Chapter 6: Josh’s Sisters Get Spicy

Katelyn had baited me with the comment about having sex with her brother to see how I’d respond so I figured I’d return the favor. I refused to rise to the bait and actually got ‘hot’ thinking about she and Fiona fucking their brother. I noted that the idea of incest didn’t bother me at all.

I told them, “Oh, that would be so nice. You guys love each other and already touch and kiss more than in many families. Just extend what you’re doing a little and bingo, you’re there. Josh is so thoughtful about making sure you cum. Have you guys ever done Josh, perhaps in a threesome or more some?”

Jaws dropped again, both at my casual attitude about their potential incest as well as at my suggestion of a family love in. I actually thought I wouldn’t mind a lesbian-like encounter with either sister – or both of them. Holy shit! Where had that thought come from? I was reverting to my college days when I roomed with Alex.

There was a long silence and then I could hold in my laughter no longer. I burst out laughing.

“It’s okay guys. You’re brother’s a hunk. Even though you’re related you can still lust after him. I bet half the women in Boston do and the other half haven’t met him yet. And, you don’t have to answer my last question.”

Both girls relaxed a little and grinned.

Fiona finally said, “You knew we were playing with you?”

“Of course,” I said. “But I still bet you think bedding your brother would be nice.”

Both of them nodded.

“Just put that on your bucket list. I won’t stand in your way. Hell, I’d even encourage it.” I gave them a devilish grin. I still thought the whole discussion worth a laugh. They acted shocked again.

After a long silence Katelyn volunteered in a voice just above a whisper, “I’ve had a threesome – actually a foursome – me, Carl and another couple we really like; we started a couple of months ago. We get together a couple of times a week actually.”

I looked at her with interest. I’d just learned a lot about Josh’s sister and more than he knew I was sure. Also, ‘a week’ sounded like a serious interplay between the couples. I thought of Josh’s philosophy about relationships and realized that Katelyn was probably putting all that into practice.

Fiona’s jaw was hanging open at her sister’s admission. Then a grin started to spread from ear to ear.

Fiona said, “Why Kate, you never shared that and I have about a thousand questions.”

Fiona paused and alternately looked at the two of us as she tested our receptiveness to her next announcement; “Well, let me tell you that Ray and I have a lover too. She actually lives with us and is one of my bridesmaids – Stacy.” She checked her watch and added, “Unless I’m wrong, I bet that Ray has his cock buried in her wet pussy even as we sit here. I hope they’re both enjoying their time together.” She grinned.

Now Katelyn’s mouth was hanging open and I think mine was too. Damn! This was a fun family. If this was how the rich people lived, I wanted to be rich.

Fiona went on, “I’ll tell you another secret. Stacy is going on the honeymoon with us. No one else knows so don’t either of you dare tell anyone. We’re all flying down to Puerto Vallarta on Sunday morning and intend to fuck each other’s brains out all week.”

Katelyn asked, “How long?”

Fiona answered as she reached forward and took her sister’s hand then reached and took my hand as well; “We fell in love almost two years ago. Actually Ray and I were dating then and one night Stacy needed a place to crash rather than drive home. We both knew her well and so having her stay over at our place was no big deal. One thing led to another and ... well, we all fell in love with each other. Ray will be my husband and Stacy my wife. Someday I hope we can make our triad legal; in the meantime we’ll just do what we do.”

I squeezed Fiona’s hand as a gesture of support and appreciation for her revelations.

“What about Josh? Don’t you want to share your story with him?” I asked quietly. “And Van?”

Fiona turned to me, “You find a way to tell Josh. You’re his girlfriend and understand him better than we do today. I’ll have to see about telling Van; he’s pretty wrapped up in his own life right now and wouldn’t appreciate what our relationship means – really means to each of us. I think he’s pretty conservative too and on the verge of evangelical, so to speak. We’d get a lot of flak.”

I nodded and wondered how and when I’d tell Josh.

Fiona turned to her sister and asked with a lecherous tone to her voice, “Now, Kate, tell me about your group experiences.”

Katelyn actually blushed a little and gave me a shy grin. I nodded to let her know I had great empathy with her situation and feelings. She started, “Carl and I have been friends with Beth and Doug for over a year. They live next door and had become our alter egos. Increasingly we kept finding we could share everything with them.”

She looked at us wondering if she should go on. Fiona and I nodded encouragingly to her.

“Anyway, one night they were over and we were going to watch a movie we’d rented. For some reason I felt mischievous so I went and sat with Doug. Beth held her arms up and Carl fell into them. The lights were low and soon we were hugging and kissing with our new partners as the movie played. The hugging and kissing became feeling and smoothing, and then our hands were under each other’s clothing, and then clothing started to come off, and then we made love to each other’s mate – right in the same room. It was soooo hot.”

“Was it nice?” Fiona asked her sister.

“Oh, it was beautiful. We were all together and naked, enjoying the sight and feel of each other’s bodies. I never wanted the feeling to stop but I also wanted Carl to be happy and I wanted to love him too. We all talked about what we were feeling and how we felt about each other and how we hoped our spouses were feeling. We talked until two in the morning and then made love with our new partners again, then we all slept in our big bed.”

“Did things look different in the morning?” I asked.

“I woke up in the morning being held and cuddled by Carl. He whispered in my ear that he loved me and it was one of those times when you know that love can move mountains. We hugged and kissed and then started to make love again, right next to Beth and Doug. They woke up and watched us then they made love as we watched.”

Katelyn continued, “After we cleaned up a bit, we all went downstairs and made breakfast. I can still remember than none of us got dressed; we were all naked. It had been a short night. We all continued talking about what we’d done and how we felt about each other. We realized we liked each other – a lot – and that the sex – making love – was really a confirmation of how we felt about each other. It wasn’t just lust, there was a lot of love there too. We made love again after breakfast too, and we’ve been an event ever since and that was over a year ago.”

Another long silence ensured then the sisters turned to me and Fiona said, “You haven’t told us about your threesome.”

I laughed at how off guard I’d been for her question, visualizing the scene of the foursome as she’d described the details. The sisters looked puzzled but I felt I should share this part of myself with them.

I started, “My story happened two boyfriends ago. My last boyfriend – before Josh – had an ego the size of a battleship and couldn’t have handled anything like this. Anyway, Wade, that was his name, and I were in our early twenties and as horny as rabbits all the time. I gather you guys have been through that stage too – or maybe you’re still in it?”

Both heads nodded enthusiastically.

“So one night, one of Wade’s friends was over at our apartment watching a baseball game on TV – a guy named Andy. It’s hot, we didn’t have air conditioning, and I’m running around our apartment in just a tank top and panties. Wade gets horny watching me and gets up and puts the make on me, running his hands up under my top and fingering my slit. I look and Andy is watching us and rubbing his shorts right where his cock is – and the bulge is evident. We’re turning him on.”

I paused and both sisters leaned in. Katelyn said in an urgent voice, “Go on!”

“I felt like being an exhibitionist suddenly so I pulled my top off completely. As you can see there’s more than a handful so I had plenty to put on display. Wade takes it in stride and starts to suck on my breast as I’m trying to yank his shorts down. I get Wade’s cock out so I can work it and then see that Andy is masturbating as he watches us. Next I knew Wade had two fingers buried in me and I am leaking like a faucet.”

“Without even asking Wade, I just gestured Andy over. A split second later I had another naked guy kissing me and sucking my breasts and I was in heaven. As they sucked on me, I ended up holding two stiff cocks in my hand too – very erotic to do that, I might add. Very empowering.”

“Someone pulled off my undies and then I had lots of fingers in my cunt and I got felt and licked all over. I must have cum a dozen times before the three of us ended on our bed. I can still remember I fucked Wade then Andy then Wade then Andy, back and forth. We went on for a long time – like two days taking short breaks for food and a little sleep. The guys’ recovery times at that age were a few minutes rather than hours, so I just about always had a cock inside my little cooter.”

“A one-time thing?” Fiona asked.

“I thought so that night but we got together about ten times overall. Andy was okay and I didn’t mind fucking him; he had size working to his advantage too. At the time I really liked Wade, so long as he was okay with what was going on, I was too. Wade and I then started to have relationship problems and ultimately broke up. We had sex after we broke up and stopped living together; we just knew there was no long-term relationship there. Andy joined us several times after we broke up. It was all lust by then, just the three of us satisfying our carnal urges and we had a lot of them stored up. Every time we got together we fucked all weekend, just like our first time together.”