hanging her head.
“Wow... Um okay so what do we do now?” I inquired.
“You tell me.” Kate answered quickly.
“Well, it’s up to you. I do want you to be happy. If you want to move in with Sarah, then that’s what you need to do. I won’t stand in your way. It’s not what I want but... you need to decide that for yourself.” I offered.
“I’m just trying to figure out how to make everyone happy.” Kate sighed.
“I don’t think that’s possible Kate.” I answered.
I picked up Jennifer from the airport Sunday evening and we went straight home. She was telling me about the campus and the trading facility that she would use. She explained the entire program and assured me that everything was taken care of. I suggested she take at least one more visit before formally announcing her choice. She agreed and decided to visit Arizona State in two weeks. I did not say anything to Jennifer about the conversation that Kate and I had. I did not want to burden Jen while she was trying to make a difficult decision.
I put my relationship on hold with Kate. It made no sense to take her to bed if all she could think about was Sarah. She kept promising she would figure it out and let me know. I took Jennifer to the airport once again on a Thursday night and returned home. Kate was waiting for me in the living area.
“Jace, we need to talk.” she stated.
“OK Kate, talk.” I replied.
“Jace, I do love you. I need you to know that. But I’m in love with Sarah. I can’t lie to you or myself anymore.” she said, tears running down her cheeks.
“I understand Kate. You can’t pick and choose who you fall in love with.” I replied, feeling a bit sick to my stomach.
“Jace, I know you don’t love me like you did Shelby. I can see that by the way you look at Jennifer.” Kate stated.
Kate’s last comment made me very angry. I had to hesitate a bit before I said something that I could not take back. It took about thirty seconds.
“Kate, you’re better than that remark. Don’t you dare ever blame Jennifer for what you are doing. I love you the only way I know how. I realized raising someone else’s child is a bit unorthodox, but she grew up in front of my eyes. Jennifer is not the reason you’re leaving me and do not even hint that is why. You’re leaving to be with Sarah, period.” I replied.
“No, I didn’t mean anything by that...” she started.
“It’s okay Kate. So, what are you going to do?” I asked.
“I’m going to move in with Sarah after I talk to Jennifer.” Kate replied.
“I think it would be better for you to leave this weekend while Jen is gone. Then you can call her Sunday night and explain. Or meet her the following week after school. I don’t want her to see you leaving.” I stated.
“Oh ... Well, I guess I could do that. Would it be alright for me to use the Suburban to move all my clothes and things.” she asked.
“Sure, not a problem.” I answered.
Kate got up and walked over to me and leaned over and gently kissed my lips for quite a while. It had been quite a while since she had kissed me like that.
“Jace, would you take me to bed tonight ... One last time?” she asked.
“I really want to Kate ... But I can’t for two reasons. One, it would hurt too fucking much to actually feel what I am losing. And second, don’t go into a relationship with Sarah cheating on her already.”, I replied.
“You’re right Jace. Thank you.” Kate replied.
That Saturday morning, Kate moved out of my house in just two trips in the Suburban. She said goodbye at seven thirty on a Saturday night with one small brief kiss and my engagement ring in my right hand. I did not sleep well that night knowing once again my world had turned upside down. How was I going to explain this to Jennifer? Even though it was informal, she was once again going to lose the mother figure in her life.
I picked up Jennifer around noon from the airport, and she filled me in on the ride home. While she had a great time, she still preferred the Clemson campus. We arrived home, and I brought her suitcase in and took it to her room. I came back into the kitchen where Jen was going through the refrigerator looking for something to eat.
“Where’s Mom?”, Jen asked, her head still in the refrigerator.
“Kate has moved out, Jen. She won’t be coming back.” I replied.
“What the fuck?” Jennifer screamed, turning around.
“Jennifer, please, the language.” I said in a reprimanding tone.
“What happened?” Jennifer said, devastated.
“Nothing bad happened, Jennifer. She simply fell in love with someone else. It happens, sweet pea.” I responded.
“With whom?” Jen answered, crying.
“Another doctor she works with.” I responded.
“Wait, aren’t all the doctors that work with her women?”, Jen asked, surprised.
“Yes, they are. The lady’s name is Sarah. Kate will call you, and the two of you can talk.” I offered.
“How are you doing?” Jen asked, walking over to me and putting her arms around me.
“Not too good, but I’ll get better...” I promised.
Sacred Heart finished the season with a record of 35-1 and the number one seed in the state in the AAA classification. Jennifer had been untouchable pretty much all season and set a record for most strikeouts in one season. They were prepping for the first playoff game, which we would host because of the best record in our classification. As long as we won, we would continue to host as the home team. Jennifer had been extremely kind and considerate to me, knowing the situation I was in. In fact, a few times I had to be careful not to pull away and offend her.
I had not heard from Kate for a couple of weeks when her mother called me out of the blue. I debated whether or not to answer the phone, but I figured sooner or later this would happen.
“Jace, this is Laura McKinney. What the hell is going on with you two?” she asked.
“Nothing, Laura. Kate has decided to move on. She fell in love with someone else.” I answered.
“What happened?” she inquired.
“Nothing really... We never fought or argued. She just spent a lot of time with Sarah, and I guess it happened.” I responded.
“Jace, I am so sorry... I just don’t know what to say.” Laura said.
“I know the feeling...” I replied.
On Friday night, I got to the field about ninety minutes prior to game time and spent a few minutes with Jennifer before her warm-up. Apparently, word must have gotten around about my breakup because every girl on the team was around me and cutting up. I knew Jennifer was worried about me after all I had been in two failed relationships in a short time. With everything going on, I don’t really think losing Kate had sunk in yet. Jennifer, with college only months away, and me with the gym being really busy, was a distraction to say the least.
I returned to the bleachers and sat down on the Scared Heart side, waving to a few of the other girls’ families. One dad remarked that this team was really good and they would need Jennifer in a big way today. Jen had become a celebrity, and she very seldom ever disappointed.
Jennifer took the mound and warmed up as usual. She looked good, and she was snapping the catcher’s glove. She drove through the first three batters with a total of eleven pitches for the first three outs. The home plate umpire had a large strike zone, and Jen immediately took advantage of it.
Jennifer pitched an amazing game, striking out fifteen of the twenty-one batters she faced. I think she might have approached sixty-eight or sixty-nine miles an hour on several of the fastballs she threw. Working in the gym on her legs had definitely given her more velocity on the pitch. She was two for four at the plate with a single and a triple on the night. They posted a 6-0 victory and advanced to the second round of the playoffs.
After the game, Jennifer asked me if she could invite several girls over to spend the night at home. I told her that was no problem as long as their parents understood that Kate was no longer there. The last thing I needed at this time was a disgruntled parent on my hands.
I drove straight home, but it was about ten thirty when Jennifer arrived with three other girls. Jen had brought Katy Wills, Becky Thompson, and Rylie Hendricks with her. They were all starters and had played together since they were young girls. I offered them the entire house, including the pool, which they jumped at the offer. In less than an hour, they had taken over the backyard. I ordered three large pizzas for them and one large for myself.
I went to bed around midnight with all the girls huddled in blankets in the theatre room, binge-watching movies. They were very quiet and did not disturb me at all. I was up at six the next morning to knock out my early workout. I was back lifting heavy, trying to put on about ten to fifteen pounds. I finished my workout and went home around noon. The girls were just getting up after a long night watching movies.
All four of them were in the kitchen warming up pizza from the night before when I walked in. Of course, like young girls do, they all had to giggle, presuming I had heard what they were talking about, which I did not.
“Hey, Jennifer’s dad. How are you?” Rylie laughed.
“I’m good, Rylie, and you?” I asked.
“Oh, I’m really good...” she replied, laughing hard.
“Do you know you have been voted the hottest dad in the school?” Becky giggled.
“No, I did not. Why didn’t you tell me, Jen?” I asked, trying to be serious.
“Uh, maybe because I don’t want to tell you what they say about you.” Jen replied cautiously.
“Makes no difference to me, sweet pea.” I stated, heading for the bedroom.
About two hours later, Jennifer brought the girls home and then returned to the house, crashing in her room. She had not gotten much sleep the night before, so she was extremely tired, and they had practice Sunday morning.
I decided to go on another cycle to gain some size this time, using testosterone, HGH, Winstrol, and Anavar. I went on beast mode in the gym, training sometimes eight to ten hours a day. When I wasn’t lifting, I was training with the Muay Thai instructor or in Krav Maga. I blocked everything out of my life other than Jennifer. In just months, I was back up to two hundred sixty-five pounds and was as big as ever. I just pushed through it, determined to get myself into the best shape of my life.
Jennifer had an incredible senior season, and Sacred Heart won their second straight AAA State Championship. She was named to the first All-State Softball team as a pitcher and second team as an infielder. She was named Best Senior in the state and was ranked the fourth best pitcher in the country. Jennifer’s room looked like a college trophy room with all the awards sitting around.
Jennifer graduated with a 3.98 grade point average and accepted a full scholarship from Clemson. She had put her medical school dreams on hold to concentrate purely on softball. She left for Clemson in late July to get situated, and I took the trip with her. We set her up in the athletic women’s dorm, and I met all her coaches. Everything was provided to Jennifer, including three meals a day in the athletic complex. I did get Jen a credit card for any other expenses and told her I would pay the bill.
Once Jen left, the idea of losing Kate finally hit me. The house was so quiet at night, and sometimes I had trouble sleeping. Jen called almost every night, and we would talk for maybe ten minutes or so. She would tell me everything going on, but in part, I knew she was worried about me being alone. She did admit that her training and practice were beyond anything that she had ever been through. She lifted weights every day, hit hundreds of balls, and pitched hundreds of pitches. By the time she was finished, she was exhausted.
Several weeks later, I received a text from Kate. She asked me if I would feel uncomfortable with her and Sarah working out at the gym. I thought about it for a while and then replied that I had no problem with it. I was not a person to hold grudges or ill will against someone. Most of the world didn’t care about it, and most times, the only person who felt bad was you. Hating took a lot of emotions, and most of them were negative.
The following morning at around six in the morning, Kate and Sarah did show up. I was working legs and under the squat rack when they showed up. I had just finished a set when the two of them walked over. Sarah appeared to be extremely nervous.
“My god, Jace ... how much weight have you put on?” Kate stated, kissing me on the cheek.
“I’m pushing two seventy right now,” I replied.
“How is Jennifer?” Kate inquired.
“She’s great. She is at Clemson, but they are working her butt off. She’s trying to adjust,” I answered.
“OK, we’ll let you get back to your workout. Thanks for letting us use the gym,” she said.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.