Chapter 10

After his date with Tina, when the two admitted their feelings for one another, Corey was on cloud nine. Addie pestered him for details on what had happened, but he chose not to tell her. This was something he didn’t want to share with anyone. It was just between him and Tina. The most he did was tell her they went to dinner, then a movie, and fooled around after. She didn’t need to know they almost had sex. What Corey didn’t know was that Addie and Tina had already made plans the next time their parents were out for the day. That would be in a week and a half, and the girls had kept that to themselves.

For the next week, Corey had regular nightly visits from his sister Addie. They couldn’t actually have sex due to Addie’s time of the month, but she would let him do anything else he wanted. He fucked her mouth, her tits, and came on her face a few times. It was messy but he started to keep a small towel in his room in case she showed up.

Night after night, he was awakened by her mouth or hand on his cock. He enjoyed it immensely, but it drained him slowly of both sleep and cum. He wasn’t sure how Addie managed to maintain her energy night after night, and he felt bad about wanting to turn her away. She was really sexy, and he enjoyed the things they did together, but he didn’t know how much more he could take.

One night, a couple of days before Addie knew Tina was coming over, she sneaked back into her brother’s room. As usual, he was asleep in the darkness of his room. Addie stripped off her clothes and climbed into bed with him and let her hands roam over his body. He still wore boxers to bed, even though his sister asked him to sleep naked. Her lips touched his ear, and she whispered, “wake up big brother, I want you.”

Corey just made indecipherable noises and tried to roll over, but Addie wouldn’t have it. She decided a more direct approach was necessary. She crawled over his face and pushed her pussy against his mouth as she used her fingers to hold herself open. She smeared her wetness all over his face before she fully smothered him with her sex.

Corey rudely awoke when he struggled to breath, as a weight pushed down on his head. He coughed and sputtered at first, uncertain as to where he was or what was happening. The scent did smell familiar though, but he just wanted to breathe first. He managed to find an air pocket and reached over to his bedside lamp. He saw his sister’s cunt right in his face. Being stronger, he flung her off of him and onto the bed.

“What are you trying to do, kill me?” he said in an annoyed tone.

“What a way to go though, death by pussy,” said Addie as she laughed. He didn’t seem too amused.

“Why are you in here tonight, Addie?”

“I’m good to go, couldn’t you tell by my fresh pussy in your face?”

“You’re such a little slut, sis.”

“Yeah, and I’m hungry for your cock in me. Don’t leave me wet and horny, Corey.”

Corey was exhausted and just wanted to get back to sleep but he couldn’t deny the lump in his boxers. Reluctantly, he pulled his sister onto his face and lapped at her wet cunt. As always, she tasted good as his tongue buried itself deep inside her. Droplets of moisture rained down on his face as her hips gently rocked on his face.

“Oh fuck, I love when you eat me,” Addie moaned out. Addie’s hands massaged her tits as her brother ate her pussy. She would pull on her nipples just hard enough that it was on the edge of being painful. That turned her on more and made her want to scream in pleasure. Instead, she had to put a hand in her mouth to keep herself quiet.

Corey pinched her inner thigh, which had become their sign to keep it down. Addie tried to reduce her volume, but it was difficult. Her body was on overdrive from a week without his touch and everything felt extra intense. Her breathing was already ragged, and Corey could tell she was close. He knew in their current position, she’d make too much noise, so he flipped her over onto her back and returned to the sweet source of honey between her legs. Addie knew enough to cover her mouth with a pillow as her body approached its brink.

With her clit between his lips, he let his tongue run over the hard pebble quickly. He felt her legs quiver against his head as she cried out into the sound absorbing material. Her thighs clamped down around his ears and held him firm as she coated his face with her lubricant. Corey continued to lap it up as best he could until she released him from her tight embrace.

Addie’s face was beet red when she removed the pillow. Her small chest rose and fell quickly as she tried to catch her breath. She didn’t want to stop though and pulled his head up from between her legs and brought his lips to hers. “Kiss me, Corey. Kiss me like you kiss Tina.”

Corey was shocked to hear his sister say that. She never mentioned Tina in the bedroom and wasn’t sure what to say. “Addie, I...”, but she put her fingers to his lips.

“Shhhh,” she replied, “close your eyes and pretend I’m Tina. Please!” she said in a desperate tone.

Not sure what to do, Corey simply nodded and closed his eyes. He pictured himself on top of Tina, they were both naked and he leaned down and pressed his lips to hers. It was soft and tentative at first, a gentle exploratory peck. As the girl beneath him responded, his kisses became more passionate and loving. In that moment, he truly did act as though Tina was there with him instead of his sister.

Addie felt the difference in how he reacted, and it made her excited but also sad. His hips started to move between her legs, unconsciously he humped against her as he got into the roleplay. Addie decided to play this out and spread her legs apart to give him access to her waiting slit. She felt his steel hard cock poke against her crotch, a few inches from its target. She reached down and guided it to the entrance. With one thrust, he was buried inside her completely.

He muttered out, “Oh Tina!” as he penetrated his sister. He immediately regretted what he said as he looked to see the hurt in his sister’s eyes. He’d gone too far, and he knew it. He tried to pull out, but she wrapped her legs around his back to keep him in place.

“Keep going. Fuck me, Corey. Fuck me and cum in me, something Tina will never allow,” Addie said with spite in her voice.

“Addie, I’m sorry. I was just doing what you told me.” He tried to explain but she wasn’t having it. She ground her pussy on his cock and used her legs to thrust him in and out.

“I know, just fuck me. Don’t ever stop fucking me, Corey.”

“But what if you make too much noise?”

Addie reached out to the floor and picked up her dirty panties off the ground. She didn’t say another word as she put the wet, dirty garment into her mouth and continued to move her hips. Corey looked down at his sister and felt bad. Her small tits pressed against his chest as his cock was buried to the hilt inside of her.

Corey pulled out partially and thrust back in, her legs kept him from a full withdrawal. His cock plunged in and out of his sister as he looked down on her face. She moaned as he fucked her, but he could sense the sadness that emanated from her. He brought his face down to hers, as his lips touched the material of her panties. In the light of the small lamp, he could see the white cotton and small pink hearts that covered her panties bunched up in her mouth.

In an attempt to make her and himself feel better, he kissed a part of the panties that stuck out from her lips. His hand ran along her cheek and brushed a small strand of hair from her face. Both of their bodies reacted to the touch, and Corey could feel himself get close. Addie’s noises and groans increased too.

“I love you, sis,” Corey said softly as he shot his cum deep into her sex. It filled her up and spilled out onto the bed in a small pool.

In an inaudible voice, Addie mumbled, “I love you too, Corey. Always,” as she felt his cum fill her insides. It triggered her own orgasm as she came on his cock.

Neither said much afterward. Corey lay in bed in a little wet puddle while Addie picked up her clothes and left. She quietly returned to her room and climbed into bed. Her pussy leaked his cum onto the new pair of panties she’d put on. Her fingers traveled down inside them and scooped a small glob up and she brought it to her lips. She cleaned off her fingers before her eyes watered and she broke down in tears.

The next day, neither Corey nor Addie spoke about what had happened the night before. They carried on as if nothing had happened. At night, Addie still came to Corey’s room and the two engaged in their nighttime coitus. They didn’t speak much before or after, Addie would just climb onto his bed to wake him up and they would have sex, but the spark wasn’t there.

The next time Corey spoke with Tina, she suggested their next date be at his place when his parents would be gone. Tina hinted they might be able to do more than what they’d been doing, but didn’t disclose that Addie knew about it. She thought that her friend would be happy for her and her brother, but that wasn’t the case. Addie was now more determined than ever to put an end to their relationship, she just needed a few things to go her way.

Corey woke up later than normal on the day of his date. Addie had kept him up much later than normal, and despite his protests, made him cum numerous times. He hoped that if things with Tina progressed today, that he still had something left in the tank if things got physical. The thought that today could be their first time together did give him a bit of strength to finally roll out of bed after 11:00.

He threw on some shorts and a shirt and wandered downstairs to see when his parents were planning to leave. Tina was expected to come over around 1:00, and they’d stay there until his parents got home. Tina suggested she drive over to his place instead of him picking her up and driving back. It just made more sense.

Corey heard nothing but the TV in the living room. He looked around but didn’t find anyone but his sister in the kitchen making a sandwich.

“Where is everyone?” Corey asked, as he put some bread in the toaster.

“They left early. You slept in too long,” Addie said as she poured herself a glass of orange juice.

“Oh ok, did they say when they’d be back?”

“Around 7:00, I think. They said something about getting food, why?”

“Tina’s coming over, remember. Just hoping for a little alone time,” Corey said with a little bit of trepidation. After the other day, he avoided the topic of Tina with his sister as much as possible.

“Oh yeah? Hoping to get lucky or something? You’ve already got a good thing here, Corey. She’s a tease who won’t give you whatever you want like you know I will.”

“Addie, please. Let’s not get into that, ok? I love both of you but she’s my girlfriend.”

“Yeah, I know ... whatever,” Addie said before she turned around and headed back to the living room. Corey thought about finally hashing things out, but he knew he likely didn’t have the time before Tina got there. He wanted to shower and clean up a bit before she arrived. He just had to hope his sister behaved or at least stayed out of their way when they wanted to be alone.

Corey cleaned his room for over an hour, and made sure the bed was perfectly straight and clean. He wanted things to be perfect for his girl, if she thought today was the day. He wouldn’t push her to do anything she wasn’t ready to do, but after the last time in the car, he suspected it could be any time soon. He now made sure he had a condom in his wallet and a few more in his bedside table, just in case. He’d learned his lesson about being prepared.