Unexpected Affections
Copyright© 2025 by BreaktheBar
Chapter 43
Romance Sex Story: Chapter 43 - Oliver is surrounded by friends and loves his nerdy life, but after entering a silly Dating App contest his life starts to turn upside down. This is a slow-burn harem story about a big (in size and quality) nerd and the various women in his life.
Caution: This Romance Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa Mult Consensual Romantic Lesbian BiSexual Heterosexual Fiction Humor Sharing Group Sex Harem Polygamy/Polyamory White Male White Female Oriental Female Cream Pie Exhibitionism First Facial Oral Sex Petting Squirting Tit-Fucking Voyeurism Big Breasts Public Sex Size 2nd POV
“I’m sorry you were offended,” Zara said, her arms crossed as she blinked several times rapidly and tossed her red mane of hair to one side.
The three of you were in the parking lot. The guys in the other lane had left, moving on to some bar or club, and you, April and Zara had finished up your own round before deciding to call it. April was in charge of the plans for the night, so you weren’t sure if this was it or if there was another stop. When you’d gotten outside into the pleasantly cool evening air, however, April had stopped both of you at the front of your car.
“Zara,” April scoffed. “That’s not an apology and you know it.”
Zara made a face at April and then rolled her eyes. April didn’t back down however and just stared at her friend. The redhead wilted a little under her glare and glanced back at you. “I’m sorry I made you feel uncomfortable?”
“I-”
“Are you asking if you’re sorry, or are you telling him you’re sorry?” April interrupted you before you could accept.
Zara grit her teeth, looking at April again, then back at you. “Oliver, I’m sorry that I made you feel uncomfortable. It was wrong.”
“And?” April prompted.
“And what?!” Zara asked in exasperation.
“You sat your skinny little butt right in his lap,” April said.
Zara rolled her eyes again. “I’m sorry for sitting my skinny, perky, perfect ass on your lap.”
“And you led others to believe he’d be having a threesome tonight.”
“And for- Wait, why am I apologising for that?” Zara asked. “Those guys thought Oliver was the man for that.”
“Yeah, but he’s not having one, is he?” April asked. Then a look passed over her face, one you hadn’t seen before. “Unless he is.”
“What?” you asked.
Zara had her eyes locked with April, like they were the only two people in the world. “Unless he is?” Zara asked.
“Unless ... he is?” April asked right back. Each time they said it their inflection changed.
“Unless he ... is,” Zara said.
“Unless he is,” April nodded.
Zara frowned in a ‘Huh’ sort of way. “Unless he is.”
You pressed the car alarm button on your key fob and your car started honking and blinking its lights, making both ladies jump a little. Another press turned it off. “How about we start using full sentences again instead of BFF telepathy?” you suggested.
“Zara doesn’t need to apologise for that last part,” April said, turning and taking your hand in hers. “Is Hikaru home tonight, or is she out?”
“Um, I think she was working, but that would have ended a couple of hours ago. She might have had plans with Margot after.”
“OK,” April said, leading you towards the driver’s side door of your car. “Bring us to your place.”
“Oh ... kay,” you said, letting her open the door for you. “Is this-?”
“Unless you are,” April said, smiling a little and raising her eyebrows.
“I am?”
Her grin got bigger. “You are.”
You got chills and felt like your back was sweating as you sat down. April got into the back seat behind you while Zara got into the back from the other side. “No one say anything,” April said.
Starting the car, you pulled out of the parking lot and headed towards your place. The quiet was ... weird. Especially after how chatty both ladies had been all evening. Was what you were thinking happening really happening?
Had April and Zara just decided to have a threesome with you?
That couldn’t possibly be what was happening, right?
Right?
You opened your mouth to ask something, even if you weren’t sure what the first question coming out would be, but April put a hand on your shoulder from the back seat as you inhaled. “I need to say something to both of you separately. So just ... trust me, baby.”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.