Chapter 6

I didn’t expect my sister to suggest that I go completely raw dog and fuck her without a condom. I suppose I didn’t expect her to suggest I fuck her at all.

I was so pleasantly surprised by how this was all shaking out that I almost didn’t notice when Maddie said that she didn’t want me to “make her lick Eve’s jizzed-in-cunt.”

She had agreed to do whatever I told her, but there was no real penalty if she refused. She wasn’t powerless to stop me from making her lick Eve’s asshole if I wanted to see it. She could just say no.

My sister may not have thought about how it sounded when she said it, but I got the impression that I could do anything I wanted with or to Maddie as long as I ignored her smart-assed, sassy attitude. It felt like she was only fighting me to show that she was resisting, not to actually win.

I wasn’t sure why that was the case, but I felt like that was what Maddie was telling me between the lines of what she actually said.

That wasn’t really the epiphany. It was cool to think about, but the epiphany was that my sister had actual sex fantasies. She had dirty, filthy depraved ones like I did. I didn’t believe most girls were capable of that and I admired Maddie for being just as disgusting and nasty as I was.

As I fed her unlikely, humiliating scenarios I dreamed up on the spot, she was begging for details and using them to get off as much as she’d already used Eve’s body. I talked about super gluing her hands to her ass and leaving her out in the woods to find her way home. I talked about renting her out as a fuck doll to the Football team if they won a game. I talked aout putting chains in her cunt and tying her to an old tire and letting them use her for a tackling dummy if they lost a game.

I talked about making her my dog bitch and walking her on a leash, or renting her out around the neighborhood to fuck dirty old perverts. The filthier the idea, the better. Maddie seemed revolted but her pussy was dripping and she got so excited she couldn’t stand it when I hesitated to tell her the details of what I had in store for her.

She said “No” plenty of times, but she kept egging me on to tell her more and more about it like she really didn’t have a choice anyway.

My sister was like Eve in more ways than she wanted anyone to know. She let me whip her pussy, she’d begged me to fuck her, and she’d done as she’d been told. Sure, sometimes reluctantly, sometimes eagerly, but she’d eventually complied. I had to reevaluate everything now.

Part of me had been waiting for Maddie to get bored with the game or get too pissed off at me to continue, and she’d turn the tables on me. But now it finally sank in that she wouldn’t. She wanted me to win. She wanted me to use her, to degrade her, and even to punish her for being a brat.

I went back to our game with renewed confidence now that I better understood the girl who was my sister.

“Who said you’d eat pussy! I want to see you lick her ass!” I commanded.

Eve was quickly on all fours, her ass up and spread, dutifully waiting to be used and dripping wet. The eager crispness in her movements told me that she was into what was going on. I wondered how many families she served that had incestuous siblings like us.

I wondered if they were incestuous before Eve arrived and became a shared sex doll for them to play with together. I could imagine two brothers fighting over Eve’s use and eventually touching cocks for the first time while they were both slamming her.

I doubted that I’d be with Maddie right now, if Eve hadn’t been present. I certainly wouldn’t have just suggested we go upstairs alone. I knew Maddie wouldn’t have made that suggestion out of the blue, either.

Eve was the reason my sister belonged to me. If Maddie still doubted that her ass was mine, I was going to make her see that both cheeks and the whole in the middle belonged to me before Eve got shipped off to her next assignment.

I pressed the tawse deeper into Maddie’s cunt until the leather handle protruded like some perverse tail. “Lick Eve’s asshole clean, sis. Right now.”

“No. If I do, will you fuck me? Please? You don’t have to use a condom!” Maddie negotiated.

She’d gone from demanding to negotiating to begging, but something was still missing. I wanted Maddie’s full compliance, and I wanted it without her thinking she could control a thing. Her being free of restraints made her my sister, not a slave.

Maddie needed to know her place. Her place wasn’t to freely use Eve but to join Eve. I’d fucked Eve’s cunt because Maddie had manipulated me into it.

I’d come up here to fuck Eve’s ass, and I’d brought Maddie to keep Eve safe from Maddie getting carried away. Now that I understood my sister better and understood that my sister was projecting, I knew what I had to do.

I looked around the room for something I could use to bind my sister’s wrists. I grabbed them and held them behind her like I was going to break one arm and pushed her head down. “How many guys have fucked you at one time?”

“What?” she said as she moved her head away from Eve’s plugged ass. I pushed her nose closer to Eve’s crack.

“I need to know how many. When we are at school, I plan to break the record! I’ll give you to the entire football team if they win a game. You can lick all their assholes, suck their dicks, and then they can use you for tackling practice but never fuck you.”

“You are not really going to do that,” she insisted as if she were pissed that I was just roleplaying.

I ignored her.

I reached over her and unceremoniously plucked the plug out of Eve’s ass, tossing it to the floor without looking at it.

Maddie tried to keep her head away from Eve’s asshole, so I grabbed a fist full of her hair, and I pushed her down. Maddie resisted, but not enough.

“I’m not going to do it. You’re right for once about something in your life,” I said.