Chapter 23

Alex pulled his cock out of her, then pushed it back in until her ass had fully engulfed him again.

“I love how the tip goes in and out,” she told him.

Always one to oblige a lady, Alex pulled his cock out, pushed just the head into her asshole and pulled it back out again. He repeated this a couple of times as she moaned and groaned and squirmed beneath him. Continuing the ass fucking, he reached around her waist and started to rub her pussy lips. His hand on her lower belly could actually feel his cockhead pushing in and out. It felt incredibly erotic.

She was now out of control underneath him. His cock popping in and out of her ass was like nothing she had ever experienced. It felt so stimulating. So dirty. So obscene. So vulgar.

But so amazingly good.

She was so close to cumming again that she could barely hold on to her senses. Suddenly, he rammed all the way in and she saw stars. She could feel his cock pumping her bowels full of hot cum and it was enough to tip her over the edge. She practically screeched as she came. Alex heard her shriek and felt her pussy convulse under his fingers as her ass constricted around his throbbing cock.

As they both slowly settled back down, Alex looked down at his cock still inside Freya’s amazing ass. Being inside her this way was so tight and hot and smooth. It was easily his new, new favorite place to put his dick. Freya, on the other hand, had it as her second favorite. As awesome as her first experience with anal sex was, she still wanted his cock in her mouth and down her throat, most of all. She wanted to feel it and taste it and hold it. She wanted the control that she had with a blowjob.

Although, anal sex did have something to offer her that oral or even vaginal sex didn’t have. Freya had discovered that she actually enjoyed letting go of her control a little. She kind of liked having Alex in charge. She enjoyed the thrill of not knowing exactly what was going to happen next. But there was also something deeper.

And darker.

But right then, she was content to lie on the blanket with her boyfriend’s arms around her. Her gently throbbing asshole was a reminder of this new avenue that they had begun to explore together. His fingertips idly touched one of her erect nipples.

“Thank you for the best birthday ever,” he whispered to her.

She clutched his hand to her breast and he could feel her beating heart.

“Ding-dong,” the doorbell rang, interrupting the game show that Cynthia and Katie were watching.

Katie jumped up, “I’ll get it! That’s for me!” And before Cynthia could even register what was happening, Katie dashed out of the room. Cynthia sat there for a few seconds, bewildered as to why her doorbell in her apartment would ring and it would be for Katie, when she heard Katie talking to someone at the door.

Cynthia got up to investigate.

Katie had just closed the door and was walking down the hallway carrying two pizza delivery boxes, when Cynthia caught up to her. “Surprise! Dinner is here!”

“I thought we were going out?” Cynthia said.

“I wanted to treat you to a relaxing night in,” Katie told her girlfriend as she put the boxes on the table and went back to the front hallway. Katie returned with a shopping bag and put it on the counter. “And a special dessert,” she winked at Cynthia.

“It smells delicious,” Cynthia commented and opened the first box while Katie got plates, although Katie wasn’t planning on eating.

Eating any pizza, anyway.

“Oh! Meat-lover’s! My favorite.”

“Yup,” Katie smiled. “Sit, sit,” she motioned to the nearest chair. Katie pulled a slice out of the box and placed it on the plate in front of Cynthia.

“Mmm.” Cynthia dove in.

Katie sat across from her. After a few bites, Cynthia noticed that Katie had not even taken a slice. “Are you going to eat?”

“No. I had a little bite before I came over.”

Cynthia stared at Katie. “What – why?”

“This is all for you, Cynthia.” Katie smiled at her lover. “As much as you can eat.”

Cynthia continued to stare at Katie.

“You indulged my kinky side,” Katie explained, “Now, let’s indulge yours.”

“I ... I ... You...” Cynthia stammered.

“I know you like to eat. And sometimes you like to eat a lot,” Katie told her. “I’ve seen the look in your eyes when you ... overindulge. I’ve seen the look on your face.”

Cynthia was still staring at Katie.

“Come on. We’ve known each other our entire lives. I watched the way that you overate on our first date. Eating turns you on.” Katie paused looking right into Cynthia’s eyes. “Sexually, right?”

Katie smiled and nodded her head slightly. “No need to answer. I know.” Then added, “And it’s okay.” She reached across the table and touched Cynthia’s hand. “In fact, I was kind of turned on by your stuffed belly last weekend. It looked sexy on you.”

Cynthia didn’t know what to say.

“So, eat.” Katie sat back and looked at Cynthia. Katie made no move to take a slice of pizza for herself.

Finally, Cynthia found her voice. “Both?”

“I just wanted to be sure that we had enough,” Katie smiled.

Cynthia, who could be described as a “big girl” but certainly wasn’t seen as “fat,” patted her sort of flat tummy and commented, “I think it’ll be more than enough!” She looked at the pizza and then looked at Katie sitting across from her and was kind of excited. She did love to eat, and the few times that she had allowed herself to really eat, it has been quite a turn-on for her. She took a deep breath, and said, “Okay. Here goes.”