Chapter 19

It was slightly larger than the one Katie had at home, but had no ridges. And Katie liked the ridges. She pointed to a different one and said to Cynthia, “How about that one?”

“Sure!” Cynthia replaced the first one and retrieved Katie’s choice. Cynthia read from the packaging. “Let’s see... ‘Ridged for her pleasure.’ Hmm. Sounds wonderful.”

Still leading Katie by the hand, she said, “Why don’t we go with just a dildo in your ass instead of another vibrator?” She squeezed Katie’s hand and added, “Too much and you might vibrate right off the bed!”

“Ooo!” Arriving at a rotating rack, Cynthia asked, “How about a butt plug? I think you’d like that.”

Katie is floored at how casually they are discussing sex toys, but she guesses that when you’re that comfortable with each other as they were, it’s really not that weird. She hugged Cynthia’s arm and told her, “Sure. Whatever you think.”

Cynthia brought the two items to the register, paid for them, and they both hurried back to Cynthia’s place with Katie clutching the bag containing their new purchases on her lap.

Within minutes of pulling into the driveway, they were both upstairs, fully naked, and in bed together. Cynthia had the two toys and a bottle of lube and was ready to get to work. After some mutual tit sucking and even a little bit of fingering for both of them, Katie is on her back again in the middle of the bed with her legs bent at the knees and spread open. Cynthia pushed a finger into her own wet pussy and spread some of the juices around Katie’s inner lips. Katie, eyes closed, softly moaned at Cynthia’s touch.

Katie heard a click followed by the familiar hum of a vibrator. She felt it touch her clit and shivered in anticipation. It slowly pushed down, following the center of her pussy, then she felt it enter her. The first time anything is going into either hole not by her own hand. It prodded into her and she could feel every delicious ridge bumping against her clit. It was amazing. The vibrations were coursing through her body. Her nipples tingled and her head throbbed with sexual excitement.

Cynthia started working the vibrator in and out of her lover. After a half-dozen or so thrusts, she bent down and started to lick Katie’s clit. Katie let out a long, “Ohhh...” as her legs spread even further and her toes curled.

Her mouth still on Katie’s pussy, Cynthia asked, “You like that, huh?”

“Yes. Yes. Oh, yes!,” Katie gushed.

“Well, let’s take this party up a notch,” Cynthia said and pulled the vibrator out of Katie and grabbed the butt plug and lube. Katie laid there and watched as Cynthia expertly covered the small item with lubrication, tossed the bottle of lube aside, and grabbed one of Katie’s ankles. Pulling her leg up and pushing it towards Katie’s body, she reached her other hand down and Katie felt the cold plug press against her anus and knew exactly what to do.

She relaxed her sphincter muscle and exhaled as deeply as she could, then she lightly clenched her stomach muscles and the first half of the plug slipped into her ass. Katie struggled a little with the widest portion. It was bigger around than anything that she had previously put into her ass.

“Are you okay, baby?” Cynthia asked.

Katie inhaled, which pushed the butt plug slightly out. “Yes. It’s just kind of big.”

“I know,” Cynthia sympathized. “Once it’s in, it’ll feel better. I promise.”

“Okay. I’m ready,” Katie said.

She exhaled and relaxed her asshole again. As Cynthia continued to apply steady pressure, Katie just focused on keeping her anal sphincter as relaxed as possible while still being able to tighten her abdominal muscles.

Then she felt it.

Without warning, it suddenly popped into her. There was no audible sound, but rather a strange “plop” that she felt deep in her lower bowels. It reminded Katie of that feeling when you know that you’re about to have what she always thought of as “tummy troubles.” But rather than a feeling of illness, this “plop” feel was titillating.

“Good girl,” Cynthia praised her and rubbed her hip. “You’ve done this before.” She gave Katie’s ass cheek a small slap and lowered her leg back down on the bed. “How does that feel?”

“Good,” Katie inhaled, and then began deep and slowly measured breaths. “Big, but ... Shallow ... Different. But good. Really good.” She wriggled her ass on the bed and giggled. “Really good.”

“Okay. Now, let’s get this thing back inside you,” Cynthia said as she picked up the vibrator and turned it on. Katie laid back in anticipation. She could feel it vibrating against her clit. And then it slowly entered her.

But this time it felt so much different. The ridges pushed against her clit a little more forcefully, one after the other, sending vibrations into her. But then each ridge pushed against her insides, too, opposite her clit. As each ridge of the vibrator bumped into her pussy and pushed against her insides which, in turn, pushed against the butt plug, she felt a second, more powerful vibration deep in her bowels.

To say that it was intense would be an understatement! Katie was almost instantly thrown into a frenzy.

As Cynthia dragged the vibrator back and forth under her clit and over the sensitive skin separating the butt plug inside her from the vibrator, Katie reached up and started to pinch her nipples. And pinch them hard. She squirmed and grunted under Cynthia’s vibratory manipulations.

Suddenly, Katie’s hand froze in mid-pinch and her eyes shot open. “I wish we had gotten bigger ones,” she said almost matter-of-factly.

Cynthia thought for a moment then said, “Well ... I do have a few different –”

“Get them,” Katie demanded.

“Yes, ma’am!” Cynthia got up and brought a handful of dildos and vibrators back to the bed. Katie quickly picked out the biggest one.

“I told you, we have to work up to ones like this. You’re a rather petite lady, Katie-bear.”