Chapter 14

They were both still naked, as they sat around the pool drying off from their dip and subsequent oral play. Corey sat up, intrigued by what Tina had come up with. It couldn’t be that weird, could it? She was a secret little nymphomaniac but was generally more reserved when it came to the crazy stuff. He turned to his girlfriend and nodded as he waited intently for what she had to say.

“We agree that we can’t keep lying to Addie, right?”

“Right...” Corey agreed, uncertain where she was going.

“And she’ll be mad if she finds out that’s what we’ve been doing, right?”

“Right again, where are you going with this?”

“Just follow along, ok?” Tina asked. “Addie likely feels jealous about us dating and doesn’t have a boyfriend of her own, so she can do these things too. She should experience things with someone who really loves her.”

Corey could already see the threads of where this was leading, and he couldn’t believe it. There was no way in hell Tina was about to suggest what he thought she was going to say. The gears in his mind now spun wildly as he listened to her continue.

“What if, and don’t get mad, what if she experienced it with you.” Tina’s eyes examined Corey’s blank expression. She wasn’t sure if her words had landed with him or not. She couldn’t read him at all. He just looked like his brain had melted.

In Corey’s mind, though, as each word came out of his girlfriend’s mouth, he saw a way out of his precarious but pleasurable situation. It seemed so simple, so elegant, and fun, but he never thought in a million years Tina would be the one to suggest it. He knew he had to make this happen somehow. He had to play his cards just right, or else the whole thing would topple over. First, he had to pretend to reluctantly agree with Tina without suspicion.

“Wait ... how does this help? You want me to ... what exactly?” Corey replied as sincerely as he could.

“I know this sounds insane but, if Addie thinks I lost my virginity at the same time she does, there’s no reason for her to be jealous. We’d know the truth, but she’d think we all did it together.”

“So, you want us to have a threesome ... with my sister?” He said it slowly, as if he was still not comprehending it.

“Well, no. You’d take one of us, and then the other once you’ve recovered. I don’t think Addie and I would do anything together.”

Corey desperately wanted to see that, but he knew, at the moment, there were more important things to deal with. It didn’t mean he couldn’t try to swing that the day of if he could come up with a plan or something. He was already having to think on his feet about this, no reason to get too greedy yet.

Corey continued to play up his confusion and reluctance of this plan. “Just so we’re clear, you want me to have sex with my own sister in front of you?”

“Uh yeah. Look, I know it’s a weird ask, but I think it’s best for all of us. I don’t have a brother or sister, so I don’t know what this sounds like to you. But she’s my best friend and you’re my boyfriend and her brother; I don’t want anything to come between us again. I don’t want to have to make a choice between you.”

Corey listened to Tina and put aside his own happiness of this plan for a minute. He heard and understood what she meant, that the fight between her and Addie had really hit something in Tina. Obviously, she was angry with her best friend’s betrayal of her trust, but that it might destroy their long friendship over him did resonate in Corey. If things spiraled again, like they had a few weeks ago, a worse scenario could play out for all of them, and he didn’t want that.

“Ok, Tina. Say ... say I agreed to this plan of yours. What makes you think Addie would agree too?” Corey knew he had to pretend this idea was all new to him and that he was warming up to the idea.

“I shouldn’t say this, but a month or two ago, Addie said I was so lucky to be with you. That if she wasn’t your sister, she’d date you herself. I thought it was strange when she said it, but I figured she just wanted a boyfriend of her own. Maybe it could mean more.”

Corey was legitimately surprised that Addie had said something like that to Tina. “You could be jumping to conclusions, but I can’t believe she said that at all.”

“She did, believe me. Look, you don’t need to decide today, just think about it. It would mean we wouldn’t have to hide or lie to her anymore. I could actually talk to my best friend freely again. Please, just think about it.”

“I will, I promise,” Corey replied, but he was already thinking about it and his cock responded to his mental musings. Tina couldn’t help but notice as well and wanted to give him a little motivation to swing him in the correct direction. She stood up and stretched, her ample breasts directly in Corey’s face, before she gave him a sly grin and walked naked into the house. Corey knew enough to follow quickly behind.

She led him back upstairs to her room where she climbed onto her bed, raised her ass in the air and used her fingers to spread her pink pussy open. Corey knew exactly what she wanted and was more than happy to give it to her. He took one of the condoms that were still on her nightstand and put it on as he watched her finger herself while she waited.

She let her index finger penetrate her damp pussy and slowly pushed it in and out, letting Corey get a good look. It excited her to put on a little show for her boyfriend. She never really thought about it before but with the possibility of having sex in front of someone else fresh in her mind, she found she kind of liked the idea of showing off.

Fully wrapped, Corey moved behind his sexy girlfriend, and lined up his cock where her finger currently was. Tina pulled her digit from her twat, now fully wet, and pulled his rod to her excited hole. She wanted him in her and it didn’t take long for him to thrust fully into her excited slit.

“Oh fuck!” she cried out, as he started to pound into her.

“You like it from behind, babe?”

“Yes, it feels so good. I wanted it that night when we watched that movie with my parents and Addie. You teased me so much that night, I wanted you to fuck me.”

“And now I am. I’m deep inside you, fucking your tight pussy in your bedroom.”

Corey slammed extra hard and deep on the next thrust, which made Tina groan in pleasure. He enjoyed the sight of watching his cock go in and out of her pussy. In his mind though, he kept picturing Addie and Tina naked together, waiting for him to fuck both of them together. He still couldn’t believe that it might actually happen.

He looked down at Tina’s ass. Light tan lines from her swimsuit made a little marking of where she was usually covered. Corey let his fingers run along the pale part, sliding between the crack of her ass and her little rosebud. He let his finger rub up against the rubbery exit but didn’t try to push a finger in. There would be another day for that, he thought to himself. Instead, his hand moved over her fleshy ass where her suntan was in full effect. He raised his hand up and brought it back down to spank her butt.

“Oh yeah, have I been bad?” Tina said seductively.

“Very bad. You and Tina should be punished,” Corey leaned over and whispered in her ear.

Corey spanked her again and Tina twitched and groaned, “what have I done?”

“You know what you did, my dear.” He spanked her again as he kept thrusting into her. Tina’s hips pushed back as they both got more worked up.

“Is it because I asked you to fuck your sister?” Tina replied, now fully playing along.

“Yes, because you want me to fuck my sister while you watch. Your best friend and my sister.” Corey could feel himself getting more worked up as he said those words. He had wanted to make it seem like her idea had taken root and he was coming around to it, but it really did turn him on. He could fuck his two girls together and they would watch each other do it.

As that thought rushed through his mind, he gripped hard on her hips and thrust hard and fast into Tina. He’d worked himself up too much and knew he couldn’t last much longer. Tina could sense it too, and she put her fingers back between her legs and played with her clit as he fucked her hard from behind.

It was too late though and Corey grunted as he pushed deep into her pussy and filled the condom with his potent seed. He held himself inside her for a minute before pulling out and sliding off the condom. It joined the other from earlier in Tina’s trash bin. Corey watched Tina finger herself for a few minutes before she brought herself to an orgasm. They both needed a rest and cuddled on the bed for a bit.

It was just after 8:00pm when Corey woke up with Tina in arms. He looked around and realized they must have fallen asleep after their last sex session. He looked down at his sleeping girlfriend. Her face showed a state of contentment and peace and knew that he really loved her. He wanted to wake up with her more often, to see her every day and fall asleep with her every night. But they were too young still and had their whole lives ahead of them. Anything could happen at any moment, so he needed to work hard to keep their love strong.

The next big roadblock, looming on the horizon, was Addie. He was still excited about the possibility of being open with both of them, but there were risks. The post-sex clarity told him that this could be a dangerous tightrope to walk, and he had to thread this needle very carefully or there could be resentment from one or both of them afterwards. No, this wouldn’t be simple. He needed a plan and the help of the very two girls who would be involved.

Corey ran his hand through Tina’s soft hair, as the remains of sunlight highlighted her light brown hair. He was about to kiss her cheek when he felt a pain in his stomach, and he heard it growl. Shit, he thought to himself, neither of them had eaten anything all day. They had both expended a lot of calories doing the devil’s tango and hadn’t replaced them with anything. They needed to wake up and eat something before her parents got home in a couple of hours.

He leaned over and softly kissed her cheek, but she didn’t move. His lips traveled down to hers and kissed her tenderly on the mouth and she started to stir. He watched her eyes scrunch and then slowly opened. She smiled when she saw him looking at her. She’d always wanted to wake up in his safe arms.

“Good evening, sleepyhead,” Corey said softly.

“That was such a good nap, what time is it?” she asked as she sat up and looked around for her glasses. They were on the nightstand where she left them when they first had sex after they arrived.

“Just after 8:00, my love. I think we should probably order some food.”

“Oh yeah, I guess we slept a little longer than I thought,” she replied with a little laugh. She felt the pain of her empty stomach as well. “Pizza ok?”

“Works for me.”

Tina picked up her phone and ordered a pizza and breadsticks from a local place. Both of them used the washroom to clean themselves up. They looked like they’d spent the afternoon in bed together. Their hair was messy and unkempt, and they smelled like sex and latex. If they had more time before the food arrived, Corey would have suggested they take a shower together. Instead, they just quickly washed themselves off with a wet cloth. Reluctantly, they both got dressed after having spent half the day naked together.

“I want this again,” Tina said, as she pulled her shirt down over her head.

“We’ll do it again, obviously,” Corey replied with a smile as he adjusted his pants.

“No, not just the sex. I want to spend the day with you naked like that. It was fun.”

“Maybe we can figure something out. Your parents don’t really leave the house as often as mine do, maybe we can do it there.”

“ ... but Addie...”

“Well, she might not be a problem if your plan works out,” Corey said as he looked at his girlfriend. She slowly realized what he said and was shocked.

“You’re going to do it? Are you sure?”

“I’ve had some time to think about it. Let’s just say I’m strongly considering it. I think you’re right that it might be the best way to solve things.” Corey didn’t add that it would fix another problem that she didn’t know about.

The doorbell rang and the two of them ran downstairs to get it. Corey paid while Tina set up some plates and drinks in the living room. He brought the food over and placed it on a small table to the side, being careful not to drop anything on the expensive looking carpet. They loaded their plates and turned on the TV, but neither one watched what was on screen. It was mostly on in the background as they continued their conversation.

“If ... and I do mean if we do this, how do you think we should approach Addie about this idea?” Corey asked as he swallowed some food.

“Well, I think I should talk to her first, just to get a read on the situation, you know? I think she’ll be more likely to open up to me about it than you”.

Corey had to try not to laugh at that comment, so he took a swig from his drink to mask his grin. If only she knew that Addie was more than open with him with regards to sex. No, sex with his sister was the easy part. Convincing her to let Tina know about it would be the tough part. Incest wasn’t something to be taken lightly, even if both parties agreed to it.

“Good idea, why don’t you tell her you’re concerned about having sex with me for the first time because of the way Addie’s been acting.” The wheels in Corey’s head were spinning quickly now. The food really seemed to help clear things up. “Don’t actually ask her about it, just keep it about the two of you and your friendship. Frame it that way.”