Chapter 10

That was the wrong thing to say in Dawn’s position. They both sped up and pounded her violently. Their cocks swelled, and the most powerful orgasm made her wail. Her words would embarrass her later when they replayed in her mind, but she yelled, “Yes, yes, oh yes, fill me with your cum. Fill both of my holes with your hot cum.”

Nate launched first, his creamy load making him slide easily into her ass. She felt his balls pressed against her, jerking as they pumped out her husband’s cum. Jon cried out and injected her with his sperm. Dawn held her breath and focused on the two dicks, pulsing and twitching inside her body. That author had no idea how bad she really was.

Once the post-orgasm fog lifted, Nate rolled off Dawn’s back, and she rolled off Jon. Her ass and pussy tingled with lingering pleasure. Both of her holes leaked cum, and her stomach contained Jon’s first load. The three of them lay there on their backs without saying anything. Dawn suspected the men felt the awkwardness she did. She smiled and said, “Help me up.”

Nate and Jon pulled Dawn to her feet. She took three steps and flopped on the couch. Nate sat next to her and kissed her ear. “Thank you. You’re amazing.” He pulled her naked body against his.

Dawn felt like she should thank them, but she said, “You’re welcome.”

Jon gulped some wine and started getting dressed, avoiding direct eye contact. “Thank you, ah, thank you for dinner and, um, everything. It was wonderful. I’m gonna get going.”

She could tell it was awkward for him now that they weren’t all involved, and she completely understood, so Dawn didn’t try to convince him to stay longer. “Thank you for coming,” she said and giggled when her words replayed in her mind. “Twice.”

Nate put his boxers on and got Dawn’s bathrobe for her. They said their goodbyes to Jon without discussing what had just happened. Dawn hoped things wouldn’t get more uncomfortable later when the reality sank in.

After cleaning up the kitchen, Dawn went to the bedroom and found Nate passed out. “Figures,” she said and headed for the shower. It still felt like a dream.

Dawn came out of the shower spent, but she didn’t go straight to bed. She turned on the computer and logged into XN, instead. He was a complete stranger, but Dawn felt enough of a connection with Erotic Scribbler to update the story thread so he’d know how it went. Double penetration wasn’t according to his script, but the alternate ending hadn’t been disappointing.

The story wasn’t on the first two pages of the stories section, so Dawn searched for: A Dinner Surprise for Three by Erotic Scribbler.

Two results appeared: A Dinner Surprise for Three and A Big Dinner Surprise. Dawn squinted an eye, feeling confused or maybe too tired to think clearly. She didn’t remember Erotic Scribbler having any other stories on the forum. She chose A Big Dinner Surprise and scanned down through the text.

It was the same story. The plan, the dress, the dinner, then her heart started racing. She stopped scanning and started reading carefully. Her jaw dropped, and she wanted to be mad. He had written another version of the story for Nate.

In the alternate version, Jon confided in Nate, and the two of them came up with a different plan. They took Viagra, and there was the second double penetration scene. It all made more sense now.

Dawn considered waking her husband up and yelling at him, but what would she say? You jerk, you tricked me into doing something I wanted to do. No, she had a better idea and started a private conversation:

Thank you for the great story. Everything went according to plan.

I have this friend, Julia, and I was wondering if you’re any good at writing girl-girl sex that might turn into another threesome?

Just wondering.