Finding My Sister's Killer: Part Three, Cherry-pop - Cover

Finding My Sister's Killer: Part Three, Cherry-pop

by A duck named TEF

Copyright© 2026 by A duck named TEF

Horror Sex Story: In this third part of the FMSK series we see things from Alexander's point of view. Just as he is going to make a meal of his sister someone else ruins his plans while being on the run from her own brother. Now Alexander seeks to make her pay, pound for pound of flesh. (please mind the tags. This is the 'fixed' re-posting)

Caution: This Horror Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft   Ma/Ma   Consensual   NonConsensual   Rape   Reluctant   BiSexual   Heterosexual   Fiction   Crime   Horror   Incest   Brother   Sister   MaleDom   Rough   Sadistic   Torture   Group Sex   Anal Sex   First   Masturbation   Size   Small Breasts   Cannibalism   Violence   .

“Well, this is an interesting turn of events indeed. Not a death wish, and yet completely resigned to what most of your ‘civilised’ society would call a horrific fate. She certainly was a pleasant surprise. Not too unlike my delicious aunt.”

I find myself at what may well be end. Trapped, alone, waiting for the Reaper to take me to my final resting place, and yet my mind keeps returning to her.

“Please, sit back,” I say to whoever may be listening in.

“Allow me to tell you the story of when I met a tasty little treat named Cherry-Pop.”

It was a few weeks after my dear little sister led the law to my humble abode. Such a shame, I had a freezer stocked with enough meat to make it through the winter too. Ah well, what can a man do?

Well, she was a lovely little thing. A bit younger than my normal age, but still above the usual cut-off. A more mature body has a better flavor in my opinion. As well, with how delicious my dear aunt and succulent mother had been, I was certain my dear sister would be just as savory. I had to have her.

I had been watching her for a while. Learning her ways, observing her in her element, noting every little thing she did. I had to know it all. Her schedule, her habits, her cycles and nuances. I learned everything about her.

I chose a time when she would go for a walk to the mail box for the moment I would take her. Everything was going as planned, until it happened.

A vehicle, weaving as if operated by a drunkard, clipped her, sending her flying a few feet away and crashing with a catastrophic hit to the head against a cement curb.

The breaks squealed and the driver quickly stumbled out, it was a child! Well, not an actual child, but she was young, a teenager. She hit my sister, and trepidatiously stepped back as the blood pool grew.

Did she scream? No. Did she rush to find help? No. Did she call emergency services from a personal phone? No. She ran, stumbling, back to that car and took off. She left my sister dying on the curb.

I was stunned. So many weeks of planning only for someone else to steal her from me and leave the carcass. I’m not an animal, well, not a carrion eater, I have principles. I will not lower myself to consume road kill. That’s just so unsanitary and rather putrid a thought. A meal I had been looking forward to was ruined thanks to some nobody brat who couldn’t control a vehicle.

The sound of some other vehicle caught my attention. Had someone else seen what happened too and alerted emergency personnel? Most likely, I had to make a run for it myself. I swore I’d find that little twat and make her pay pound for pound.

It didn’t take me long to find the little wench. She had crashed at the nearby park and was stumbling about. I do loathe foolish teenagers, though I blame parents for a lot of their spawn’s antics. My adoptive parents raised me well, genetics are about what, thirty-percent of the personality?

Well, it was rather easy to creep up on the girl and render her incapacitated. What a pity, there was barely any meat on her. What are they not feeding these kids? She was skin and bones. I may need to fatten her up, was my thought at the time, but I also wanted to hurry her along to the ferryman.

After bringing her back to my new place, securing her to a beam by a rope, being a teenager I didn’t quite feel right about using the meat hook yet so I used rope, I put on one of Fankie’s records. How I do love my Sinatra...

Well, she began to wake up around the time ‘My Way’ was mid-way through. The sound of vomiting stopped me from singing along and I looked over at her. How strange, most don’t vomit immediately, usually it takes me telling them what I’m going to do to them before they actually vomit.

I guess the vomiting shouldn’t have surprised me, what did surprise me was the actual cause, but we’ll get to that in a moment. I grabbed a towel and began to wipe off her nude, hanging, body. She really was small. Mosquito bite sized tits, no ass, I could almost count her ribs. Is this what kids these days strive for? I’m happy being an adult.

“Welcome back.” I said as her eyes began to focus on me. Her pupils were large, despite the room being well lit, they weren’t shrinking. I also noticed her breathing was slow and shallow. “Well fuck. You weren’t drunk, you’re under the influence of drugs.” What a pain. I don’t have a lot of naloxone hydrochloride left, but I also didn’t want her to die on me ... yet.

A few minutes after administering a dose she vomited again, looking a little more alive now than earlier. I gave her another dose, just in case. My last dose. That shit is pricey too. At least her breathing evened out as much as it could while she was hanging by her wrists. Her pupils were responding appropriately too.

For a moment she just stared at me, like she was confused. She looked around the area. There weren’t any bodies yet, I had already fully processed my last catch and cleaned the area. Originally I wanted everything to be pristine and perfect for my sister. Well now it was pristine and perfect for this little shit.

“How much?” She asked. The question was confusing. Was she still too heavily influenced by whatever drug she took?

She stared directly into my eyes. Don’t think I’ve ever seen such icy blue eyes before. It sent a chill through me, but I’d never admit that to anyone alive.

“How much did you pay him?” She asked, a little more insistent this time.

I pulled up a stool and sat down, looking up at those bright blue eyes, “The hell you mean?”

She sighed, “He caught me, obviously or I wouldn’t be here. So how much did the auction get to? How much did you pay to get me?”

“Pay to-?” I was starting to get a bit of an idea of just what was going on. I wanted to be sure though so I had a few questions of my own lined up for her. “What are the last few moments you can recall little girl?”

She looked up thoughtfully before answering, I could tell she was thinking pretty hard too. Drugs can be a nasty thing as far as one’s recall goes. I didn’t envy the girl her apparent pain. She finally looked back at me with that piercing gaze.

“I-I hit someone,” Her voice cracked a little, she was actually remorseful, “I was being chased by him, and I kept driving, I’d never done that before so I know I wasn’t controlling it well, and ... and...” She winced in pain.

“And you crashed. That’s where I come in. I pulled you from the vehicle. What’s your name?”

“Cherry-Pop.”

The hell kind of name was that? Who names their kid after a drink? Shirely would have been better! Hell, I’d take Brandy, or even Henny! Cherry-Pop?! Her parents had to be addicts. No wonder she was drugged!

“Who’s chasing you and why?”

“My brother. He wants to sell me to the highest bidder.”

The look on my face must have betrayed my disbelief. She turned a deepening red shade of embarrassed before adding, “I’m still a virgin.” In a cowed voice.

“Bullshit. Spread your legs.” I pulled the stool closer as she complied with my order. She was rather obedient and oddly enough, not complaining or pleading or anything. Most people in her position are all kinds of freaked out. This was a nice change, not as great as the time with my aunt, but still nice.

I helped her a little by holding up one of her legs under the knee and took a look. To my surprise, she still had her hymen intact. Quite impressive. Though, I was starting to get a much better picture of what was going on.

“So, your brother was pretty much just raising you to be sold off as a virgin. Did he often keep you drugged?”

She was pretty red when I looked back up at her, she didn’t return my gaze. I don’t know if it was out of embarrassment or shame, I didn’t really care either. Instead I stood up, held her chin in a gentle grip, and guided her attention back to me.

She shook off my hand but got the unspoken order and made sure to look at me while she explained her situation. “Yeah, drugged and starved from the day our parents died. He saw me as a cash-cow. He already sold my twin sister. I couldn’t do it. It would have been a fate worse than death.” She took in a sharp inhale and looked around again. I think she noticed the meat hooks hanging from the main beam. It seemed like realization was dawning on her.

I grinned, “I see. Well, I had originally planned to bring my sister here. I was looking forward to sampling her meat, and everything else she had. Then you ruined it.”

Dry swallowing hard, Cherry-Pop tried to put on a brave face. Her brow began to bead with sweat and the adrenaline rush began. I just knew that fear was rising within her. I liked that look on such a young lady.

“What’s it like?”

Another ... interesting ... question. Again, my face must have betrayed my confusion.

“Human. What’s it like? I didn’t get much to eat for the past several years. Let alone meat. If I got any meat it was usually a chicken nugget or fish stick. So, what’s human like?”

Was she salivating? She was. I could see a little saliva collecting at the corners of her lips. Her hunger must have been overriding her fear response. This was interesting indeed.

A plan began to form in my mind. I didn’t like young meat. I didn’t like that she was practically skin and bones. She wouldn’t make a good meal at all. Now, I prefer female meat, but I’ll eat a man just as easily.

“Would you like to try it?”

Shaking her head, she answered quite readily, “Yes!”

I nodded, “Alright, alright, settle down little miss Cherry. I have a proposition for you,” I began while I went to retrieve her clothing I had stashed not far from that spot.

“You see, a little thing like you, there’s no meat on your bones. Also,” I began to re-dress her, starting from her feet to work my way up.

“I don’t like youth either. Human is a lot like wine and cheese. You need it to age to a point for it to be good. Mature meat. Thirdly, virgin just doesn’t taste as good.”

I stopped after putting her trousers back on. I wasn’t going to remove the rope binding yet. “You took my well matured sister out of the equation, I don’t do roadkill. I still need something to re-place the loss. You took my sister...” I waited to see if she would catch on.

“You want my brother?”

“Bingo!” She did not disappoint, and from the look in those icy blue eyes, I could see she was more than happy to oblige.

As soon as I had her wrists untied, she wrapped her arms around my neck before she could fall. I had to grip her by the waist and gently help her down as she was so weak and unsteady on her feet. I caught a faint whiff of her scent, it was strangely ... inticing.

“I’ll teach you what I know about just how to properly process, store, and prepare the meat.” I said as I turned to leave, “You tell me where to find this brother of yours.”

“With pleasure mister...? What’s your name?”

“Alexander. So, tell me about your brother, body type, and sexual appetites.”

The girl was quiet for a bit as I started up my Lady Constance. That’s my truck, yeah I named my truck after my mom. She did teach me everything I know about cooking after all.

“Well,” her tone was hesitant but thoughtful, “He’s average I guess. Neck beard type but not super overweight or anything, maybe a few extra pounds? He likes to watch and be watched.”

“We can work with that. Is he into girls or guys?”

“I think ... both? Oh, turn here, to the left.”


It didn’t take us long to get to the place. He was in a small, looked like a one or two bedroom home built at least thirty years ago, but also, not well maintained. A shame to see someone mishandle their own living space.

I told her to come out with me. She was rather reluctant to do so, and I can understand why; she killed someone just running from this ugly place after all. I wanted her there though.

The door knocker fell off after using it. Not surprising. There were some shuffling sounds and the door opened a crack. Holy shit, the stench that followed. How can anyone live in such a state?

“This kid yours?” I held Cherry-Pop by the shoulder so she wouldn’t get spooked and run off. I could feel that she wanted to, and probably thought I was just going to hand her back to this ... well for lack of a better word, pig.

Once the guy saw her he opened the door more. Yeah he was a pig. His shirt and boxers were stained with what looked like instant noodles. She was right, he looked like he had a good layer of fat on him. I had hoped it would cook well. We’d have to clean the body before butchering though. Save shaving for after the initial slaughter. Guy was terribly unkempt.

“Cherry-Pop! Why are you bothering people again? I’m so sorry sir, my sister decided to go off her meds. I’ve been worried sick-”

“Whoa, whoa, whoa there.” I had to gently push him back with a hand to the chest. “This little lady cost me something practically priceless. She’s given her word she’s gonna pay me back pound for pound.” This guy wasn’t fooling me with that fake concern. He was for sure a dick.

“How much?”

What was with that question and these two? Yeah they were siblings...

“Not much.” I replied, “Just you.” And thrust my fist into the center of his gut. He went down easy. That guy was pretty doughy. He was also slow as shit. “Cherry, hand me that bat there.” I pointed, and she did what I asked.

A well placed hit over the head, and the guy was out like a broken bulb. It has actually taken me some time to get a feel for the right amount of force to hit the head with a blunt object in a way to knock a person out instead of shattering their skull or causing a TBI. I have my adoptive dad to thank for that.

“For a second there I thought you were gonna just give me back to him.” Cherry said as she watched me load the body of her brother into the bed of my truck.

The drive back was quiet, with an occasional humming from Cherry. It sounded familiar, like, familiar good, so I didn’t say anything to stop her.

Back at my place I went to work pretty quickly, setting everything up, instructing the girl on what to do to help, and washing the body with a quick vinegar/water rinse. He wasn’t as dirty as his clothes made him look.

Finally he was strapped with a meathook through his wrists, and an extra support pulley hooked against his shoulder blades.

You may be wondering ‘Who would remain unconscious during all that?’ I kept a measured amount of my own blend of knock-out gas right up against his nostrils. Took a long time to get it together after law enforcement raided my last place.

“Okay, strip.” I told her as I began to remove my own clothing. She looked at me, like a deer looking right into a spotlight. “It means take your clothes off kid.”

“I know what it means, why are we stripping?” She asked while slowly removing her own somewhat tattered clothing.

“You said your brother likes to watch and be watched, and he’s bisexual. The meat tastes better if slaughtered shortly after orgasm. You’ll be on front and I’ll be in back. Not a fan really, but this is gonna be your first for a lot of things and I’d prefer the meal is tasty for you.” I folded my clothing and set them aside, “Also blood is a bit tricky to wash out of clothing.”

She paused, looked at her brother who was starting to wake up, then back to me. “Does he have to be my first?”

I moved closer to her, our bodies nearly touching, and held her small chin in my hand staring deep into those icy blue eyes of hers.

God damn, those eyes, I still can’t get past them. I’ve heard women, and some men, tell me I had a hypnotic vibe to me. I think I better understand what they meant now after meeting Cherry-Pop.

“I’m not exactly gentle, little miss. With him, you’ll be in control of depth and speed. You can take it up the ass or in the pussy, doesn’t matter to me as long as he gets hard, drippy, and then has his orgasm.”

I could tell she was a bit hesitant, I could feel a slight tremble from her as I held her chin then brushed some of her loose brown hair behind her ear, but she relented.

“Alright, I’ll need to lower him a bit for you to reach. You mind putting on a record over there?” I pointed her toward the record player, there was a box with assorted records to choose from. Mostly swing, I like swing.

“Which one?”

“Dealer’s choice.” I grunted as I lowered the man enough so his dick would be even level with whichever hole she chose for it. This was going to make it a bit awkward for me as I’m a good head taller than her. Now I know how my dad felt when he was first teaching me the ropes.

Once the music started, I was actually pretty impressed. It was the lovely Peggy Lee, during the Benny Goodman years, and Cherry was sing’n along to ‘My Old Flame’ nicely. This little girl was something else. The more she got into the music, the more she began to relax. Perfect.

A sudden outburst of muffled screaming caught both our attention. Her brother was fully awake and well aware of his situation now. For the briefest moment Cherry looked terrified, but she calmed down quickly noting just how well secured he was to the meat hooks.

“Sir, the more you struggle, the more those hooks are going to sting.” I told him as I made my way to face him. He looked me up and down. Now, I am not one to boast, but I do maintain a well toned physique through work. Of late it’s been work-today paid-today manual labor which is quite physically demanding, and it keeps me in shape. I suppose the mere sight was enough to get his state of arousal started.

Soon enough Cherry was standing by my side, shyly covering her privates the best she could while sporting a blush so deep she looked like she could be a red-breasted robin in human form.

“Don’t be so modest little miss Cherry, the poor boy’s going through a lot right now, probably has no idea what to make of the situation.” I took one of her hands in my own, and guided it to his quickly swelling cock, “See, it’s not a scary thing really. Just work it a bit, and do what feels natural. I’ll be right behind him if you need some coaching.”

“It’s dry, do you have any lube?” She asked as I was getting into my own position.

I peered at her from over her brother’s shoulder, “Just spit on your hands and then rub it like you’re churning butter.” I then went back to working my own cock.

Like I’ve mentioned, I’m not to much a fan of guys. I’m straight by all means that matter, but if I have someone, anyone, strung up like this, regardless of their gender, I’m going to dominate them like an apex predator. I want them to know that they have no power. I’m in control here.

Whatever Cherry was doing had the man in the beginning stages of excitement. I could feel him trembling slightly. Once I was nice and hard I pressed myself against his backside, my cock rubbing in between his bubble-like, somewhat hairy, cheeks. “Your sister tells me you swing both ways. I hope you like your guys on the large side.” I whispered in his ear as I began to slide all nine inches into his quivering ass hole.

I looked over his shoulder and saw that Cherry chose to take his now rather hard cock into her ass. Brave for a first timer I guess.

“Well, well,” My voice remained low as I started to pick up pace with my thrusts, “looks like little sister decided to give you her anal virginity. You should feel really special. She’s a pretty special girl after all.”

My tone was getting a bit darker as I felt his ass tighten even more around my now throbbing cock. He was getting close to an orgasm I could tell. I wondered if Cherry would let him fill her ass or pull him out right before.

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In