The Coven
Copyright© 2026 by Phillip Marks
Part 5: Anna’s Choice
Supernatural Sex Story: Part 5: Anna’s Choice - A young man investigates a mysterious abandoned estate in his hometown and discovers a magical secret.
Caution: This Supernatural Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Fa/Fa Consensual Heterosexual Fiction Magic Light Bond Group Sex Facial Oral Sex
“There’s our girl, right on time,” I said as I observed Anna’s white Prius pull up to the gates of Nebelgutt. I was looking out one of the windows of the magical estate. Thriza was nearby.
“She knows quite a bit about us Michael. You’re whole method with this potential sister has made me a bit uncomfortable,” said Thriza.
I glanced back at my coven-sister. “We have to be of the world, Thriza. You’ve said that. We can’t just sit in our bubble and let history pass us by. You’ve said that too. If we don’t interact with people we will become irrelevant.”
Thriza sighed.
“I get it,” I continued. “Change is hard.” I squeezed Thriza’s hand. I had spent two hours with Anna yesterday at the coffee shop. I had told her almost everything about me and my coven-sisters. I had been fuzzy on some of the specifics but overall I had been very forthcoming. It was a different approach.
As we watched Anna looked around eagerly. She was wearing very tight jeans, boots, a white sweater and a blue winter coat. A white stocking cap hid part of her blonde hair.
“Can you teleport yourself out there Michael? Remember what happened last time?” said Thriza.
“Pfff! I got this!” I said. I focused myself, feeling the magical energy around me. “Motio, Mobilus, Transfero!”
I surprised Anna by appearing about three feet off the ground, right in front of her. I fell hard.
“Oh my God!” cried Anna. She ran up to me as I rolled over. “Are you okay?” She started to help me up.
“Aw, geez,” I stammered. “That didn’t work the way I wanted. I was supposed to appear outside your vision and on the ground. Dammit, I’ve got to work on that spell.”
“Well you did surprise me,” said Anna, forcing down laughter.
I brushed myself off. “I guess you’re interested?”
“Yeah,” Anna said. “There is some interesting stuff going on here. Sexual witchcraft? I’m intrigued.”
“Do you have any questions?”
“Yes,” said Anna. “First off is where do you keep the Mustang?”
“Oh yeah,” I replied. “There is a parking space. Cars go there magically. It’s under the estate. The Mustang is down there, we have a Honda CR-V Hybrid, and there is a gorgeous 1927 Minerva AF32 CV Sport Sedan covered in a tarp. I looked at it, started it up, and put the tarp back on after I saw it run. It’s in perfect condition. Nobody seems to know where it came from.”
“Very cool!” said Anna.
“Come on, I’ll show you the place and you can meet a few more of the ladies.”
“Sure,” said Anna, smiling.
I lead the potential witch into Nebelgutt. She looked around as we stepped into the entryway. As I had discovered months ago, this area was maintained in it’s early 1900s’ charm.
“Wow this is really Gothic,” said Anna. “It’s kind of got that vibe you know?” I helped Anna out of her jacket and cap, putting them on an old fashioned coat rack. “Wow Michael, you’re so gentlemanly.”
“It goes with the ambiance,” I responded. “This lower floor is just like how it was in the early 1900s. It has all the things you would expect from back then: a billiards room, a ballroom, and a sitting room. This estate actually belonged to the Rathmore family back in the day. Their daughter, Rayven, is a member of the Coven.”
“Yeah, I remember, I met her,” said Anna.
“Right,” I continued. “On the second floor there are some spare bedrooms. Then above that all the ladies have their rooms and I have a room too. The common area is on the fourth floor.”
Anna looked around more. “So it’s kind of like a dorm or a sorority house?”
“Well,” I began. “Maybe I guess. I can’t speak to the sorority house thing obviously but it’s certainly better than a dorm. I went to college, its better than a dorm.”
“Okay,” said Anna. “I went to the extension and did three semesters at a four year campus. I think I get what you’re saying though.”
“Lets go upstairs and you can meet some of the ladies again.”
“Will Sabrine be there?” asked Anna, a bit nervously.
“Yeah,” I said. I smiled at Anna’s nervousness. “Anna, it’s okay. Nobody will judge you here. You can be who you want and you can embrace whatever you want to embrace.”
“Okay,” said Anna. I could tell she was still nervous.
“Hell, there’s a whole torture chamber downstairs,” I commented.
“Really?” said Anna.
“Yeah you can talk to Franziska about it if you want. Michael doesn’t swing that way.”
“Intriguing.”
Anna dutifully followed me up the stairs. Thriza met us on the third floor. My coven-sister was wearing her hair long and had on a light gray sweater combo with a cropped top and a long curve hugging skirt.
“This is Thriza, she’s kind of in charge,” I said.
“It’s nice to meet you,” said Anna, offering her hand.
Thriza took it. “Well, I’m kind of in charge, sometimes. I hope to see you again Anna.”
“Me too,” said Anna.
I took Anna into one of the empty bedrooms. My coven-sisters had decided to dispense with the ‘witchy lingerie’ look and go with a little more contemporary style since Anna was a girl and not a guy. Rayven was waiting for us, sitting on a long couch. Her dark hair was loosely tied on one side and she was wearing stiletto heels, very light leather jeans, and a bulky black sweater.
“Hi Anna,” said Rayven.
“Oh hi!,” responded Anna. “It’s nice to see you again.” Anna sat down next to Rayven and I sat on the bed across from them.
Momentarily, Sabrine came into the room. She was wearing thigh high boots, tights, and a loose crop top. Her hair was long and it seemed to flash around her face. She was smiling wickedly. “It’s nice to see you again Anna,” she said. Sabrine sauntered across the room and sat down next to Anna.
“It’s nice to see you too,” said Anna a bit nervously.
“Oh fuck this,” said Sabrine. She kissed Anna. The new blonde girl, for her part, didn’t resist at all. After they separated I could see Anna calm down quite a bit. Rayven had laid a gentle hand on Anna’s leg. Anna returned the favor. The two girls smiled at each other.
“Okay, everybody is here. What kind of questions do you have for us Anna?”
Sabrine was rubbing Anna’s back very lightly. “So I would stay here and you would teach me magic?”
“Yes,” I said. “There are ten of us, nine girls and me.”
“Michael is kind of like our big brother,” said Rayven.
“And house sex toy,” added Sabrine, smiling.
I nodded, “Yeah, sure, why not.”
“I’m more of an alchemist,” said Sabrine. “Rayven and Thriza do most of the training. Michael is fairly new so he is still learning.”
“Yeah,” said Anna. “I saw that with a teleportation spell.”
Rayven looked at me smiled and shook her head.
Anna continued: “So I do yoga and photography-”
“You could still do those things. Maybe a couple sisters would like to try yoga,” said Rayven. “Michael still plays video games and goes to the gym.”
“And my job?” asked Anna.
“You could keep that but I wouldn’t recommend it. It would slow your training down quite a bit,” I said.
“That’s fine,” said Anna quickly. “I hate my job.”
“There’s room for your car too,” I added.
“What do you think Anna?” asked Sabrine.
“What if I say no?” asked Anna.
“Don’t say no,” said Rayven.
Anna looked at me and the two young women on the couch with her. She smiled. “I’m in!” she said.
Sabrine and Rayven squealed, throwing their arms around Anna. I let out a deep breath. Anna started squealing as well. As I watched the three young women quickly went from sorority girl excitement to kissing each other with deep passion. Anna didn’t hesitate a second and fully embraced her new sisters. In a matter of moments two sweaters and a crop top were on the ground. Rayven’s and Anna’s bras joined them a few minutes later.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.