Chapter 3

Maddie was Maddie, my older Sister. She’s precocious, outspoken, sometimes a smart-assed bitch, hot as hell, popular, cocky, confident, and I love her as a sister and I knew she loved me as a brother even though we tease each other and bicker at times.

I’d always respected her because I’d always respected that she was Dad’s little princess. But she’s not my princess; she is my sister. I didn’t HAVE to allow her to get away with her shit even if Dad does. I could have told her what I was okay with her doing to Eve. I’m a full member of the family, after all.

I have a say – at least, that’s how I felt.

The way Maddie had asked if I wanted to double team Eve echoed in my head. Maddie liked the idea, and that’s what freaked me out! I did not expect her to want to fuck with another girl, much less involve me.

I initially suspected she might be testing to see if I’d go for it only so she could call me a weird, incestuous pervert. Yet, she was all in- nothing about her offer seemed like a trap.

Now that I’d thought about it and had figured out what was going on in my head, a plan came to me. Let Maddie help me with Eve, but on my terms.

I pulled up my pants, flushed the toilet more out of habit than anything else, and left the bathroom, returning to the dining room and collected my thoughts on what to do next.

Eve was finishing up by clearing the plates from the table. Her ass was really red.

“There you are,” Dad said with a smile. “Did everything come out okay?”

He asked it the way he usually did after I’d spent more than a minute in the bathroom. I rolled my eyes at his lame joke and decided to just come right out with what I wanted to say.

“I want to spend some alone time with Eve, and I want Maddie to join us. I don’t trust Maddie alone with Eve, so I want to be in charge.”

I wasn’t asking – I was telling my dad and Maddie how I wanted it to be. I assumed Eve had no say anyway – she was our toy.

“Hey, I’m older than you. I should be in charge!” Maddie complained without a hint of reluctance. I thought she might be a little coy about telling Dad our father that we were going to share this strange woman he brought home to train. She was calm and business-like as if she was asking to borrow the keys to his car to take me to the mall.

She didn’t balk about having sex with me there, though. I was shocked she wouldn’t at least make a wisecrack about not getting spunk all over her by accident or shooting my load too early.

“Dad had to warn you that you weren’t to damage her. That means he shares my concerns. Take it or leave it, sis,” I said, making sure I was leaving no room in my voice for argument.

I felt like if I waffled, Maddie would end up running things and laughing at my dick or something.

“That would be my decision, Luke,” Dad said.

“You said you have no interest in seeing any of us fucking Eve, but I don’t care if Maddie sees me, and it doesn’t bother me seeing her, Dad,” I reminded him.

“Well, you do have a point,” Dad mused with a grin. “If you two are cool with it, I am cool with it. Just don’t damage my merchandise.”

“Okay, I’m in,” Maddie agreed, surprising us both. I could tell she was waiting for a reaction from me, and when I played it cool, Maddie seemed disappointed. I think she wanted to shock me.

“Maddie, you know what Luke’s suggesting?” Dad asked my sister, as if he couldn’t quite believe he had heard correctly. He didn’t have to say the word incest – we were all thinking it. At least, I was.

We would be doing things to this woman together- but it was still odd for a sister and brother to share a partner.

I was with Dad on that. I’d imagined a scenario where I’d have to force the issue and probably make an enemy of Maddie. I was ready to provide proof of times Maddie had gone too far, had lied, had broken promises, all sorts of things that had made me resent my sister. Her just up and agreeing without a fight left me off balance.

“Sure, Daddy,” Maddie replied with her smarmy, perfect smile, like a happy poodle after getting a treat. She was all smiles and cuteness with him.

“What’s the big deal? Luke wants to be the big man in charge. So let him. If he tells me to do something I don’t want to do, I don’t have to do it. I don’t care. I’m certainly not intimidated by the idea of watching him screw Eve’s big fat ass. I might even be able to give him some pointers,” she said as if she was really the caring sibling Dad thought she was. “Just as long as he doesn’t hog her. I want a proper go at her too.”

Eve wiggled her butt quietly like an eager puppy that knows someone is about to take them outside for a walk.

“The two of you together wasn’t what I was imagining when I asked for help, guys. Maddie, you’re a fully developed woman,” he said, glancing towards Dani and Marie like what he wasn’t saying was, ‘compared to your sisters’.

Maddie ignored the unintended jab at her sisters who Dad had only an hour earlier called ‘old enough’. Instead, she took an unexpected approach.

“I’m not body shy, Daddy,” she said with a giggle. “If there’s anything we’ve learned being your kids, it’s that. I can’t speak for Luke and his slinky dinky peanut winky, but if he’s game, so am I.”

The look Maddie gave me was the one where she thinks she’s really got all the power. I couldn’t wait to wipe that smirk off her face.

As for Maddie’s comment, it could have been taken as a joke, but I knew she meant it. The bitch really was insinuating that I have a tiny cock and would chicken out of letting her see it. That only made me want to do it more! I wanted to put her in her place, but I couldn’t think of a suitably scathing comeback before Dad spoke again.

“You two being individually invited to fuck a consenting adult is altogether a different thing than teaming up on her,” Dad said, before pausing for a long time, deep in thought.

No one could rush Dad when he was thinking, and we all knew better than to try. That didn’t stop Dani and Marie from having one of their wordless conversations, and it didn’t stop me from stewing over Maddie’s insult. I finally came up with a zinger, and again, Dad blocked it by making his decision.

“You know what, guys? I’d be a hypocrite if I said no, so fine. But not until after you’ve both finished your homework,” Dad said, looking intently at Maddie, letting her know he was aware she’d slacked off before dinner.

At least Maddie had the sense to blush.

“Did you guys get your homework done?” Dad asked Dani and Marie, causing more blushing from the twins.

“Almost,” Dani replied.

“We still have some reading to do,” Marie added. I’d almost forgotten they were listening in to our plans for Eve.

“It was too noisy at Macy’s place,” Dani finished her thought, then launched into the drama that was occurring at their friend’s place down the road.

Between the twins switching seamlessly back and forth with their narration, we heard all about the distant neighbor’s home life. The girls claimed their friend’s Sister was screwing her mom’s boyfriend, and she’d found out while they were there.

Dad eventually took control of the conversation back after Dani relayed how her friend’s mom had told her daughter right in front of everyone that she was going to spank the living hell out of Barbie’s ass.

“I think it’s time we wrap it up about the life and times of the Petersons’ girls. I know I wouldn’t like it one bit if I discovered another family was sitting at their dining table talking about ours. Although that brings up a good point, guys. You all had a turn with Eve, and now I want to see Luke spank Eve like the rest of you did. Eve, Present to Luke,” Dad ordered without so much as raising his voice.

I was about to ask Dad what Present meant, but Eve had already risen from her squat and came around the table between Dad and me. Eager, enthusiastic and stepping lively to get to me from where she was without hesitation.