The Kidnapping of Cherry Red
by Mushroom
Copyright© 2026 by Mushroom
Western Sex Story: Two outlaws in the old west decide to stage a final job before going straight. So they kidnap the daughter of a rancher in New Mexico to raise the money to buy a ranch in California. However, neither of them expects that "Cherry Red" might have idea of her own while she is their captive.
Caution: This Western Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft Consensual Fiction Crime Historical Western Gang Bang Group Sex Interracial White Male Hispanic Female Masturbation Oral Sex .
So, you wanna know about my days before I got into the movies when I was an outlaw? Well, it’s not as glamorous as it may seem. Yes, I was part of the Hole in the Wall and Black Jack Ketchum gangs. And I tell ya, those were wild times. But I was never actually part of the real gangs, ya know? I mostly took care of the horses, went into town to get supplies, things like that. I never actually went with them when they actually robbed or killed anybody.
But it was exciting for a nineteen year old kid. I came from a little town in western Utah, and could ride and dress out a deer without problem. But even then my eyesight was horrible. Dad was a real bible thumper, and believed we were as God made us so refused to get me glasses. So I could not hunt, and would be useless on an actual job. But one time when Robby came to visit we met up, and the next thing I knew I was in Wyoming.
Robby who, you say? Why, Robby Parker. Oh, but you would not know who he is, I forget sometimes. That’s the real name of Butch Cassidy. That would have been, oh, 1898. So I joined him in the Hole in the Wall, as I needed to do some running myself.
Oh no, nothing like that. I was not in any kind of legal trouble, but I was on the run. Let’s just say that in the last few months I had been getting increasingly friendly with Miss Mildred Franklin. To the point that two weeks before Robby returned she had told me she was afraid that I had put a baby in her. Now Mildred had these lovely large doe like eyes and udders that were already impressive for her only being seventeen. But I also knew her momma, and that by the time she was 35 she would weigh almost twice what my pa did. So after a final tussle in the brush where I was sure if she had not already caught she might well be now, with three heapings of my seed leaking out of her as I promised I would talk to her daddy soon about us getting hitched. Then Robby and I hit the trail the next morning.
And the first stop was four days in Salt Lake City, where I got my first pair of glasses. Then meeting up with Harry before finishing the trip to Wyoming.
I settled in with them well enough, and not being wanted they often used me to scout towns they wanted to hit, or be the man far in front when they moved from place to place. My vision was now better than it had ever been before, but was not all that great. But I also had absolutely no record, so I was perfect for that. Three times I even ran across some Pinks. They would question me a bit, then head on off in the direction I said I had seen some unsavory types. But we had a signal, and if when I set up camp for a night I built two smaller fires on opposite sides of my camp they knew it was safe to come join me.
Well, we finally made it to New Mexico, and it had been quite a trip. Now by then Harry had already taken up with Etta. Harry, oh, yeah. You would know of him as the Sundance Kid. But he hated being called either Sundance or Kid, so we just called him Harry. You know, a lot of those nicknames we all got back then we did not like. Take Butch, he would answer to it and was one of the few that did not mind as he actually had been an apprentice butcher before he left that to go into other things. But Harry? He got that name as he was only twenty years old and living in Sundance, Wyoming when he was caught stealing a horse. He was about thirty when I met him, not a kid and he had not been in Sundance in many years.
Myself? Oh, my sobriquet back then was “Peeper Black”, on account of my glasses and my hair back then was coal black.
But anyways, they only stayed there in New Mexico Territory for a little bit. They met up with Black Jack Ketchum, and as this time they were going to be riding fast and hard they elected to leave me behind. So I took up with Black Jack.
Why were they riding hard? Well, that was in their train robbing days, and the Pinks were really putting on the heat. Pinks, Pinkerton’s, private eyes. Yes, they were working hard to catch them and even had special posses out looking for them so they headed up north again. Me, I started to do the same thing for Jack and his gang. Scouting, making chow and running for supplies. Oh, and then there was Ann.
Ann, she’s Ann Bassett. Both her and her sister Josie were more or less parts of the gang. Naw, not really part of any one gang, but like those floozies now that hang out with the jazz singers and musicians they like. Except the Bassett sisters hung around with the outlaws. She was just a year or two older than I was, and boy did she teach me some things. Like the first night she crawled into my roll during the trip south. She showed me that her mouth could be used for more than yapping, if you know what I mean. So when Harry and Robby met up with Jack, her older sister Josie was already there so she decided to stay also instead of finding another home.
Well, we were a real thing there for about three months. She was really beautiful, and that girl could fuck like a rabbit. And it seems she had wanted to take up with Harry again, but he and Etta were already an item by then. Yes, Etta Place, she’s a real person. Oh, she was from somewhere back east, I want to say Connecticut. Even then Robby and Harry were talking about leaving it all behind and going straight. A few more big hauls, then find somewhere they could set up and go legit raising cattle.
Well, by that time I was a thing with Ann, and that girl had already been around the world and back again. Oh no, I don’t mean traveling. She was barely older than I was, yet she had been riding with those guys off and on since she was fifteen. She’d been with Harry by then, as well as Robby. And Elzy, Kid Curry, Tall Texan Kilpatrick, and a few other guys. I even heard tell that she had been with Laura Bullion a time or two, as well as with both Elzy and his wife Maude at the same time.
Well, by that time she had shown me a lot of things the girls back home had no idea about. Like after she got me to enjoy licking her kitty, she showed me how we could both do it at the same time. But after a few months she headed back to her pappy’s ranch and I stuck on.
Then things started to go to hell. They had robbed a few trains, then Jack’s brother Sam took most of the gang out to do it again and never came back. Jack took off and left me in charge of the camp as he was going to hit another train and see if he could find his brother. It was two weeks later when I went to town for some coffee and other supplies when I got the news. Sam had been killed in a shootout, and Jack had been captured.
Well, that was enough for me. The other camp hand was a guy named Bill Prescot, and the two of us packed up everything and hit the trail. We hit Las Cruces and sold off the extra horses and supplies, and with just the buckboard and a saddle horse for each of us we headed to El Paso.
We hung out there for about three weeks, ready to make a run into Mexico if things got hot. But we soon realized that we were not wanted at all, nobody seemed to even know we existed. So we took up a life of grifters. Mostly small time things, change the brand on two or three cows and sell them with forged papers. Deeds and shares to silver mines that had gone bust in the Arizona Territory that Jack had gotten in a train robbery, things like that. We did that all the way from El Paso to Houston, then went north to Oklahoma and started to do the same thing heading west. But we never made much, just enough to keep us in whiskey and cigars.
But then we had an idea. If we could get just one good score, we could head to California and go legit ourselves. Land out there was selling for $20 an acre, so if we could get together around $5,000 we could buy two hundred acres and still have enough to get a herd of cattle and set up for ourselves.
The only problem was how to come up with the $5,000.
By that time we were already heading back to El Paso, so we hit the Gila Trail. And when we were in New Mexico, Bill handed me a newspaper that had an interesting article. Out in Animas some rancher had the dumb luck to be digging a watering hole for his cows and hit silver. The two of us looked at each other, and for the next week as we headed west we hatched a plan.
The article talked about how he was a widower named Frank Fitzpatrick, and lived with his daughter Rosa. And once we got to Lordsburg we put our plans in motion. Bill was older and had been with the gang for years, so used some contacts to find out a bit more. Frank and his daughter lived to the south of town, and we even got the location of a cave we could hide up in. So once we got the supplies we wanted we headed down and found the cave.
And it was a right nice cave. There were broken pots and even bits of arrows and bones which showed the Indians knew about it and had used it for years. But it was dry, level, and even had a small spring a hundred feet from the entrance. We spent two days getting it ready, filling up the water barrel, cleaning it up and tossing or burning all the stuff the Indians had left behind. Even digging out a pool at the end of the run the spring made before fading into the ground. Then finally setting up a small cage in the back with some wood and scrap iron we found in the area.
Then Bill spent several days scouting out the ranch. The old man would ride the fences and herds as his daughter seemed to stick to the ranch. But finally on the fifth day we caught a break. Bill was on watch as I was smoking a deer when the girl Rosa went for a ride alone.
The first thing I knew of it was when I heard horses galloping up the trail towards the cave. I grabbed the rifle and was crouched near the entrance as all I could see was there were two horses approaching. Then Bill called out it was him and a guest.
And when they arrived, I was a bit shocked. Bill had a black eye, and the girl was tied to her horse and wearing a blindfold made from a blue bandana. She was a pretty thing, with slightly dusky skin that must have come from her momma. But the red hair and freckles were proclaiming that her father was indeed a true son of Ireland.
She was fussing quite a bit, and I saw she had a gag as well as her arms tied behind her back. Well, I helped Bill get her down off the horse, then he went to secure his and frighten her own off as I brought our guest to the cave. And once she was secure in the cage I had her sit as I untied her hands and removed the gag.
And oh could she swear! And in two languages as well! Well, I let her rant on as she called Bill every name she could think of, then she started in on me. And I let her go for a couple of minutes, then she said one thing that made me see red. I immediately held up my hand and yelled at her to be quiet. And then told her that she could say all that she wanted about me or Bill. But that my momma was a good Christian woman, and that she had died after giving birth to my little sister. That she was welcome to call me any name in the book she liked, but my mother was not a “puta”. And I was not a bastard as my folks were legally married.
And it surprised me a bit when she looked somber a moment, then nodded. Then in a soft voice apologized, saying that indeed was not fair. I brought over a canteen and handed it to her, and she took a drink before pulling a handkerchief from inside her blouse and wiping her eyes.
I told her we were not going to hurt her, and she would be free to leave in a few days. “Sure, after you rape me half a hundred times, I’m sure” she said. And that actually shook me, as that thought had never occurred to either of us. We were kidnapping her for money, but we were not rapists.
Oh, don’t look at me like that, I’ve never raped a woman in my life unless she asked for it! Oh no, not even like that. Well, let’s just say that was a game that Ann taught me that we did a few times. Oh, she liked being raped by me, but we both knew it was just a game. Some nights on the trail she really liked being the innocent farm girl that was raped by a savage Indian in the brush. Or the milk maid being forced to do things she should not be doing by the cow hand. But that’s all it ever was, a game.
Well, I did my best to reassure Miss Rosa that neither one of us would rape her, or harm her in any way. “Honest, we are just trying to raise a stake, and you are the way we are getting it. Once your pappy gives us enough we’re heading to Oklahoma.”
At that time Bill returned, and she sat in silence as I got the stew ready. She even thanked me softly when I gave her a bowl, and looked embarrassed and asked how she should take care of her needs.
I went and got an old Indian pot I had found when clearing out the cage, and after having her move to the other side unlocked the door and put it inside before locking it again. I then went to the front to give her some privacy, then after cleaning up I returned and went to dump it in the hole we had made outside for such stuff.
Bill pulled out the bottle of whiskey he had gotten in town and was soon three sheets to the wind as I talked with Rose. And she felt bad for what she had said to me, as her mom had died when she was six but they had lost her brother as well. “I felt ashamed when you told me, and you are right. You are a horrible man that I’m sure is going to rape me, but your mother did nothing wrong but give birth to you.”
“Miss Rosa, believe me when I say I am not going to rape you. Neither is Bill. We have both done some bad things in the past, but neither of us is a killer or a rapist. You will be leaving here as untouched as when you arrived.”
She looked at me closely, and softly said “Not even a little bit?”
“Miss Rosa, not even a little bit. So long as you give us no trouble, neither one of us will lay a hand upon you. I swear.”
That did seem to put her at ease a bit, and a bit later she softly asked if I could give her some privacy once again. I did so, and when I returned to empty the pot again I noticed she had removed her dungarees and had folded them neatly and placed them in the corner. And I had to admit, she had nice legs. We talked a bit more, and I found out she was fifteen years old.
And as we talked, she admitted that her friends often called her Cherry, Red, or Rose, because of her hair. I asked her if they were crew, and she actually shook her head and smiled. “Oh no, I go to school with them. And I think most are jealous. Some are Mexicans like my momma, others Anglo like poppa. But all seem to like my red hair. Me, I’m both so neither side gives me too much trouble.”
I grinned as she told me that, and I said that I would call her “Cherry Red” or “Rose”, if that was alright. And when I finally said goodnight she did seem more relaxed, and I hoped she was reassured that we were not going to rape her.
And it’s true, Bill and I were part of an outlaw gang. I was fairly new to it, but he had been doing it for years. But neither of us had actually taken part in a robbery, nor had either of us shot at or killed anybody. Our jobs in the gang were scouting, cooking, taking care of the horses, and going into town to get information or supplies. After all, there was never any way to be sure that if they were robbing somebody they would have coffee. Or whiskey. Or a slab of bacon. So people like us were a part of most gangs, who had no records and were not actually criminals but were paid well by them for doing such things and keeping our mouths shut.
The next day Bill headed off after breakfast, and between preparing another stew for the night and getting more water we talked. And I was not surprised when she admitted there was a guy she had been seeing, and her father hoped they would get married.
“Patrick’s father owns over three hundred acres to the west of us, so poppa hopes if we get married he can combine both of them into one. That is, unless he can sell ours first.”
“What, with the silver he hopes somebody will buy him out?” I asked, and she gave me a smile and nodded.
“But if somebody else does not buy it, I’ll probably marry Patrick.”
“Well, is that so bad?” I asked, and she gave me another smile and shook her head. But the conversation soon moved on to other things, and we were just finishing our supper when Bill returned. He told us he saw one person searching the area, but not near the canyon we were hidden in.
As usual he sat near the front with a bottle of whiskey, and Cherry Red and I sat in the back and talked. She was actually a bright girl, having finished six years of school. That was two more years than I had, and she asked me if I had a bible.
I was a bit surprised at that, and admitted we did not have one. “Oh, tomorrow is Sunday, and you are not likely to let me go to church. I was hoping I could at least read that a bit if nothing else.” I felt my gut tighten a bit at that, and apologized that I did not have one. And she actually nodded before wiping her eyes and giving me a small smile.
That night in the darkness I saw her moving around a bit like she had problems falling asleep, and I heard her cry a few times but she was trying to keep it quiet. And I was actually starting to have second thoughts at what we were doing.
The next morning I asked Bill if he was going into town, and he nodded. “Yep, I finished the last of my bottle last night. Thought I would get a couple of more, see what they are saying in town, and a few other things.”
I gave him a list of items to get from the mercantile, including another five pounds of beans, another two pounds of coffee, a pound of flour, and a bible. He looked at me at the last, and I nodded to the back.
“Miss Rose is a Godly girl, and she seems sad that she can not head to church today. She asked me for a bible to read, but I know we don’t have one and I don’t think you do. I think that might help as well, and it would not hurt.” And he nodded at that, and soon was heading out of the cave.
I had just finished cleaning up and emptying her pot when Cherry Red asked me if she could have some water to wash with. I came back with another bucket of water, then dug into my saddlebag and came up with a towel and bar of soap. I went back to the front to give her privacy as she washed up, and about ten minutes later she called me to the back.
I was a bit surprised when I saw her sitting with her back to the door of her cage, and that she was naked. “Mister Blackie, do you have anything I can wear? I have been in that shirt for over two days now, and it’s a bit ripe.”
I quickly went to the larger kit I normally had in the buckboard and pulled out a spare shirt and brought it over to her. And when she turned to take it I caught a lovely sight. Her breast was sharp like a cone, and capped with a very large and dark areola. She thanked me, and not realizing I had seen her breast I scurried to the front again as she put it on then washed her own shirt.
And when I gave her lunch, we sat and talked again. And I was shocked when I glanced down where she was sitting, and realized I could see her cunt. I realized then she had obviously washed her underclothes as well, as she had not changed those either since Bill grabbed her.
Bill returned just as the sun was setting, and handed me his saddlebags. And emptying them I set everything out, then smiled when I saw the bible. Cherry Red seemed very happy when I brought that back and handed it to her, and she softly thanked me.
After eating as she sat in her cage reading the bible, Bill and I quietly talked in the front. It seems that most of the town was in an uproar and a lot of them were looking for Miss Rose. But most of the locals suspected she had likely been grabbed up by one of the local Apache bands and taken to either the Arizona Territory or down into Mexico.
“After all, apparently the local bands do that sometimes. At least those that are not on the reservations.” He took another drink, then smiled at me. “I figure I can head back out tomorrow, and put a letter in the post telling her father what we need. I already wrote the note, telling him to go to that dead tree near the river to look for the next set of instructions. And I got the note I will leave there also, telling him we want $5,000 in gold and silver coins.”
I told him that was a clever idea, and soon he was back on his bender so after I checked on the horses I went to the back to chat with Cherry Red some more.
But I stopped before I got to the back, as in the firelight I could see she was not asleep. Nor was she looking like she wanted to talk. She was laying on the bedroll we had put in there for her, laying on top of it. And with her legs spread about shoulder width apart she was pleasing herself.
Yes, that is exactly what I mean. Even though it was Sunday and she had been reading the bible not much earlier, she was laying there committing the sin of Onan. Well hell, I’m not sure if it actually is the sin of Onan if it’s a girl doing it. But that’s what she was doing. And I had never seen a woman or girl do that before, but it sure was pretty. And when she was almost to her climax I heard her giving soft sounds. And it was the same sounds she had been making the night before.
And I had a really hard time going to sleep that night. After all, it had been over a month since the whore in El Paso had serviced me, and I was in need as well.
Bill headed off early the next morning, and I was oiling the tack when Cherry Red asked me if she could help. I looked up at her and she sighed. “I’m bored, I can’t move, and I’m getting sore. Please, if I promise not to run it will give me something to do.”
I sighed, and nodded. I prepared the cave first, putting one of the canvas stools near her cage and the other towards the front of the cave. I then unlocked the cage and stepped away. And I actually winced when she stood up for the first time in days and I heard her joints pop. And she gave a small cry and I even saw a tear as she stood up and stretched.
I had not realized she had not been able to stand in days, and apologized. We had made her cage big enough to lie down in, but it was only about four feet tall. She actually nodded and sat on the stool, and I handed her the jar of oil and a cloth. And every ten minutes or so she would stand and stretch before sitting again. And after the third time, I realized I was seeing her cunt yet again as she sat back down.
We talked as we oiled everything, and she went back in the cage but I did not lock it as I bought the gear to the front of the cave when we were finished. She thanked me again for the bible to read, saying it had helped her a lot and she was feeling better.
She also admitted she missed her boyfriend, as normally he took her to church as her father rode behind them. Then he brought her home as her father stayed and had a few drinks in the saloon. I asked her if that was safe, and she gave me a smile.
“Oh, Patrick is a nice boy. We do some sparking before he goes home though. I think poppa encourages it, he really wants us to get married.”
“Oh, so you and he are doing some sparking?”
She grinned at me and nodded, and the little minx actually blushed. “But don’t tell anybody, that’s supposed to be a secret.” I assured her it would remain our secret, and she smiled back. And I’ll be darned if she did not move her thighs a bit farther apart, giving me an even better look at her cunt.
It was surrounded by hair as red as that on her head. And I know I had been caught looking when she closed them again, and she asked in a soft voice if I was going to rape her. I quickly looked up into her eyes, and knelt down in front of her and assured her as honestly as I could that I was not going to rape her.
She sounded a bit breathless when she asked again if Bill was going to rape her. And I again assured her that Bill would never do that.
“But what if he did?” she said quietly. And I assured her that if he even tried I would stop him.
“So you are not going to rape me, and Bill is not going to rape me. So, nobody is going to rape me.”
“Cherry Red, Miss Rosa, neither of us is going to rape you. Honest, that is not who we are.” And suddenly I got this feeling in my gut, and asked her if somebody had raped her before. And I felt both sad and mad when she slowly nodded her head.
But what I did not expect is when she looked into my eyes, and said her boyfriend raped her most Sundays. “Wait, he rapes you, and you still want to marry him? And you have not told nobody else he does that to you?” I asked, more than a bit flabbergasted.
“Well, I do want to marry him. And I know it’s a sin, but I can’t stop him. When he touches me the way he does, I just get so gooey inside. And as we’re not married, it has to be rape.”
I leaned back and looked up into her eyes. So large and expressive, and she seemed to be completely honest. “So, do you tell him no? Does he force you?”
“Oh no, but it must be rape. As I’m a good girl. And I’ve been told that good girls don’t do that if they are not married, unless they are raped. And since we ain’t married, he must be raping me.”
And even looking back on that conversation all these years later, I could still see her twisted understanding of the words. Apparently she did not understand being seduced and the desire for fornication, so she was equating the act outside of marriage with rape. And it seems more like what was going on between her and Patrick was not unlike what had been going on between Mildred and myself.
And that by her definition, I guess I had raped Mildred. At least a couple of dozen times. But Mildred sure as hell never seemed to think that what we did was rape, she wanted it as much as I did. Well, at least until I took to the trail when she told me she might be expecting. And for all I know, I might be accused of rape if I ever tried to return home. Not that I ever had to rape Mildred, she enjoyed what we did.
And suddenly, I could sense what Rose might actually be saying. I looked into her eyes, and very softly said “Cherry, did you like it when he raped you?” And after looking down a moment, she shyly nodded, clearly a bit embarrassed.
“I shouldn’t, but I couldn’t help myself. I would get this feeling in my pecho, and ingle.” And as she said that, one hand moved up to cup her breast as the other moved down to cup her groin, making it obvious what she meant.
She noticed I was watching her, and blushed as she moved her hands back down into her lap. “Rose, those feelings are natural. Sex is supposed to feel good, and it sounds like he was indeed making you feel good.”
She nodded, and softly said “But obviously not as good as he felt, as he always stopped then made a big mess on my thigh, yet I never experienced the rapture that those books I sometimes catch the hands reading.” And by that, I knew she meant those trashy dime novels that I think most of us who worked the trail and had our letters knew about. Heck, even Ann had one of them, that she would sometimes lie in bed and read them aloud to me. That one was about a flea that was narrating a perverse story about a young girl and was full of things I had never imagined before then. Like priests fucking young girls and fathers fucking their daughters.
I asked her where she had read such things, and she continued to blush when she confirmed my thought when she told me about finding books in the bunkhouse while cleaning. Where she would take one and read it, then a week later return it and borrow another one.
We talked softly for a while longer, before I locked the cage and headed to my roll to sleep. And I did not miss that in the light of the dying fire Cherry was again pleasing her cunt.
The next morning I saw that Bill had forgotten to get the bacon and the salt which I had forgotten to tell him we were out of. And as we knew it would be suspicious if he went two days in a row I saddled my horse and headed into Animas.
I went to the mercantile and grabbed the salt and bacon, as well as some tinned foods and a jar of pickles and a couple of pennies worth of candy. And I saw that across the street was a pawnbroker, so I threw everything in the saddlebags and walked my horse across the street.
They had the usual assortment. Saddles, pistols and rifles, and clothing. There was a case of jewelry that had a stout iron bar in the back, and I saw in a dusty corner a bookshelf. Now while I had hated school, I did appreciate getting my letters. As often times in the Hole in the Wall it would just be me and a book or two for company. And as I perused the selection, I saw a collection of stories by Mark Twain, including one about a very large bank note.
I picked it up, and the pawnbroker told me they were two bits each. I kept looking and nothing caught my interest, until one of them did. It was called “Flossie: A Venus of Fifteen”, and I had a suspicion of what kind of book it might be.
And my suspicions were correct, as I opened it to a random page and was delighted to see the narrator was talking of the titled Flossie using her hand on the narrator’s member as she described using her mouth on a classmate from boarding school.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.