Chapter 3

“What took me so long to do that?” Ally asked, still lying atop Dave.

“Well, there’s that unwritten rule about no dipping in the group pond.” Dave replied.

“Fuck that” Ally said, “but there no need to share this with them. I don’t want to deal with the wrath of the group.”

“OK” Dave replied “mums the word. From now on when we’re together away from the group you’re completely comfortable around me. You’re happy just hanging around with me nude and just hanging out. You’re openly affectionate with me when we’re together and you enjoy my affection as well. You love fucking me but know I’m not posessive of you. However, before you sleep with someone else you’re going to make sure I know.”

“What’s with the rules Dave?” Ally inquired.

“You’ll follow the rules I tell you but will forget that I told them to you. You’ll think it’s what you consider right. When we’re with the group you’ll act as you always have with me and give them no indication that anything has changed between us.” Dave replied.

“OK” Ally said, dropping whatever concerns she’d had earlier.

Dave had an idea then said to Ally. “Call your mom and let her know you’ll be spending the night here.”

“What about the monster?” Ally asked.

“You aren’t concerned if Darcy will be here. You also won’t consider her returning today. You’re going to just enjoy spending time with me whatever we do.”

Ally immediately relaxed. She called her mom and told her she’d be spending the night. This wasn’t all that unusual because Ally had often spent the night at Dave’s place when they got together with the rest of the group. Also her mom knew Ally was an adult and could do whatever she pleased. She trusted Ally and they had a good relationship.

Dave and Ally spent the next few hours playing some video games, having lunch and eventually going up to his parent’s room for some more fun. Dave was thoroughly enjoying himself as Ally was always available to him in whatever capacity he wanted. He kissed, groped and played with her whenever he wanted and she did the same. Dave really enjoyed their time in bed because it was very relaxed and comfortable. He didn’t feel driven to do anything in particular and just went with their flow.

Dave and Ally were up in his folks room napping when Darcy came back from the carwash. “Hey lover!” she yelled after coming in the door.

Ally woke with a jolt and frantically whispered to Dave “The monster’s back!”

“Don’t move” Dave said and Ally froze in place. “You’re relaxed and enjoying just laying there for now.

“Up here, Darce!” Dave yelled down to his step-sister.

Darcy made it upstairs and started saying “Hey” before entering the room, got to the door, saw Ally in bed with Dave and continued “dipshit, what are you and your loser friend doing?”

“Darcy, Ally is under my control too so you don’t have to act mean.” Dave said.

“Thank God, I’m not enjoying it like I used to. I’m even having difficulty keeping it up if you come up with my friends. I mean it’s easy for me to do, I just don’t like doing it.” Darcy explained. She looked at Darcy laying on the bed, nude and unmoving. “Looks like you didn’t miss me too much, have fun?”

“We’ve been having a good time. Just a minute.” Dave said and then turned to Ally. “Al, you feel completely comfortable with Darcy being here, being nude in front of her and doing anything I tell you to do as well. You’ll also feel comfortable and not bothered by anything I do with Darcy or anyone else. You can move and talk now.”

Ally sat up next to Dave and put her arm around him.

Although Dave had known that Darcy was returning and he wanted Ally there when she got back he hadn’t really planned what to do with them next. Now that he knew Ally was somewhat unsure of her sexuality he thought it might be nice if she had a chance to see what it was like with another woman. Even though he had come not too long ago his cock was starting to stir at the thought of Ally and Darcy together.

“You two are not going to remember what I’m telling you now.” Dave started “Darcy you’re going to apologize to Ally for the way you’ve treated her in the past. You’re going to realize the reason you’ve been so shitty to her is because you’re actually attracted to her but you’ve been jealous that I’m her friend and you aren’t. You’ll let Ally drive things, be open to anything Ally wants to do and will be accepting and sensitive to any sort of fears or reservations she has. Also you’re going to feel somewhat jealous we’re both naked and will strip down. Ally, you’ll know that you’ve always been attracted to Darcy even though the two of you are very different. When Darcy apologizes to you you’ll think that you’ve been judging her too harshly. You’ll accept she wants different things from life but you know you can enjoy each other when you’re together. Now both of you are going to start discussing experiences with each other and me. As you’re doing that you’re going to be very open with each other and accepting and you’ll also be getting more and more aroused as our discussion goes on. OK, we’ll start now.”

“Ally, I want to tell you how sorry I am that I’ve been such a bitch to you.” Darcy said with complete sincerity.

“Wow, thanks” Ally said somewhat shocked at the apology. “I think I might have had the wrong impression of what kind of person you are.”

“Thanks. How long have you two been, uh, enjoying each other?” Darcy asked.

“Well, I’ve had the hots for your step-brother for as long as I can remember, but I’ve always been too afraid of making a move because the group wasn’t OK with that. Anyway, after what you did to Dave on Friday I thought he might need some cheering up so I came over today to make him feel better.” Ally said.

“And did it?” Darcy asked, turning to Dave.

“Very much so.” Dave replied to Darcy.

“You two look so comfortable, mind if I get comfortable too?” Darcy inquired.

“Sure” Ally said

Dave sat back and watched Ally watching Darcy take off her clothing. Little things revealed her secret desire for his step-sister. Ally opened her mouth a little and stuck the tip of her tongue slightly out and ran little circles on the corner of her upper lift. Ally’s nipples got a little firmer and her breathing seemed to increase a little bit. All the while she was trying to keep her cool as Darcy revealed more of herself.

As Darcy finished up Ally let out a rather deep sigh. “How can I compete with that?” she said looking at Dave’s now nude step-sister.

“Do you know how long it takes me to end up looking like this?” Darcy asked Ally then answered her own question, “I need at least an hour before I can leave the house in the morning. I envy you Ally, you have a wholesome natural beauty that shows through even without much prep. I’ve seen you the few times you didn’t know I was going to be here after one of the nights you spent here with your group. Yes I knew I was a bitch those few times and sneered at you, but I was always impressed by your relaxed appeal.”

“If you’re talking about these”, Darcy said looking down at her tits, “I do have to say I like them, but do you know how much unwanted attention I get from creeps. I think if I had a choice, and knew what I know now I’d choose your chest over mine. You’re perky and look young and fresh. I’m willing to bet you’re going to look great long after mine start to get saggy and old.” “Whether you know it or not, you compete very well with me. You might not get as much attention as I do but remember you also probably don’t get as much unwanted attention. You’re also smart, funny and from what I can tell caring. I don’t think there are many people who think the same about me.”

“I’d like to start having you as a friend, or something more. Dave’s changed me and I have to say I’m feeling happier than I ever have before. I know I have a reputation to keep up to hide Dave’s secret, but even though it’s only been a day give or take an hour It’s much easier to live in my skin than it was before.”

Ally was impressed with Darcy’s observations, both about her and about Darcy’s own self. She also felt better about herself after what Darcy said. “Thank you” she replied, “you’re not so bad yourself now that I know you a little better.” She was also feeling more attracted to Darcy even though she didn’t know part of it was at Dave’s suggestion.

Dave was still too much of a control freak to let things progress organically. “So Darce, have you ever kissed a girl?”

Darcy sat down on the bed then answered “Several times with several different girls. We’ve had truth or dare games at the cheerleading camp and those usually end up with some kissing and more.”

“And more?” Ally chimed in.

Darcy looked at Ally with a compassionate and slightly passionate gaze and replied, “I’ve squeezed a few tits, had my tits squeezed, sucked a few nipples, had mine sucked, touched someone down there and been touched down there by someone. Most of the times were at all girl events, but sometimes when we’re partying with the guys they’ll come up with some lame douchebag jock games to get us girls to show off for them. At the mixed parties we’re performing for the guys, at the all girl gatherings sometimes it’s more than acting. How about you?”

Ally looked a little bit uncomfortable at becoming the focus of attention, “Well, I’ve always been in a mixed group so I haven’t really had any all girl things. I’ve always been somewhat one of the guys so I don’t have a lot of female friends. I think I’m afraid I might be more interested in girls than I thought I was. I haven’t really been ready to realize that until now.”

“So you’ve had feelings for girls?” Darcy pushed further.

“I’d call them more twinges than feelings. Sometimes I’ve wondered what it might be like to kiss some girls but it really hasn’t gone beyond that.” Ally replied.

“That’s OK,” Darcy said, “I’m sure you’ll do something if it feels right and is the right time for you. I’ve definitely enjoyed playing with other girls, but never wanted to go beyond that. The cheerleading community isn’t that lesbian or bi positive and I didn’t really want to try anything that could negatively affect me there.”

Dave was sitting back watching Darcy and Ally talking. He was picking up on little clues that they were both getting more and more excited. Both of them had fairly erect nipples. Also both of them were fidgeting slightly as if repositioning themselves would scratch an itch they were feeling. Dave was also noticing that Ally’s heartbeat and breathing were getting faster.

Ally wanted to change the subject even though she felt comfortable. “How long have you and Dave been this comfortable around each other this way?” she said pointing out Dave’s nude body.