Chapter 5: That’s a Naughty Game

“Are you sure?” I asked Kelly and Moira, ‘that’s taking things a whole step further, and she’s your sister.” As I said this, I was looking directly at Moira, not sure if she really meant what she was saying.

“So, you and Kel are doing it, why not?”

“She’s cute and is interested, Moira has spoken to her, and she’s interested. She’s not sure if she wants to join in with everyone, but is keen to try a little bit.”

“Everybody? Apart from us three, there’s only Lee left.”

“Well that’s it, she isn’t into Lee, but you? For some reason she likes you. She’s already been with me, so going with Kelly would be no big deal. Look Si, give it a try. Let Fiona join in. God, I thought you’d be dying for it. Imaging three girls to choose from.”

I still wasn’t sure, they were suggesting that we bring Fiona, Moira’s younger sister, into our group. I wasn’t convinced, things were getting out of hand, the more people who got involved, the more chance somebody would let something slip.

“You mean you and Fiona have done it together?” I couldn’t believe that Moira and her sister had had sex together.

“Not all the way, not like you and Kelly, or me and Kelly,” she giggled when she said that.

“I’m not sure, I mean she’s a bit younger than us.”

“She’s in your class at school,” Kelly said.

“Yeah but she’s the youngest in the class, and I’m the oldest, I’m nearer in age to you than I am her. Kelly, I’m not sure.”

“Look, just let her try some things with us. Play the spin the bottle game. Once she knows she’s going to get naked and that you will be ogling her maybe, that will stop her. But she has the right to have the chance,” Moira said.

“OK, but you take any blame that’s coming if she freaks out.”

“She won’t. She’s cool, trust me.”

“But only us three, not Lee as well.”

“Why jealous do you want her all to yourself?” teased Kelly. “No I told you, she doesn’t want Lee involved.”

“No, I just ... Oh fuck it, do what you want.”

Why the hell was I being hesitant about bringing another girl into the mix, and she was in my class, so I couldn’t object. The problem was Fiona seemed such a kid, very quiet in class. Very shy.

I was feeling excited but worried. Against my better judgement, I’d agreed to let Fiona join in our little group, but it was to be just Kelly, Moira and me. I wanted to try and keep this under some kind of control. Knowing Lee, he’d get over-excited and blow things.

“You’re sure Fiona knows what is going to happen?”

Kelly nodded her head, which was buried in her phone as she was texting away like mad.

“Yep, that we are going to get together and have sex.”

“And she’s OK with it?”

“Think so.”

“You only think so!”

“Look Si, everything’s cool. Moira wants to bring her in and, I trust her judgement, Moira’s spoken to Fiona and told her that she doesn’t need to do anything she doesn’t want to. Fiona can just hang out if that’s all she wants.”

“Oh, great! I’ve now got a hot girl hanging out, watching me have sex with my sister.”

“Don’t forget you’ll be having sex with her sister as well, and I will. Anyway, as soon as she sees you naked, she’s going to want to join in. Now, don’t tell Moira or Fiona I told you this, but Fiona, has this like, massive crush on you. If you’d take any notice of her at school, she’d have let you do anything you wanted to.”

Just then Kelly’s phone dinged with a text message, she squealed and ran to the front door. Opening it, she pulls Moira into the hallway and gives her a big sloppy tongue swirling kiss. As they pawed at each other, a small figure pushed past and stood looking at them in awe, at the same time as casting shy glances my way.

I managed to close the door behind Kelly and Moira and looked at Fiona. As I’ve explained, although we are in the same year and nominally the same class, she is the youngest in the class whilst I’m the oldest. Plus, she obviously is a girl and hangs out with the girls, while I do with the boys. For most of us, there’s not much mingling amongst the different sex’s as friends yet.

When I saw her standing there, taking notice of her properly for the first-ever time. I’m not sure what reacted the most. My cock, at the sight of this undeniably cute, sexy, young, yet shy girl. Or my heart for the gorgeous creature I was looking at. I knew I was in trouble right then. Moira is my ‘unofficial’ girlfriend and ‘official’ sex buddy, and I knew I was already falling for her sister.

Fiona was cutesy and little girl all in one, to be fair I’m not much more than a boy. As I say, she was all cute, but with an underlying sexiness about her. Just the hint of what might be in the future. The sexy woman she could become. The sort of look that promises so much. The kind that grown men can find irresistible and can be dangerous. The thing is, she didn’t look like this in school, nondescript would describe her there. Fading into the background. I’d never seen her look like this at her home either. Not that I’d seen her there very often, as I say we didn’t really mix. I must have been blind!

Fiona stands about five-foot three-inches tall. With a slender body. But her boobs have started to grow and were making a nice bulge in her shirt. She had a cute little bum from what I could see, as it made the back of her skirt stick out. She has coppery coloured hair, hanging in a mane to her shoulders, in contrast to Moira’s, which is more chestnut. Wide, hazel coloured eyes. The cutest little snub nose, and soft looking lips, that she was biting the bottom one of. Nervously pulling it into her mouth and biting down on it. I could see little white teeth. She was also wearing a little eye shadow and a trace of pale pink lipstick.

She stood there, hopping from foot to foot, not knowing what to do. I took a few more seconds to look at her as our sisters were making out. Fiona had on a pair of white Adidas trainers, with the three stripes picked out in pink. Pink ankle socks, with those little frills on. A washed-out, denim skirt that was just above mid-thigh in length. The type that buttons up the front, a couple of them were open, showing a bit more of her legs. A pink shirt that she had tied the ends of around her, just under her boobs, leaving her belly bare. A thought flashed through my mind, ‘I bet she’s wearing pink panties and bra. Now that was a very, very nice image that drifted into my mind.

I had changed my mind. I wanted Fiona in the group. No, I wanted her for myself, I was sure of it.

“Hi Fiona, come in. Don’t let those two put you off.”

“Are they always like that?” Fiona giggled at my attempt to make her feel more at ease.

“Hey, sis, cut that out.”

“Why do you want some?” Kelly said as she broke off from kissing Moira, and to my surprise, folded herself into me and kissed me just as she had been doing to Moira. I heard a shocked gasp from Fiona.

“Wow, you don’t mess about do you?”

“Nope, life’s too short for that,” said Moira, as she prised Kelly away from me and marched us all into the living room.

Kelly and Moira flopped onto one of the sofas, which left the other free for Fiona and me, forcing us together. As Fiona perched nervously next to me, I realised how sweet she seemed. I’m sure she was already having second, third, and fourth thoughts about why she was here and what she would be doing.

“So, what happens? Like do you all get naked and just do it? Like all together?” Fiona asked, breaking the silence.

“No, not really, not just like that. Well, we do, sometimes, but not always, and we’re not today. We are going to play a little game, just to help get you more relaxed and in the mood.”

“Err; what game?”

“Spin the bottle.”

“What? That’s a naughty game, you have to do all sorts of things. It’s worse than truth or dare.”

Unable to control ourselves, Moira, Kelly and I burst out laughing, much to Fiona’s annoyance.

“Why are you laughing?”

“It’s just what you said,” I managed to tell her eventually. “You do know what is likely to happen to you today, don’t you?”

“Yeah.”

“Well, you just said, spin the bottle is a naughty game, and you have to do all sorts of things.”

“So!”

“Think about it. You’re probably going to be doing lots of naughty things, and not just in the game.”

“Oh.” Suddenly the light dawned, OH! Oh, right,” Fiona giggled, as she blushed endearingly.

“So what’s the rules,” Fiona continued, eager to get things going.

“Fi, first one thing. You must realise this. What we are going to do, you can’t tell anybody about. Nobody. Is that clear?” A nod of the head, “What we’re doing isn’t legal. We’re all under age for one thing, and Simon and Kelly are brother and sister, and you and me are sisters. So that’s something else that definitely nobody gets to know about.”

Fiona let out a little gasp as she nodded her head, “Kelly, have you and Simon really done it, like done it together?”

Kelly nodded her head and smiled as she looked at Fiona.

“Wow. And you’ve done it, with Moira?”

“Both of us have, and we all have been together.”

“Wow, that is so cool. I promise I won’t tell a soul, Guides Honour.” I didn’t think the Girl Guides would approve of that promise.

“Fiona, one last thing, this is serious, and the three of us agreed on it before we said you could join in. You don’t have to do anything you don’t want to. And you can stop anytime you want. If all you want to do today is watch, then that’s fine with us. Although I think that might upset Simon, from how he’s looking at you.”

Fiona glanced over at me and smiled shyly. My heart began pounding. How the hell had I not noticed her in class before now.

“And me,” came from Kelly.

“I want to do everything, but I’m not sure if I can. If I’ll be brave enough,” Fiona replied nervously.

“Well, for God’s sake, stop talking and let Simon kiss you,” Moira told her.

I felt Fiona stiffen as she sat beside me.

Fiona turned towards me with a nervous look on her face. I put an arm around her shoulders and whispered, “Just kissing, nothing more, I’m not going to touch you.”

Fiona sat there eyes wide open as I pressed my lips against hers. As I guessed they were soft and sweet, but as yet unresponsive. This was not going to work out, I told myself, she’s too young. She’s going to freak out.

I broke away to give Fiona a chance to decide what to do. Then kissed her again, now for longer and a little bit harder, as she relaxed just a little, and kissed me back.

“Um, that’s nice,” I whispered to her in encouragement.

“No, it’s not, but it will be. Your lips are different from Moira’s, harder but nice.” Then I remembered that she had been making out with her sister for a while now, so wasn’t totally innocent.

We kissed again, for longer. Fiona, responding by opening her lips slightly. Letting me slip my tongue inside her mouth to run it around her teeth and lips, and twirl with her tongue. A soft moan came from her, vibrations echoing in my mouth.

“Now that’s nice,” Fiona panted as she came up for air.

“So, who do you like kissing more? Me or Moira?”

“Not sure,” she replied honestly, never having had to make a comparison before.

“It will be Moira. Girls are better kissers than boys,” Kelly butted in from the other sofa. As Fiona and I looked over at the other two girls, they had been well at it. Clothing was in disarray, and they both looked flushed, and I’m sure Kelly’s hand was already up Moira’s skirt.

“I think I need to check Simon out a bit more,” said Fiona. She was not as innocent as I at first imagined.

Fiona and I continued to kiss for at least another ten minutes, becoming more confident and adventurous with each kiss. We weren’t exactly groping each other, as Moira and Kelly were. Fiona had one arm around my neck, the other around my body, pulling me close against her. I could feel her small boobs as they crushed against me. My hand that wasn’t around her neck or caressing her cheek had rested on her hip. Aware of where it was, I didn’t move it in any direction, just resting it naturally. Fiona was trying to grind and rub herself against me as her passion rose.

There was lots of groaning and moaning coming from the other pair as they continued to make out as well.

“Umm, OK, time for a change,” said Kelly. “Fi, fancy snogging me for a bit? See what a proper kiss is like?”

Fiona looked at me as she pulled her lips from mine, unsure what she wanted to do. She seemed very happy where she was right now.

“Go on,” I mouthed to her. “It’s what you came here for, isn’t it.”

Fiona peeled herself away from me and stood up, giving me a glimpse of her cute little bum as she did.

“Gotcha,” laughed Moira as she joined me on the sofa. Her hand, going straight to my groin as she watched our sisters getting together. Fiona, melting into Kelly’s arms at once. “Umm, seems like you like my little sister,” Moira continued as she discovered how hard my cock was.

“No, just thinking of you and Kell did this.”

“Liar, but please take care of her later.”

“I did with you, didn’t I? Anyway, it may not happen today.”

“It will believe me it will. Fi’s been talking of nothing else all week. And you.”

Here I was kissing, and feeling up my unofficial girlfriend, while my eyes were watching our sisters as they got very close together. I think Kelly’s hands explored more than mine had done.

“Change over, I want a boy, but I’ll have to do with my brother,” teased Kelly as she pulled Moira away from me and dropped into my lap. “Oooh, Moira, what have you been doing with my little brother? He’s gone all hard down there.”

I wasn’t sure of Kelly’s motives. Whether she wanted to let Fiona see us kissing, or if she wanted to see Fiona and Moira snogging. Or even to shock Fiona as some sort of a test.

Moira and Fiona giggled as they got together. Kelly made as if to kiss me, but I stopped her saying I just wanted to watch Moira and Kelly for a bit. God, it was hot watching them make out. I thought watching Kelly and Moira was hot, but this was blowing my mind. After a while, Kelly was getting annoyed, so I surrendered to her for a hot snogging session that lasted about twenty minutes.

I don’t think I’d done so much kissing without having hands wandering in my life before.

Kelly once again decided to change things, but now it was to move forward to the next level. This is where we would find out how far Fiona was prepared to go.

“Fi, do you want a drink?” Kelly inquired.

“I’ll have a coke or something please.”

“No, I mean a drink drink,’ said Kelly as she showed Fiona a couple of bottles of cider, and a bottle of white wine we had managed to get hold of.

It was a laugh how we did it. The two girls flounced into a local off licence that all the kids knew was pretty lax on who they sold alcohol to, as long as it wasn’t spirits. To be on the safe side, they were flirting and teasing like mad, with the young lad behind the counter. Lots of short skirts rising as they bent down. Low cut tight tops, leaning over so he could look down them. Kelly also made sure that the pervy old owner got a good look up her skirt. The boy serving was so distracted, I think I could have walked out without even paying, but just rang up the purchase when I placed them on the counter.