Fractured Hearts – the Wrong Way to Love
Copyright© 2026 by Dilbert Jazz
Part II – The Return & The Secret
Erotica Sex Story: Part II – The Return & The Secret - In a sweltering Kansas City summer, a mother and son cross the forbidden line, claiming every room in their home with raw, possessive passion. When the daughter returns and uncovers a decades-old secret, the family’s hidden lover reappears, drawing them into a tangled, defiant polyamory of guilt, desire, and unbreakable love. Facing judgment from the outside world, they choose each other—loudly, unapologetically—proving the “wrong” way can be the only way to heal.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa mt/ft Ma/ft Fa/Fa ft/ft Fa/ft Mult Teenagers Consensual Romantic Lesbian BiSexual Heterosexual Fiction Tear Jerker Incest Mother Son Brother Sister Light Bond Rough Spanking Group Sex Harem Orgy Polygamy/Polyamory Anal Sex Analingus Cream Pie Double Penetration Exhibitionism Facial Masturbation Oral Sex Pegging Sex Toys Squirting Tit-Fucking Voyeurism BBW Big Breasts Public Sex AI Generated
Sarah’s Return
The heat had finally broken a week earlier—replaced by a sticky, overcast humidity that made everything feel closer, heavier, more intimate.
The house on 47th Street had settled into a rhythm that was anything but typical: doors no longer locked, clothes rarely worn for long, every room carrying the faint, unmistakable scent of obsession.
Lisa and Ethan moved through the days like conspirators—stealing touches in the hallway, fucking quietly in the laundry room. At the same time, the dryer masked the sounds, collapsing into bed each night, too exhausted to pretend they weren’t addicted.
Then the front door opened.
The sound was ordinary—a familiar creak of hinges, the soft thud of a suitcase wheel on hardwood—but it hit like a gunshot in the quiet house.
Sarah stepped inside.
Twenty-two, fresh off a brutal breakup and the end of a lease in Chicago, she looked smaller than Lisa remembered—long dark hair pulled into a messy ponytail, oversized hoodie swallowing her frame, eyes tired but brightening when they landed on her mother.
“Mom?”
Her voice cracked just a little—relief, exhaustion, something fragile underneath.
“I’m home.”
Lisa froze in the hallway archway, heart slamming against her ribs for reasons she couldn’t name out loud.
The past three weeks had rewritten her body and mind; every nerve still hummed with Ethan’s touch, every muscle remembered the shape of him inside her.
Now Sarah—her daughter—was standing there, suitcase in hand, looking for the home she’d left behind.
Lisa crossed the space in three quick strides, pulling Sarah into a fierce hug.
The girl smelled like airport coffee, faint vanilla shampoo, and the same lavender body lotion she’d used since high school.
Lisa held her too long, too tight, breathing her in like she could somehow shield her from the storm already raging inside these walls.
Ethan appeared at the top of the stairs a moment later—hair damp from a shower, wearing only low-slung gray sweatpants, chest bare and still marked with faint red lines from Lisa’s nails two nights before.
He stopped dead when he saw his sister.
“Sarah?”
His voice came out rougher than intended—caught between surprise and something darker, hungrier.
She pulled back from Lisa, turning toward him with a watery smile.
“Hey, big brother. Surprise?”
He descended the stairs slowly, like he was approaching something fragile.
When he reached her, he didn’t hug her right away—just stood there, looking down at her upturned face.
Then he wrapped one arm around her shoulders, pulling her against his chest.
She buried her face in his shirt, inhaling the clean scent of him, the faint trace of soap and something muskier underneath—something that made her pause for half a heartbeat.
“Missed you,” he muttered into her hair.
“Missed you more,” she whispered back.
The three of them stood like that in the entryway for what felt like minutes—a tangled knot of arms and unspoken history.
The house, which had spent weeks pulsing with only two heartbeats, suddenly felt fuller—crowded, electric, precarious.
They moved to the kitchen because that’s where everything happened now.
Sarah dropped her suitcase by the island.
Lisa busied herself making tea, hands trembling slightly as she filled the kettle.
Ethan leaned against the counter, arms crossed, watching his sister with an intensity Lisa recognized too well—the same look he gave her when he was about to take her apart.
Sarah hopped up to sit on the island—the exact spot where Lisa had been taken apart so many times she’d lost count.
The granite was cool against her thighs through her leggings.
She swung her legs idly, oblivious.
“So,” she said, glancing between them.
“What’s new? You two look ... different.”
Lisa’s hand jerked; hot water splashed over the rim of the mug.
“Just ... settling into the empty nest thing,” she said, too quickly.
Ethan’s eyes flicked to Lisa—dark, warning, hungry—then back to Sarah.
“Yeah. Quiet. Too quiet.”
Sarah tilted her head, studying them.
Her gaze lingered on the faint bruise peeking above Ethan’s collarbone—a mark Lisa had left with her teeth two nights ago.
Then it drifted lower, to the way Ethan’s sweatpants clung to his hips, the obvious outline of him half-hard just from being in the same room as them.
“You’re both acting weird,” she said softly.
“Like, weird-weird.”
Lisa forced a laugh.
“Jet lag making you paranoid?”
Sarah shrugged, but her gaze sharpened.
She slid off the island, brushing past Ethan on her way to the fridge.
Her hip grazed his.
She paused—just for a second—close enough that he could smell her hair, feel the warmth radiating off her skin.
She pulled out a bottle of water, twisted the cap, and took a long drink.
A drop escaped the corner of her mouth, slid down her chin, and dripped onto her collarbone.
Ethan’s jaw ticked.
Lisa watched the whole exchange, pulse roaring in her ears.
Sarah wiped her mouth with the back of her hand.
“I’m gonna crash soon—long flight. But ... It’s good to be home.”
She looked at them both—really looked.
“Feels like something’s changed here. Like the air’s ... heavier.”
Neither answered.
She smiled—small, knowing, a little dangerous—and headed for the stairs, suitcase in tow.
When her bedroom door clicked shut upstairs, the kitchen fell deathly quiet.
Ethan turned to Lisa, eyes blazing.
“She knows,” he said, voice low.
Lisa swallowed.
“She suspects.”
He stepped closer, crowding her against the counter—the same counter where he’d fucked her senseless not twelve hours ago.
“What do we do?” he asked.
Lisa’s gaze drifted toward the stairs.
Then back to him.
Then to the faint sound of water running in the guest bathroom overhead—Sarah showering, probably.
Her voice came out soft, trembling with something between fear and exhilaration.
“We wait,” she whispered.
“And we see how far she’s willing to push.”
Upstairs, under the hot spray, Sarah closed her eyes and let the water pound against her skin.
She thought about the way her brother had looked at her—like he was starving.
Thought about the marks on his neck.
Thought about the way her mother’s hands shook when she poured the tea.
And she smiled—slow, secret, curious.
Home had changed.
And she wasn’t sure she minded.
Heightened Suspicion & Invitation
The house felt smaller the moment Sarah’s bedroom door clicked shut upstairs.
The kitchen, which had once been their private sanctuary of stolen nights and whispered filth, now felt exposed—too bright, too quiet, the air still thick with the scent of dinner and something older, more dangerous.
Lisa stood frozen against the counter, fingers curled tight around the edge of the granite, knuckles white.
Ethan hadn’t moved either.
He leaned against the opposite counter, arms crossed over his bare chest, the faint red scratches from two nights ago still visible under the overhead light.
His jaw was locked, a muscle ticking beneath the skin.
His sweatpants did nothing to hide the fact that he was still half-hard—had been since Sarah brushed past him, since her hip grazed his, since that single drop of water slid down her throat and disappeared beneath the collar of her hoodie.
“She knows,” he said again.
Voice low.
Rough.
Like he was testing the words to see if they’d break something.
Lisa swallowed.
“She suspects.”
Her voice cracked on the last syllable.
She looked toward the stairs—where the faint sound of running water had just stopped.
Sarah was drying off now.
Probably standing in front of the mirror in the guest bathroom, towel wrapped around her body, hair damp and clinging to her shoulders.
Ethan pushed off the counter.
Took two steps toward Lisa.
Crowded her against the island—the same island where he’d fucked her senseless not twelve hours earlier, where he’d whispered “Mom” while he filled her until she leaked down her thighs.
“What do we do?” he asked.
His breath was warm against her cheek.
His hand lifted—hesitant—then settled on her hip, thumb brushing the bare skin just above the waistband of her shorts.
Lisa’s pulse roared in her ears.
She could still feel the ghost of his cock inside her from the morning, the faint ache between her legs, the bruises he’d left on her hips that she’d traced with reverent fingers in the shower.
And now Sarah—her daughter, their daughter—was upstairs, possibly hearing echoes of the same sounds through the same thin walls.
“We wait,” Lisa whispered.
Her voice trembled with a mix of terror and exhilaration.
“And we see how far she’s willing to push.”
Ethan’s eyes darkened.
His hand tightened on her hip—possessive, almost bruising.
“You want her to push,” he said.
It wasn’t a question.
Lisa didn’t answer right away.
She looked up at him—really looked.
Saw the hunger there, the fear, the same twisted need that lived inside her.
“I don’t know what I want,” she admitted.
“But I know I can’t pretend anymore. Not with her here. Not with her looking at us like she already sees everything.”
Upstairs, Sarah stood in front of the bathroom mirror, towel knotted loosely at her chest.
Steam still clung to the glass, fogging her reflection.
She wiped a circle clear with her palm and stared at herself.
Same face.
Same eyes.
But something felt ... different.
She’d noticed the marks on Ethan’s neck the moment she walked in.
Fresh.
Purple.
The kind of marks that didn’t come from a girlfriend or a casual hookup.
They looked like teeth.
Like desperation.
She’d noticed the way Lisa’s hands shook when she poured the tea.
The way Ethan’s eyes tracked her—her mother—like he was starving and she was the only thing keeping him alive.
And she’d noticed the way the house smelled.
Not just dinner.
Not just laundry.
Something darker.
Musky.
Intimate.
She’d heard them.
Last night.
Through the wall.
The low, rhythmic thump of the bedframe against plaster.
Her mother’s broken moans—soft, desperate, pleading.
Ethan’s rough grunts—low, possessive, calling her “Mom” like it was the dirtiest word in the world and the only one that mattered.
Sarah had stood under the scalding shower spray, fingers slipping between her thighs, circling her clit while she listened.
She’d come hard—silent, shaking—hating herself for it.
And yet ... she couldn’t stop replaying it.
She dried her hair slowly, letting the towel drop to the floor.
Naked now, she studied her reflection again.
Her body—curves softer than her mother’s, breasts fuller, hips wider.
She touched herself absently—fingers trailing down her stomach, brushing the dark curls between her legs.
She wasn’t sure what she felt.
Anger.
Betrayal.
Curiosity.
A heat that pooled low in her belly and refused to be ignored.
She slipped into an oversized T-shirt (one of Ethan’s old track tees she’d stolen from his drawer years ago) and tiny cotton sleep shorts.
No bra.
No panties.
She told herself it was comfort.
She knew it wasn’t.
When she came back downstairs twenty minutes later, the kitchen light was dimmed.
Lisa and Ethan were still there—sitting at the island now, close enough that their thighs touched beneath the counter.
Sarah paused in the doorway.
They both looked up at her.
No one spoke for a long moment.
Then Sarah stepped forward—slow, deliberate.
She stopped between them, close enough that Ethan could smell her shampoo, that Lisa could see the faint flush still on her cheeks from the hot shower.
“You’re not going to tell me, are you?” she said quietly.
Her voice was calm.
Almost gentle.
But her eyes were sharp—darting from Lisa’s trembling hands to Ethan’s clenched jaw, then lower, lingering on the way his sweatpants tented unmistakably.
Lisa opened her mouth.
Closed it.
Sarah’s gaze moved to Ethan.
She lifted one hand—hesitant, testing—and brushed her fingertips along his bare chest, right over his racing heart.
He sucked in a sharp breath, muscles jumping under her touch.
“I heard you,” she whispered.
“Last night. Through the wall.”
Her fingers trailed lower—down his sternum, over the ridges of his abdomen, stopping just above the waistband.
She didn’t go further.
Just rested there, palm flat against his burning skin.
“I stood under the shower with hot water burning my skin,” she continued, voice barely audible, “and I touched myself listening to you fuck her. Listening to her beg for you.”
Her eyes flicked to Lisa.
“I hated myself for it. But I couldn’t stop.”
Lisa made a slight, broken sound—half sob, half moan.
Sarah’s hand stayed where it was—warm, steady, trembling just enough to betray her own nerves.
“I’m not mad,” she said.
“I’m ... curious.”
She looked between them.
“How long?”
Neither answered immediately.
Sarah’s fingers curled slightly against Ethan’s stomach.
Then, so quietly it was almost lost in the hum of the fridge:
“Tell me to stop,” she whispered.
“Or tell me what happens next.”
Ethan’s hand lifted—slow, shaking—and covered hers, pressing her palm harder against his skin.
Lisa’s breath left her in a shaky rush.
And the tension in the house, already razor-sharp, twisted tighter still—coiling, waiting, begging for the inevitable snap.
Heightened Suspicion & Invitation
The house felt smaller the moment Sarah’s bedroom door clicked shut upstairs.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.