Chapter 6: Choosing a Dick

Someone yelled out, asking who wanted to be fucked first. Mary Beth just laughed and answered for us. “Sorry guys, just girls for the two of us.” Then she pointed at me, “Now Kelly is a different story but you’ll have to convince her you’re sponge-worthy!”

I couldn’t believe she said that! Basically she just invited them to fuck me! It really wasn’t a problem as I was so horny by then I wanted it anyway but still, it felt strange being volunteered like that. Oh well, a hard cock was just the thing I really needed about then so I wasn’t going to complain if one appeared. Everyone started to cheer and yell, urging me to fuck someone. I stood up in front of them, naked and my face covered with pussy juice. It felt so wild to stand there like that, totally nude and having all those guys looking at me, each of them dying to fuck me.

“Well, who wants to fuck me?” I called out. Naturally everyone raised their hands so I just laughed. “If you really do then show me your cock so I can pick out the best one.”

Normally cock size and look wasn’t a big thing for me but tonight was different. If I was going to be fucked in front of all these people then at least I was going to have a big cock for my trouble. Six guys came forward and started to unzip their pants. Well, they weren’t going to get off that easy!

“Not so fast!” I scolded them, “I want nudity, total depravity. Strip it all off if you want to be in the running.”

A couple of guys weren’t too sure about it and moved back leaving four guys. Sure enough, they stripped and in just seconds I had four naked guys standing in front of me, their limp cocks hanging down waiting for me. I’d figured that anyone willing to strip in front of everyone would be built pretty well and they didn’t disappoint me. All four were hunks - athletic looking and all had nice looking cocks. I paced back and forth in front of them.

“Wow, this is a tough decision. I guess I’ll just have to sample the selection in order to make a choice!”

I knelt in front of the first guy and took his cock in my mouth. Now I hadn’t had a cock in my mouth for almost two months and damn, it tasted so good! I sucked on it for a few minutes and it quickly hardened. I could’ve sucked it a lot longer but there were more to try. Moving to the next two, each of them also had great tasting cocks and I was loving the taste of them. So far I would have said the first three were better than average in terms of size and taste and any one of them would have been OK with me so I was wondering how I was going to choose just one.

When I got to Number Four, he was still soft and so I easily took him all in my mouth. I love the feel of a soft cock when I start sucking a guy, then have it harden in my mouth as I get him off. There is just something about knowing that I can have that kind of effect on a guy that makes me feel so hot and sexy inside. Well, he started to harden quickly and I was amazed and thrilled - my God he was getting huge! I’d never seen a cock grow that much before! I looked up and he was smiling, obviously he knew what he was packing and he realized I was loving it.