Call Me Baby
Copyright© 2025 by EroticScribbler
Chapter 10
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 10 - A man with a sketchy past gets the anal virginity of his girlfriend as part of a deal, only to find it is much, much more than he ever expected. Twists galore, a huge surprise, and payback in the form of bitchy karma reigns supreme in this tale of revenge. By the author of Hall-of-Fame honored Potential (5 books) and Attic Voyeur: The Incest Next Door, Fast Car, Let It Snow, Girls Just Wanna Have Fun, The Kiss, A Dinner Surprise for Three, Alice in Dragonland, and The Tide.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft ft/ft Blackmail Coercion Consensual Reluctant Teen Siren BiSexual Heterosexual Fiction Crime Mystery Cheating Incest Father Daughter Anal Sex Cream Pie First Oral Sex Pregnancy
“Sixteen?” He shook his head. “How the fuck could you—”
“I read Traci Lord’s autobiography. If she could fake her way into the porn industry at fifteen and fuck men like a pro, I figured I could make you believe I was old enough. I sure had the tits and ass for it.”
“But why would you want to if you thought I’m a rapist? Why did you stay with me all this time? I thought you loved me.”
“Well, I wanted to kill you when I first read Jennifer’s journal, but killing someone, no, that’s not me. So I had to come up with another plan. I got this idea, and it grew on me, and it worked perfectly, except I never expected it to take so long. Can you believe that; my mother gets knocked up when she didn’t even want you to fuck her, and it took me almost a year.”
“Huh, what are you talking about? I’m not, you’re not—”
“Yes, yes to both,” April said and rubbed her belly. “You don’t have to worry, Daddy, me and Georgina are going to raise her. Or him, I don’t know yet, but I’m hoping for a girl. Georgina is going to be so excited.”
April enjoyed the horrified expression on John’s face. “And I do love you. I didn’t want to. The plan was to have you arrested for fucking me. You know how people are about sex with young girls these days. No way they wouldn’t believe me with a pussy and ass full of your cum. But you turned out to be a better person than I thought you would be, so I had to change my plan.”
“Who’s Georgina?”
“Oh, um, she’s my girlfriend,” April said.
“Girlfriend? You really are crazy, aren’t you,” John said. “You expect me to believe all this nonsense? First, you’re twenty-one, then you’re sixteen and my daughter, and I’m supposed to be the father of your baby. Nobody is going to believe it! Untie me!”
“You seem mad. I’d hate to let you go if you’re mad. You might do something mean.” She got off his lap and dug around in the backpack. “Ah, here it is. It’s amazing how easy it is to get DNA tested these days. I’ve got the report right here, and I’ve already done it, but if you wanna watch, I’ll piss on another stick for you, Daddy. I kinda like the sound of that, Daddy. I never got to have a daddy until now.”
“I’m not mad,” John said. “I’m in shock, and if this is all true, I’m sad, I think. Why didn’t you just come to me and tell me? There was no need for all of this.”
She sat across John’s lap. “I figured you wouldn’t want to have sex if you knew you were my father.”
“No, no, of course not,” he said.
“Then how could I have gotten pregnant?”