Chapter 29: Cosplay

-- MONDAY (TWO DAYS LATER) --

A stray beam of sunlight woke me up. The curtains had been shut, but there was a half-inch of space between them, and at this very time on this very date, the sun’s rays came through at just the right angle to hit me right in the eyes. I immediately winced and shifted away from the unwanted illumination, only to feel my vision swim as vertigo took over after attempting to move my head too quickly for my sluggish brain to keep up.

My skull felt like it had shrunken two sizes too small. My mouth tasted like I had a cotton ball on my tongue. My throat was dry and scratchy. And the room around me spun when I tried to look around and put together the puzzle pieces comprising my present existence that would explain the who, what, when, why, and where of my current condition.

Oh, right. We’re back to this point again.

It took me a little while, but I eventually remembered everything that had transpired between Sam showing up in my bedroom Saturday night and this moment here on Monday morning. Despite never having met each other before, Isabela and Sam hit it off right away and had their faces in each other’s crotch within minutes. And although I felt pretty wiped out having already cum four times, Sam was quick to fetch Matty Junior and then proceeded to drill the horny Hispanic babe into the mattress right next to me.

At the end of the night, we all cleaned up, took showers, and then crashed in one of the four available beds. Isabela and Luna took Naimh’s room, Eva took Sam’s room, Lily stayed in Belle’s room with her, and Sam and Naimh both stayed with me. Having my busty blonde bombshell back in my arms for our “Sam Saturday” night had even stirred up a miracle fifth erection for me, and I’d finally cum deep inside my Aphrodite’s warm and welcoming pussy before collapsing on top of my lover and quite literally passing out from exhaustion while we were still joined together.

And then Sunday turned out to be more of the same.

The girls had let me sleep in past noon as I definitely needed the rest and recovery time. When I finally woke up and came downstairs, the house was empty except for Naimh. My Head Girlfriend was curled up in the armchair under a blanket, fast asleep with one of her school textbooks on the armrest beside her. I’d woken her up from her impromptu nap by way of softly kissing her lips until she moaned into my mouth and reached up to hold my head to hers.

I’d started to say my usual ‘Maidin mhaith’ greeting before catching myself and muttering, “I actually don’t know how to say ‘good afternoon’ in Gaelic.”

“Tráthnóna mhaith,” Naimh explained.

I made a face and muttered, “You know what? I think I might’ve finally maxed out my foreign language mental library. How about I just say, ‘I love you’ instead?”

“Works for me.” She giggled and then kissed me again.

Naimh explained that the others had all left: Sam and Belle went running, Lily and Eva wanted to talk, and Isabela and Luna had gone home. But later in the afternoon when Sam had asked for a recap of the previous evening and then mourned regretfully for missing out on most of it, Naimh had suggested we just do it all over again since everyone had seemed to have so much fun.

So we did it all over again.

Lily and Eva returned to the house before dinnertime, and Isabela and Luna arrived shortly thereafter with overnight bags. We had another barbecue (fish and vegetable skewers instead of chicken and corn). We played Mario Party as a group (Eva dominated). And then we socialized around the living room with a few drinks.

Scratch that: a LOT of drinks. My skull felt like it had shrunken two sizes too small this morning, remember? And I blame the alcohol for getting me to let the girls blindfold me again.

In any case, I found myself stripped naked and seated on the couch wearing Naimh’s sleep mask while the girls took turns giving me blowjobs while I tried to guess which one of them was blowing me. The girls were having a grand old time, laughing and giggling as I made incorrect guess after incorrect guess. You’d think I’d recognize my girlfriends’ mouths by now or something, but they each were deliberately obfuscating their technique, and what made the whole thing even more frustrating was that even after I made an incorrect guess, they still wouldn’t tell me who was who!

And what made the whole thing even MORE frustrating was that somewhere along the way, Belle whispered into my ear that Luna had taken a turn sucking my dick for the very first time. I very nearly whipped the sleep mask off my head right then and there, but my impish pixie giggled and quickly added, “I’m kidding! I’m kidding!”

But she said it in such a way that I wasn’t completely convinced that she was kidding.

Such a tease.

Five minutes later, it felt just like old times to hear Sam commanding, “Do NOT make him pop!”

The girl who was currently trying (unsuccessfully) to deep-throat me pulled off and whined, “Aww...”

Her voice gave her away, and I reached up to pat her head, “Another time, Lil.”

After that was the blindfolded fucking round with the girls taking turns riding me cowgirl and mashing their tits into my face. I actually got pretty good at guessing who was who since the girls had neglected to order me NOT to use my hands to grab their asses, plus I was pretty good at identifying their breast tissue against my cheeks and the feel of their nipples in my mouth.

But then they had to go and spoil my fun by switching to reverse cowgirl so their friends could eat them out at the same time while ordering me to not use my hands. So once again I found myself being used as a living dildo that existed solely to provide the girls with a hard object to sit on. But I didn’t actually mind this time. The whole blindfolded round-robin aspect of it felt like old times, actually, and I rather selfishly enjoyed feeling like the center of attention again. Letting ALL of the girls find their pleasure with me - not just Isabela - apparently made all the difference in the world. And I was happy to hang on for the ride as one-by-one, each of them got themselves off on me (except for Luna, of course).

Even Eva cried out in climax while riding me reverse cowgirl. She didn’t have another girl licking her out at the same time or anything, but Naimh leaned in and told me I was allowed to reach around and help rub her off. And after she collapsed back against my chest, sweaty and satisfied, she turned her face to mine and we shared a sweet kiss while the other girls around us clapped and cheered.

THEN they let me take my blindfold off. And in gratitude for me sitting there compliantly for the better part of an hour, I was given permission to grab any of the girls I wanted, take them wherever I wanted, and fuck them however I wanted for the rest of the night.

I must’ve started drinking more then, because the rest of the night is a fuzzy haze of fragmented memories. I remember roaming about all over the house throwing girls over my shoulder and carrying them to whatever odd locations struck my fancy so we could fuck. I bent Lily over the dryer and banged her from behind, her shorty legs waving in the air, unable to reach the floor. I skullfucked Sam against the kitchen cabinets. And I cornholed Naimh’s sacred core while standing atop on Belle’s bed with my lovely Irish lass kneeling face-down and ass-up, just because I’d never done so with her in Belle’s room before.

I do remember that started up an anal round, because Sam parked herself face-down and ass-up right next to Naimh, and then Belle pulled out the butt plug she’d been wearing to park herself right next to Sam.

Lily had also been wearing a butt plug, and after reassuring me that she was ready to try out the real thing for the very first time, I pulled out of Belle and started easing myself into Lily’s heretofore virgin anal chute. But I never actually got the mushroom head inside, because my cute ku’uipo wriggled and writhed in complaint too much, instinctively reaching back to plant her palm against my midsection and prevent me from pushing. So I told her that we needed to stop trying for the night.

I didn’t miss Belle’s fleeting guilty smile at Lily’s inability to take my big dick up her ass on her first try.

In any case, Eva was next to park herself face-down and ass-up and let me sodomize her like a drilling oil derrick. But right when I was about to cum, Belle warned that if I blasted my yummy cum within the depths of Eva’s cornhole, Matty’s Little Cumslut wouldn’t be able to keep herself from going after the creampie.

Eva clamped up TIGHT at that pronouncement and nearly made me lose my load deep within her bowels, but as soon as she relaxed I pulled myself out, turned my hips, and started pumping out what felt like gallons of cum straight down my Baby Belle’s gullet as she sucked my schlong straight out of Eva’s ass.

Isabela, however, balked at surrendering her asshole to me. “Lo siento. I don’t think I can fit tu verga gigantesco dentro de mi culo pequeñito.”

“No problemo,” I assured her.

“You know the word ‘problemo’ isn’t actually Spanish, ¿verdad?”

I simply laughed.

She was quite happy for me to fuck her doggy-style though, so long as my verga gigantesco didn’t try entering her culo pequeñito.

At the end of the night, we all cleaned up, took showers, and then crashed in one of the four available beds. I wanted Sam to sleep with me again, but my ex-Head Girlfriend reminded me that it was a school night and went to bed alone in her room. She then suggested that Eva very well might appreciate spending the night with me for the first time, and the pretty Hawaiian hapa girl blushed pink but surprisingly smiled in such a way that I thought that was a very good idea, and I told Eva that I’d be very happy for her to come join me. Belle and Lily stayed together again. Naimh volunteered to share her room with Isabela and Luna. And in the end, Eva and I had a very pleasant makeout session in my bed without having sex (I was WAY too tired by then) before she finally fell asleep with her head on my chest while I gently stroked her hair.

So now you know Eva and I went to bed alone, which begs the question: how did we end up waking with Isabela?

To be honest, I thought I’d only dreamed about the beautiful, buxom brunette slipping into bed beside me in the middle of the night. I’d been spooned up behind Eva, but the dark-haired succubus had gently turned my face to hers for a tender kiss that slowly grew in passion and intensity until I rolled onto my back and took her in my arms. She’d hand-pumped my slumbering cock, rapidly reviving it while our tongues tangoed. And before I’d even known what was going on, our two bodies were enjoined once more.

Crushing her big tits against my bare chest, Isabela and I made love with our mouths in equal measure to the undulation of our loins. But when we broke for air, I looked to my left and found Eva watching us with half-lidded eyes while one hand wriggled between her legs. Isabela also noticed my evening’s bed partner and quickly turned her head to the hapa beauty, leaning over and pressing their lips together.

But Eva gasped in surprise, a cutely innocent sound that made me chuckle inside, before she pulled her head back an inch or two.

Isabela gave the other girl a warm smile, intoning softly, “It’s alright. It’s alright. Just feel it.”

She leaned in to start kissing Eva again, and this time Eva started kissing the luscious Latina in return. But it was only for a moment before Eva pulled back once more and gave the other girl an apologetic look.

To Isabela’s credit, she stopped, held up her hands, and said gently, “Hey, it’s cool if you don’t swing that way.”

“I-I-I-uh ... I just...” Eva stammered for a second before Isabela gestured with both hands for her to relax.

“Calma, calma ... con calma,” Isabela encouraged soothingly. “It’s cool.”

Eva’s nervous eyes went to me, and I immediately leaned in to kiss her instead. We made love that way for a long time, with me alternating liplocks with the two incredible women in my bed. In the end, Isabela rode herself to a pleasant but quiet orgasm, and then pulled off so she could swallow my spending. And then she crawled up alongside me and the three of us fell back asleep.

My head had been swimming the whole time and there was a strangely surreal quality to my memory fragments of the midnight encounter, right down to the confused and yet still interested expression on Eva’s face.

But there was nothing surreal or strange about this morning when Isabela slithered up my body, held my dick in position, and sighed in sweet satisfaction as she sat herself down. I was fully conscious even if a bit hungover. I knew the who, what, when, why, and where of my current condition. And I’d had enough of passively letting myself get ridden like a living dildo.

So I rolled the buxom brunette onto her back, grabbed her legs and pinned them down by her ears.

And then I fucked her.

Ten minutes later, I thrust forward one final time and bellowed while blasting what felt like gallons of pent-up sperm into the back of the beautiful brunette’s womb. I’d neglected to actually turn my alarm clock off, so the damned thing started blaring its infuriatingly shrill sound of demonic exasperation designed so that no human being could ignore it for long mere seconds after I’d started blowing my brains out through the thick column of my cock straight into Isabela’s creaming cunt. She screamed, I screamed, and the fucking alarm clock screamed with us in riotous cacophony until Eva finally reached out and shut the damn thing off.

The noise had brought back my ear-splitting headache though, and since Eva got up and got off the bed, I no longer had my personal teddy bear to cuddle up with to help quiet the pulsing throb of my skull.

I was still happy to collapse on top of Isabela and hold her close. But she only put up with it for five seconds before tapping my shoulders in a clear indication for me to roll off. I wound up flat on my back, panting heavily while Isabela smiled beside me in supreme satisfaction. Her limbs were askew as she gasped for breath, her big breasts heaving. And I glanced down with a bit of a smirk at the sight of my creamy jism leaking out from the blissfully satiated girl’s gaping-wide slit.

Eventually, the pain in my skull subsided enough for me to get up and start getting dressed. Eva had likewise gotten her clothes on, and we were soon both ready to head downstairs. Isabela, meanwhile, remained naked across my bed. When I went to check on her, she waved me off and said, “You two go ahead. I need another minute. ¡Dios mío, Matty! You fuck like a GOD.”

I honestly didn’t think I’d done anything particularly “God-worthy” this morning, but I accepted the compliment with a nod. Part of me wanted to grin and give her a cocky look of smug condescension. But the other part of me knew better than to get a big head about it. And besides, I still felt hungover and slightly confuzzled.

Plus, I knew that today was Monday and we all needed to get to class. So after we’d both gotten dressed, Eva and I headed downstairs together and went straight to the kitchen.

“Morning, Sam,” Eva greeted politely to the beautiful blonde bombshell dressed in a crisp navy-blue suit with a white blouse and navy miniskirt.

Sam turned away from the gas range and said brightly, “Morning, Eva. Morning, Matty. I’ll have brekkie ready in a jiff.”

Eva jerked a thumb over her shoulder. “Thanks, but I need to run back to my room to change and everything before class.” The heavenly hapa girl then leaned in to tenderly kiss my cheek, saying, “See you later ... cowboy.”

“Bye,” I replied warmly, sad to see her go but happy to watch her leave.

Eva glanced back at me over her shoulder as she departed, and when she found me staring at her ass, she gave it a quick wiggle before disappearing around the corner.

Meanwhile, Sam left the range and came to me in the doorway. “I’m still not entirely sure what to think of Eva calling you ‘cowboy’. Doesn’t really fit the image of you I have in my head.”

I chuckled and gave her a weary smile, as if the effort of making sense of the nickname wasn’t worth aggravating my already existing headache.

My ex-Head Girlfriend (but still girlfriend) held me in her arms and gave me a look of concern, asking, “You alright? You look like you’ve been burning the candle at both ends.”

I grimaced and shook my head, which was a bad idea, and as the vertigo returned I wound up leaning one hand against the doorway to keep from toppling over while Sam quickly grabbed me for support. And with a sigh, I muttered, “That candle metaphor is pretty accurate. You girls have wiped me out.”

“C’mon. We had crazier weekends over the summer,” Sam chided as she adjusted her grip around my midsection and then gave me a quick peck on the lips.

I kissed her back and then groaned, “I felt just as wiped out by the end of those as well. My head is so foggy right now, the last couple of days are only a half-remembered blur.”

My ex-Head Girlfriend narrowed her eyes and gave me a look of concern. “I heard Isabela screaming her bloody head off a minute ago. How many times did you go in the past thirty-six hours or so? Are you feeling that same sunburnt/chafed thing again?”

“Nah, not chafed. I’m doing alright,” I reassured her.

“Glad to hear.” Sam gave me what I assumed to be another peck, but then her lips parted and her tongue snaked into my mouth.

I moaned into her mouth, blissful feelings of love washing away all my sadness and even quite a bit of the headache. I could feel in the strength of her embrace how much Sam still loved me and loved to be held by me. Getting repeatedly laid all weekend with me and the girls - in addition to quitting the orgy early in the evening so she could get a full night’s sleep - had done wonders for Sam’s mood. I made a mental note to thank Isabela for making this weekend happen, if for no other reason than the improvement in Sam’s mental state. And I basked in the warm glow of my lover’s loving embrace while we kissed each other with tenderly intimate passion for a minute or two.

But alas, all good things must come to an end. Sam and I were still kissing when rapturous moans floated into the kitchen from the open doorway. My buxom blonde bombshell and I broke apart, both of us giggling.

“That sounded like Neevie,” Sam remarked.

“And that sounded like Luna,” I added when another moan emerged.

“Right: Izzy and Luna. Good thing I’m making extra food.”

“Can I help you?”

“Nah, I got it.” Sam patted my ass and then made shooing gestures with the backs of her fingers. “Get the OJ and set the table, yeah?”

I nodded, gave her one last peck on the lips, and then headed outside to do as she’d instructed before taking a seat. Belle and Lily joined me a couple of minutes later. Then Isabela came downstairs. And finally Naimh and Luna emerged halfway through breakfast with pink blushes and sheepish grins.

Just another routine Monday morning.

Per our normal Monday/Wednesday routine, Naimh held my hand for the walk from our house onto campus while Belle and Lily followed behind us. One slight deviation from our routine was that Isabela and Luna accompanied us today, and I wondered how much of a regular occurrence that would start to be. No one had yet discussed whether or not the Latina newcomers would eventually join The BTC. But if my recent history with girls was any indication, it seemed rather likely.

When Naimh and I reached our usual intersection, my happy Head Girlfriend gave me a quick kiss and then bounced away towards the Biology buildings while Belle slid her small hand into mine for the journey that remained. Lily then slid her hand into mine from the other side while Isabela and Luna lined up behind us, and I felt a surge of cocky pride flood through me as I navigated the school walkways with four sexy girls surrounding me.

But Lily and Luna split off together at the next intersection as their classes were in the same vicinity. Isabela gave Luna a quick kiss goodbye. I gave Lily a quick kiss goodbye, and then she and Belle did their little palms-pressed-together thing before gently pushing each other away. The next thing I knew, Isabela was slipping her hand into mine from the other side, taking Lily’s place. And I wound up walking towards E10 sandwiched between Belle and “not-Bella”.

When we got to the plaza outside the auditorium, my petite “little sister” jumped up into my arms and wrapped her legs around my waist so she could give me a passionate French kiss. I let her snog me for a minute before relaxing my grip as a signal for her to put her feet down. But then rather than spin around to head off towards Chemistry, she wrapped her arms around the back of Isabela’s neck and started snogging with her.

“Oh, damn,” some guy behind me muttered in appreciative awe, and I glanced over my shoulder to see two other students staring wide-eyed at the Sapphic display.

But Belle and Isabela acted like they hadn’t heard a thing and kept right on kissing for another few seconds until pulling apart and grinning at each other with sparkling eyes. And it was Isabela who patted Belle’s ass and then sent her off towards Chemistry.

“Almost makes me wish you and I were splitting off to different classes so that we’d have an excuse to kiss each other goodbye,” Isabela remarked lightly. “Ah, fuckit.”

The pretty brunette quickly wrapped her arms around the back of my neck and plunged her tongue into my mouth. I chuckled before kissing her back, but we only stayed like that for a minute before I patted her ass. And she set her heels back down onto the ground and smiled up at me before looping her arms through my elbow and asking, “¿Vamos?”

I smirked and patted her forearm before leading the way into the building, no longer caring what people might think about me walking into the auditorium with a pretty girl hanging on my arm. While I might’ve briefly harbored some illusions about not winding up with the kind of reputation I’d had back in high school, Belle, Naimh, Skylar, and now Isabela had quickly disabused me of such an unrealistic notion.

We entered the building together and then walked over to the lecture hall, descending the steps side-by-side. Isabela did most of the chatting while demonstratively flirting with me. She rubbed my arm, giggled, and played with her hair while I took note of the way surrounding conversations hushed around us. And when we got to the fourth row, Isabela entered first to sit down on the seat next to mine before I dropped down into my regular spot.

Isabela and I kept chatting right up until the familiar sound of high heels rhythmically striking individual stair treads caught my attention. I glanced up just in time to see Skylar descending towards us, and the beautiful, busty blonde bombshell gave me and Isabela kind smiles before continuing on her way.

Skylar started taking questions from students. Isabela and I kept chatting. And eventually, Professor D ambled over to the front of the class at the bottom of the stairs.

“Good morning, students,” the stodgy old graybeard greeted in his typically loud but quavering voice. “Let’s begin.”

Isabela’s hand slid onto my thigh.

“Matty, would you be so kind?” Skylar asked me while holding out her takeout bag just outside the front door of her apartment.

“Oh, sure,” I said, taking hold of the bag with my free hand while my other hand still held Naimh’s. Skylar then fit her key to the lock, braced her foot against the base, and then put her right shoulder into the door to get it unstuck and open up, the same way she’d always done whenever bringing us back to her place. The three of us then walked inside and I set Skylar’s paper bag onto the dining table.

“So now that we can have a private conversation,” Skylar began out of the blue as she closed the door behind us and started walking over to the dining table, “would either of you like to tell me what happened this weekend?”

Naimh and I glanced at each other in confusion, and I queried, “Ah, can you be more specific?”

Skylar grinned as she took a seat. “Specifically, I’m curious to know what led to Isabela giving both Matty AND you very, very passionate kisses after class today.”

“Ah. That,” I muttered lamely before giving Skylar a sheepish look and then glancing over at Naimh.

The redhead didn’t look sheepish at all. Naimh smiled and replied matter-of-factly, “Oh, we spent all weekend fookin’ each other’s brains out.”

Skylar blinked in surprise. “How did THAT happen?”

“Well you see, young Skylar,” I began carefully. “When two people love each other very much--”

Skylar snorted and kicked my shin beneath the table to cut me off.

I shrugged and said instead, “You should know better than to expect me to talk about my sex life.”

“You? Certainly,” Skylar conceded before grinning conspiratorially, setting her elbows down on the table, and dropping her cheeks into her hands while facing my girlfriend. “Neevie?”

Naimh lit up with her ‘Ooh! I get to gossip!’ face on while I merely sighed and rolled my eyes at the double-standard of it all.

“So it all started with cosplay,” the redhead began.

Skylar frowned. “Cosplay?”

“You know: dressing up as costumed characters from movies, books, and videogames?”

“I know what cosplay is,” Skylar muttered dryly. “I simply fail to see the immediate connection between cosplay and Isabela shoving her tongue down your throat in full view of all my students.”

Naimh giggled. “Well, Matty and I first met Isabela at the school Halloween party. I’d made costumes for everyone, and they were pretty good, if I do say so myself.”

“They were really good,” I interjected. “Neevie’s amazing.”

My girlfriend blushed and gave Skylar a rather embarrassed look. “I’m a mere amateur compared to some of the artists I’ve seen online. But anyways: Isabela noticed Matty from class, but then -I- noticed Isabela’s friend Luna in her handmade Catwoman costume.”

“Seriously, Neevie couldn’t stop gushing about how difficult it would be to stitch all the leather panels together and make them fit perfectly,” I added.

“I’m serious. Luna is good. WAY better than me,” Naimh insisted.

“I find that very hard to believe,” I muttered skeptically.

“Aww, you’re sweet, luv.” Naimh blew me an air kiss. “But while I like to dabble in this stuff, Luna is a true cosplayer.”

Skylar looked perplexed. “Define being ‘a true cosplayer’.”

Naimh pursed her lips and pondered for a bit before responding. She took a deep breath and considered her words. And only after solidifying her thoughts did she finally speak.

“First and foremost, I think of myself as a friend to The BTC girls and Matty’s girlfriend,” Naimh explained. “Collectively, they are my number one priority.”

“I totally agree,” I stated while rubbing my Head Girlfriend’s knee beneath the table.

She smiled at me and elaborated, “So I guess you could say I primarily consider myself ‘a girlfriend’ when it comes to my sense of identity. Then, I consider myself ‘a daughter’ to my parents. And on the next level down I consider myself ‘a student’.”

“I think I get where you’re going with this,” Skylar pondered.

“While I enjoy dressing up, ‘being a cosplayer’ isn’t part of my sense of identity the way it is for Luna. If anything, I think she sees herself as ‘a cosplayer’ above identifying herself as ‘a student’. She’s told me about skipping high school to go to Comic-Con. She’ll spend hours and hours on her costumes.”

“And you don’t?” I interjected.

Naimh shrugged. “I’ll spend a lot of me free time on it, yeah, but as soon as you’re home and available, I’ll immediately walk away from me sewing machine to come spend as much time with you as I can. And if I’ve got a test to study for, I study for the test.”

“And Luna won’t?” I queried.

Naimh waggled her head. “She’s still a good student - good enough to get into Cal, at least - but she’s told me plainly about how important cosplay is to her. How shy she feels when she’s just herself, but how confident and powerful she feels when she’s in costume. And she tells me I have the kind of special talent to be ‘a real cosplayer’ meself.”

“Well that I can certainly agree with,” I stated firmly. “You ARE an amazing talent.”

My girlfriend blushed until her freckles disappeared again.

“Well I can totally see you being an amazingly talented artist, even if you only brought half the passion I’ve already seen into your designs,” Skylar interposed. “And while I’d love to see your work sometime, I think we’re getting a little off-topic.”